SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 9
Descargar para leer sin conexión
The ecommerce
super league
A benchmarking study of the world’s top 25 ecommerce markets
Produced in association with
Anita Balchandani
Partner and head of UK retail,
OC&C Strategy Consultants
Twenty-five years ago the World Wide Web was
introduced across the globe, and in what is a
relatively short space of time, it has already cre-
ated a big transformation in how we shop. Online
represents a material part of retail sales in many
countries around the world and consumers are
displaying a healthy propensity to shop online for
a range of categories – not just for books, media
and technology but also in fashion, beauty and
luxury where there might have originally been
scepticism about the potential for online retail.
UK retailers have not stood still in the face
of these developments and have evolved into the
leading ecommerce economy on many dimen-
sions. To mark this 25th year of the internet,
OC&C Strategy Consultants and Retail Week
have collaborated on this publication to enable us
to calibrate the UK’s progress in e-retailing and
how it fares compared with the other nations in
the world.
The study examines the world’s top 25
ecommerce economies on a number of dimen-
sions, drawing from both public and proprietary
data sources. We consider both demand
andsupplydimensions.Onthedemandside,meas-
uressuchasecommerceshareoftotalretail,spend
perconnectedcustomer,multi-categorypurchase
behaviour online and mobile commerce penetra-
tion are good indicators of customer readiness.
On the supply side, we look at measures such as
peakconnectivityspeed,easeoflast-miledelivery
andthedevelopmentofclick-and-collectpointsto
signify the infrastructure readiness of a country
to support and enable ecommerce growth.
This cross-country benchmarking leads us to
celebrate a number of dimensions where Britain
isintheclearlead,notablyhowadvancedBritain’s
consumers are in terms of their propensity and
appetiteforecommerce.However,thereareother
dimensions where British retailers have more to
do in order to keep pace with the most advanced
consumers in the world, such as improving the
customer experience across all device platforms
(particularly mobile), innovating in fulfilment
and advocating the case for faster connectivity
speeds. Let the debate for Britain to retain its
crown as the leading ecommerce nation in the
world commence!
partner foreword
“UK retailers have not
stood still in the face of
developments and evolved
into the leading ecommerce
economy on many dimensions”
Chris Brook-Carter
editor-in-chief, retail week
It is 20 years since the sale of a Sting CD
became the world’s first recognised ecommerce
transaction, and in doing so fired the starting
gun on a digital revolution that has reshaped
the retail industry.
Technology has since revolutionised shopping
habits,changingforevertherelationshipbetween
retailers and their customers, bringing about the
downfall of a roll call of previously great high
street names, which were unable to adapt, while
giving birth to new giants of the industry.
The disruptive nature of ecommerce may
have been present for 20 years, but the concept
ofdigitalretailinghasconstantlyevolved.Today’s
mobile and digitally connected landscape seems
a lifetime away from the early interactions with
nascent technologies such as the CD-Rom that
sparked these changes.
British retail has been at the forefront of the
global industry’s response to this ever-shifting
environment. But at the heart of its success is
the extraordinary way British consumers have
embraced online shopping.
This report, produced by OC&C in associa-
tion with Retail Week, underscores the extent
to which consumer behaviour has acted as an
engine for this growth. And it highlights how
the UK still leads the world in digital retailing,
with the highest proportion of retail sales online
as well as the highest ecommerce spend per
connected customer.
This global leadership has been nurtured
by the innovative and entrepreneurial nature
of the UK sector and its track record in launch-
ing successful pure-play businesses, from Asos
to Ao.com.
But the research will also warn that in its
response to that customer demand, across
a series of supply metrics, the UK is being out-
paced by some of its international rivals.
The industry’s reaction to the explosion of
mobile retailing is a case in point where coun-
FOREWoRD
“Technology has
revolutionised shopping
habits, changing forever
the relationship between
retailers and their
customers”
32
tries such as China, South Korea and the US
have leapfrogged the UK. As recently as last year,
only 50% of the top 100 UK retailers had mobile-
optimisedwebsites,accordingtodatafrommobile
technologygroupSkava,while3G/4Gpenetration
and peak internet connection speeds are also
showing signs of slowing developments.
The UK has been a pioneer in digital retailing
since those early days, but the gap between con-
sumer demand and the infrastructure in place to
serve it is a reminder of how fast ecommerce is
developing,andhowhardthesectorneedstowork
just to keep pace with the customers it serves.
| September 2014 September 2014 |
5
in partnership with:
On the 20th anniversary of the world’s first
ecommerce transaction, Retail Week and OC&C
Strategy Consultants have collaborated to take
stock of British digital retailing.
In the two decades since, technology has
revolutionised shopping habits across the globe,
changing forever the relationship between
retailers and customers. British retail has been
at the forefront of the global industry’s response
to this ever-shifting environment.
This research seeks to benchmark the UK
retail sector against the top 25 ecommerce
markets around the world to uncover the reality
of its performance across a number of demand
and supply metrics.
A British consumer love affair with digital
retail has been nurtured by the innovative and
entrepreneurial nature of the UK industry and
its track record of launching successful pure-play
businesses such as Asos and Ao.com.
But this research also warns that in its
response to that customer demand, across
a series of supply metrics, from capability to
infrastructure,theUKisbeingoutpacedbysome
of its international rivals.
With regards to demand-side measures, the
UK tops the list of the world’s most advanced
and high-performing ecommerce markets. It not
only enjoys thehighestproportion ofonline retail
sales,butitalsohasthehighestecommercespend
per connected consumer.
UK shoppers outpace those elsewhere too by
displaying the most developed multi-category
purchasing behaviour – there are 12 product
categories in which online sales as a percent of
total retail are more than 15%.
The UK also has the highest proportion of
businessestakingordersonlineandagoodlevelof
businessinnovationwhichsupportsthisdemand.
And yet, notwithstanding its clear global
leadership position, there are already warning
signs that UK retailers need to take heed of, most
Executive
summary
notably in its response to the explosion in mobile
commerce, an area in which countries such as
China and South Korea have leapfrogged the UK
in some respects.
Furthermore, on the supply side, the UK’s
current record is less impressive. It only ranks
at number eight, behind markets such as Japan,
Scandinavia, Germany and the Netherlands.
While internet connectivity and online
payments do not pose much of an issue, the UK
lags behind when it comes to last-mile fulfilment
options, particularly in the development of click-
and-collect infrastructure. Peak connectivity
speeds and 4G coverage also fall behind those
of other developed nations and are likely to
constrain ecommerce growth.
The UK has been a pioneer in digital retailing
since the early days, but the gap between
consumer demand and the infrastructure in
place to serve it is a reminder of how quickly
ecommerce is developing and how hard retailers
needtoworkjusttokeeppacewiththecustomers
they serve.
And while British retailers have reaped the
rewardsofpursuingonline-ledgrowthstrategies,
this research highlights the challenges the
industry faces if it is to unblock infrastructure
bottlenecks, notably last-mile fulfilment and
high-speed connectivity, so that the UK can keep
its crown as the most digitally advanced nation
in the world.
chapter summary
Chapter 1
UK consumers most advanced
in the world
l The UK has the highest penetration of online
retail sales
l The UK has highly diversified online spending
across product categories
Chapter 2
UK retailers embrace online, but are
losing out in m-commerce
l The UK has the highest proportion of
businesses that take orders over the internet
l The UK is losing out to other countries with 	
more advanced m-commerce technology
Chapter 3
the Last-mile battleground
l Same-daydeliveryintheUKisnotasdeveloped
as in other countries
l The UK has a smaller ratio of ‘pick-up and
drop-off’ points than many Western countries
Chapter 4
UK infrastructure at risk of slowing
down ecommerce
l The UK is falling behind other countries in
terms of internet connection speeds
l Slow internet speeds have a negative impact
on customer experience
Chapter 5
the ecommerce demand versus supply gap
l Retailers must invest in the efficacy of their
online channels
l Speed and convenience are crucial if UK
retailers are to remain competitive
“A British consumer
love affair with digital
retail has been nurtured
by the innovative and
entrepreneurial nature
of the UK industry and its
track record of launching
successful pure-play
businesses”
5
UK consumers
most advanced
in the world
CHAPTER 1
4 | September 2014
7
The UK is the leading ecommerce economy across
a number of metrics:
Share of retail that is online
£1 in every £7 spent on retail in the UK is spent
online,comparedwith£1in£11intheUS.Thatgives
the UK the highest penetration of online retail
sales. Ecommerce sales represent 14% of total
retail sales in the UK, five percentage points
ahead of the US, Finland and South Korea, where
ecommerce sales represent about 9% of total
retail sales (see chart 1.1).
