1. BIOMETRIC FUTURES
By Edward D. Campbell, JD
This is taken from a paper originally developed for Amida Biometrics, L.L.C.,
in 2002, by Edward D. Campbell, and edited for use on the IBMBS web site in
September, 2003.
BIOMETRICS FUTURE & PROFIT
The International Behavioral and Medical Biometrics Society, exists to foster the
development of talent and foresight, to explore and understand the entire field of character and
medical diagnostics and human resource valuations through the skillful use of the computer data
processing and biometric scanning and observing comparative biological markers and behavioral
patterns and health conditions, for use in daily living, private industry, civil service, education, law
enforcement, military, medicine and psychology, throughout all aspects of human life. This paper
outlines some of the field, the potentials and the goals, including more immediate goals and hints
at the products that can be produced over the coming years.
Biometrics, A Definition:
The terms "Biometrics" and "Biometry" have been used since early in the 20th century to
refer to the field of development of statistical and mathematical methods applicable to data analysis
of problems in the biological sciences. Statistical methods for the analysis of data from agricultural
field experiments to compare the yields of different varieties of wheat, for the analysis of data from
human clinical trials evaluating the relative effectiveness of competing therapies for disease, or for
the analysis of data from environmental studies on the effects of air or water pollution on the
appearance of human disease in a region or country are all examples of problems that would fall
under the umbrella of "Biometrics" as the term has been historically used. More recently the terms
have been used to refer to identification technologies.1
Currently the principal use of the hardware and software dedicated to human biometrics is
for identification purposes. This requires recording in some fashion an image of the subject that can
later be utilized as a template to identify another image of the same part of that subject. It depends
upon a digital form of matching. In the future, behavioral and medical diagnostics will utilize much
the same type of equipment and pattern recognition and matching.
IBMBS TECHNOLOGICAL DIRECTIONS
IBMBS would like to see the expansion of the current identification technology to
recognize basic patterns that may be identified with certain character evaluations and/or medical
diagnoses. We believe that this will have immediate and potentially wide scale application in health
1
Biometrics Journal http://stat.tamu.edu/Biometrics/
2. care delivery and human resource assessment intelligence contractor who reports that at least one
applications from career and educational planning to of the agencies tried to do what we propose in either
medical diagnostics, job placement and labor skills the 80's or perhaps early 90's but was not successful
auditing. For example many of us believe that with its attempt. At that time, the state of the art as
applications could, develop home m odules and be as published in the west depended upon an
comm on as the current use of PCs for delivery of incompatible approach to character analysis, failing
health care and hum an services significantly to take into account the other observers who had
improving the future delivery systems, effectiveness more than a couple of thousand years of observations
and profit potentials of HMO’s health insurance, to their credit and w ho knew from this long
pharmaceuticals, and reducing the costly risks of experience certain basic information that could be
mistakes that now plague the industry. Others see derived from the observed human anatomy, and
the vast use in career development both in where this information could be found [hand analysts
educational curric ulu m planning and job - serious palmists].
placements, while still others can see the potential
use of this in governm ent, military and in profiling in How ever, scientists, working in the field
this age where security is of such importance. known as dermatoglyphics, had opened the door to
more scientific and comm ercial use of the
Fortunately, we do not have to reinvent the information, through their repeated findings of
wheel. Much of the information to implement these correspondences between the observed skin patterns
applications is already available, even if not well and the human condition. Those of us familiar with
known. New processing programs are required to both approaches have found many more. A couple
fully integrate and test this data already available and of the author’s experiences may help explain.
easily accessible.
Some years ago Gloria came to see me.
