SSA partnered with ABC Pty, an FMCG company in Indonesia facing rising costs, to improve profitability. SSA diagnosed inefficiencies across ABC's operations and developed a three-pronged approach using Lean, DMAIC problem solving, and TPM. Lean eliminated waste in 13 production lines, improving productivity 20%. DMAIC reduced material loss 30% in 5 lines. TPM improved machine availability 26% in 4 lines. Overall, SSA's initiatives generated over $1 million in annual savings for ABC through cost reduction and productivity gains.
1. Profitability Improvement in FMCG Manufacturing Operations
SSA embarked its journey to expand and serve, to international markets and Indian MNCs abroad,
in the year 2011. During this course, SSA came across varied industries like FMCG, Machine
Manufacturing and other service industries, across Africa and Asia, who in specific had
requirements to improve their operational profitability. This was because industries around the
world were challenged with increase in labour, material cost and other operating costs. ABC Pty (a
subsidiary in Indonesia of an Indian MNC giant) is one such FMCG who was facing these
challenges. The following article describes how SSA had handheld and supported ABC to deploy
‘Profitability Improvement & Cost reduction drive’ using process improvement tools and
techniques.
Business Challenge
ABC Pty is an FMCG serving Indonesia and nearby Southeast Asian markets with Home Care and
Body Care products, with a turnover of approx. INR 1500 Cr. ABC recently came across two major
challenges in their business, which was eating away their available operating gross margins. One of
them was, rise of about 55% in minimum wages as enforced by the local government; and the other
major challenge was devalue of local currency which increased their cost of material that was
imported from different parts of world. This led to an immediate need for a Cost reduction drive
across the plant operations, which can help themcompensate against the current challenges raised.
It is not the strongest of the species that survives, Or the most intelligent that survives.
It is the one that is the most adaptable to change.
- Charles Darwin
SSA partnered with ABC Pty to initially diagnose and identify the focus areas for Cost reduction
and define a time bound approach to achieve the desired financial savings, which delivers a
perpetual result for the Organization.
Diagnosis
SSA has a unique approach to diagnose and prescribe roadmap for profitability improvement. This
diagnosis is carried out across all the organization’s elements like Sales & Marketing, NPD cell,
Product Design, Production Planning, Procurement, Production, Supply chain and Warehouse. The
focus of Diagnosis is to identify profit leakages, identify opportunity for process optimization,
calculate Cost of Poor Quality & financial losses and finally estimate the potential savings
opportunity across the organization.
2. Approach to Improvement
Based on the diagnosis and identified focus areas in product manufacturing lines, SSA took a three
pronged approach to deploy Operational cost reduction initiative at ABC. The basic focus was to
deploy process improvement techniques to achieve the financial goals using these three
methodologies – Lean Manufacturing, DMAIC problem solving and Total Productive Maintenance
(TPM).
Project Deployment
ABC has about 25 to 30 products and each product category has a separate manufacturing line
setup. At ABC Pty plant almost 13 production lines had an opportunity to improve productivity by
deploying Lean. The focus of deployment was to eliminate wastage in material movement caused
due to convoluted layout, eliminate over-processing, improve resource utilization through capacity
balancing, reduce process cycle time of manual operations through Kaizens and reduce WIP
through flow balancing.
Following Rapid Lean approach was deployed to achieve necessary productivity and financial goals:
3. PrintingDryingCutting
Start
Arrange for
sheets
Open the pack
of sheets and
arrange on
table
Check and refill
the ink, if
required
Printing - place
sheets on machine
for continuous
printing
Halt for
paper
arrange
ment
Arrange sheets
in set of 100
post printing
Move sheets to
common WIP
area
sheets
waiting
for next
process
1000 pcs
7 for 6 machines
6 for machine and
1 for WIP arrangement
Move sheets from
WIP table to Spray
feed table
Arrange sheets
for feed
Feed sheets to
Line - 2 at a
time
Automated
Spraying
operation
Automated 1st
drying
operation
Check for
Unsprayed
sheets and
remove them
Sheets
collected in
Tray post
1st drying
Halt due
to spray
issues
Lot of halt issues
Halts are done afetr
every 6 to 8 pages
Sheets
arranged at the
tray
8 for 2 machines
4 for feeding
2 spraying experts
2 at collection
400 pcs
Arrange Sheets
for Sizing
Size the sheets
before cutting -
300 sheets
sized together
Arrange sheets
for Cutting
Cut sheets to small
pcs - 300 sheets
Cut together to
prepare 9000 pcs
Arrange the cut
pcs in Trays
Move Tray to
packing tables
Pcs
waiting
in Trays
2 for 2 machines used for
cutting sheets to small pcs
Sheets
Process Flow -
Before
1800 pcs
Arrange tray &
pcs on
machines to
pack
Feed the