l The UK has the highest penetration of online retail sales
l Connected UK consumers spent an average of £662 per person on ecommerce in 2013
l The UK has highly diversified online spending across product categories
Big spenders online
Lookingatpercapitaecommercespending,theUK’s
connected consumers (those with internet access)
spentonaverage£662perpersononecommercein
2013.Thatisabout£50moreperpersonthaninthe
US, which ranks second in the world (see chart 1.2).
Diversified spend profile
The UK’s strength in this area is further
underpinned by the fact ecommerce spending is no
longer concentrated in only a handful of categories.
Across the 25 global markets in the study,
the books category has the highest ecommerce
penetration, at 35% of retail sales. DIY is the least
well-developed, at 7% (see chart 1.3).
Mostothercategorieshaveonlinepenetrationin
therangeof10%to20%.Acrossthesecategories,the
UK has the most diversified purchasing behaviour.
There are 12 categories in which online represents
more than 15% of sales, providing further evidence
oftheUKconsumerembracingecommerceaheadof
consumers in other markets (see chart 1.4).
By contrast, in the US, there are only five
categories with more than 15% of sales online.
6
The UK is the leading ecommerce economy
UK
US
Finland
South Korea
China
Ireland
Sweden
Denmark
Norway
Germany
France
Netherlands
Australia
Czech Republic
Austria
Japan
Canada
Spain
Belgium
Poland
Russia
Brazil
Italy
Turkey
India
14%
9%
9%
9%
8%
7%
7%
7%
7%
7%
6%
6%
6%
5%
5%
5%
3%
3%
3%
3%
2%
2%
1%
1%
0%
Ecommerce market maturity1
1.1 Ecommerce share of retail market, 2013
% sales
UK
US
Norway
Finland
Ireland
Australia
Denmark
Sweden
France
Germany
Austria
South Korea
Netherlands
Japan
China
Belgium
Canada
Czech Republic
Spain
Italy
Poland
Russia
Brazil
Turkey
India
662
616
556
525
447
443
432
420
364
339
312
309
299
253
237
188
188
181
151
108
98
82
68
40
9
1
Includes all online sales through retailers – both pure-plays and retailer websites. Categories incorporate: personal appliances, domestic appliances, books, clothing and accessories, CDs/
DVDs, toys, footwear, gifts, flowers, greetings, DIY, tools, garden equipment, home furnishings/furniture, home and household goods, sports equipment
Source: World Bank, Eurostat, OCC analysis
1.2 Ecommerce spend/connected consumer, 2013
£
UK shoppers at ease with ecommerce, no matter what the category
Books
CDs/DVDs
Domestic appliances
Sports equipment
Clothing and accessories
Toys
Personal appliances
Gifts, flowers, greetings
Footwear
Home furnishings/furniture
Home and household goods
DIY, tools, garden equipment
Multi-category purchasing
1.3 Average category purchasing penetration1
Categories with penetration 15%2
UK
South Korea3
Japan
Germany
Czech Republic
France
Denmark
Netherlands
Turkey
Poland
Austria
US
Sweden
Russia
China3
Ireland
Brazil
Norway
Australia
Finland
Canada
Belgium
India3
Italy
Spain
12
11
10
10
9
9
8
8
7
6
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
3
2
2
2
2
1
0
0
1
Average across top 25 global ecommerce markets
2
15% of internet users have made an online purhase in this category
3
OCC estimation based on spend per connected consumer for India and South Korea; China from CNIC
Source: Google Barometer, CNIC, OCC analysis
1.4 Multi-category purchasing
Catergories with penetration 15%2
, Max = 12
35%
33%
18%
17%
16%
16%
14%
12%
11%
11%
10%
7%
Betterpenetratedcategories
7
Copy
Copy indentwing area of the market.
crosshead
Copy
l Sequod qui cone que volorunt quis doles esequiam, untor magniam apiente ctempella as dio.
Copy
copy
£0bn
7
UK retailers embrace
online, but are losing
out in m-commerce
CHAPTER 2
| September 2014
The high level of ecommerce demand from
UK consumers is enabled by retailers actively
developing their online propositions.
A total of 36% of all businesses in the UK
take orders over the internet. That is the highest
proportion among the 25 largest ecommerce
markets and significantly ahead of the average for
these markets of about 20% (see chart 2.1).
Business innovation also plays an important
role in enabling ecommerce as technology and
business capabilities rapidly evolve in this fast-
moving area of retail.
AfterAustralia,theUKhasthehighestnumber
ofnewbusinessesregisteredpercapita,indicating
a leading level of business innovation in these
markets.
The UK has a strong history of launching
successful online pure-play retail businesses
such as Ao.com, Asos, Farfetch, Net-a-Porter and
Wiggle, which with their strong propositions have
pavedthewayinacceleratingecommercedemand
from consumers.
A look at international ecommerce provides
further evidence of the sophistication of online
retail among UK retailers – in 2013 the UK was
the world’s leading exporter of online goods with
a trade surplus of more than $1bn.
Similarly, that UK’s multichannel players –
ArgosandJohnLewisinparticular–areexcellent
examplesofstore-ledbusinessesthatarereshaping
l The UK has the highest proportion of businesses that take orders over the internet
l In 2013 the UK was the world’s leading exporter of online goods
l The UK is losing ground to other countries in the advancement of m-commerce
themselvesasadvantagedmodelsforadigitalage.
However, it is not just innovative retailers that
are driving more consumers to purchase online.
Creative propositions in other areas have also
been important in building the strong demand
for ecommerce that is seen in the UK.
Examples of businesses making ecommerce
more accessible include Simpleshop.com,
which makes it easy for businesses to
operate online by combing website templates
and EPoS systems; Fits.me, which provides
retailers with the technology to offer an
online fitting room; Shutl, which offers
same- day delivery by aggregating local couriers;
and StreetHub, which aggregates products from
local boutiques for customers to click-and-collect.
These innovative businesses are enabling
retailers to provide a high level of convenience
for customers, making ecommerce increasingly
suitable for today’s lifestyle.
But despite its strong ecommerce credentials
overall, the UK is losing out in mobile commerce
–inparticulartocountriesthathaveleapfroggedit
intermsoftechnology,suchasChina,SouthKorea
and India.
In the UK about 62% of the population own a
smartphone. That places the UK fifth among the
25largestecommercemarkets,aheadofcountries
such as the US, Netherlands and Germany, but
behind South Korea, Norway and Australia
(see chart 2.3).
When it comes to 3G/4G penetration 78% of
the UK population have 3G/4G SIM cards , which
ranks the UK ninth overall among the 25 largest
ecommerce markets.
39%UKsmartphoneowners
tohavemadeapurchase
withtheirphones
“Business innovation plays an
important role in enabling
ecommerce as technology and
business capabilities rapidly
evolve in this fast-moving
area of retail”
UK organisations have led in developing online propositions
Organisational readiness
2.1 Organisational online readiness
% businesses taking orders online
Australia
UK
Norway
Sweden
Russia
Ireland
Netherlands
Denmark
Czech Republic
France
Spain
China
Belgium
US
Finland
South Korea
Italy
Germany
Canada
Japan
Turkey
Poland
Austria
Brazil
India
7,998
7,108
5,088
4,093
3,081
2,997
2,941
2,816
2,050
1,841
1,809
1,681
1,616
1,580
1,505
1,473
1,264
860
732
721
518
405
334
269
80
2.2 Level of business innovation
# new businesses registered/per million people
UK
US
Brazil
Netherlands
Japan
Norway
Denmark
Germany
South Korea
Ireland
Sweden
Belgium
Czech Republic
Austria
Finland
Canada
Russia
France
Spain
Poland
Turkey
Australia
Italy
China
India
36%
35%
34%
33%
32%
31%
28%
28%
28%
25%
24%
23%
22%
20%
20%
18%
18%
15%
13%
10%
9%
9%
3%
3%
1%
Source: UNCTAD, Statista, NAICS, World Bank, Census Data, Press Search, OCC analysis
Finland and Sweden have the highest
penetration of 3G/4G, with 122% and 118%
respectively (some consumers have multiple SIM
cards for their phones and tablets).
Good connectivity is a prerequisite of a great
customer experience across digital channels – a
dimension on which the UK does not make it to
the top of the league table.
Among smartphone owners, less than half,
about 39%, have made a purchase with their
phones. This puts the UK 10th in terms of
m-commerce penetration and leaves considerable
room for improvement.
Thetopthreemarketsintermsofm-commerce
penetration are all countries that have leapfrogged
thetypicaltechnologycurve,bypassingthedesktop
era – China, South Korea and India. In China, the
majority (70%) of smartphone users have made
purchases with their phones (see chart 2.5).
UK retailers have been relatively slow to adapt
to mobile as a channel – in 2013, only 50% of
the top 100 retailers had mobile-optimised
websites. By 2014, this has increased and today
25% of the top 100 retailers do not offer a mobile-
optimised version of their website according
to findings in the annual UK Retailer Mobile
Optimisation Report .
With smartphone penetration relatively high
and likely to continue to grow, UK retailers will
need to rapidly evolve their mobile website and
app propositions, an area in which retailers in the
more advanced m-commerce markets – China,
South Korea, India and the US – could provide
inspiration.
The race to be ready
Mobile penetration
China
South Korea
India
US
Ireland
Japan
Turkey
Australia
Russia
UK
Sweden
Norway
Germany
Denmark
Austria
Brazil
Italy
Czech Republic
Poland
Canada
France
Finland
Spain
Netherlands
Belgium
70%
56%
54%
46%
44%
44%
43%
41%
39%
39%
33%
33%
32%
31%
30%
30%
30%
30%
29%
27%
26%
26%
25%
18%
16%
2.5 M-commerce penetration2
, 2013
% smartphone users
The race to be ready
Mobile penetration
South Korea
Norway
Australia
Sweden
UK
Denmark
Ireland
US
Canada
Spain
Netherlands
Austria
China
Finland
France
Czech Republic
Italy
Germany
Russia
Poland
Belgium
Turkey
Brazil
Japan
India
73%
68%
65%
63%
62%
59%
57%
56%
56%
55%
52%
48%
46%
45%
42%
41%
41%
40%
36%
35%
33%
29%
26%
25%
17%
2.3 Smartphone penetration, 2013
% population
Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis
Finland
Sweden
Japan
Australia
South Korea
Denmark
Norway
Spain
UK
US
Austria
Italy
Netherlands
Russia
France
Ireland
Poland
Brazil
Czech Republic