Your author has Gloria had a very interesting middle finger. She had
been studying, developing been born with no pattern (Figure 24) on her middle,
a n d w orkin g w ith, the number 3 finger. In a subsequent examination, I
speaking and w riting mentioned to her com panion, a chiropractor, that in
about parts of these palmistry this finger was know n as the balance or
protocols for close to judgment finger. Gloria was notorious for being
twenty years. In late 1998 flighty, not knowing from day to day even where in
or early1999 he was asked the country she would be. The Chiropractor replied
by an intelligence agency that my observation about balance was interesting,
contractor if he would be because every time Gloria shut her eyes, she lost her
interested in developing a balance. The eyes, the inner ears and the
program for one of the proprioceptors control balance. His observation was
services w i t h h is a clear indication to me that there this no print
know ledge in the area, as the major problem was not developed by the 16 th week of gestation was a very
with the very good equipment we possessed, but in probable indication of some abnormality in the base
choosing the hum an teams that use it. While that did of the brain w here the proprioceptor information is
not proceed swiftly in a budget tight time during the processed, because that area of the brain was being
Clinton administration, it is a use that perhaps the developed during the period that the print was
Russians have subsequently considered.2 developing. Prints are influenced by both
environment and genetics.
We have also spoken with another
The next interesting print was seen on two
persons, and involved distortions to the thumb print.
2 The first was on a lady who was accom panied by her
See Appendix II, Selecting Military
husband. The nail phalange of the thumb is related
Specialists
-1-
5. diagnosed as liver cancer that had metastasised from Current Uses. Finger scans can accomplish
the bowel. The sclera is the white area of the eye. for use in identification in two to three seconds.
Of course the pupil is that dark spot in the middle They are used in forensics, security and even at
that we look through and its shape and size, with home uses such as to lock ones computer.
total or partial deformations may be observed as a Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems
sign of many things, including impending Cerebral (AFIS) are used throughout the country and
hemorrhages or clotting that could be accompanied Lockheed Martin recently completed a one hundred
by coma or paralysis. These are all capable of million dollar contract for the FBI to install and
biometric analysis. implement this program for its vast records.
III. RETINA SCANNING Methods and Accuracy of Finger
Scanning. Three methods of scanning are currently
This technology has been around since the used, silicon plates, optical and ultrasound. The
1930 and is still one of the ultrasound may be the most accurate as it reads
most accurate around, through the dirt and grime. The silicon plate is very
depending on the scanning cost effective and can be incorporated into small-
retinal patterns through scale devices. It depends on identification of the
the pupil by a viewer patterns from the the DC current passing between
placed about ½ inch from the finger and the silicon capacitor plate. Optical is
the eye. The eye follows a the oldest method.
green light that illuminates
the inside of the eye to One aspect of finger scanning has long been
reveal the unique pattern used in medicine. That is the observation of
blood vessels. fingernails. Using the fingernails for medical
diagnostics is found in basic Physical Examination
Uses. Retina handbooks. See Appendix II, Nail Diagnosis.
scans have historically be used for high end security
applications. They benefit from having the smallest V. HAND SCANNING
of the templates used in biometrics. They may be
more easily disturbed by eye damage that iris A typical hand scan is produced by a digital
scanning. camera taking a 100 digital measurements of the size
and proportions of the hand and converting them into
IV. FINGER SCANNING a template Typically it reads the top and sides,
identifying shapes, sizes and internal measurements.
Finger Scanning as understood by In health technologies the scan w ould go beyond this
identification technologists and fingerprinting need not only to identify these features, but also the
to be distinguished. The scanning equipm ent is still complete palmar surface, details of the fingernails,
required to take an image of the entire fingerprint, and add in the fingerprints. So health uses would
but the full print is not stored. Only certain key data require some expansion of the current scanning
from the print is stored that is sufficient to match it modalities.
to a later acquired image of the print, or partial print.
From an original scan identified features are Part of hand scanning involves comparisons
converted to a digital template and stored for later of finger lengths. It has long been suspected by hand
use through mates by the computer softw are. This analysts that when the ring finger exceeds the length
differs from the need of the Health Technologists of the index finger that reaches a normal length, it is
who would require the storing for comparison
complete patterns for reference w ith pattern types for
diagnostic purposes.
-4-
9. developing auditable values of these resources using through the use of the speed gained through
the knowledge gained through the study of biometric scanning and computer analysis and is not
behavioral and m edical biometrics. In this era of dependent on the language of the em ployee, so it is
globalization it will add human resources as a very applicable to persons of all nationalities. CEO’s
tangible part of the balance sheet of any enterprise. familiar with the general human resource needs of
their enterprises, could experience great relief from
GROSS REVENUES being at the mercy of their manager’s families,
friends and cronies in who is hired, fired and
The total gross revenue from Biometric promoted.
