Debate/Debat B. Ing, Materi, Contoh, Wisatawan Mengeksploitasi Budaya Kita

1. THAT TOURISM EXPLOITS OUR CULTURE
- AFFIRMATIVE
* DEFINITION
Culture is a complex whole that it contains the knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and
any other capabilities acquired skills by a person as a member of society.
Culture can be defined as a way of life that developed and owned jointly by a group of people
and passed from generation to generation.
Exploitation is the act with or without the consent of the victim which include a variety of things
that take advantage of the power and ability of a person by another party to benefit both material and
immaterial.
Exploitation is the use of political arbitrarily excessive exploitation of something which is only
subject to purely economic interests without considerations sense of decency, fairness and welfare
compensation.
As we know, in our country in Indonesia, we have various culture diverse cultures both in the
arts, tourism, local language, local homes, food and other areas. For example, the island of Lombok,
the tower, the beach. In addition there are many other cultures are not known by public, such as the
island of komodo. Before organized exploitation, Komodo island has not been widely recognized by
the public and even the world. Though Komodo island is a amazing island. Fortunately with organized
exploitation, could introduce Komodo island.
* SOME BENEFIT FROM TOURISM EXPLOITS OUR CULTURE
There are some benefit that we get from tourism exploits our culture, among them are :
1. We can show our culture to the world by tourism. Indirectly, exploits the culture can introducing
excess in this country. If the world know more about the culture it will make abroad people be
interested to visited our country.
2. Exploits our culture by tourism, we can find some beautiful hidden culture. We can bring it and
promote it in the world as the pride of our nation.
3. Exploits our culture by tourism will increase seen in the world. There are many people will come
and want to know more about the culture. This all can be happen if that tourism exploits our
culture.
With the exploits, all the potential culture can be better developed. Any shortfall can be covered slowly
and any excess could be improved to benefit. Even with the exploitation that could significantly affect
to the country because in addition to income, the state can also be known for the beauty of the diverse
tourism.

2. * Negative
Culture is a complex whole that it contains the knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and
any other capabilities acquired skills by a person as a member of society.
Culture can be defined as a way of life that developed and owned jointly by a group of people
and passed from generation to generation.
Exploitation is the act with or without the consent of the victim which include a variety of things
that take advantage of the power and ability of a person by another party to benefit both material
and immaterial.
Exploitation is the use of political arbitrarily excessive exploitation of something which is only
subject to purely economic interests without considerations sense of decency, fairness and welfare
compensation.
The rise of cultural exploitation in tourism abused by people who are not responsible.
Exploitation raises human trafficking, it so dangerous because in addition to interest in the beauty of
the place only, a lot of foreigners who seek sexual satisfaction. It is happen in Bali, many sexual slavery
and night clubs there. This is the main result and reason of the exploitation of culture.
* BAD IMPACT
1. Would disrupt the natural balanced of the ecosystem. Because indirectly act of the exploitation will
change the original order forms of nature. In fact, often destruction exploitation of nature and the
environment. For example, a lot of trees in the coastal areas cleared for hotel building.
2. From the cultural arts, the various performing arts exploited displayed by the general public,
including people outside the state will bring an unpleasant action. For example, reog ponorogo from
our country copy in Malaysia. This is due to our country is not prepared to set up their own culture.

3. THAT BALI IS THE ONLY DESTINATION
- AFFIRMATIVE
* DEFINITION
Bali is an amazing island with many beautiful place. Especially in the coastal sector. One of the
most interest is the view of the sunset was beautiful. Event the island known as the island of the God. In
Indonesia, Bali is the place most visited by tourist both domestic tourist and foreign tourist in the
country.
Bali is a tourist spot that is recognized by the entire word in natural beauty and cultural richness
that is very thick. Beaches in Bali also in one of the ten best beaches in the world. 7 best beach in Bali,
there are,
1. Padai Bai beach
2. Dreamland beach
3. Legian and Seminyak beach
4. Sanur beach
5. Amed and Tulamben
6. Lovina beach
7. Candi Dasa beach
* REASON
Bali has a variety of beauty that can captivate all visitors.
* FACTOR
There are some factor why Bali is the only destination, among them are:
1. Having a unique culture.
Bali have a beautiful and unique culture. Many local and foreign tourists visiting Bali because of the
variety and uniqueness of its culture. The culture that is able to attract a variety of captivating
tourists, both from Asia and outside Asia. Regional Tourism Bali recorded as much as 41.38 percent
of foreign tourists who come to Bali because of the uniqueness of Balinese culture. In 2003, there
were 993,029 people of foreign tourists to Bali. The number rose 46.85 percent in 2004 to 1,458,309
people. While in the period January to August 2005, there are 1,004,656 people are foreign tourists
to Bali.
2. Natural beauty
Bali has a variety of amazing natural beauty. A very beautiful and charming.
3. People
Balinese friendliness makes Bali visited by many foreign tourists. Most people honest, intelligent,
have good manners.
4. Image
Bali is well known to many people, both from within the country and abroad will be everything he
had. It makes the visitors curious and tempted to visit Bali. After visiting Bali, visitors interested in
coming back.

