Los días 7 y 8 de mayo organizamos en la Fundación Ramón Areces con la Fundación General CSIC el Simposio Internacional 'Microbiología: transmisión'. La "transmisión" en microbiología hace referencia al proceso por el que material genético es transferido de una célula a otra, de una población a otra. Es un proceso clave para entender el origen y la evolución de los seres vivos. El objetivo de esta reunión era conocer mejor la logística de la transmisión para ser capaces de modular o suprimir algunos procesos de transmisión dañinos.
2. Flow of antibiotic resistance genes, antibiotics
and pathogens in the environment
Built
environmentSoil
People
Water Food
Farm
animals
Wild life
3. Flow of antibiotic resistance genes, antibiotics
and pathogens in the environment
Built
environmentSoil
People
Water Food
Farm
animals
Wild life
• Viability/ infectious dose ?
• Detection/ culturable ?
• Rates of transmission and drivers ?
• Alternative hosts for replication ?
• Impacts on human health ?
• Models and mitigation
4. The connectivity of potential sources of pathogens
Wellington et al., 2013 Lancet ID
5. The connectivity of potential sources of pathogens
Host transmission: HOW WHEN WHERE IMPACT
Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex
MTBC
Antibiotic resistance genes and
pathogens
6. Transmission Routes Direct transmission
Indirect transmission
Unboiled milk
Drink blood
Meat
Contact
Aerosol
Urine, Faeces
Water use
Intensive system
Aerosol
meat
Urine, Faeces
Water use
Water use
Faecal and urine
contamination
11. qPCR vs. Culture
King et al., Sci Rep 2015
Immunoassay all test prevalence correlated with qPCR spring/summer
Spearman's rho=0.92, p=0.007
12. Bubble plot of shedding
• Small number of social groups responsible for most of the bacteria shed into the
environment
• High prevalence social groups represent biggest risk for transmission
King et al., Sci Rep 2015
15. Bacterial load
• Samples with the highest M.bovis loads usually social groups
with the highest prevalence
• Bacterial loads in faeces (proxy for respiratory shedding) robust
surrogate of onward transmission
• Mycobacterial loads and their distributions in the environment
are important in our understanding of risk
• Spatial-temporal data show the social groups that have the
highest bacterial loads and, by implication, represent the
biggest risk for transmission
16. Determining optimal sample number
• Randomised subsampling (whole year) without replacement: 10,000 bootstraps
• High prevalence groups between 5 – 20 samples per year at 95 % probability of
detecting positive
• Lower prevalence groups between 30 – 50 samples per year at 95 % probability
17. Bovine Tuberculosis in the UK
• Mycobacterium bovis
is the causative agent
of tuberculosis in
cattle
• Incidence in cattle
herds ~4%
• Spreading
geographically
• Cost taxpayers £500
million in the past 10
years
(Defra 2014)
IMPACT
18. Rainy and dry seasons
18
Faecal and dust sampling in Tanzania
19. C: cattle G: goat
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
C G C G C G C G C G C G
Malinzanga Itunundu Mboliboli Kinyika Kitisi Tungamalenga
Prevalence of Mb shedding
14.0%
9.2%
Prevalence of Mb shedding in cattle
faeces
Positive
Putative
Negative
N=390
11.2%
10.3%
Prevalence of Mb shedding in goat
faeces
Positive
Putative
Negative
N=120
Faecal shedding of M. bovis in cattle and goats
20. bTB and TB in Tanzania
Faecal shedding
Cattle herds RD4 scar assay (bTB) Goat herds
RD4 scar assay Household dust RD9 assay (TB)
21. Patterns of household shedding of M. tuberculosis
in the Tanzania case control NIH study
Mann-Whitney statistical test at the 0.05 p-value RD9 assay
No M.bovis shedding detected RD4 assay
22. Distribution and extent of M. tuberculosis shedding in TB
case households and control households in the study
region in Tanzania
IMPACT ?
23. Application of sewage sludge to land:
what is the impact on antibiotic resistance soil?
Sewage treatment and
disposal
24. Waste water treatment plants as a
reservoir for antibiotic resistance
Waste Water treatment plants
Hotspot for Horizontal Gene Transfer (HGT)
as waste received from various sources
Little is known about the impacts of
effluent further downstream in the river
or the possible role of co-selection of
antibiotic resistant determinants via
quaternary ammonium compounds
(QACs) (Gaze et al., AAC 2005, ISMEJ
2011)
25. •3 sediment cores were taken at 3 x
500m intervals below (DS) and above
(US) Finham sewage works on the River
Sowe
•Samples taken a year apart in late 2009
and early 2011
•Cultivation on Chromocult and PCR
screening 3rd generation cephalosporin
(3GC) resistance gene abundance and
diversity
WWTP effluent acts as an input and or/selects for
mobile antibiotic resistance determinants
26. 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
DS1 DS2 DS3 US1 US2 US3
Prevalence/(%)
Sample site
intI1
qacE∆1
qacE
qacH
Integron prevalence based on real time PCR
data
Down stream of WWTP Upstream of WWTP
27. Resistance Quotients Coliforms
4.48 x 105 coliforms / g DS 2.07 x 105 coliforms / g US
* P<0.05
0
5
10
15
20
25
Resistanceprevalence/(%)
Antibiotic selection
DS
US Downstream and
upstream of WWTP 2009
and 2011
*
*
*
*
* * *
Flow of resistance genes into the rivers:
Waste Water treatment plants
Amos et al., 2014. J AC 69, 1785
28. 3GC resistance gene analysis
A subset of E. coli and other Enterobacteriaceae were taken from 2011
samples for further analysis
Sequencing of blaCTX-M
revealed all belonged to
the genotype blaCTX-M-15
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CTX-M TEM SHV intI1
Prevalence/(%)
Gene
DS
US
708 blaCTX-M carrying
presumptive coliforms /
g DS
141 blaCTX-M carrying
presumptive coliforms /
g US
29. Mobilisation of blaCTX-M-15
DS E. coli carrying FIA, one DS E. coli carrying HI2.
