42. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
STAGES IN
DEVELOPMENT
OF BENEFICIARY
CONTRIBUTION
SCHEME
43. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
CROSS IMPACT BALANCE (CIB) ANALYSIS FOR
PROPOSED SCHEME
Qualitative but systematic form of systems analysis
Based on expert judgments of interactions of system elements
Balance algorithm to determine consistent network
configurations
Applied as qualitative scenario technique in various fields
Analysis via ScenarioWizardBasic
(Weimer-Jehle 2006)
44. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
DESCRIPTORS IN CIB
A. Financial B. Public
participation
C. Local
poverty
D. Policy and
regulation
E. Corruption F. Stakeholder
relationship
G. Political
interference
H. Project
management
I. Economic
tools
46. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
CONSISTENCY SCENARIO
Scenario No. 1 Current Scheme
A.Financial: A1 Uncertainty in budget
B.Public participation: B1 Inform- Lowest
C.Local poverty: C1 income not increase and lower than average
D.Policy and regulation: D1 Command and control
E.Corruption: E3 Strong
F.Stakeholder relationship: F1 Conflict
G.Political interference: G3 Strong
H.Project management: H1 Business as usual
I.Economic tools: I2 National and local government grants
47. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
CONSISTENCY SCENARIO
Scenario No. 2 Beneficiary Contribution
A.Financial: A2 Budget line commitment
B.Public participation: B3 Collaborate and empower-Highest
C.Local poverty: C2 Income increase but lower than average
D.Policy and regulation: D2 Collaborative decision making
E.Corruption: E1 None
F.Stakeholder relationship: F3 Collaborate and Engage
G.Political interference: G1 None
H.Project management: H2 Life cycle management
I. Economic tools: I3 Beneficiary contribution and government grants
49. >> 0 >> 1 >> 2 >> 3 >> 4 >>
USE OF TEMPLATES
You are free to use these templates for your personal
and business presentations.
Do
Use these templates for your
presentations
Display your presentation on a web
site provided that it is not for the
purpose of downloading the template.
If you like these templates, we would
always appreciate a link back to our
website. Many thanks.
Don’t
Resell or distribute these templates
Put these templates on a website for
download. This includes uploading
them onto file sharing networks like
Slideshare, Myspace, Facebook, bit
torrent etc
Pass off any of our created content as
your own work
You can find many more free templates on the
Presentation Magazine website
www.presentationmagazine.com
We have put a lot of work into developing all these templates and retain the copyright
in them. They are not Open Source templates. You can use them freely providing
that you do not redistribute or sell them.
In an attempt to solve the malfunction project problems, beneficiary contribution system is introduced.This approach is a combination of stakeholder management, responsibility sharing and technical matters. The basic principles of beneficiary contribution approach in this research are:
Process flow in the proposed beneficiary contribution scheme is presenting. This proposed scheme may facilitate responsibility sharing and sense of ownership to related stakeholder and encourage multi-stakeholder management scheme to the government official which could eliminate malfunction of small-scaled water resources project in Thailand
The purpose of this exercise is to examine the consistency of assumptions about the proposed beneficiary contribution approach as well as constructing consistent images of the network behavior.Cross-impact balance (CIB) analysis is a systematic form of qualitative system analysis to generate consistence scenarios using a balance algorithm.A typical application of CIB is to analyze scenarios and determine consistent configuration of impact networks using a pair-interaction system approach based on the concept of mathematical systems theory
Identify a list of the most relevant system factors (“descriptors”). The descriptors for this scenario analysis were extracted from relevant concepts emerged from multi-stakeholder mental models analysis. As a result from multi-stakeholder mental models associated with malfunction project analysis, the eight descriptors have been identified.Define a set of variants (qualitative alternative) which characterize the possible state of the descriptors.Asses the interactions of the impact of state x of descriptor X on the state y of descriptor Y based on appropriate investigation.Determine consistent scenarios. Consistent scenarios are determined via the influence balance of the impact network. The consistent scenarios are reported in “scenario report” generated by the ScenarioWizard software.
Two scenarios were proved to be consistent meaning that scenarios that do not contain contradictions between both perspectives.Scenario 1 is current scheme and scenario 2 is beneficiary contribution scheme with specific conditions of descriptors.