SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 4
Descargar para leer sin conexión
TOP 10 PRODUCT
LIFECYCLE
MANAGEMENT
SOFTWARE REPORT
Comparison of the Leading PLM Software Vendors
2015 EDITION
Product lifecycle management comprises the processes and practices associated with managing
a product throughout its lifecycle, from its conception through design and manufacturing stages, to
service and decommission. Product lifecycle management software utilizes PLM methodologies to
provide a central repository for all data and assets that enable workers to collaborate on products
in real time. When effectively implemented and leveraged, PLM software can merge business
systems, people and data processes to facilitate a streamlined approach to product development.
These solutions will benefit any business that creates and sells products. PLM is a must-have for
product manufacturers.
Today’s top-rated PLM software solutions are both comprehensive and collaborative. Look for
software that tracks and records information from
various sources and departments, making that
information available to suppliers, engineers,
marketing teams and other departments that
are vital to product development. Your product
lifecycle management software should also manage
product design (both 2D and 3D design elements),
oversee the production pipeline, work in real time
and significantly reduce the costs associated with
regulatory compliance. PLM software should also
effectively manage bill of materials (BOMs).
Use this handy Top 10 Product Lifecycle
Management Software guide to familiarize yourself
with top vendors and compare the leading solutions
by key features and pricing models.
Key Features
		 © 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited.
About Business-Software.com
Business-Software.com is your go-to source for business software reviews, expert advice, in-depth articles and
product white papers to meet all of your software needs. We’re the most comprehensive online resource for buyers
and vendors, catering to more than 300,000 members who trust us to connect them with the right software.
We offer exclusive comparison reports for 80+ business software segments, enabling you to efficiently research
and review highly rated software products. Download our free reports to discover top business solutions for
Accounting, CRM, ERP, CMS, Manufacturing, HR and more.
Overview of Product Lifecycle
Management Software Solutions
Collaboration
tools
BOM
management
Information
authoring
Document
management
Computer-aided
design (CAD)
On-premise
solution
Real-time
alerts
SaaS solution
Change
management
Top 10 PLM Software Comparison
Autodesk PLM 360
$
Select Customers
Porex, Electrical
Components International,
Zep Solar, Greenpoint
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Complete product
lifecycle management
•	 Engineering change
management
•	 View and manipulate 3D
and 2D representations
•	 Role-based authoring
•	 Change management
•	 New Product
Introduction (NPI)
•	 Supplier collaboration
•	 Quality management
•	 Project management
•	 Corrective and
Preventative Actions
(CAPA)
•	 Cost management
•	 Process workflow
creation and definition
•	 Workspace creation and
configuration
•	 View BOMs in the right
context
•	 Integration with
Autodesk Vault and
other PDM solutions
Arena PLM
www.arenasolutions.com
Select Customers
GoPro, Beats by Dre,
Medtronic, Violin Memory,
Cadence, SunPower
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Invented Cloud PLM
•	 Next generation Bill
of Materials (BOM)
Management
•	 Quality Management
•	 Central repository for
BOMs, AML, AVL,
documents, design files
•	 Capture contextual design
information from sites like
Arrow or Digi-Key
•	 Project & Change
Management
•	 Compliance Management
•	 New Product Introduction
(NPI) & collaboration
•	 Quality processes like
CAPA and ECOs
•	 Three supply chain
solutions
•	 MCAD, ECAD, MRP and
ERP integrations
Infor PLM Discrete
www.infor.com
Select Customers
Sypris, Henkel, RPM
International, Inalfa Roof
Systems, Promethean
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Product lifecycle
intelligence
•	 Product data
management (PDM)
•	 Integrates with ERP and
CAD systems
•	 Manage products and
related documents from
one location
•	 Compliance
management
•	 Enterprise content
management
•	 In-house and supplier
collaboration tools
•	 Document management
•	 Version control
•	 BOM master
•	 Industry-specific
manufacturing solutions
for food and beverage,
specialty chemicals,
high tech, fashion and
discrete manufacturers
Siemens Teamcenter
www.siemens.com
Select Customers
Firewire Surfboards,
Procter & Gamble,