Disciplines, without the input of Behavioral and
Medical Biometrics, are expected to grow from $399 INTERESTED IN FURTHER
million in 2000 to $1.9 billion by 2005. 18 We INFORMATION?
estimate that current technologies cover less than
.5% of potential applications for biometrics over the Contact Ed C ampbell, 206 783 3410, or
next ten to fifteen years, and most of the growth will www.edcampbell.com, or write to Ed Campbell,
not be in identification but in analysis of the subjects 9534 14 th Avenue NW,
scanned. Seattle, WA 98117-2308
or send an inquiry through
THE LABOR - HR MARKET this web site. See
Appendix II for further
This discussion does not include any detailed reference to scientific
analysis of the potential markets for behavioral and journals and literature on
medical Biometrics products and services in these subjects. R eturn to
medicine, education, defense, law enforcement, civil original w eb site
service and government, all of which are large, and ww w.ibmbs.org.
some of which will dwarf the human resource
markets.
Business HR M arket: In the United States
there are almost 600,000 firms employing over APPENDIX I – NAIL DIAGNOSIS
twenty people and together they employ over 80% of
the private w orkforce, approximately 90 million TAKING A CLOSER LOOK
people.19 Behavioral Biometrics could offer the
only way verifiable way for CEO ’s, plant and AT YOUR NAILS
division managers and head hunters to evaluate and
track any detailed comparable analysis of the values Changes in toenails and fingernails may indicate
of the aptitudes, character and potential reliability of specific types of illnesses. Following are some of
these employees to his or her business, as the more com mon nail problems and what they
individuals, team members and in the aggregate. could mean:
Such a survey, breakdown and individual evaluation,
Nail bending - Rheumatoid arthritis.
Brittle nails - Vitamin A, calcium or iron
deficiency, thyroid problems, impaired
18 kidney function or circulation problems.
Revenues:
http://www.finger-scan.com/finger-scan_mark Clubbed purple nails (rise upward and
et_report.htm curl around the fingertip) - Lung, liver,
colon or heart disorders.
19 Deep blue nails - Pulmonary obstruction
such as asthma or emphysema.
http://www.bizstats.com/businesses.htm
i
11. Relationship between genetic anomalies of VS, Khalfina M E: Kardiologiia 1993
different levels and deviations in 33:43-5
dermatoglyphic traits. Part 7:
Dermatoglyphic peculiarities of females Deaf-Mutism, Congenital
with cervical and endometrial carcinoma. Characteristics of the D ermatoglyphics of
Bejerano M , Yakovenko K, Katznelson the hand in Congenital Deaf-mutism
MB, et al.: Z Morphol Anthropol Gagaeva, LF: Tsitol Genet, 1977 Mar-
(Germany), 2001, 83(1) p75-108 Apr 11:109-13
Cerebral Palsy Diabetes
Quantitative Analysis of Digitopalmar Palmar Flexion Creases and
Dermatoglyphics in M ale Children with Dermatoglyphics Among Diabetic Patients
Central Nervous System Lesion by Eswaraiah G, Ball, RS: Am J Phys
Quantification of Clinical Parameters of Anthropology 1977 Jul 47:11-3
Locomotor Disorder Cyjeticanin M,
Polovina A, Acta Med Croatica 1999, DOOR Syndrome
53:5-10 DOO R Syndrome: Aditional Case and
Literature Review
Childhood (prepubescent) Behavioral Patterns Bos CJ, Ippel PF, Beemer FA: Clin
Prepubescent children show the adult Dysmorphol 1994 Jan 3:15-20
relationship betw een dermatoglyphic
asymmetry and perform ance on sexually Down’s Syndrome
dimorphic tasks. Dermatoglyphics in Down’s Syndrome
Sanders G, Kadam A: Cortex (Italy), Feb Rajangram S, Janakiram S., Thomas IM:
2001, 37(1) p91-100 J Indian Med Assoc 1995 Jan; 93:10-3
Chromosome Aberrations Dy slexia
Screening for Autosomal Aberrations Palmar Dermatoglyphics of Dyslexia
Hqurashi M, Segewa M, Matsui I, Ihbuma Jamison C S: Am J Phys Anthropol 1988
K, Nakagome Y, Acta Peadiatr Scand Aug 76:505-13
1977 Jul 66:501-4
Epileptic Disorders
Congenital Defects The Mechanisms of the Occurrence and
Dermatoglyphics in Cleft Lip and Cleft Development of the Epileptic Range of
Palate Anomalies Disorders
Nalgir RS, Indian P ediatr 1993 Mar Bogdanov NN, Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im S S
30:341-6 Korsakova, 1999; 99:37-47
Fluctuating Asymmetry and vertebral Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
Malformation. A Study of Palmar Dermatoglyphic Abnormalities in the Fetal
Dermatoglyphics in Congenital Spinal Alcohol Syndrome
Deformities Quzi QH, Masakawa A, McGann B,
Glodberg CJ, Fogarty EE, Moore DP, Woods J: Teratology 1980 Apr;
Dowling FE, Spine 1997, Apr 22:775-9 21(2):157-60
Coronary Heart Disease Dermatoglyphic Asymmetry in Fetal
Genetic Markers of susceptibility to Alcohol Syndrome
Myocardial Infarct Wilber E, New ell-Morris L, Streissguth
Polzkk E V, Sidorovich SB, Kazantwev AP: Biol Neonate 1993;64(1):1-6
iii
12. Fetal Developmental Instabilities Tuberk 1993 :33-5
Dermatoglyphic Morphology in Some Diseases
Lopuszanska M , Jankowska E: Pol Klinefelter’s and Turner’s Syndromes
Merkuriusz Lek (Poland), Sep 2001, A study of Dermatoglyphics in Gonadal
11(63) p282-6 Dysgenesis: A Com puterised Analysis
Applicable in Under-developed C ountries
Hypertension Richards, B, Mandasescu S: Stud Health
Palmar Dermatoglyphics in Essential Technol Inform 1997 43 Pt A:290-4
Hypertension
Pursnani ML, Elhence GP, Tibrewaia L: Leprosy
Indian Heart J 1989 Mar-Apr 41:119-22 Palmar Flexion Creases and
Dermatoglyphics in Leprosy Patients
Relation of Fingerprints and Shape of the Eswaraiah G, Ball, RS: Int J Lepr Other
Palm to Fetal Growth and A dult Blood Mycobact D is 1978 Jan-Mar 46:56-60
Pressure
Godfrey KM, Barker DJ, Peace J, Cloke J, Male Infertility
Osmond C: BMJ 1993 Aug 14; Study of Finger and Palmar
307(6901):405-9 Dermatoglyphics in Primary Infertile Males
Makol N, Kshatriva G, Basu S:
Caveat On the Association Between Anthropol Anz 1994 Mar 52:59-65
Adult Blood Pressure and
Dermatoglyphics as Prenatal Markers of Parental Dermatoglyphics relative to
Development (WW II twins: pairs and co- Congenitally Malformed Children
twins) Dermatoglyphics of the Relatives of
Reed, T, J. Hypertension 1995 Jun; Children with Congenital Defects in Development
13(6):595-601 Usoev, SS: Genetika 1975 11:151-5
Disproportionate Fetal Growth and Personality Clasification
fingerprint Patterns Medical Anthropological Aspects of Hand
Wheeler T, Godfrey K, Atkinson C, Phalanx Dermatoglyphics
Badger J, Kay R, Ownes R, Osmond C, Zviagin VN: Shpak Liu: Sud M ed Ekspert
Br. J: Obstet Gybaecol 1998 May; 2000 Jul-Aug 43:16-20
105(5):562-4
Psychotic Disorders
Idiopathic Intellectual Disability Congenital Dermatoglyphic Malformations
Dermatoglyphics and Abnormal Palmar and Psychosis: a Twin Study
Flexion Creases as Markers of Early Rosa A, Fañanás L, Bracha HS, Torrey
Prenatal Stress in Children with Idiopathic EF, van Os J: Am J Psychiatry 2000,
Intellectual Idiopathic Intellectual Sept; 157:1511-3
Disability
Rosa A, Gutiérrez B, Guerra A, Arias B, Respiratory H ypersensitivity
Fañanás L, J Intellect Disabil Res 2001 Dermatoglyphics in Nasobronchial
Oct 45:416-23 Allergic Disorders
Joshi P, chavan V D, Mulev PY: Indian J.