US E. coli carrying FIB and HI2.
DS C. Freundii carrying FIB + K and one DS C. Freundii carrying FIB and I1/IY
• CTX-M-15 is carried throughout a wide range of genetic contexts and plasmids
• Contexts were seen in human pathogens, including several novel genetic contexts
• The environment may mobilise CTX-M-15 between plasmids and species and WWTP
effluent may drive this process
Amos et al., 2015
IS26 tnpa
716 bp
CTX-M-15
875 bp
ORF47
7
151 bp
47 bp spacer
ISeCP1 tnpa
181 bp
256 bp, ISeCP1 IR CTX-M-15 promoter,
spacer
CTX-M-15
875bp
IS26 tnpa
716 bp
124 bp spacer Is26 IRL 80 bp, IS26 IR CTX-M-15 promoter, spacer
CTX-M-15
875 bp
CTX-M-15
875 bp
30. Introduction or selection or both?
• More detailed typing of the E. coli (MLST) was used to
determine if E. coli were of the same origin upstream
and downstream
• Upstream the E. coli sequence types were mainly
uncharacterized (80 %), indicative of a more
environmental origin
• Downstream the sequences types were split between
the clinically familiar ST131, ST167, ST3103, ST1421
and environmental STs
• Mshana et al., 2009 “Our data demonstrate the presence of IncFI
plasmids within the prevailing E. coli population in a hospital setting
and suggest that the dissemination of CTX-M-15 allele is associated
to lateral transfer of these well-adapted, conjugative IncFI plasmids
among various E. coli genotypes.”
32. • Low-contact water sports average volume of water ingested = 3.7ml
• Risk model:
inverse cumulative Poisson distribution
• Assumption 1: The number of organisms needed for transient
colonization of a human is less than or equal to the number of organisms
need for infection.
• Assumption 2: The river will contain between 1% and 10% of the
resistance load in the sediment sample depending on the level of
disturbance in the sediment.
Human exposureIMPACT
the relative risk for each activity; children swimming (consuming on average 37 ml of water) downstream of treatment plants have a >99
% chance of being transiently colonized by a 3GC resistant coliform. Adults swimming (average water consumption 16 ml) are at high risk (
99 %) upstream and downstream if under disturbed levels of sediment. Other water-based activities such as canoeing, boating, and rowing (3
– 5 ml consumed on average (20), all carry measurable risks downstream particularly under high levels of sediment perturbation when ex
posure to resistant Enterobacteriaceae will be high (> 99 %)
33. Collaboration with Wallingford CEH, meta-data available
13 sites samples every 3 months for a year: analysed for integron
prevalence and 3GC resistance counts
Contribution of WWTP effluent to integron levels
in a whole river system
River Thames catchment area:
Amos et al., 2015 ISME J
37. CONCLUSIONS
Faecal shedding major route for transmission - DNA optimal
detection method
Pathogens survive well in environment eg MTBC and Enteric
bacteria which can transfer genes to both G+ and G- indigenous
bacteria
Pollutants, sewage, WWTP effluent associated with increased
resistance- anthropogenic effects
QUESTIONS
• What are the risks of environmental exposure?
• Which mitigation strategies are possible?
• How can efficiency of interventions be measured?
38. Acknowledgements MTBCOrin Courtenay
Emma Travis
Phillip James
David Porter
Frank Sweeney
Archer Hung
Hayley King
Andrew Murphy
Vicky Hibberd
Glyn Hewinson
Jason Sawyer
Jennifer Cork
Dez Delahay
Paul Spyvee
Rudovick Kazwala, Goodluck Paul, Joseph Malakalinga (Tanzania) and
Woutrina Millar (UCD, US)
Eamonn Gormley
Leigh Corner
39. Acknowledgements Ab resistance
University of Warwick
Dr William Gaze
Dr Greg Amos
Gemma Hill
Dr Andrew Mead
Dr Lihong Zhang
Dr Leonides Calvo-Bado
Helen Green
Abigail Carter
Shruthi Sankaranaryanan
University of Birmingham
Professor Peter Hawkey
Claire Murray
University of York
Professor Alistair Boxall