Poka-yoke is a Japanese term that means "mistake-proofing" or "inadvertent error prevention". A poka-yoke is any mechanism in a process that helps an equipment operator avoid mistakes and defects by preventing, correcting, or drawing attention to human errors as they occur.
2. Introduction
• Poka-yoke is a Japanese term that means "mistake-proofing" or
"inadvertent error prevention".
• A poka-yoke is any mechanism in a process that helps an
equipment operator avoid mistakes and defects by preventing,
correcting, or drawing attention to human errors as they occur.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 2
3. • Poka-yoke is a Japanese quality control technique developed by
former Toyota engineer Shigeo Shingo.
• Translated as “mistake-proofing”, poka-yoke aims to prevent defects
in the manufacturing process that are the result of human error.
• Poka-yoke is a lean manufacturing technique that ensures that the
right conditions exist before a step in the process is executed.
• This makes it a preventative form of quality control since errors are
detected and then rectified before they occur.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 3
4. Understanding poka-yoke
• Some process errors cannot be detected ahead of time.
• In this case, the poka-yoke technique seeks to eliminate errors as
early on in the process as is feasible.
• Although the poka-yoke technique became a key part of Toyota’s
manufacturing process, it can be applied to any industry or indeed
any situation where there is potential for human error.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 4
5. • One of the most well-known examples of poka-yoke in action is in the case of
a manual automobile.
• The driver must engage the clutch (a process step) before changing gears.
• This prevents unintended movement of the car and reduces wear on the
engine and gearbox.
• Another example can be found in washing machines, which do not operate if
the door isn’t closed properly to prevent flooding.
• In both cases, poka-yoke principles mean that automation is in place to
prevent errors before they occur.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 5
6. Six principles of poka-yoke
Elimination
Prevention.
Replacement
Facilitation
Detection
Mitigation
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 6
7. Elimination
The most preferable solution. It
involves redesigning a product
or process so that a particular
step is no longer necessary.
Prevention
or engineering a product or
service so that it is virtually
impossible for an individual
to make a mistake.
Replacement
Can a more reliable process
be substituted in to lessen
the chances of an error
occurring?
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 7
8. • Facilitation – or the adoption of techniques to make a task easier to
perform. This may involve combining certain steps.
• Detection – or identifying an error before further process steps are
undertaken. This allows the error to be rectified without further
damage to equipment or personnel.
• Mitigation – the least preferable solution. Here, the aim is to
minimize the effects of errors without necessarily solving them.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 8
9. Three types of poka-yoke
SERVER
POKA-YOKES
Task poka-
yokes,
Treatment
poka-yokes,
and
Tangible poka-
yokes.
CUSTOMER
POKA-YOKES
Preparation
poka-yokes.
Encounter
poka-yokes.
Resolution
poka-yokes.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 9
10. Task poka-yokes.
• Task poka-yokes focus on server tasks and common mistakes servers
make while performing the service/task for the customer.
• A good example of a control-oriented, task poka-yoke is the coin return
machine used in may fast-food restaurants.
• The coin portion of a customer's change from payment is returned
automatically through these machines.
• This takes the control out of the hands of the cash register operator,
eliminating errors and speeding up the processing of customers.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 10
11. Treatment poka-yokes
• Treatment poka-yokes focus on the social interaction between the
customer and the server (i.e., eye contact, greeting).
• By mistake-proofing/standardizing what servers say and do to customers,
managers can reasonably ensure that customers receive proper, fair and
consistent treatment.
• Burger King utilized warning-oriented, treatment poka-yokes by placing
"cue cards" at the service point ensuring that servers know what to say
the minute they interface with the customer.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 11
12. Tangible poka-yokes.
• Tangible poka-yokes attempt to improve the tangible, physical
impression and experience for the customer in addition to the direct task
of the server (i.e., dirty office, unkempt server, sloppy documents).
• Motorola uses a control-oriented poka-yoke in the legal department by
having a second lawyer inspect all legal work for spelling, presentation,
and arithmetic.
• In this way, the legal department is ensuring that the "tangibles" of the
service are satisfactory in addition to the task of the service (legal work).
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 12
13. Customer Poka-yokes-Preparation Poka-yokes.
• Preparation poka-yokes attempt to fully prepare the customer before
they even enter the service.
• An example of a warning-oriented, preparation poka-yoke is the notice a
university sends to each student prior to registration for the next
semester detailing the courses he needs to finish his degree.
• This system could be converted to a control system by having an
automated registration process which would not allow students to sign
up for classes out of sequence or until all prerequisites are met.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 13
14. Encounter Poka-yokes.
• Encounter poka-yokes attempt to fail-safe a customer at a service
who may misunderstand, ignore, or forget the nature of the service
or their role in it. A good example of a control-oriented, encounter
poka-yoke is the use of concrete curbing at an oil& lube shop that
directs customers so that they do not/cannot pull the wrong way
into the station. This system also assists in the selection process so
that customers are not served out of order.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 14
15. Resolution Poka-yokes.
• Resolution poka-yokes attempt to remind customers of the value of their
input to the continuous improvement of a service.
• A hotel which uses an automated check-out system through the
television in each room could attach a few questions to the check-out
process to ensure the customer provides feedback on key issues.
• This would be a control-oriented resolution poka-yoke.
• Obviously, one of the keys to the success of any customer-oriented poka-
yoke is to obtain willing customer participation.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 15
16. Benefits of poka-yoke principles for businesses
• Improved profitability
• Errors on production lines decrease profitability – whether that be through
line shutdowns or expensive worker injuries.
• But poka-yoke principles improve a company’s bottom line in other ways.
• For example, hotels now require that guests insert their key-card into a slot
to activate electricity in their room.
• Since many guests do not bother to turn the lights off after they leave, the
hotel can save money on wasted electricity consumption.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 16
17. • Improved productivity
• Preventing errors before they occur increases productivity.
• Online forms require that every field be filled out before submission.
• This reduces errors in forms resulting from incomplete or missing information,
saving the company time and money in having to chase up consumers for the
extra details.
• ATMs also chime or flash to remind the customer to retrieve their debit card and
cash.
• This greatly reduces the once common error of customers leaving their cards in
the machine.
• It also saves the bank money in loss prevention, giving customer support the
resources to deal with other problems.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 17
18. • Simplification of smaller, error-prone tasks
• Small tasks with high probability of error are particularly prevalent in some
industries such as the service and hospitality industries.
• Cashier errors in counting change, for example, are relatively
inconsequential errors in isolation that have the potential to lose a business
a lot of money over the long term.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 18
19. Key takeaways:
• Poka-yoke is a Japanese quality control technique that aims to make
processes error-proof.
• Although having origins in the manufacturing industry, poka-yoke
principles are useful in any scenario where there is potential for human
error.
• Poka-yoke error prevention is guided by six principles, with elimination
the most desirable and mitigation the least desirable.
• All six principles can nevertheless improve productivity, profitability,
and simplify smaller, error-prone manual tasks.
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 19
20. Barriers to implementation
• Difficulty in accepting change
• Justification of the investment
• Using inappropriate and ineffective methods
• Time requirements
• Difficulty encountered as a result of continuous process
10/22/2021 Poka-yoke 20