Astrium, BAE Systems
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Computer-aided design,
manufacturing and
engineering analysis
(CAD/CAM/CAE)
•	 Product data
management (PDM)
•	 Bill of materials (BOMs)
•	 Process management
tools such as design
review and change
management
•	 Requirements
management
•	 Service lifecycle
management (SLM)
•	 Manufacturing process
management
•	 Supplier collaboration
•	 Quality management
with CAPA
•	 Product cost
management
•	 Sustainability and
environmental
compliance
•	 Systems engineering
IFS Applications
www.ifsworld.com
Select Customers
CNH Industrial, SAAB,
Colfax, Vigor Shipyard,
Ensign-Bickford
Key Features
www.autodeskplm360.com
$ $$$$ $$$ $$$$
		 © 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited.
Additional Features
•	 Integrated PLM solution
offered as part of ERP
software suite
•	 Complete product
lifecycle management
•	 View data in real time
•	 User permissions
•	 Collaboration tools for
suppliers and customers
•	 Equipment repository
•	 Preventative
maintenance
•	 Condition-based
maintenance
•	 Inventory and
procurement
•	 SCM
•	 Sales contract
management
•	 Product data
management (PDM)
•	 Purchase orders and
shop orders
•	 Track project progress
and milestones
•	 Eco-friendly solutions
© 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited.
MasterControl Quality
Management System
$$
Select Customers
BioMimetic Therapeutics,
A.P. Pharma, Nelson
Laboratories
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Automates task
assignment, routing,
scheduling and review
of all document-based
processes
•	 CAPA system ensures
compliance
•	 Training management
•	 Nonconformance
automation software
automates, manages
and streamlines
processes for utilizing
nonconforming materials
•	 Quality audit
management
•	 Forms-based processes
automation
•	 Facilitates electronic
delivery of FDA
applications
•	 Industry-specific PLM
solutions for medical
device, pharmaceutical
and biotech
manufacturers
IQMS EnterpriseIQ
Manufacturing ERP
www.iqms.com
Select Customers
Donnelly Manufacturing,
Gill Industries, Tessy
Plastics, Mar-Bal Inc
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Complete audit trail of
product’s lifecycle
•	 PLM module connects
to broader ERP and
manufacturing solutions
•	 Central repository for all
quotes, FMEA, PPAP,
tooling, CRM and other
related information
•	 Easily convert quotes to
a BOM when project is
awarded
•	 Track and automate
workflows
•	 Cross-application
visibility, collaboration
and traceability in real
time
•	 Link information such as
number of rejects and
order releases
•	 Expedited order and
shipping processing
•	 Accessible by tablet,
smartphone, PC, PDA
and more
Active Sensing PDXpert
www.buyplm.com
Select Customers
UTC-Kidde, Revolabs,
Brammo Motorcycles,
Philips Healthcare, Zodiac
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Manages product data
and processes
•	 Parts list management
•	 Rules-based document
and part numbering
system
•	 Bill of materials
•	 Engineering drawing
management
•	 Electronic file repository
•	 Engineering change
management
•	 Vendor source
management
•	 Materials content
identification for
regulatory compliance
•	 Import legacy parts,
BOMs, design files and
other PLM-related data
•	 Multi-user secured
access
•	 On-site or private cloud
•	 Subscription or
perpetual licenses
Dassault Systemes
3DEXPERIENCE Platform
www.3ds.com
Select Customers
Eterna, Barilla, J.G.
Weisser & Soehne, Eaton,
Scania Group
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Platform comprises
various product
development software
applications for a
comprehensive solution
•	 Data and process
management
•	 Cross-functional BOM
management
•	 CATIA offers 3D
CAD tools for all
manufacturing
organizations
•	 ENOVIA provides digital
collaboration functions
•	 Robust simulation tools
•	 NETVIBES lets users
create personalized
dashboards for real-
time monitoring, social
analytics and knowledge
sharing
•	 GEOVIA offers eco-
friendly modeling and
simulating tools
PTC Windchill
www.ptc.com
Select Customers
Axeon, Medco Equipment,
Xerox Corporation,
InterComm
Key Features
Additional Features
•	 Manages, cross-
references and offers
visibility into all product-
related content such as
MCAD, ECAD, software
and documents
•	 Compliance and risk
management
•	 Quality management
•	 Product data
management (PDM)
•	 Cost estimation
•	 Requirements
management
•	 Supplier management
•	 Centralized vaulting and
revision control of CAD
models
•	 Supply chain
communication and
collaboration
•	 Design and content
management
Top 10 PLM Software Comparison
www.mastercontrol.com
$$$$ $ $$$ $$$

