SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 4
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Impactful Leadership – The Focus on Money and Meaning 
Rakesh Khurana, Professor of Leadership Development at Harvard Business School, and fellow professor Joel Podolny have stated that, because most contemporary organizational researchers talk about leadership only in terms of its impact on economic performance rather than its ability to give the organization a sense of purpose, something crucial has been lost. 
This focus on economic results, they say, gives a one-sided picture of what leaders are actually able to accomplish. The effectiveness of organizational leadership should also explore their ability to forge new or renewed meaning and purpose for the organization and its employees. 
There’s no hidden inference here that a leader should take their focus away from bottom-line results (either profit orientated in the private sector or delivering services on time and on budget in the public and not-for-profit sectors). What is being suggested is this: if leaders don’t take the time to intentionally create an understanding of the meaningful purpose of the organization (beyond the monetary elements stated above) they miss out on the enormous potential of such a focus. 
Values and meaning 
For most of us, after our basic needs are satisfied, there are a couple of others, which lend themselves to our sense of leading a meaningful life. These are our need to feel both valued and valuable.
In organizational terms how these needs begin to be met is by us experiencing alignment between our 
own values and ideals and those of the organization. That is, we understand how our work is 
contributing to the goals and ideals we value. The second way these needs begin to be met is through 
the quality of social interaction we have with others who share in the organization’s vision, goals and 
rewards. 
Therefore, another essential element of leadership, in addition to the bottom-line focus, is to create an 
organizational context where individuals feel creatively empowered through connection with what’s 
meaningful to them. A context where organizational culture, processes and systems enable its 
members to behave in a way that actively supports not only ownership of the organization’s vision but 
creates an authentic sense of responsibility in making that vision a reality. 
Great picture, but how does a leader create a perceptual framework, which allows them to begin to 
create such an organizational context? 
Well let’s fuel this picture with another. 
Individual Values and Beliefs 
•Personal Values 
•Leadership Style 
•Individual Drivers 
and Worldviews 
•Skills and Knowledge 
Individual Actions and 
Behaviours 
• Personal Behaviours 
•Leadership Behaviours 
•Organisational Role (Authority) 
•Modes of Decision-Making 
Group Values 
and Beliefs 
•Group Culture 
• Shared Vision 
• Organisational Values 
• Organisational Beliefs 
• Group Drivers & Worldview 
Group Actions 
and Behaviours 
•Strategies 
•Policies 
•Processes 
•Systems 
•Performance Measures 
•The Brand 
Values Behaviours 
Collective Individual 
Structural 
Alignment 
Vision & Values 
Alignment 
Mission Alignment 
Personal Alignment 
Sustainability 
Source: Ruth Garrett 2010 
This diagram is based on the work of author and researcher Ken Wilber who argues that values and 
beliefs are the hidden drivers of human behaviour.
In Wilber’s four quadrant model of the human system we see how individual (upper left quadrant) and organizational beliefs and values (lower left quadrant) drive individual (upper right quadrant) and organizational behaviour (lower right quadrant). It’s only through aligning all the facets of the human system that individual empowerment and flexible and fluid sustainable growth takes place. 
• To have personal alignment there must be alignment between personal values (upper left quadrant) and personal behaviours (upper right quadrant). 
• To have the effective execution of organizational vision and values there must be alignment of personal (upper left quadrant) and organizational cultural vision and values (lower left quadrant). 
• To have alignment of how the vision of the organization is carried out, i.e. the mission, there must be congruence between the behaviours of the individual (upper right quadrant) and the systemic behaviour of the organization (lower right quadrant). 
• To have structural congruence there must be an alignment of the espoused cultural values of the organization(lower left quadrant) and the strategic policies, procedures and systems (lower right quadrant). 
Underpinning this alignment there is a need for a leader to be willing to: 
1. Maintain organizational values even when there is some perceived economic cost to doing so. As Khurana and Podolny point out if espoused organizational values are violated when there’s a perceived benefit, it will erode organizational culture through suspicion, derision and cynicism. 
2. Ensure (through design and blended learning) that the individuals within the organization get a clear sense of the fit between what they do and who they believe themselves to be 
3. Commitment of their time and organizational resources to ensuring that each member of the organizations understands how what they do links to the purpose of the organization. 
4. Ensures that recruitment and retention policies are congruent with hiring individuals who will gain personal meaning from organizational values and purpose. 
Bibliography Khurana R., Podolny J., Legace M. (2005), How to Put Meaning Back into Leading, http://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/4563.html accessed October 2010
Ruth Garrett MSc. PhD 
For the past 20 years, Ruth has been a facilitator, coach and mentor of individual and organizational transition and change. 
She works with a wide range of organizational clients in the corporate, retail, manufacturing, public and education sectors assisting them in realizing their highest levels of growth. 
Ruth also works with a variety of individual clients assisting them in getting from where they are to where they want to be. 
Contact details: 
Web: www.manifestingyourabundance.com 
www.integralcoachingandmediation.com 
Email: ruth@manifestingyourabundance.com 
integralcoaching@sympatico.ca 
Cell: 705-441-6581