machine with
3pcs in each
slot for Packing
Machine to
Pack the pcs in
sachet
Collect 12
sachets and
rubber band
around them
Sachets waiting
for next operation
- till 12 rubber
packs are made
At
collection,
check for
proper
paking
PrintingDryingCuttingof3Spcs
Start
Arrange for
sheets
Open the pack
of sheets and
arrange on
table
Check and refill
the ink, if
required
Printing - place
sheets on machine
for continuous
printing
100 pcs
6 for 6 machines
6 for machine and
Arrange sheets
for feed
Feed sheets to
Line - 2 at a
time
Automated
Spraying
operation
Automated 1st
drying
operation
Check for
Unsprayed
sheets and
remove them
Sheets
collected in
Tray post
1st drying
6 for 2 machines
2 for feeding
2 spraying experts
2 at collection
400 pcs
Arrange Sheets
for Sizing
Size the sheets
before cutting -
300 sheets
sized together
Arrange sheets
for Cutting
Cut sheets to small
pcs - 300 sheets
Cut together to
prepare 9000 pcs
Slide to Cutting
table
2 for 2 machines used for
cutting sheets to small pcs
Arrange tray &
pcs on
machines to
pack
Feed the
machine with
3pcs in each
slot for Packing
Machine to
Pack the pcs in
sachet
Collect 12
sachets and
rubber band
around them
Sachets waiting
for next operation
- till 12 rubber
packs are made
At
collection,
check for
proper
paking
Collect 12
rubber packs
bags to
wait till 4 Prepare
Fill each carton Seal the
Carton
Process Flow -
After
Sample Lean Deployment in a production line:
Let us consider one product ZRoll. ZRoll is one of the highest selling products for ABC Pty. The
ideal production line has a capacity to produce about 30,000 pieces per day, based on the capacity
of constraint process. As against this, the line was producing about 22,000 pieces per day, which is
almost 73% of the bought capacity. The target was to improve the productivity and produce at least
90% of the bought capacity. Rapid Lean was deployed for the line and a detailed analysis was done
through Production stream mapping, Gemba walks and Capacity analysis. Significant improvement
was brought through Layout Changes, Capacity re-balancing along with manpower re-allocation
and Kaizens.
Sample section analysis and before & after condition:
Process Flow - Before Process Flow - After
4. Kindly note, multiple activities were eliminated in post improvement conditions, reducing the
overall lead time, individual process cycle time and resources engaged in wasteful activities.
5. Specific DMAIC projects were taken in material filling, liquid filling and gas filling production
lines to reduce loss of material due to process variation, spillage and leakage issues. These projects
followed the regular roadmap of Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve and Control. Detailed
brainstorming was done to identify potential root causes and then statistical analysis was done to
identify and verify the causation. Appropriate technical solutions were implemented and optimal
process parameters were defined with standard SOPs to obtain the desired financial gains.
Many product manufacturing lines in ABC Pty were highly dependent on semi-automatic machines.
The downtime of these machines was a major issue identified during the diagnosis and hence TPM
(Total Productive Maintenance) was initiated for 6 machines in 4 specific production lines.
Following roadmap was implemented by SSA to deploy TPM at ABC Pty:
It’s a unique 3 phase approach for TPM which focuses on bottom line profitability and builds
autonomous maintenance culture across the plant.
TPM initially focused on increasing the uptime of machines by:
Eliminating deviations identified in machine during basic machine evaluation
Solving chronic machine issues
Give basic knowledge to workers on different machine systems like Mechanical,
Lubrication, and Hydraulics etc.
These basic steps in itself supported in reducing the downtime and increased per shift production,
thus resulting in substantial annual benefits in running these machines.
6. Following is a sample of deviation analysis performed by team:
Deliverables:
SSA looked into ABC’s current production practices and identified opportunities for cost
reduction and productivity improvement
With Lean tools and techniques, SSA enhanced Labour productivity and eliminated flow issues
in specific production lines
Identified areas for improving point efficiency and eliminated issues like spillage, leakage,
material loss and process variation through DMAIC problem solving
Improved asset utilization, machine performance and thereby increased production per shift by
building TPM culture
Results achieved & financial gains
Following were the monetary results achieved by the team
Initiative Savings Generated
Lean Deployed in 13 production lines, it achieved
an improvement of 20% in productivity in $ 5,45,000
7. these lines
DMAIC Deployed in 5 production lines, it achieved
30% reduction in material loss and process
leakages
$ 3,20,000
TPM Deployed in 4 production lines, it achieved
26% improvement in machine availability,
directly helping to save shift running cost
$2,70,000
So an overall annualized savings of 1 million USD and above was achieved for ABC Pty through
this Profitability improvement initiative by SSA.