Germany
Canada
Belgium
China
Turkey
India
122%
118%
107%
105%
103%
97%
82%
79%
78%
68%
63%
62%
58%
57%
57%
57%
55%
48%
46%
46%
41%
36%
31%
30%
4%
2.4 3G/4G penetration1
, 2013
Subscribers/total population
The race to be ready
Mobile penetration
8 9
1
Can be 100% since some consumers have multiple SIM cards
Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis
2
Includes all purchases ever made on a smartphone, given the consumer
owns a smartphone
Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis
| September 2014 September 2014 |
10
Copy
copy
£0bn
Copy
copy
£0bnthe Last-mile
battleground
CHAPTER 3
The UK is behind other markets on some key
last-mile fulfilment measures.
Ease of last-mile delivery as evidenced by the
ratioofpopulationdensitytopavedroaddensity,is
broadlyinlinewithmostotherWesternEuropean
markets, although not as high as in Belgium and
the Netherlands.
However, home delivery lags behind
countries such as the US and China, where
same-day delivery is more prevalent and
better-developed.
For instance, JD.com, one of China’s leading
ecommerce retailers, is at the forefront of making
same-day the market norm by getting products to
consumersthesamedayiforderedbefore11am,or
the next day if ordered after that time.
For an extra fee, JD.com also offers ‘super-fast’
delivery, which gets products to buyers within
threehours.Italreadyserves80millioncustomers
across six cities with this speedy service and plans
to grow coverage.
IntheUS,Amazonisalreadycapableofserving
23% of the population the same day, versus 17%
in the UK.
l Same-day delivery in the UK is not as developed as in other countries
l The UK has a smaller ratio of pick-up and drop-off points than many Western countries
l The UK’s ‘drive-thru’ network is underdeveloped
Despite ease of last-mile delivery being in line
with other markets, the UK also has a smaller
ratio of pick-up and drop-off (PUDO) points than
most other Western markets for the size of the
ecommerce market.
PUDO points include convenience stores,
railwaystationsandsupermarkets.Theyareplaces
where consumers can collect or drop off parcels
that they have purchased online.
These points are typically served by a range
of courier businesses, which in the UK include
companies such as Collect+ and Hermes. They do
not include the respective Post Office networks.
For the size of its ecommerce market, the UK
hasalownumberofPUDOpointscomparedwith
other Western markets.
The UK offers 0.5 PUDO points per £1m of
ecommerce spend versus 1.8 points in Germany
and 0.8 points and 0.7 points in Belgium and
France respectively.
That has in part been driven by European
operators of collection points being slow to enter
the UK and an underdeveloped ‘drive-thru’
network compared with markets such as France.
17%TheamountoftheUK
populationAmazoniscapable
ofservingthesameday
“home delivery lags behind
countries such as the US
and China, where same-day
delivery is more prevalent
and better-developed”
The UK lags Western markets in fulfilment options such as click-and-collect
Last-mile delivery/fulfilment
3.1 Ease of last-mile delivery1
Indexed to max
Germany
Belgium
France
Spain
Poland
US
Netherlands
UK
Australia
Czech Republic
1.8
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.3
0.2
1
Population density/quality road density indicates ease and cost of delivering to households (values are indexed to Belgium)
2
Pick up and drop off points, does not include post offices or points for collection only
Source: World Bank, Desk Research, World Bank, OCC Modelling, OCC analysis
3.2 PUDO2
points per £1m of total ecommerce spend
Number of points
Belgium
Netherlands
France
Germany
UK
Denmark
Czech Republic
Italy
Ireland
Austria
Spain
Japan
Poland
South Korea
India
US
Turkey
Sweden
China
Norway
Finland
Canada
Russia
Australia
Brazil
100
84
49
46
44
44
42
41
35
35
33
23
23
22
20
11
11
8
7
6
4
1
1
1
1
11September 2014 |
Copy
copy
£0bnUK infrastructure
at risk of slowing
down ecommerce
CHAPTER 4
Strong ecommerce relies heavily on national
infrastructure – good connectivity and payment
methods enable online purchasing.
Here the UK falls into the ‘middle of the pack’
among the 25 largest ecommerce markets despite
an overall well-developed starting point in terms of
populationwithinternetaccessandonlinepayment
options such as credit and/or debit cards.
While the UK is reasonably well-positioned
in terms of its internet user base and penetration
of online payments, there are signs that the
l The UK is falling behind other countries in terms of internet connection speeds
l Slow internet speeds have a negative impact on customer experience
l There is room for improvement in the UK’s approach to business regulation
Online purchasing is enabled by good connectivity and payment methods
Infrastructure maturity
4.1 Internet user penetration
% population
4.2 Online payment penetration1
% population
Norway
Sweden
Denmark
Netherlands
Finland
UK
Japan
Canada
South Korea
US
Germany
Australia
Belgium
France
Austria
Ireland
Czech Republic
Spain
Poland
Russia
Italy
Brazil
Turkey
China
India
1
Maximum of credit and debit card penetration
Source: World Bank, OCC analysis
95%
95%
95%
94%
92%
90%
86%
86%
85%
84%
84%
83%
82%
82%
81%
78%
74%
72%
63%
61%
59%
52%
46%
46%
15%
Netherlands
Norway
Sweden
Finland
Denmark
Austria
Canada
UK
Germany
Belgium
Australia
US
Ireland
Japan
Spain
France
Czech Republic
South Korea
Turkey
China
Brazil
Russia
Poland
Italy
India
98%
97%
97%
95%
92%
91%
91%
90%
88%
88%
82%
78%
77%
71%
71%
69%
69%
64%
62%
54%
52%
45%
44%
37%
14%
infrastructure is not keeping pace with the best in
the world.
Peak connection speeds of 990Mbps (which
enables downloading of a HD movie in 50 seconds)
in the UK rank only 12th among the 25 largest
ecommercemarkets–behindtheUSandanumber
of European countries (see chart 4.3).
South Korea leads on this dimension, with
peakconnectionspeedsofupto2,360Mbps(which
enablesdownloadingofaHDmoviein20seconds),
followed by Japan and the Netherlands.
Connection speeds and ease of doing business lag other markets
South Korea
Japan
Netherlands
Sweden
Czech Republic
Finland
Ireland
Denmark
US
Norway
Belgium
UK
Canada
Austria
Russia
Germany
Poland
Spain
France
Australia
Italy
Turkey
China
Brazil
India
Consumer connectivity
4.3 Peak connection speeds
Mbps
US
Denmark
South Korea
Norway
UK
Australia
Finland
Sweden
Ireland
Canada
Germany
Japan
Netherlands
Austria
Belgium
France
Poland
Spain
Italy
Turkey
Czech Republic
Russia
China
Brazil
India
Source: World Bank, BMI, Euromonitor, Statista, Econsultancy, Ystats, World Bank, OCC Modelling, OCC analysis
4.4 Ease of doing business
Indexed to max
2,360
1,460
1,240
1,160
1,120
1,070
1,070
1,050
1,050
1,010
1,000
990
970
940
860
810
750
720
660
600
520
500
320
260
170
98%
98%
97%
96%
95%
95%
94%
93%
93%
90%
89%
86%
86%
85%
81%
80%
77%
73%
66%
64%
61%
52%
50%
39%
30%
Slower connection speeds dampen the
experience customers have and could hold
back UK ecommerce from growing at a more
rapid pace.
Although ranked fifth, there is also room
for improvement on ‘ease of doing business’, a
metric which looks at the regulatory environment
for businesses across things such as starting a
business, tax and registering property. Here,
too, the UK is behind the US, Denmark,
South Korea and Norway (see chart 4.4).
12 13September 2014 |
14
Copy
copy
£0bn
* XXXXX 						 SOURCE:MobileRetailretailersurvey
14
The ecommerce
demand versus
supply gap
CHAPTER 5
15
Overall, the range of metrics considered in
this study highlight that British consumers
lead the way in ecommerce (coming first
in the top 25 countries) and that the shift to
online and multichannel across a broad range
of categories is the most marked in the UK (see
chart 5.1).
However, the supply-side infrastructure
(in which the UK comes eighth in the rankings)
in the UK is not keeping pace with the consumer
appetite for shopping online (see chart 5.2).
Online could be a faster-growing channel
than it has been if the UK and its retailers invest
inmoreadvancedfulfilmentcapabilityandhigher
internet speeds.
The leading levels of ecommerce demand
in the UK continue to represent a significant
opportunity for retailers. Maximising this
opportunity is likely to require addressing the
supply challenges and continuing to innovate as
consumer behaviour evolves.
In our view, to keep up with advancing
consumers, UK retailers should be taking the
following steps:
1. Invest in the customer experience
across multiple device platforms
Consumers expect that their journey will be
smooth, no matter on what device they access
a site. Retailers need to play catch-up to ensure
theirdigitalchannelsacrossallmobile,tabletand
desktop platforms are working well.
2. Innovate in fulfilment
Investments in speed of fulfilment (same/next
day) and convenience (collection and return
networks) are required in order for retailers to
remain competitive.
3. Influence the connectivity agenda
Retailersshouldbeworkingwithgovernmentand
partnering with telecom companies to champion
theagendaforhigherinternetspeedsthroughout
the country.
l Retailers must invest in the efficacy of their online channels
l Speed and convenience are crucial if UK retailers are to remain competitive
l Retailers should work with telecoms providers and Government to improve connection speeds
“The leading levels of
ecommerce demand in
the UK continue to represent
a significant opportunity
for retailers”
Ecommerce demand versus supply metrics for the
largest 25 ecommerce markets
5.1 Demand ranking
Source: OCC analysis
5.2 Supply ranking
Country Country
1 UK 14 Ireland
2 South Korea 15 Austria
3 US 16 Russia
4 Sweden 17 Canada
5 Japan 18 Spain
6 Australia 19 Czech Republic
7 Norway 20 Italy
8 Denmark 21 Poland
9 Germany 22 Turkey
10 China 23 Belgium
11 France 24 India
12 Finland 25 Brazil
13 Netherlands
Country Country
1 Japan 14 Canada
2 Netherlands 15 Russia
3 South Korea 16 Czech Republic
4 Denmark 17 Spain
5 Germany 18 France
6 Norway 19 Poland
7 Sweden 20 Turkey
8 UK 21 China
9 Belgium 22 Australia
10 US 23 Italy
11 Finland 24 India
12 Ireland 25 Brazil
13 Austria
September 2014 |
Produced in association with