Imunology Chest Dis Allied Sci 1992 Oct-Dec 34:185-90
Correlation of Dermatoglyphic and
Cellular Immunity parameters in Children Rheumatic Diseases
with Early Stage of Primary Tuberculosis Dermatoglyphics in Patients with
Khodzitskaia V K, Zosim ov A N: Probl Rheum atism
iv
13. Belov BS, Miakotkin VA: Ter Arkh 1988 Cannon M, Byrne M, Cotter D, Sham P,
60:101-4 Larkin C, O ’Callaghan E, Schizophr Res
1994 Sept; 13(2):179-84
Selecting M ilitary Specialists
Prospects for Using Dermatoglyphics for Preliminary Evidence for an Association
Evaluating the Mental Status of Service Between Minor Physical Anomalies and
Members Second Trimester Neurodevelopment in
Kolkutin W, Krymova TG: Voen Med Zh Schizophrenia
(Russia) 2001 Nov 322:9-12, 96 Green MF, Bracha HS, Satz P, Christenson
CD, Psychiatry Res 1994 Aug; 53(2):119-
Sex Offenders 27
Dermatoglyphics in Individuals with
Asocial Behavior Caveat Derm atoglyphic Patterns in
Gustavson, KH, M odrzewska K, Sjöquist Schizophrenic Patients
KE: Ups J Med Sci 1994 99:63-7 Varma SL, Chary TV, Singh S, Azhar MZ,
Dharap A S: Acta Psychiatr Scand 1995
Sexual Orientation Mar; 91(3):213-5
Dermatoglyphics, Handedness, Sex, and
Sexual Orientation. Prenatal Development of Monozygotic
Mustanski BS, Bailey JM, Kaspar S: Arch Twins and Concordance for Schizophrenia
Sex Behav (United States), Feb 2002, 31(1) Davis JO, Phelps JA , Bracha H S:
p113-22 Schizophr Bull 1995; 21(3):357-66 for
Erratum see Schizophr Bull
Schizophrenia 1995;21(4):559
Palmar Dermatoglyphics of Schizophrenic
Patients Dermatoglyphic A-b Ridge Count as a
Zh Nevropatol Psikhiatr Im S S Korsakova Possible Marker for Developmental
1975 75:891-7 Disturbance in Schizophrenia: Replication
in Two Samples
Dermatoglyphic Evidence of Fluctuating Fañanás L, van Os J, Hoyos C, McGrath J,
Asymmetry in Schizophrenia Mellor CS, Murray R, Schizophr Res 1996
Mellor CS, Br J Psychiatry 1992 Apr; Kul 5; 20:(3):307-14
160:467-72
Prenatal Grow th Markers in
Second-Trimester Markers of Fetal Size In Schizophrenia: a Monozygotic Co-Twin Control
Schizophrenia: A Study Study
Bracha HS, Torrey EF, Gottesman II, Davis JO , Bracha HS, Am J. Psychiatry
Biglow LB, Cunniff C: Am J Psychiatry 1996 Sept; 153(9):1166-72
1992 Oct 149:1355-61
Minor Physical Anomalies and Their
Genetic Loadings in Schizophrenia: A Relationship to the Aetiology of
Dermatoglyphic Study Schizophrenia.
Balgir RS, Murphy RS, Wig N N: Isr J Murphy KC , Owen MJ: Br J Psychiatry
Med Sci 1993 May 29:265-8 1996, 168: 139–142.
Further Evidence for Anomalies in the Schizophrenia: A disorder of
Hand-prints of Patients with Neurodevelopment?
Schizophrenia; a Study of Secondary Commentary, Harrison, PJ: Current
Creases Opinion in Neurobiology 1997, 7:285-289
v