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Managing with KPI's and KRI's
Managing with KPI's and KRI's Managing with KPI's and KRI's
Managing with KPI's and KRI's
Andrew Smart
 
Role of management information system
Role of management information systemRole of management information system
Role of management information system
Slide Hub
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulations - 23 NYCRR Part 500
NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulations - 23 NYCRR Part 500NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulations - 23 NYCRR Part 500
NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulations - 23 NYCRR Part 500
 
Managing with KPI's and KRI's
Managing with KPI's and KRI's Managing with KPI's and KRI's
Managing with KPI's and KRI's
 
Role of management information system
Role of management information systemRole of management information system
Role of management information system
 
Global E-Business and Collaboration
Global E-Business and CollaborationGlobal E-Business and Collaboration
Global E-Business and Collaboration
 
Gr. 8, Information System and Its Types
Gr. 8, Information System and Its TypesGr. 8, Information System and Its Types
Gr. 8, Information System and Its Types
 
HOW INFORMATION SYSTEM IS EFFECT ON AN ORGANIZATION
HOW INFORMATION SYSTEM IS EFFECT ON AN ORGANIZATIONHOW INFORMATION SYSTEM IS EFFECT ON AN ORGANIZATION
HOW INFORMATION SYSTEM IS EFFECT ON AN ORGANIZATION
 
Introduction to NIST’s Risk Management Framework (RMF)
Introduction to NIST’s Risk Management Framework (RMF)Introduction to NIST’s Risk Management Framework (RMF)
Introduction to NIST’s Risk Management Framework (RMF)
 
What are policies procedures guidelines standards
What are policies procedures guidelines standardsWhat are policies procedures guidelines standards
What are policies procedures guidelines standards
 
Mis introduction
Mis introductionMis introduction
Mis introduction
 
functional application of mis
functional application of misfunctional application of mis
functional application of mis
 
MIS concepts
MIS conceptsMIS concepts
MIS concepts
 
Cybersecurity digital marketing plan
Cybersecurity digital marketing planCybersecurity digital marketing plan
Cybersecurity digital marketing plan
 
VTU - MIS - MODULE 2 - KINDS OF INFORMATION SYSTEM
VTU - MIS - MODULE 2 - KINDS OF INFORMATION SYSTEMVTU - MIS - MODULE 2 - KINDS OF INFORMATION SYSTEM
VTU - MIS - MODULE 2 - KINDS OF INFORMATION SYSTEM
 
History of Management Information System
History of Management Information SystemHistory of Management Information System
History of Management Information System
 
ITB - UNIT 1.pdf
ITB - UNIT 1.pdfITB - UNIT 1.pdf
ITB - UNIT 1.pdf
 
CONTROL & AUDIT INFORMATION SYSTEM (HALL, 2015)
CONTROL & AUDIT INFORMATION SYSTEM (HALL, 2015)CONTROL & AUDIT INFORMATION SYSTEM (HALL, 2015)
CONTROL & AUDIT INFORMATION SYSTEM (HALL, 2015)
 
TPS
TPSTPS
TPS
 
Cómo crear un Centro de Excelencia de Automatización 2
Cómo crear un Centro de Excelencia de Automatización 2Cómo crear un Centro de Excelencia de Automatización 2
Cómo crear un Centro de Excelencia de Automatización 2
 
Embedding RCSA into Strategic Planning and Business Strategy
Embedding RCSA into Strategic Planning and Business StrategyEmbedding RCSA into Strategic Planning and Business Strategy
Embedding RCSA into Strategic Planning and Business Strategy
 
IT Audit Methodologies
IT Audit MethodologiesIT Audit Methodologies
IT Audit Methodologies
 

Similar a Top10_PLM_applications

Plm fundas part 2
Plm fundas part 2Plm fundas part 2
Plm fundas part 2
Anand Joshi
 
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
Doina Draganescu
 
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
kailashgavare
 
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
Andy Larsen
 
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
Highbar Technocrat
 

Similar a Top10_PLM_applications (20)

Plm & windchill
Plm & windchillPlm & windchill
Plm & windchill
 
Product Data Management
Product Data ManagementProduct Data Management
Product Data Management
 
Plm fundas part 2
Plm fundas part 2Plm fundas part 2
Plm fundas part 2
 
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
2. oracle bpm soa 11g - simple - unified - complete
 
The road to plm
The road to plmThe road to plm
The road to plm
 
The Road to PLM
The Road to PLMThe Road to PLM
The Road to PLM
 
ARC's Dick Slansky's PLM with Shop Floor Operations Presentation at ARC's 200...
ARC's Dick Slansky's PLM with Shop Floor Operations Presentation at ARC's 200...ARC's Dick Slansky's PLM with Shop Floor Operations Presentation at ARC's 200...
ARC's Dick Slansky's PLM with Shop Floor Operations Presentation at ARC's 200...
 
What Is Your PLM Challenge - Manage configurable products and maintain produc...
What Is Your PLM Challenge - Manage configurable products and maintain produc...What Is Your PLM Challenge - Manage configurable products and maintain produc...
What Is Your PLM Challenge - Manage configurable products and maintain produc...
 