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

What’s Happening On The High Street
What’s Happening On The High StreetWhat’s Happening On The High Street
What’s Happening On The High Street
NeilHalford
 
Consumer electronics bm_retail
Consumer electronics bm_retailConsumer electronics bm_retail
Consumer electronics bm_retail
Taposh Roy
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Rapport 2016 E-commerce B2C Européen
Rapport 2016 E-commerce B2C EuropéenRapport 2016 E-commerce B2C Européen
Rapport 2016 E-commerce B2C Européen
 
The Future of eCommerce en FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) 2017
The Future of eCommerce en FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) 2017The Future of eCommerce en FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) 2017
The Future of eCommerce en FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) 2017
 
Borderless Digital Commerce 2013
Borderless Digital Commerce 2013Borderless Digital Commerce 2013
Borderless Digital Commerce 2013
 
What’s Happening On The High Street
What’s Happening On The High StreetWhat’s Happening On The High Street
What’s Happening On The High Street
 
"Shopping for Growth": Cómo puede el retail impulsar el crecimiento y el empl...
"Shopping for Growth": Cómo puede el retail impulsar el crecimiento y el empl..."Shopping for Growth": Cómo puede el retail impulsar el crecimiento y el empl...
"Shopping for Growth": Cómo puede el retail impulsar el crecimiento y el empl...
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Trends and digital advertising opportunities in...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Trends and digital advertising opportunities in...E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Trends and digital advertising opportunities in...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Trends and digital advertising opportunities in...
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Tomasz Mazur - Danone
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Tomasz Mazur - DanoneE-commerce Berlin Expo - Tomasz Mazur - Danone
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Tomasz Mazur - Danone
 
Consumer electronics bm_retail
Consumer electronics bm_retailConsumer electronics bm_retail
Consumer electronics bm_retail
 
Transmodal 2015 Ponencia E commerce norbert dentressangle 2015-eng_scl
Transmodal 2015 Ponencia E commerce norbert dentressangle 2015-eng_sclTransmodal 2015 Ponencia E commerce norbert dentressangle 2015-eng_scl
Transmodal 2015 Ponencia E commerce norbert dentressangle 2015-eng_scl
 
Keynote presentation global ecommerce summit Wijnand Jongen: The End of Onlin...
Keynote presentation global ecommerce summit Wijnand Jongen: The End of Onlin...Keynote presentation global ecommerce summit Wijnand Jongen: The End of Onlin...
Keynote presentation global ecommerce summit Wijnand Jongen: The End of Onlin...
 
Lecture 6 - VDIS10047 Fashion Marketing - Trends & Impacts of eBusiness
Lecture 6 - VDIS10047 Fashion Marketing - Trends & Impacts of eBusinessLecture 6 - VDIS10047 Fashion Marketing - Trends & Impacts of eBusiness
Lecture 6 - VDIS10047 Fashion Marketing - Trends & Impacts of eBusiness
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Cross Border Ecommerce: Making the Most of Chin...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Cross Border Ecommerce: Making the Most of Chin...E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Cross Border Ecommerce: Making the Most of Chin...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - Cross Border Ecommerce: Making the Most of Chin...
 
European b2c e commerce report 2015 light 20150615.pdf
European b2c e commerce report 2015 light 20150615.pdfEuropean b2c e commerce report 2015 light 20150615.pdf
European b2c e commerce report 2015 light 20150615.pdf
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Oliver Prothmann - Bundesverband Onlinehandel
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Oliver Prothmann - Bundesverband OnlinehandelE-commerce Berlin Expo - Oliver Prothmann - Bundesverband Onlinehandel
E-commerce Berlin Expo - Oliver Prothmann - Bundesverband Onlinehandel
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo - InPost - Marcin Bosacki
E-commerce Berlin Expo - InPost - Marcin BosackiE-commerce Berlin Expo - InPost - Marcin Bosacki
E-commerce Berlin Expo - InPost - Marcin Bosacki
 
BRINGING SMES ONTO THE E-COMMERCE HIGHWAY (English)
BRINGING SMES ONTO THE E-COMMERCE HIGHWAY (English)BRINGING SMES ONTO THE E-COMMERCE HIGHWAY (English)
BRINGING SMES ONTO THE E-COMMERCE HIGHWAY (English)
 
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - The German E-Commerce Market: How the Consumer ...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - The German E-Commerce Market: How the Consumer ...E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - The German E-Commerce Market: How the Consumer ...
E-commerce Berlin Expo 2017 - The German E-Commerce Market: How the Consumer ...
 