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
TLF8
 
Embracing change transformational leadership 013013
Embracing change   transformational leadership 013013Embracing change   transformational leadership 013013
Embracing change transformational leadership 013013
Wright
 
Motivational & transformational leadership
Motivational & transformational leadershipMotivational & transformational leadership
Motivational & transformational leadership
David Stonehouse
 
A Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
A Review Of Transformational Leadership ModelsA Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
A Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
Robert Marbun
 
The Symbolic Frame
The Symbolic FrameThe Symbolic Frame
The Symbolic Frame
guest19e59c
 
Workplace spirit
Workplace spiritWorkplace spirit
Workplace spirit
Jeff Allen
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
Transformational Leadership Forum (TLF8)
 
Transformational leadership II
Transformational leadership IITransformational leadership II
Transformational leadership II
 
Transformational Leadership vs. Transactional Leadership
Transformational Leadership vs. Transactional LeadershipTransformational Leadership vs. Transactional Leadership
Transformational Leadership vs. Transactional Leadership
 
Transformational leadership
Transformational leadershipTransformational leadership
Transformational leadership
 
Embracing change transformational leadership 013013
Embracing change   transformational leadership 013013Embracing change   transformational leadership 013013
Embracing change transformational leadership 013013
 
Motivational & transformational leadership
Motivational & transformational leadershipMotivational & transformational leadership
Motivational & transformational leadership
 
A Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
A Review Of Transformational Leadership ModelsA Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
A Review Of Transformational Leadership Models
 
TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP
TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIPTRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP
TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP
 
Transformational leadership 2015-06-22
Transformational leadership   2015-06-22Transformational leadership   2015-06-22
Transformational leadership 2015-06-22
 
Four-Frame Model - Reframing Organisations
Four-Frame Model - Reframing OrganisationsFour-Frame Model - Reframing Organisations
Four-Frame Model - Reframing Organisations
 
Organizational behavior
Organizational behaviorOrganizational behavior
Organizational behavior
 
The Symbolic Frame
The Symbolic FrameThe Symbolic Frame
The Symbolic Frame
 
Avi leadership
Avi leadershipAvi leadership
Avi leadership
 
Transformational Leadership Webinar 010710
Transformational Leadership Webinar 010710Transformational Leadership Webinar 010710
Transformational Leadership Webinar 010710
 
Corporate World and spirituality
Corporate World and spiritualityCorporate World and spirituality
Corporate World and spirituality
 
The 4 Elements of Transformational Leadership
The 4 Elements of Transformational LeadershipThe 4 Elements of Transformational Leadership
The 4 Elements of Transformational Leadership
 
Organizational Culture 2014 (03)
Organizational Culture 2014 (03)Organizational Culture 2014 (03)
Organizational Culture 2014 (03)
 
Workplace spirit
Workplace spiritWorkplace spirit
Workplace spirit
 
Power in the workplace; alternative to the iron fist 15 30 min presentation.
Power in the workplace; alternative to the iron fist 15 30 min presentation.Power in the workplace; alternative to the iron fist 15 30 min presentation.
Power in the workplace; alternative to the iron fist 15 30 min presentation.
 
