Ethical Challenges in Research with Developing Communities
•Descargar como PPTX, PDF•
2 recomendaciones•764 vistas
![Road Map ,[object Object]]()
Recomendados
Recomendados
Más contenido relacionado
Similar a Ethical Challenges in Research with Developing Communities
Similar a Ethical Challenges in Research with Developing Communities (20)
Más de the nciia
Más de the nciia (20)
Ethical Challenges in Research with Developing Communities
- 1. Ethical Challenges in Research with Developing Communities Carey Bell Rachel Dzombak Tara SulewskiKhanjan Mehta Humanitarian Engineering & Social Entrepreneurship (HESE) Program The Pennsylvania State University
- 3. Importance of ‘Research’
- 4. The Institutional Review Board (IRB)
- 5. Challenges Faced & Lessons LearnedNavigating the IRB process Conducting study in Kenya Larger Conflicts and Challenges
- 6. HESE @ Penn State
- 8. EDSGN 452 || Section 1 ESSENTIAL DESIGN Renewable Energy Solar Driers Anaerobic Digesters Wastewater Management Water Filtration Systems Briquetting Machines Water Well Drilling Rigs
- 9. EDSGN 452 || Section 2 Mashavu: Networked Health Solutions for the Developing World 234 Students + 5 Faculty 40 Majors & Ten colleges
- 10. EDSGN 452 || Section 3 WishVast Building Trust and Social Capital using Cell Phones Beta-tested in Kenya; Pilot Testing in South Africa
- 11. EDSGN 452 || Section 4 iSPACES: Rethinking Science Education in Tanzania Bachelors of Education (Science) Degree Science, Systems and Entrepreneurship
- 12. EDSGN 452 || Section 5 Project Prerana + Mpower ICT Solutions for Women’s Education Affordable Technologies for Maternal Health
- 13. Fieldwork: Real; Rigorous; Intense
- 14. Research Emphasis Applied Science, Designs, Methodologies, Curricular Models Lessons Learned & Resources 23P; 6R; 9M; 5D; 12N
- 15. Why Research?
- 17. Increased Academic Rigor
- 18. Enhanced Résumés
- 20. Institutional Review Board Review and Approve ‘research’ involving human participation Operates independently in compliance with Federal Regulations Exempt Expedited Full Review
- 21. Navigating the IRB Informed Consent Form FDA Approval Local Approval Detailed Protocol Minimal Risk Expedited (3 weeks) Data Storage & Disposal Photos Location Collaboration Letters Recruitment Script
- 22. Benefits of IRB Standardization; Rigor; Peace of Mind
- 23. Critiques of IRB Biomedical Res; Time constraints; Simplification
- 24. Research in Developing Communities Chaotic;
- 25. Research in Developing Communities Chaotic; Dynamic;
- 26. Research in Developing Communities Chaotic; Dynamic; Unfamiliar
- 27. Countdown: Lessons Learned 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
- 28. 10: Kumi Preparing Protocol START EARLY!!!
- 29. 9: Tisa Preparing Protocol Be concise; Meet Face to Face; Get Letters
- 30. 8: Nane Preparing Protocol Risk Management: What if???
- 31. HakunaMatata 7: Saba Recruitment and Consent
- 32. 6: Sita HakunaMatata Language Barrier
- 33. 5: Tano HakunaMatata Research Participation Incentives
- 34. 4: Nne HakunaMatata Involvement Criteria
- 35. 3: Tatu Non-medical student Engagement HakunaMatata
- 36. 2: Mbili Larger Conflicts Research on a shoestring budget
- 37. 1: Moja Larger Conflicts “Hit and Run” Research Ethical?