E-commerce in China
E-commerce in ChinaE-commerce in China
E-commerce in China
 
Richard Unwin, Backbone IT
Richard Unwin, Backbone ITRichard Unwin, Backbone IT
Richard Unwin, Backbone IT
 
E commerce ashish
E commerce ashishE commerce ashish
E commerce ashish
 

Destacado (8)

Día del tutor
Día del tutorDía del tutor
Día del tutor
 
2015 Adult and children's Summer Art Workshop
2015 Adult and children's Summer Art Workshop2015 Adult and children's Summer Art Workshop
2015 Adult and children's Summer Art Workshop
 
The eTail European Ecommerce Trends Report
The eTail European Ecommerce Trends ReportThe eTail European Ecommerce Trends Report
The eTail European Ecommerce Trends Report
 
Planificación
PlanificaciónPlanificación
Planificación
 
Produk plat strip
Produk plat stripProduk plat strip
Produk plat strip
 
Quick Look - Retail Benchmark Report | UserZoom
Quick Look - Retail Benchmark Report  | UserZoomQuick Look - Retail Benchmark Report  | UserZoom
Quick Look - Retail Benchmark Report | UserZoom
 
How to Conduct UX Benchmarking
How to Conduct UX BenchmarkingHow to Conduct UX Benchmarking
How to Conduct UX Benchmarking
 
How to Benchmark Your Online Customer Experience Against Competition
How to Benchmark Your Online Customer Experience Against CompetitionHow to Benchmark Your Online Customer Experience Against Competition
How to Benchmark Your Online Customer Experience Against Competition
 

Similar a EcommerceBenchmarkOC&C_DIGITAL

Ecommerce, social business, digital economy report
Ecommerce, social business, digital economy reportEcommerce, social business, digital economy report
Ecommerce, social business, digital economy report
Niall Devitt
 
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H..."From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
NeilMunzJones
 
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
John Keogh
 
Uk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadbandUk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadband
Mark Mandel
 

Similar a EcommerceBenchmarkOC&C_DIGITAL (20)

Digitalhound - Online Marketing Help for Exporters to UK
Digitalhound  - Online Marketing Help for Exporters to UKDigitalhound  - Online Marketing Help for Exporters to UK
Digitalhound - Online Marketing Help for Exporters to UK
 
Global Perspective on Retail: Online Retailing (July 2013)
Global Perspective on Retail: Online Retailing (July 2013)Global Perspective on Retail: Online Retailing (July 2013)
Global Perspective on Retail: Online Retailing (July 2013)
 
Growth of e commerce industry
Growth of e commerce industryGrowth of e commerce industry
Growth of e commerce industry
 
Ecommerce, social business, digital economy report
Ecommerce, social business, digital economy reportEcommerce, social business, digital economy report
Ecommerce, social business, digital economy report
 
Chptr 10 retail logistics
Chptr 10 retail logistics Chptr 10 retail logistics
Chptr 10 retail logistics
 
BUILDING CONSUMER TRUST IN AN ONLINE WORLD
BUILDING CONSUMER TRUST IN AN ONLINE WORLDBUILDING CONSUMER TRUST IN AN ONLINE WORLD
BUILDING CONSUMER TRUST IN AN ONLINE WORLD
 
Decoding the Cross border eCommerce Puzzle - an Anchanto Document
Decoding the Cross border eCommerce Puzzle - an Anchanto Document Decoding the Cross border eCommerce Puzzle - an Anchanto Document
Decoding the Cross border eCommerce Puzzle - an Anchanto Document
 
Online to offline (O2O) Commerce
Online to offline (O2O) CommerceOnline to offline (O2O) Commerce
Online to offline (O2O) Commerce
 
Ganing the Edge in China's E-Commerce
Ganing the Edge in China's E-CommerceGaning the Edge in China's E-Commerce
Ganing the Edge in China's E-Commerce
 
US Passport 2015: Cross-border Trading Report
US Passport 2015: Cross-border Trading ReportUS Passport 2015: Cross-border Trading Report
US Passport 2015: Cross-border Trading Report
 
The Digital Consumer Guide to Online Shopping
The Digital Consumer Guide to Online ShoppingThe Digital Consumer Guide to Online Shopping
The Digital Consumer Guide to Online Shopping
 
Internet Usage Trends and Economic Development :BCG Case Study in UK
Internet Usage Trends and Economic Development :BCG Case Study in UKInternet Usage Trends and Economic Development :BCG Case Study in UK
Internet Usage Trends and Economic Development :BCG Case Study in UK
 
The Evolution Of The internet
The Evolution Of The internetThe Evolution Of The internet
The Evolution Of The internet
 
The evolution of the internet slideshare
The evolution of the internet slideshareThe evolution of the internet slideshare
The evolution of the internet slideshare
 
World class payments a report on how consumers around the world make payments
World class payments a report on how consumers around the world make paymentsWorld class payments a report on how consumers around the world make payments
World class payments a report on how consumers around the world make payments
 
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H..."From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
"From eCommerce to Multi-Channel to Omni-channel: the retail journey in the H...
 
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
IoE_Retail_Whitepaper_010915_FINAL3
 
Uk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadbandUk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadband
 
module 1.pptx
module 1.pptxmodule 1.pptx
module 1.pptx
 
Uk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadbandUk paying for romanian broadband
Uk paying for romanian broadband
 