Transformation theory
Transformation theoryTransformation theory
Transformation theory
 

Similar a The empowering element of leading - CICAM fall 2010

PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts                  PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
dannies7qbuggie
 
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bankA comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
shweta mukherjee
 
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership EssayOrganizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
Jessica Finson
 
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
 +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
Dr. Paul A. Rodriguez
 
An Analysis of Leadership
An Analysis of LeadershipAn Analysis of Leadership
An Analysis of Leadership
Joel M. Schrap
 
Bm 09 organizational_culture
Bm 09 organizational_cultureBm 09 organizational_culture
Bm 09 organizational_culture
Diana Diana
 
Sustaining culture change
Sustaining culture changeSustaining culture change
Sustaining culture change
Hay Group India
 
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
asfawm
 
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
asfawm
 
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docxRunning head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
jeanettehully
 
051016 Transformative Learning
051016 Transformative Learning051016 Transformative Learning
051016 Transformative Learning
Jayson Krause
 

Similar a The empowering element of leading - CICAM fall 2010 (19)

Organizational culture
Organizational cultureOrganizational culture
Organizational culture
 
PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts                  PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
PHI 2604 – Critical ThinkingEthics Handouts
 
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bankA comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
A comperative study of organizational culture of sbi, icici, hdfc bank
 
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership EssayOrganizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
Organizational Leadership Versus Tactical Leadership Essay
 
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
 +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
 
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
 +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy +Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
+Unm paper mentoring future leaders copy
 
An Analysis of Leadership
An Analysis of LeadershipAn Analysis of Leadership
An Analysis of Leadership
 
Sargado, Jenny (Management 1)
Sargado, Jenny (Management 1)Sargado, Jenny (Management 1)
Sargado, Jenny (Management 1)
 
Bm 09 organizational_culture
Bm 09 organizational_cultureBm 09 organizational_culture
Bm 09 organizational_culture
 
Notes on Organisation behavior (Introduction Of Organisation Behavior for BBA...
Notes on Organisation behavior (Introduction Of Organisation Behavior for BBA...Notes on Organisation behavior (Introduction Of Organisation Behavior for BBA...
Notes on Organisation behavior (Introduction Of Organisation Behavior for BBA...
 
Unm paper mentoring future leaders
 Unm paper mentoring future leaders Unm paper mentoring future leaders
Unm paper mentoring future leaders
 
Chapter 9: Social Behavior and Good Governance
Chapter 9: Social Behavior and Good GovernanceChapter 9: Social Behavior and Good Governance
Chapter 9: Social Behavior and Good Governance
 
Sustaining culture change
Sustaining culture changeSustaining culture change
Sustaining culture change
 
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour NotesMBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
 
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
 
A Study on Impact of Organization Culture on Employee Behaviour with Special ...
A Study on Impact of Organization Culture on Employee Behaviour with Special ...A Study on Impact of Organization Culture on Employee Behaviour with Special ...
A Study on Impact of Organization Culture on Employee Behaviour with Special ...
 
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
3 c organizational behavior, development, culture paper final
 
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docxRunning head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
Running head ORGANIZATIONAL FOUNDATIONS1ORGANIZATIONAL F.docx
 
051016 Transformative Learning
051016 Transformative Learning051016 Transformative Learning
051016 Transformative Learning
 

