Marketing Week 2010 Presentation by Jason Dunstone Managing Director of Square Holes re brands, passions and how marketers should seeks a deeper connection with consumers
1. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
This report is provided for information purposes only. Except to
the extent permitted by law, no part of this presentation / report
may be reproduced, published, adapted, distributed, stored in a
retrieval system, transmitted or communicated for any
commercial purpose [including education or training] without
the prior written approval of Square Holes Pty Ltd. Any
reference to the research findings contained in this report
should state 'Source: report on Make Love Not War Research
[2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd
2. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
“We shall fight on the
beaches.
We shall fight on the
landing grounds.
We shall fight in the
fields and in the
streets.
We shall fight in the
hills.
We shall never
surrender.”
Winston Churchill
4 June 1940
Is this you?
3. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
retain customers expand into new markets
increase brand awareness
grow market share
build shareholder value
maximise sales
new product development
4. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Digital Advertising PR Media Research Sales
etc…
5. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Are we so busy fighting our
competitors we forget our consumers?
6. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Or, do we treat our consumers
like the enemy?
7. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
CheaperEasier
Bigger
Faster
Better
Free bit
Friendlier
Stronger
8. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
There’s much more
depth to consumers
than meets the eyes
9. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Major issues, such as smoking,
unhealthy eating or unsafe driving, are
not rationally-based decisions.
Why do many marketers assume that
consumers make rational decisions?
10. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
When it comes to our life passions, the
things we can’t live without, these are
not rational, but highly emotional
11. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
12. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
The consumer isn't
a moron, she is
your wife
13. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
To develop any true relationship,
marketers need to get to the hearts of
consumers rather than
bombarding their heads
14. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
15. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Mission
“To explore
the power
of ‘love’ in
marketing”
Stage 3.
National survey
N=1,000
16+ year olds *
Stage 2.
In-home affinity
discussions
Stage 1.
Ethnographic / Semiotic
Investigation
* Australia-wide representative sample – regional / metro, age, gender etc
16. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Manifestations of Love
Traditional
Emerging
JOYOUS LOVE
PASSIONATE ROMANCE
PRIZED POSSESSION
QUIRKY LOVE
HAPPY LOVE
UNIVERSAL LOVE
PROTECTIVE LOVE
FAMILY LOVE
COMMITTED LOVE
IDLYLLIC ROMANCE
BENEVOLENT LOVE
EPIC LOVE
17. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
What drives us?
18. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Experiences
Dine out / good food
Going out with friends
Travel
Friends
Experiencing new things
Personal Growth
Creating art / craft
Live arts performances
Studying / reading
Gardening / cooking
Working
Time Out
Watching TV
Using the Internet
Shopping
Using social media sites [e.g. Facebook, Twitter]
Movies
Relaxing with nothing to do
Active Lifestyle
Playing sport
Exercising
Watching sport
Camping / going to the beach
Escape
Having good beer
Having good wine
Gambling
Family
Family
Spending time with children / grandchildren
71%
51%
25%
70%
34%
32%
19. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
We are not all the same
Introducing …
Square Holes’ Driver Segments
20. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Carefree Survivors Jo Average Dreamers
A bit about me …
I’m an older female focused
on my family. Other loves
include new experiences,
and time to relax.
I’m a male on a lower than
average income just getting
by how best I can. My family
is important
I’m a typical person. My
family is important to me,
yet I also love new
experiences.
My mind is firmly set on the
future – living the dream.
Experiencing life, learning
new things and chilling out.
Segment size 12% 11% 48% 29%
Who are they …
Gender Skewed to females [64%] Skewed to males [66%] Spread across Spread across
Age
Skewed to older
[62%;>40yrs]
Spread across Spread across
Skewed to younger
[75%;<40yrs]
Average income $69,000 $48,000 $67,000 $68,000
Drivers …
Experiences 71% 28% 78% 73%
Personal Growth 35% 13% 38% 32%
Time Out 55% 33% 51% 55%
Active Lifestyle 29% 14% 39% 34%
Escape 6% 18% 33% 24%
Family 92% 50% 87% 47%
21. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
More about what we love …
22. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
23. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
family friends
brandspassions
24. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Family, 78%
Friends, 45%
Passions
Brands
Good food 41%
Travel Oz 30%
Travel O/S 29%
Internet 27%
Reading 27%
Eating out 24%
Movies 24%
Relaxing 20%
New things 20%
Food 33%
Travel 29%
Technology 28%
Communication 20%
Beverages 19%
Motor vehicles 14%
Clothing & accessories 13%
Everyday 9%
Retail 9%
Services [eg banking] 3%
Only 5% love their workmates
Only 2% love their neighbours
25. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
So, what are the
Top 10 Loved Brands?
26. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Number 1?
27. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
28. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Number 1?
29. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
If you’re not relevant, you’re invisible
Are you
talking to
me?
30. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
31. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
If you’re not sincere, I can’t trust you
Don’t
give me
any
bullshit!
32. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
New media has a key role in
cutting the bullshit
33. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
sincerity
relevance
Where do you fit?
If you’re not relevant,
you’re invisible!
Don’t give me any bullshit?
Love
34. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Communication
Technology
Beverages
Food
Everyday Retail
Travel
Motor Vehicles
Services
Clothing &
access
sincerity
relevance
35. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
There are notable category
differences
36. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
37. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
38. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
39. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
It’s all about marketers sincerely fitting
with consumers, not vice versa
40. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Clothingandaccessories
Services
Motorvehicles
Travel
Retail
Everydayproducts
Food
Beverages
Technology
Communication
Aesthetic appeal - looking good 59% 4% 34% 9% 29% 23% 6% 4% 28% 10%
Basic needs - something you can't live without 29% 68% 49% 19% 50% 61% 43% 34% 52% 66%
Self indulgence - it's about you 46% 7% 32% 43% 41% 42% 55% 57% 39% 24%
Family and friends - something you share 11% 10% 22% 42% 20% 19% 37% 42% 33% 37%
Safety and well-being - security and health 6% 30% 38% 27% 8% 14% 9% 7% 8% 15%
Success - pride and fulfillment 12% 14% 23% 13% 11% 6% 5% 4% 18% 10%
Loved brands are often ‘something I can’t
live without,’ unlike competing brands
41. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
42. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
When love goes wrong
43. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
SwingingSubstance
People need people Just words
BaggageTrying too hard
44. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
“How can brands expect us to love them, when
they don’t do what they say?”
Substance
45. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
“It’s like they just don’t want to talk to
us anymore”
People need people
46. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Love doesn’t guarantee sales
Swinging
Communication
Technology
Beverages
Food
Everydayproducts
Retail
Travel
Motorvehicles
Services
Clothingandaccessories
Other
<20% 47% 62% 58% 58% 51% 44% 56% 57% 55% 56% 55%
20-50% 18% 19% 19% 20% 20% 28% 19% 18% 20% 27% 23%
>50% 34% 20% 25% 21% 28% 27% 25% 24% 25% 16% 23%
It just improves the chance of demanding a brand
Proportion of annual category spend
47. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
“When ‘love’ is used in advertising it is
annoying. They don’t love us”
Just words
48. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Ave 36%
16-20 62%
21-30 42%
31-39 38%
40-49 30%
50+ 24%
sincerity
relevance
sincerity
relevance
sincerity
relevance
sincerity
relevance
Trying too hard
You can’t please everyone
49. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Baggage
Too many bad relationships
Relevance
Sincerity
Love
16-20 21-30 31-39 40-49 50+
Age …
50. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
Baggage
Too many bad relationships
Need segments …
Relevance
Sincerity
Love
Carefree Survivors Jo Average Dreamers
51. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
So, what am I saying?
How do you get to the heart of
consumers?
52. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
53. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
But, there’s no ‘one-size fits all’
You need to get intimate with your
consumers and understand them
54. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected
The consumer is not a moron
Drivers
Needs
Emotions
Love
‘Get to the
hearts of
consumers’
Creativity
Connect with your consumers
+
Clarity
Find message precision
+
Commitment
Think big
Be brave
Make a difference
Sincerity
If you’re not sincere,
I can’t trust you
‘Don’t give me any bullshit’
+
Relevance
If you’re not relevant,
you’re invisible
‘Are you talking to me?’
Communications Consumers
Sincerely
fitting with
consumer
lives
Speaking
with the
right tone
What
drivers
them?
55. ‘Make Love Not War Research’ [2010] by Squares Holes Pty Ltd. All rights protected