EcommerceBenchmarkOC&C_DIGITAL

  • 1. The ecommerce super league A benchmarking study of the world’s top 25 ecommerce markets Produced in association with
  • 2. Anita Balchandani Partner and head of UK retail, OC&C Strategy Consultants Twenty-five years ago the World Wide Web was introduced across the globe, and in what is a relatively short space of time, it has already cre- ated a big transformation in how we shop. Online represents a material part of retail sales in many countries around the world and consumers are displaying a healthy propensity to shop online for a range of categories – not just for books, media and technology but also in fashion, beauty and luxury where there might have originally been scepticism about the potential for online retail. UK retailers have not stood still in the face of these developments and have evolved into the leading ecommerce economy on many dimen- sions. To mark this 25th year of the internet, OC&C Strategy Consultants and Retail Week have collaborated on this publication to enable us to calibrate the UK’s progress in e-retailing and how it fares compared with the other nations in the world. The study examines the world’s top 25 ecommerce economies on a number of dimen- sions, drawing from both public and proprietary data sources. We consider both demand andsupplydimensions.Onthedemandside,meas- uressuchasecommerceshareoftotalretail,spend perconnectedcustomer,multi-categorypurchase behaviour online and mobile commerce penetra- tion are good indicators of customer readiness. On the supply side, we look at measures such as peakconnectivityspeed,easeoflast-miledelivery andthedevelopmentofclick-and-collectpointsto signify the infrastructure readiness of a country to support and enable ecommerce growth. This cross-country benchmarking leads us to celebrate a number of dimensions where Britain isintheclearlead,notablyhowadvancedBritain’s consumers are in terms of their propensity and appetiteforecommerce.However,thereareother dimensions where British retailers have more to do in order to keep pace with the most advanced consumers in the world, such as improving the customer experience across all device platforms (particularly mobile), innovating in fulfilment and advocating the case for faster connectivity speeds. Let the debate for Britain to retain its crown as the leading ecommerce nation in the world commence! partner foreword “UK retailers have not stood still in the face of developments and evolved into the leading ecommerce economy on many dimensions” Chris Brook-Carter editor-in-chief, retail week It is 20 years since the sale of a Sting CD became the world’s first recognised ecommerce transaction, and in doing so fired the starting gun on a digital revolution that has reshaped the retail industry. Technology has since revolutionised shopping habits,changingforevertherelationshipbetween retailers and their customers, bringing about the downfall of a roll call of previously great high street names, which were unable to adapt, while giving birth to new giants of the industry. The disruptive nature of ecommerce may have been present for 20 years, but the concept ofdigitalretailinghasconstantlyevolved.Today’s mobile and digitally connected landscape seems a lifetime away from the early interactions with nascent technologies such as the CD-Rom that sparked these changes. British retail has been at the forefront of the global industry’s response to this ever-shifting environment. But at the heart of its success is the extraordinary way British consumers have embraced online shopping. This report, produced by OC&C in associa- tion with Retail Week, underscores the extent to which consumer behaviour has acted as an engine for this growth. And it highlights how the UK still leads the world in digital retailing, with the highest proportion of retail sales online as well as the highest ecommerce spend per connected customer. This global leadership has been nurtured by the innovative and entrepreneurial nature of the UK sector and its track record in launch- ing successful pure-play businesses, from Asos to Ao.com. But the research will also warn that in its response to that customer demand, across a series of supply metrics, the UK is being out- paced by some of its international rivals. The industry’s reaction to the explosion of mobile retailing is a case in point where coun- FOREWoRD “Technology has revolutionised shopping habits, changing forever the relationship between retailers and their customers” 32 tries such as China, South Korea and the US have leapfrogged the UK. As recently as last year, only 50% of the top 100 UK retailers had mobile- optimisedwebsites,accordingtodatafrommobile technologygroupSkava,while3G/4Gpenetration and peak internet connection speeds are also showing signs of slowing developments. The UK has been a pioneer in digital retailing since those early days, but the gap between con- sumer demand and the infrastructure in place to serve it is a reminder of how fast ecommerce is developing,andhowhardthesectorneedstowork just to keep pace with the customers it serves. | September 2014 September 2014 |
  • 3. 5 in partnership with: On the 20th anniversary of the world’s first ecommerce transaction, Retail Week and OC&C Strategy Consultants have collaborated to take stock of British digital retailing. In the two decades since, technology has revolutionised shopping habits across the globe, changing forever the relationship between retailers and customers. British retail has been at the forefront of the global industry’s response to this ever-shifting environment. This research seeks to benchmark the UK retail sector against the top 25 ecommerce markets around the world to uncover the reality of its performance across a number of demand and supply metrics. A British consumer love affair with digital retail has been nurtured by the innovative and entrepreneurial nature of the UK industry and its track record of launching successful pure-play businesses such as Asos and Ao.com. But this research also warns that in its response to that customer demand, across a series of supply metrics, from capability to infrastructure,theUKisbeingoutpacedbysome of its international rivals. With regards to demand-side measures, the UK tops the list of the world’s most advanced and high-performing ecommerce markets. It not only enjoys thehighestproportion ofonline retail sales,butitalsohasthehighestecommercespend per connected consumer. UK shoppers outpace those elsewhere too by displaying the most developed multi-category purchasing behaviour – there are 12 product categories in which online sales as a percent of total retail are more than 15%. The UK also has the highest proportion of businessestakingordersonlineandagoodlevelof businessinnovationwhichsupportsthisdemand. And yet, notwithstanding its clear global leadership position, there are already warning signs that UK retailers need to take heed of, most Executive summary notably in its response to the explosion in mobile commerce, an area in which countries such as China and South Korea have leapfrogged the UK in some respects. Furthermore, on the supply side, the UK’s current record is less impressive. It only ranks at number eight, behind markets such as Japan, Scandinavia, Germany and the Netherlands. While internet connectivity and online payments do not pose much of an issue, the UK lags behind when it comes to last-mile fulfilment options, particularly in the development of click- and-collect infrastructure. Peak connectivity speeds and 4G coverage also fall behind those of other developed nations and are likely to constrain ecommerce growth. The UK has been a pioneer in digital retailing since the early days, but the gap between consumer demand and the infrastructure in place to serve it is a reminder of how quickly ecommerce is developing and how hard retailers needtoworkjusttokeeppacewiththecustomers they serve. And while British retailers have reaped the rewardsofpursuingonline-ledgrowthstrategies, this research highlights the challenges the industry faces if it is to unblock infrastructure bottlenecks, notably last-mile fulfilment and high-speed connectivity, so that the UK can keep its crown as the most digitally advanced nation in the world. chapter summary Chapter 1 UK consumers most advanced in the world l The UK has the highest penetration of online retail sales l The UK has highly diversified online spending across product categories Chapter 2 UK retailers embrace online, but are losing out in m-commerce l The UK has the highest proportion of businesses that take orders over the internet l The UK is losing out to other countries with more advanced m-commerce technology Chapter 3 the Last-mile battleground l Same-daydeliveryintheUKisnotasdeveloped as in other countries l The UK has a smaller ratio of ‘pick-up and drop-off’ points than many Western countries Chapter 4 UK infrastructure at risk of slowing down ecommerce l The UK is falling behind other countries in terms of internet connection speeds l Slow internet speeds have a negative impact on customer experience Chapter 5 the ecommerce demand versus supply gap l Retailers must invest in the efficacy of their online channels l Speed and convenience are crucial if UK retailers are to remain competitive “A British consumer love affair with digital retail has been nurtured by the innovative and entrepreneurial nature of the UK industry and its track record of launching successful pure-play businesses” 5 UK consumers most advanced in the world CHAPTER 1 4 | September 2014