The empowering element of leading - CICAM fall 2010

  • 1. Impactful Leadership – The Focus on Money and Meaning Rakesh Khurana, Professor of Leadership Development at Harvard Business School, and fellow professor Joel Podolny have stated that, because most contemporary organizational researchers talk about leadership only in terms of its impact on economic performance rather than its ability to give the organization a sense of purpose, something crucial has been lost. This focus on economic results, they say, gives a one-sided picture of what leaders are actually able to accomplish. The effectiveness of organizational leadership should also explore their ability to forge new or renewed meaning and purpose for the organization and its employees. There’s no hidden inference here that a leader should take their focus away from bottom-line results (either profit orientated in the private sector or delivering services on time and on budget in the public and not-for-profit sectors). What is being suggested is this: if leaders don’t take the time to intentionally create an understanding of the meaningful purpose of the organization (beyond the monetary elements stated above) they miss out on the enormous potential of such a focus. Values and meaning For most of us, after our basic needs are satisfied, there are a couple of others, which lend themselves to our sense of leading a meaningful life. These are our need to feel both valued and valuable.
  • 2. In organizational terms how these needs begin to be met is by us experiencing alignment between our own values and ideals and those of the organization. That is, we understand how our work is contributing to the goals and ideals we value. The second way these needs begin to be met is through the quality of social interaction we have with others who share in the organization’s vision, goals and rewards. Therefore, another essential element of leadership, in addition to the bottom-line focus, is to create an organizational context where individuals feel creatively empowered through connection with what’s meaningful to them. A context where organizational culture, processes and systems enable its members to behave in a way that actively supports not only ownership of the organization’s vision but creates an authentic sense of responsibility in making that vision a reality. Great picture, but how does a leader create a perceptual framework, which allows them to begin to create such an organizational context? Well let’s fuel this picture with another. Individual Values and Beliefs •Personal Values •Leadership Style •Individual Drivers and Worldviews •Skills and Knowledge Individual Actions and Behaviours • Personal Behaviours •Leadership Behaviours •Organisational Role (Authority) •Modes of Decision-Making Group Values and Beliefs •Group Culture • Shared Vision • Organisational Values • Organisational Beliefs • Group Drivers & Worldview Group Actions and Behaviours •Strategies •Policies •Processes •Systems •Performance Measures •The Brand Values Behaviours Collective Individual Structural Alignment Vision & Values Alignment Mission Alignment Personal Alignment Sustainability Source: Ruth Garrett 2010 This diagram is based on the work of author and researcher Ken Wilber who argues that values and beliefs are the hidden drivers of human behaviour.
  • 3. In Wilber’s four quadrant model of the human system we see how individual (upper left quadrant) and organizational beliefs and values (lower left quadrant) drive individual (upper right quadrant) and organizational behaviour (lower right quadrant). It’s only through aligning all the facets of the human system that individual empowerment and flexible and fluid sustainable growth takes place. • To have personal alignment there must be alignment between personal values (upper left quadrant) and personal behaviours (upper right quadrant). • To have the effective execution of organizational vision and values there must be alignment of personal (upper left quadrant) and organizational cultural vision and values (lower left quadrant). • To have alignment of how the vision of the organization is carried out, i.e. the mission, there must be congruence between the behaviours of the individual (upper right quadrant) and the systemic behaviour of the organization (lower right quadrant). • To have structural congruence there must be an alignment of the espoused cultural values of the organization(lower left quadrant) and the strategic policies, procedures and systems (lower right quadrant). Underpinning this alignment there is a need for a leader to be willing to: 1. Maintain organizational values even when there is some perceived economic cost to doing so. As Khurana and Podolny point out if espoused organizational values are violated when there’s a perceived benefit, it will erode organizational culture through suspicion, derision and cynicism. 2. Ensure (through design and blended learning) that the individuals within the organization get a clear sense of the fit between what they do and who they believe themselves to be 3. Commitment of their time and organizational resources to ensuring that each member of the organizations understands how what they do links to the purpose of the organization. 4. Ensures that recruitment and retention policies are congruent with hiring individuals who will gain personal meaning from organizational values and purpose. Bibliography Khurana R., Podolny J., Legace M. (2005), How to Put Meaning Back into Leading, http://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/4563.html accessed October 2010
  • 4. Ruth Garrett MSc. PhD For the past 20 years, Ruth has been a facilitator, coach and mentor of individual and organizational transition and change. She works with a wide range of organizational clients in the corporate, retail, manufacturing, public and education sectors assisting them in realizing their highest levels of growth. Ruth also works with a variety of individual clients assisting them in getting from where they are to where they want to be. Contact details: Web: www.manifestingyourabundance.com www.integralcoachingandmediation.com Email: ruth@manifestingyourabundance.com integralcoaching@sympatico.ca Cell: 705-441-6581