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE
 
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
Introductiontoadaptiveand3dexperience 180807145140
 
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
attune Fashion Suite Accelerators.2016
 
Reconnect17 PeopleSoft Supply Chain Management SIG Meeting
Reconnect17 PeopleSoft Supply Chain Management SIG MeetingReconnect17 PeopleSoft Supply Chain Management SIG Meeting
Reconnect17 PeopleSoft Supply Chain Management SIG Meeting
 
SharePoint PLM Software Overview
SharePoint PLM Software OverviewSharePoint PLM Software Overview
SharePoint PLM Software Overview
 
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
5D BIM ERP Digital Project Management Platform by Highbar Technocrat Limited
 
EAC Hunter Fan Presentation
EAC Hunter Fan PresentationEAC Hunter Fan Presentation
EAC Hunter Fan Presentation
 
Hunter Fan + EAC Presentation
Hunter Fan + EAC PresentationHunter Fan + EAC Presentation
Hunter Fan + EAC Presentation
 
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE Cloud
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE CloudIntroduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE Cloud
Introduction to Adaptive and 3DEXPERIENCE Cloud
 
Collaborate 2018: Hyperion and PeopleSoft - Hands Off Automation
Collaborate 2018: Hyperion and PeopleSoft - Hands Off AutomationCollaborate 2018: Hyperion and PeopleSoft - Hands Off Automation
Collaborate 2018: Hyperion and PeopleSoft - Hands Off Automation
 