  • 4. 7 The UK is the leading ecommerce economy across a number of metrics: Share of retail that is online £1 in every £7 spent on retail in the UK is spent online,comparedwith£1in£11intheUS.Thatgives the UK the highest penetration of online retail sales. Ecommerce sales represent 14% of total retail sales in the UK, five percentage points ahead of the US, Finland and South Korea, where ecommerce sales represent about 9% of total retail sales (see chart 1.1). l The UK has the highest penetration of online retail sales l Connected UK consumers spent an average of £662 per person on ecommerce in 2013 l The UK has highly diversified online spending across product categories Big spenders online Lookingatpercapitaecommercespending,theUK’s connected consumers (those with internet access) spentonaverage£662perpersononecommercein 2013.Thatisabout£50moreperpersonthaninthe US, which ranks second in the world (see chart 1.2). Diversified spend profile The UK’s strength in this area is further underpinned by the fact ecommerce spending is no longer concentrated in only a handful of categories. Across the 25 global markets in the study, the books category has the highest ecommerce penetration, at 35% of retail sales. DIY is the least well-developed, at 7% (see chart 1.3). Mostothercategorieshaveonlinepenetrationin therangeof10%to20%.Acrossthesecategories,the UK has the most diversified purchasing behaviour. There are 12 categories in which online represents more than 15% of sales, providing further evidence oftheUKconsumerembracingecommerceaheadof consumers in other markets (see chart 1.4). By contrast, in the US, there are only five categories with more than 15% of sales online. 6 The UK is the leading ecommerce economy UK US Finland South Korea China Ireland Sweden Denmark Norway Germany France Netherlands Australia Czech Republic Austria Japan Canada Spain Belgium Poland Russia Brazil Italy Turkey India 14% 9% 9% 9% 8% 7% 7% 7% 7% 7% 6% 6% 6% 5% 5% 5% 3% 3% 3% 3% 2% 2% 1% 1% 0% Ecommerce market maturity1 1.1 Ecommerce share of retail market, 2013 % sales UK US Norway Finland Ireland Australia Denmark Sweden France Germany Austria South Korea Netherlands Japan China Belgium Canada Czech Republic Spain Italy Poland Russia Brazil Turkey India 662 616 556 525 447 443 432 420 364 339 312 309 299 253 237 188 188 181 151 108 98 82 68 40 9 1 Includes all online sales through retailers – both pure-plays and retailer websites. Categories incorporate: personal appliances, domestic appliances, books, clothing and accessories, CDs/ DVDs, toys, footwear, gifts, flowers, greetings, DIY, tools, garden equipment, home furnishings/furniture, home and household goods, sports equipment Source: World Bank, Eurostat, OCC analysis 1.2 Ecommerce spend/connected consumer, 2013 £ UK shoppers at ease with ecommerce, no matter what the category Books CDs/DVDs Domestic appliances Sports equipment Clothing and accessories Toys Personal appliances Gifts, flowers, greetings Footwear Home furnishings/furniture Home and household goods DIY, tools, garden equipment Multi-category purchasing 1.3 Average category purchasing penetration1 Categories with penetration 15%2 UK South Korea3 Japan Germany Czech Republic France Denmark Netherlands Turkey Poland Austria US Sweden Russia China3 Ireland Brazil Norway Australia Finland Canada Belgium India3 Italy Spain 12 11 10 10 9 9 8 8 7 6 5 5 5 4 4 4 4 3 2 2 2 2 1 0 0 1 Average across top 25 global ecommerce markets 2 15% of internet users have made an online purhase in this category 3 OCC estimation based on spend per connected consumer for India and South Korea; China from CNIC Source: Google Barometer, CNIC, OCC analysis 1.4 Multi-category purchasing Catergories with penetration 15%2 , Max = 12 35% 33% 18% 17% 16% 16% 14% 12% 11% 11% 10% 7% Betterpenetratedcategories 7 Copy Copy indentwing area of the market. crosshead Copy l Sequod qui cone que volorunt quis doles esequiam, untor magniam apiente ctempella as dio. Copy copy £0bn 7 UK retailers embrace online, but are losing out in m-commerce CHAPTER 2 | September 2014
  • 5. The high level of ecommerce demand from UK consumers is enabled by retailers actively developing their online propositions. A total of 36% of all businesses in the UK take orders over the internet. That is the highest proportion among the 25 largest ecommerce markets and significantly ahead of the average for these markets of about 20% (see chart 2.1). Business innovation also plays an important role in enabling ecommerce as technology and business capabilities rapidly evolve in this fast- moving area of retail. AfterAustralia,theUKhasthehighestnumber ofnewbusinessesregisteredpercapita,indicating a leading level of business innovation in these markets. The UK has a strong history of launching successful online pure-play retail businesses such as Ao.com, Asos, Farfetch, Net-a-Porter and Wiggle, which with their strong propositions have pavedthewayinacceleratingecommercedemand from consumers. A look at international ecommerce provides further evidence of the sophistication of online retail among UK retailers – in 2013 the UK was the world’s leading exporter of online goods with a trade surplus of more than $1bn. Similarly, that UK’s multichannel players – ArgosandJohnLewisinparticular–areexcellent examplesofstore-ledbusinessesthatarereshaping l The UK has the highest proportion of businesses that take orders over the internet l In 2013 the UK was the world’s leading exporter of online goods l The UK is losing ground to other countries in the advancement of m-commerce themselvesasadvantagedmodelsforadigitalage. However, it is not just innovative retailers that are driving more consumers to purchase online. Creative propositions in other areas have also been important in building the strong demand for ecommerce that is seen in the UK. Examples of businesses making ecommerce more accessible include Simpleshop.com, which makes it easy for businesses to operate online by combing website templates and EPoS systems; Fits.me, which provides retailers with the technology to offer an online fitting room; Shutl, which offers same- day delivery by aggregating local couriers; and StreetHub, which aggregates products from local boutiques for customers to click-and-collect. These innovative businesses are enabling retailers to provide a high level of convenience for customers, making ecommerce increasingly suitable for today’s lifestyle. But despite its strong ecommerce credentials overall, the UK is losing out in mobile commerce –inparticulartocountriesthathaveleapfroggedit intermsoftechnology,suchasChina,SouthKorea and India. In the UK about 62% of the population own a smartphone. That places the UK fifth among the 25largestecommercemarkets,aheadofcountries such as the US, Netherlands and Germany, but behind South Korea, Norway and Australia (see chart 2.3). When it comes to 3G/4G penetration 78% of the UK population have 3G/4G SIM cards , which ranks the UK ninth overall among the 25 largest ecommerce markets. 39%UKsmartphoneowners tohavemadeapurchase withtheirphones “Business innovation plays an important role in enabling ecommerce as technology and business capabilities rapidly evolve in this fast-moving area of retail” UK organisations have led in developing online propositions Organisational readiness 2.1 Organisational online readiness % businesses taking orders online Australia UK Norway Sweden Russia Ireland Netherlands Denmark Czech Republic France Spain China Belgium US Finland South Korea Italy Germany Canada Japan Turkey Poland Austria Brazil India 7,998 7,108 5,088 4,093 3,081 2,997 2,941 2,816 2,050 1,841 1,809 1,681 1,616 1,580 1,505 1,473 1,264 860 732 721 518 405 334 269 80 2.2 Level of business innovation # new businesses registered/per million people UK US Brazil Netherlands Japan Norway Denmark Germany South Korea Ireland Sweden Belgium Czech Republic Austria Finland Canada Russia France Spain Poland Turkey Australia Italy China India 36% 35% 34% 33% 32% 31% 28% 28% 28% 25% 24% 23% 22% 20% 20% 18% 18% 15% 13% 10% 9% 9% 3% 3% 1% Source: UNCTAD, Statista, NAICS, World Bank, Census Data, Press Search, OCC analysis Finland and Sweden have the highest penetration of 3G/4G, with 122% and 118% respectively (some consumers have multiple SIM cards for their phones and tablets). Good connectivity is a prerequisite of a great customer experience across digital channels – a dimension on which the UK does not make it to the top of the league table. Among smartphone owners, less than half, about 39%, have made a purchase with their phones. This puts the UK 10th in terms of m-commerce penetration and leaves considerable room for improvement. Thetopthreemarketsintermsofm-commerce penetration are all countries that have leapfrogged thetypicaltechnologycurve,bypassingthedesktop era – China, South Korea and India. In China, the majority (70%) of smartphone users have made purchases with their phones (see chart 2.5). UK retailers have been relatively slow to adapt to mobile as a channel – in 2013, only 50% of the top 100 retailers had mobile-optimised websites. By 2014, this has increased and today 25% of the top 100 retailers do not offer a mobile- optimised version of their website according to findings in the annual UK Retailer Mobile Optimisation Report . With smartphone penetration relatively high and likely to continue to grow, UK retailers will need to rapidly evolve their mobile website and app propositions, an area in which retailers in the more advanced m-commerce markets – China, South Korea, India and the US – could provide inspiration. The race to be ready Mobile penetration China South Korea India US Ireland Japan Turkey Australia Russia UK Sweden Norway Germany Denmark Austria Brazil Italy Czech Republic Poland Canada France Finland Spain Netherlands Belgium 70% 56% 54% 46% 44% 44% 43% 41% 39% 39% 33% 33% 32% 31% 30% 30% 30% 30% 29% 27% 26% 26% 25% 18% 16% 2.5 M-commerce penetration2 , 2013 % smartphone users The race to be ready Mobile penetration South Korea Norway Australia Sweden UK Denmark Ireland US Canada Spain Netherlands Austria China Finland France Czech Republic Italy Germany Russia Poland Belgium Turkey Brazil Japan India 73% 68% 65% 63% 62% 59% 57% 56% 56% 55% 52% 48% 46% 45% 42% 41% 41% 40% 36% 35% 33% 29% 26% 25% 17% 2.3 Smartphone penetration, 2013 % population Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis Finland Sweden Japan Australia South Korea Denmark Norway Spain UK US Austria Italy Netherlands Russia France Ireland Poland Brazil Czech Republic Germany Canada Belgium China Turkey India 122% 118% 107% 105% 103% 97% 82% 79% 78% 68% 63% 62% 58% 57% 57% 57% 55% 48% 46% 46% 41% 36% 31% 30% 4% 2.4 3G/4G penetration1 , 2013 Subscribers/total population The race to be ready Mobile penetration 8 9 1 Can be 100% since some consumers have multiple SIM cards Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis 2 Includes all purchases ever made on a smartphone, given the consumer owns a smartphone Source: Google, World Bank, OCC analysis | September 2014 September 2014 |