- 38. Larger Conflicts 0: Sifuri Chaos of Eship (in Africa) vs. Discipline of Research
- 39. Appropriate & Rigorous Research and Design to Build Multi-Million Smile Enterprises
Notas del editor
- Current VenturesImportance of ‘Research’The IRBLessons LearnedNavigating the IRB processWhile in KenyaPreparing Research ProposalsLarger Conflicts and ChallengesCurrent VenturesImportance of ‘Research’The IRBLessons LearnedNavigating the IRB processWhile in KenyaPreparing Research ProposalsLarger Conflicts and Challenges
- Innovative Designs
- Anecdotal vs. (in)Credible ResearchIncreased Academic RigorEnhanced RésumésBuilding a body of knowledge
- Two of the most notorious of these abuses were the experiments of Nazi physicians that became a focus of the post-World War II Doctors' Trial, and the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, a project conducted between 1932 and 1972 by the U.S. Public Health Service on black men in rural Alabama to study the natural progression of untreated syphilis in poor, rural black men who thought they were receiving free health care from the U.S. government.[1]. Tuskegee Syphilis Study Exposed in 1972 ethical standards; primarily because researchers knowingly failed to treat patients appropriately after the 1940s validation of penicillin as an effective cure for the disease they were studyingThe Nuremberg Code is a set of research ethics principles for human experimentation set as a result of the Subsequent Nuremberg Trials at the end of the Second World War. Declaration of helsinkiwas developed by the World Medical Association (WMA), as a set of ethical principles for the medical community regarding human experimentation, and is widely regarded as the cornerstone document of human research ethics. The Declaration is an important document in the history of research ethics as the first significant effort of the medical community to regulate research itself, and forms the basis of most subsequent documents.Prior to the 1947 Nuremberg Code there was no generally accepted code of conduct governing the ethical aspects of human research, although some countries, notably Germany and Russia, had national policies [3a]. The Declaration developed the ten principles first stated in the Nuremberg Code . The Declaration more specifically addressed clinical research,Nuremberg Code and the related[1] Declaration of Helsinki are the basis for the Code of Federal Regulations Title 45 Volume 46 [3], which are the regulations issued by the United States Department of Health and Human Services governing federally-funded research in the United Statespassed by Congress National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical & Behavioral Research established to oversee and regulate the use of human experimentation in medicine
- taraFormal structure….operate independently from their parent structure and in compliance with federal regulationsDon’t know what picture to put here *
- RachelHow many IRBs did we have to submit for our trip, this is what I came up with:Mashavu’s IRBs: Health Clinic Interview Health Interview Fun Survey Community Focus Groups Doctor and Nurse Focus groupsWishvast: Community Interviews (more detail)Essential Design: Anaerobic Digester communityinterviewsChartak’s Nairobi Interviews (may have mispelled his name)
- Standardize Research Methods and approach to ethical dilemmasDevelop students as researchers
- Biomed researchTimeAmerican contextRegulations impede research, particularly in the social sciencesTime constraintsFrustration leads to simplifying research
- Rachel
- rachelInherently chaotic and unpredictable
- rachelInherently chaotic and unpredictable
- Rachel
- RachelBe concise while eliminating potential points of misunderstanding.Penn state requires 5 days to approve exempt reviews, ours took 2 months for approval,IRB is inundated with IRB requests at this time of the year
- RachelBe concise while eliminating potential points of misunderstanding.If irb approval is needed, must get approvalIf not, approval from local officials is necessaryUPS situation
- RachelBe concise while eliminating potential points of misunderstanding.Splitting of IRBs to reduce riskHave to consider “what if? “Something happens on the ground? IRB expects protocols to be in place]Someone comes very sick to the clinic – emergency hospital
- CareyRecruitment and Consent
- Language Barrier
- No direct incentive for participation, customary to conduct over food/drink which is more just part of the businessWe also gave our stamps with infoResearch Participation Incentives
- CareyInvolvement CriteriaIRB approval for a kids kiosk for play, no data collected
- CareyNon-medical students and medically oriented research
- Strictures of the IRB and those of a Student Research BudgetAs our IRB admitted, most of these IRB are performed on large budget sufficient staff
- RachelBe concise while eliminating potential points of misunderstanding.Research or entrepreneurship? Entities that focus on both, particularly troubled by researchers that swoop in, do their research and fly out, gathering what they need from the community and leaving nothing behindWhat happens when they do collide? Khanjan comes in, next we are looking at:Blah blahblah, ethical and business issues that arrise when eship and research collide.
- Pick either 24 or 25 couldn’t decide what I liked betterThe discipline of research and chaos of eship