4. 5. Prices
Based on Long Haul Report survey that compares the cost of a holiday in 32 cities, Indonesia is at the
third position, especially Bali. Tourism in Bali is not too expensive, as well as products that are
available in Bali. This is certainly the main attraction for visitors or tourists.
* Some special thing in Bali. There are :
1. Bali has a variety of hotels that some countries both asia and Europe prefers to Bali than the other
island
2. Balinese hospitality that has been well known that is made the foreign tourist visiting bali couldn’t get
bored.
3. Bali has an incredible surf spot in Kuta or Sanur Beach which makes many tourist amazed.
4. Bali has adequate facilities and support such as resorts, hotels, and restaurants that can make Bali is
the only destination.
5. Bali is famous as the island of God in the world as a symbol of the incredible beauty of Bali.
6. Some craft and art shows that spoil anyone’s eyes that see them.
7. Some reason why Bali is the only destination
Now the government is heavily promoting Bali as a tourist attraction that must be visited in Indonesia.
Bali has beautiful places and unique that is not owned by another island.
For it is evident that every tourist who
disappointed.
comes either domestically or abroad have never been

5. - NEGATIVE
* DEFINITION
Bali is a province in the country of Indonesia. The island is located in the westernmost end of
the Lesser Sunda Islands, lying between Java to the west and Lombok to the east.
Bali is the name of the province of Bali in Indonesia and also the name of the largest island that
is part of the province. Besides consists of the island of the Bali, Bali province also consists of the islands
smaller in the vicinity.
* REASON
Bali is not the only islands that made attraction in Indonesia. Even now emerging islands in
Indonesia, which has a beauty that is not inferior to the islands of Bali. So there is still many beautiful
islands beside Bali islands in Indonesia.
There are some complained about the condition of Bali by the tourist, among them are :
1. Based on a survey of Bali Provincial Tourism Office, who first complained of tourists while in Bali is
garbage, traffic, and airports.
2. According to Andrew Marshall in Time magazine, Kuta Beach is now polluted. Swimming in Kuta for
half an hour would make your skin allergy.
3. According to Andrew Marshall was also lavish in Bali construction of buildings that are not supported
with adequate facilities such as parking and more. It is then that one of the causes of traffic Bali
became chaotic.
* WEAKNESS OF BALI ISLAND
1. Bali still lack the hall, so bali isn’t a promise to hold a business meeting/agreement.
2. Bali is still often have problems of water shortage, power failure, garbage strewn and of course this is
very disturbing comfort of tourists
Now besides Bali island, there are many island in Indonesia already be tourism island. There are
1. LOMBOK
Lombok island caught the attention of tourists. Lombok has now become an icon of tourism in
Indonesia, the beauty of the island of Lombok in Indonesia is second to none. The good attitude of
Sasak people beautiful beaches coral reefs and extra ordinary biological richness, splendor of mount
Rinjani and cultural uniqueness Sasak many inviting tourist appresation.
The beauty of the island of Lombok and eksotic will invite honeymooners. Similarly the eksotic
island gillis will also invite people to enjoy the beauty of the island. Lombok natural beauty makes it be
one of some place o destination.
2. RAJA AMPAT PAPUA
Raja Ampat Papua is a tourist area of maritime tourism in the world, both from the natural
beauty, cultural richness and various marine life here. Raja Ampat Papua is located in the remote west
Papua.. This area stores a million beauty beneath the sea. Raja Ampat marine tourism is recognized as
one of ten best diving in the world. The charm and natural wealth under a mainstay Raja Ampat to the
competitive in the world. This region is known as the richest natural resources in tropical Indonesia.
3. KOMODO ISLAND

6. Komodo island is famous for its uniqueness that is an island that has a beautiful beach and
around the island there are many Komodo which should now include rare animals. In fact, Komodo
island is designated as one of the wonders of the world.