  • 6. 10 Copy copy £0bn Copy copy £0bnthe Last-mile battleground CHAPTER 3 The UK is behind other markets on some key last-mile fulfilment measures. Ease of last-mile delivery as evidenced by the ratioofpopulationdensitytopavedroaddensity,is broadlyinlinewithmostotherWesternEuropean markets, although not as high as in Belgium and the Netherlands. However, home delivery lags behind countries such as the US and China, where same-day delivery is more prevalent and better-developed. For instance, JD.com, one of China’s leading ecommerce retailers, is at the forefront of making same-day the market norm by getting products to consumersthesamedayiforderedbefore11am,or the next day if ordered after that time. For an extra fee, JD.com also offers ‘super-fast’ delivery, which gets products to buyers within threehours.Italreadyserves80millioncustomers across six cities with this speedy service and plans to grow coverage. IntheUS,Amazonisalreadycapableofserving 23% of the population the same day, versus 17% in the UK. l Same-day delivery in the UK is not as developed as in other countries l The UK has a smaller ratio of pick-up and drop-off points than many Western countries l The UK’s ‘drive-thru’ network is underdeveloped Despite ease of last-mile delivery being in line with other markets, the UK also has a smaller ratio of pick-up and drop-off (PUDO) points than most other Western markets for the size of the ecommerce market. PUDO points include convenience stores, railwaystationsandsupermarkets.Theyareplaces where consumers can collect or drop off parcels that they have purchased online. These points are typically served by a range of courier businesses, which in the UK include companies such as Collect+ and Hermes. They do not include the respective Post Office networks. For the size of its ecommerce market, the UK hasalownumberofPUDOpointscomparedwith other Western markets. The UK offers 0.5 PUDO points per £1m of ecommerce spend versus 1.8 points in Germany and 0.8 points and 0.7 points in Belgium and France respectively. That has in part been driven by European operators of collection points being slow to enter the UK and an underdeveloped ‘drive-thru’ network compared with markets such as France. 17%TheamountoftheUK populationAmazoniscapable ofservingthesameday “home delivery lags behind countries such as the US and China, where same-day delivery is more prevalent and better-developed” The UK lags Western markets in fulfilment options such as click-and-collect Last-mile delivery/fulfilment 3.1 Ease of last-mile delivery1 Indexed to max Germany Belgium France Spain Poland US Netherlands UK Australia Czech Republic 1.8 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.3 0.2 1 Population density/quality road density indicates ease and cost of delivering to households (values are indexed to Belgium) 2 Pick up and drop off points, does not include post offices or points for collection only Source: World Bank, Desk Research, World Bank, OCC Modelling, OCC analysis 3.2 PUDO2 points per £1m of total ecommerce spend Number of points Belgium Netherlands France Germany UK Denmark Czech Republic Italy Ireland Austria Spain Japan Poland South Korea India US Turkey Sweden China Norway Finland Canada Russia Australia Brazil 100 84 49 46 44 44 42 41 35 35 33 23 23 22 20 11 11 8 7 6 4 1 1 1 1 11September 2014 |
  • 7. Copy copy £0bnUK infrastructure at risk of slowing down ecommerce CHAPTER 4 Strong ecommerce relies heavily on national infrastructure – good connectivity and payment methods enable online purchasing. Here the UK falls into the ‘middle of the pack’ among the 25 largest ecommerce markets despite an overall well-developed starting point in terms of populationwithinternetaccessandonlinepayment options such as credit and/or debit cards. While the UK is reasonably well-positioned in terms of its internet user base and penetration of online payments, there are signs that the l The UK is falling behind other countries in terms of internet connection speeds l Slow internet speeds have a negative impact on customer experience l There is room for improvement in the UK’s approach to business regulation Online purchasing is enabled by good connectivity and payment methods Infrastructure maturity 4.1 Internet user penetration % population 4.2 Online payment penetration1 % population Norway Sweden Denmark Netherlands Finland UK Japan Canada South Korea US Germany Australia Belgium France Austria Ireland Czech Republic Spain Poland Russia Italy Brazil Turkey China India 1 Maximum of credit and debit card penetration Source: World Bank, OCC analysis 95% 95% 95% 94% 92% 90% 86% 86% 85% 84% 84% 83% 82% 82% 81% 78% 74% 72% 63% 61% 59% 52% 46% 46% 15% Netherlands Norway Sweden Finland Denmark Austria Canada UK Germany Belgium Australia US Ireland Japan Spain France Czech Republic South Korea Turkey China Brazil Russia Poland Italy India 98% 97% 97% 95% 92% 91% 91% 90% 88% 88% 82% 78% 77% 71% 71% 69% 69% 64% 62% 54% 52% 45% 44% 37% 14% infrastructure is not keeping pace with the best in the world. Peak connection speeds of 990Mbps (which enables downloading of a HD movie in 50 seconds) in the UK rank only 12th among the 25 largest ecommercemarkets–behindtheUSandanumber of European countries (see chart 4.3). South Korea leads on this dimension, with peakconnectionspeedsofupto2,360Mbps(which enablesdownloadingofaHDmoviein20seconds), followed by Japan and the Netherlands. Connection speeds and ease of doing business lag other markets South Korea Japan Netherlands Sweden Czech Republic Finland Ireland Denmark US Norway Belgium UK Canada Austria Russia Germany Poland Spain France Australia Italy Turkey China Brazil India Consumer connectivity 4.3 Peak connection speeds Mbps US Denmark South Korea Norway UK Australia Finland Sweden Ireland Canada Germany Japan Netherlands Austria Belgium France Poland Spain Italy Turkey Czech Republic Russia China Brazil India Source: World Bank, BMI, Euromonitor, Statista, Econsultancy, Ystats, World Bank, OCC Modelling, OCC analysis 4.4 Ease of doing business Indexed to max 2,360 1,460 1,240 1,160 1,120 1,070 1,070 1,050 1,050 1,010 1,000 990 970 940 860 810 750 720 660 600 520 500 320 260 170 98% 98% 97% 96% 95% 95% 94% 93% 93% 90% 89% 86% 86% 85% 81% 80% 77% 73% 66% 64% 61% 52% 50% 39% 30% Slower connection speeds dampen the experience customers have and could hold back UK ecommerce from growing at a more rapid pace. Although ranked fifth, there is also room for improvement on ‘ease of doing business’, a metric which looks at the regulatory environment for businesses across things such as starting a business, tax and registering property. Here, too, the UK is behind the US, Denmark, South Korea and Norway (see chart 4.4). 12 13September 2014 |
  • 8. 14 Copy copy £0bn * XXXXX SOURCE:MobileRetailretailersurvey 14 The ecommerce demand versus supply gap CHAPTER 5 15 Overall, the range of metrics considered in this study highlight that British consumers lead the way in ecommerce (coming first in the top 25 countries) and that the shift to online and multichannel across a broad range of categories is the most marked in the UK (see chart 5.1). However, the supply-side infrastructure (in which the UK comes eighth in the rankings) in the UK is not keeping pace with the consumer appetite for shopping online (see chart 5.2). Online could be a faster-growing channel than it has been if the UK and its retailers invest inmoreadvancedfulfilmentcapabilityandhigher internet speeds. The leading levels of ecommerce demand in the UK continue to represent a significant opportunity for retailers. Maximising this opportunity is likely to require addressing the supply challenges and continuing to innovate as consumer behaviour evolves. In our view, to keep up with advancing consumers, UK retailers should be taking the following steps: 1. Invest in the customer experience across multiple device platforms Consumers expect that their journey will be smooth, no matter on what device they access a site. Retailers need to play catch-up to ensure theirdigitalchannelsacrossallmobile,tabletand desktop platforms are working well. 2. Innovate in fulfilment Investments in speed of fulfilment (same/next day) and convenience (collection and return networks) are required in order for retailers to remain competitive. 3. Influence the connectivity agenda Retailersshouldbeworkingwithgovernmentand partnering with telecom companies to champion theagendaforhigherinternetspeedsthroughout the country. l Retailers must invest in the efficacy of their online channels l Speed and convenience are crucial if UK retailers are to remain competitive l Retailers should work with telecoms providers and Government to improve connection speeds “The leading levels of ecommerce demand in the UK continue to represent a significant opportunity for retailers” Ecommerce demand versus supply metrics for the largest 25 ecommerce markets 5.1 Demand ranking Source: OCC analysis 5.2 Supply ranking Country Country 1 UK 14 Ireland 2 South Korea 15 Austria 3 US 16 Russia 4 Sweden 17 Canada 5 Japan 18 Spain 6 Australia 19 Czech Republic 7 Norway 20 Italy 8 Denmark 21 Poland 9 Germany 22 Turkey 10 China 23 Belgium 11 France 24 India 12 Finland 25 Brazil 13 Netherlands Country Country 1 Japan 14 Canada 2 Netherlands 15 Russia 3 South Korea 16 Czech Republic 4 Denmark 17 Spain 5 Germany 18 France 6 Norway 19 Poland 7 Sweden 20 Turkey 8 UK 21 China 9 Belgium 22 Australia 10 US 23 Italy 11 Finland 24 India 12 Ireland 25 Brazil 13 Austria September 2014 |