Top 10 bi
Top 10 biTop 10 bi
Top 10 bi
 
Top 10 bi
Top 10 biTop 10 bi
Top 10 bi
 

Top10_PLM_applications

  • 1. TOP 10 PRODUCT LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE REPORT Comparison of the Leading PLM Software Vendors 2015 EDITION
  • 2. Product lifecycle management comprises the processes and practices associated with managing a product throughout its lifecycle, from its conception through design and manufacturing stages, to service and decommission. Product lifecycle management software utilizes PLM methodologies to provide a central repository for all data and assets that enable workers to collaborate on products in real time. When effectively implemented and leveraged, PLM software can merge business systems, people and data processes to facilitate a streamlined approach to product development. These solutions will benefit any business that creates and sells products. PLM is a must-have for product manufacturers. Today’s top-rated PLM software solutions are both comprehensive and collaborative. Look for software that tracks and records information from various sources and departments, making that information available to suppliers, engineers, marketing teams and other departments that are vital to product development. Your product lifecycle management software should also manage product design (both 2D and 3D design elements), oversee the production pipeline, work in real time and significantly reduce the costs associated with regulatory compliance. PLM software should also effectively manage bill of materials (BOMs). Use this handy Top 10 Product Lifecycle Management Software guide to familiarize yourself with top vendors and compare the leading solutions by key features and pricing models. Key Features © 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited. About Business-Software.com Business-Software.com is your go-to source for business software reviews, expert advice, in-depth articles and product white papers to meet all of your software needs. We’re the most comprehensive online resource for buyers and vendors, catering to more than 300,000 members who trust us to connect them with the right software. We offer exclusive comparison reports for 80+ business software segments, enabling you to efficiently research and review highly rated software products. Download our free reports to discover top business solutions for Accounting, CRM, ERP, CMS, Manufacturing, HR and more. Overview of Product Lifecycle Management Software Solutions Collaboration tools BOM management Information authoring Document management Computer-aided design (CAD) On-premise solution Real-time alerts SaaS solution Change management
  • 3. Top 10 PLM Software Comparison Autodesk PLM 360 $ Select Customers Porex, Electrical Components International, Zep Solar, Greenpoint Key Features Additional Features • Complete product lifecycle management • Engineering change management • View and manipulate 3D and 2D representations • Role-based authoring • Change management • New Product Introduction (NPI) • Supplier collaboration • Quality management • Project management • Corrective and Preventative Actions (CAPA) • Cost management • Process workflow creation and definition • Workspace creation and configuration • View BOMs in the right context • Integration with Autodesk Vault and other PDM solutions Arena PLM www.arenasolutions.com Select Customers GoPro, Beats by Dre, Medtronic, Violin Memory, Cadence, SunPower Key Features Additional Features • Invented Cloud PLM • Next generation Bill of Materials (BOM) Management • Quality Management • Central repository for BOMs, AML, AVL, documents, design files • Capture contextual design information from sites like Arrow or Digi-Key • Project & Change Management • Compliance Management • New Product Introduction (NPI) & collaboration • Quality processes like CAPA and ECOs • Three supply chain solutions • MCAD, ECAD, MRP and ERP integrations Infor PLM Discrete www.infor.com Select Customers Sypris, Henkel, RPM International, Inalfa Roof Systems, Promethean Key Features Additional Features • Product lifecycle intelligence • Product data management (PDM) • Integrates with ERP and CAD systems • Manage products and related documents from one location • Compliance management • Enterprise content management • In-house and supplier collaboration tools • Document management • Version control • BOM master • Industry-specific manufacturing solutions for food and beverage, specialty chemicals, high tech, fashion and discrete manufacturers Siemens Teamcenter www.siemens.com Select Customers Firewire Surfboards, Procter & Gamble, Astrium, BAE Systems Key Features Additional Features • Computer-aided design, manufacturing and engineering analysis (CAD/CAM/CAE) • Product data management (PDM) • Bill of materials (BOMs) • Process management tools such as design review and change management • Requirements management • Service lifecycle management (SLM) • Manufacturing process management • Supplier collaboration • Quality management with CAPA • Product cost management • Sustainability and environmental compliance • Systems engineering IFS Applications www.ifsworld.com Select Customers CNH Industrial, SAAB, Colfax, Vigor Shipyard, Ensign-Bickford Key Features www.autodeskplm360.com $ $$$$ $$$ $$$$ © 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited. Additional Features • Integrated PLM solution offered as part of ERP software suite • Complete product lifecycle management • View data in real time • User permissions • Collaboration tools for suppliers and customers • Equipment repository • Preventative maintenance • Condition-based maintenance • Inventory and procurement • SCM • Sales contract management • Product data management (PDM) • Purchase orders and shop orders • Track project progress and milestones • Eco-friendly solutions
  • 4. © 2015, All Rights Reserved. Reproduction Prohibited. MasterControl Quality Management System $$ Select Customers BioMimetic Therapeutics, A.P. Pharma, Nelson Laboratories Key Features Additional Features • Automates task assignment, routing, scheduling and review of all document-based processes • CAPA system ensures compliance • Training management • Nonconformance automation software automates, manages and streamlines processes for utilizing nonconforming materials • Quality audit management • Forms-based processes automation • Facilitates electronic delivery of FDA applications • Industry-specific PLM solutions for medical device, pharmaceutical and biotech manufacturers IQMS EnterpriseIQ Manufacturing ERP www.iqms.com Select Customers Donnelly Manufacturing, Gill Industries, Tessy Plastics, Mar-Bal Inc Key Features Additional Features • Complete audit trail of product’s lifecycle • PLM module connects to broader ERP and manufacturing solutions • Central repository for all quotes, FMEA, PPAP, tooling, CRM and other related information • Easily convert quotes to a BOM when project is awarded • Track and automate workflows • Cross-application visibility, collaboration and traceability in real time • Link information such as number of rejects and order releases • Expedited order and shipping processing • Accessible by tablet, smartphone, PC, PDA and more Active Sensing PDXpert www.buyplm.com Select Customers UTC-Kidde, Revolabs, Brammo Motorcycles, Philips Healthcare, Zodiac Key Features Additional Features • Manages product data and processes • Parts list management • Rules-based document and part numbering system • Bill of materials • Engineering drawing management • Electronic file repository • Engineering change management • Vendor source management • Materials content identification for regulatory compliance • Import legacy parts, BOMs, design files and other PLM-related data • Multi-user secured access • On-site or private cloud • Subscription or perpetual licenses Dassault Systemes 3DEXPERIENCE Platform www.3ds.com Select Customers Eterna, Barilla, J.G. Weisser & Soehne, Eaton, Scania Group Key Features Additional Features • Platform comprises various product development software applications for a comprehensive solution • Data and process management • Cross-functional BOM management • CATIA offers 3D CAD tools for all manufacturing organizations • ENOVIA provides digital collaboration functions • Robust simulation tools • NETVIBES lets users create personalized dashboards for real- time monitoring, social analytics and knowledge sharing • GEOVIA offers eco- friendly modeling and simulating tools PTC Windchill www.ptc.com Select Customers Axeon, Medco Equipment, Xerox Corporation, InterComm Key Features Additional Features • Manages, cross- references and offers visibility into all product- related content such as MCAD, ECAD, software and documents • Compliance and risk management • Quality management • Product data management (PDM) • Cost estimation • Requirements management • Supplier management • Centralized vaulting and revision control of CAD models • Supply chain communication and collaboration • Design and content management Top 10 PLM Software Comparison www.mastercontrol.com $$$$ $ $$$ $$$