Stock options are about the only method many companies, including the high tech "gazelles," as rapidly growing tech-centric firms are called, can use to attract the experienced and high quality management they need. Since this business began, tech investors, including venture capitalists, have recognized that "you bet the jockey and not the horse." However, in order to attract qualified jockeys, the parties have to find a way to pay the potential managers in a currency which is meaningful to the recruit and which the issuer can afford.
2. 1
Stock options are about the only
method many companies, including the high
tech "gazelles," as rapidly growing tech-
centric firms are called, can use to attract the
experienced and high quality management
they need. Since this business began, tech
investors, including venture capitalists, have
recognized that "you bet the jockey and not the horse."
However, in order to attract qualified jockeys, the parties
have to find a way to pay the potential managers in a currency
which is meaningful to the recruit and which the issuer can afford.
Inducing someone to take a new job (and leave, in many cases, a
comfortable environment) often requires extraordinary potential
rewards.
Frequently, there is not enough spare cash around (cash
being a scarce resource in a business dependent on R&D for
growth) with which to motivate the jockeys to make a change; and
growth companies need the best jockeys, in view of their growth
ambitions.
Equity-flavored compensation (a piece of the
upside so to speak) is, therefore, an imperative.
3. 2
The problem with many commentaries on the subject of
stock options is that the writers have apparently failed to
understand features which make options particularly attractive
(prominently not, anymore, including the accounting treatment).
First, options represent the principal pieces of paper which
afford the executive a piece of the upside (at least the only
type in current use) and which do not entail a tax as of the
date of the award.
To return again to the point with which we started this discussion,
there may be little cash to spare by, among others, gazelles in
their super-growth stage. Certainly not enough to fund tax
payments to the Treasury (whether the payor is the individual or
the company).
Stock options work because there is no tax
involved as of the date of grant; restricted stock
often does not do the job because tax is owed
when the grant occurs.
Moreover, restricted stock, which makes the recipient an instant
stockholder, is unlikely to be distributed democratically; assuming
the stock has value, only the top echelon, those who can afford to
pay the tax, will be receiving restricted stock awards; an unlikely
policy for the government and the SEC to adopt expressly.
4. 3
Another virtue of stock options (often
neglected as far as I have been able to see) is
that the bonus compensation comes from the
stock market rather than from the company.
The company is able to use its cash internally;
the market itself is the one that makes the
jockey's trip worthwhile. Stock options may be an expense in the
eye of FASB but they are of no concern to, for example, creditors.
Since IRS 409A the exercise prices of the options have to be
at fair market value and that may entail an opinion from an
outside source but there are vendors which are not in the arm and
a leg variety.
Stock options are, in short, a fundamental
cornerstone of our entrepreneurial economy and
the trick is to grant them intelligently…not too
much but certainly not too little in order to keep
the jockeys in the saddle.
5. 4
This valuable information was originally published by Joseph Bartlett, Founder and
Chairman of VC Experts. If you are looking for more information on venture capital
and private equity please visit www.vcexperts.com and check out our Intelligence
Database and Reference Material.
VC Experts.com, Inc. Disclaimer: The information contained herein is from sources deemed reliable; it
does not, however, purport to constitute investment advice nor does VC Experts represent that it
contains all information concerning the identified Company deemed necessary or appropriate for
investment decisions. VC Experts is neither a broker/dealer nor investment adviser and has no financial
interest in the Company analyzed nor in the sale or purchase of any of its securities. The information and
data are for reference purposes only and no implied or expressed warranties or assurances as to its
accuracy or completeness are furnished by VC Experts. Estimates of valuation are, as indicated,
estimates based on such information as we found available, the completeness of which is neither
represented or guaranteed; users for any purpose are cautioned and required to undertake and perform
their own investigations and due diligence. To the extent that the information incorporates content
from specified sources of financial information, VC Experts disclaims any responsibility for the accuracy
or completeness of such content.
About VC Experts.com, Inc.: VC Experts.com provides specialized content, valuation & term sheet data
on thousands of venture capital financing events, and analytics for managing & modeling private
company capital structures. Visit VCExperts.com for more information.