SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 36
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Luigi Curini - @Curini
VOICES from the Blogs & University of Milan
#Spoletta @ Mashable Social Media Day 30-Jun-2015
Separating the wheat from the
chaff: Signal, Noise & Other
stories in the Big (Data) World
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
They are:

๏ Big (in volume)

๏ Many (per unit of time)

๏ Unstructured (messy, not ready to be processed)
Big (or organic) data
Sources:

๏ Administrative repositories

๏ Transaction data

๏ Social media & Social Network
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Can we really ignore this?
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Do they work at all?
The blue side of Big data
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Big data
“believers”
Wired Magazine (2008): “The End of Theory:
The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method
Obsolete”.
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Big data
“detractors”
Financial Times (2014): “Big Data: Are We
Making a Big Mistake?”
?
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Time (2014):
“Google’s Flu Project
Shows the Failing of
Big Data”
Big Data: the Big Fail?
Testo
S&P500, butter production in
Bangladesh and causality
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Believer or Detractor?
“BIG Data” are today’s “data”
answer:
“there are Big Data & small data scientists”
change the data scientist, not the data!
a good advise:
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Testo
Believer or Detractor?
Data Scientist is the answer!
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Let us focus

on big data

coming from

Social Media
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
geo-localized data
retrospective analysis (capture opinions when they are
expressed)
real-time analysis (continuous monitoring and/or alerting)
speed of data analysis (if you know how to do it)
gathering of unsolicited opinions
census-type analysis: analyze the entire population of
texts not just a sample
population on social media not necessarily
representative of demographic population
can’t ask questions, just listen to people: if people
don’t discuss about a topic you don’t have the data
textual analysis, language evolves continuously
and changes according to topic, media, etc.
pros
cons
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Three
simple
ideas
“Romance should never begin with sentiment.
It should begin with science
and end with a settlement.”
Oscar Wilde, An Ideal Husband
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
NO: Mentions, Likes or Retweet. Computers
are good at this, but humans can do better!
How to analyze Social Media data (1)
Obama 16.8M of followers
Romney 0.6M of followers
Final result: Obama +4.0% !
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
NO: ontological dictionaries, nor NLP rules
How to analyze Social Media data (2)
Testo
“This movie has good premises. Looks like it has a nice plot, an
exceptional cast, first class actors and Stallone gives his best. But it
sucks”
"Ibis redibis numquam peribis in bello", can be translated as “will go,
will come back, will not die in war", but also the opposite way, “will
go, will not come back, will die in war"
“ragazza stufa scappa di casa… i genitori muoiono di freddo”
“There is no favorable wind for the mariner who doesn’t know where to go” (Seneca)
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
NO: ontological dictionaries, nor NLP rules
How to analyze Social Media data (2)
Look at the data
Look into the data
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Switch to Supervised Techiniques!
The advantages of human beings…
• Always in sync with linguistic expressions
[dictionaries are static]
• Completely language-independent
• Moreover….
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Beyond sentiment…
there is more information out there!!!
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Opinions, reasons, attitudes, tones…
see the colours!
NO: individual classification and later
aggregation. Estimate directly the aggregated
distribution of opinions!
How to analyze Social Media data (3)
We don’t care about the needle in the haystack...
...we care about the haystack! (G. King)
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
The iSA® innovation
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
What people
don’t say if asked
but discuss on
social media!
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
about 2.5M arab texts
July-October 2014
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Charlie Hebdo effect?
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Short Memory Effect!
Positive
support
October 2014 7 & 8 January Next week
World 21,2% 18,1% 21,9%
Europe 21,9% 17,5% 20%
France 20,8% 3% 17%
See the large picture:
the Moncler case study
www.voicesfromtheblogs.com | we capture the sentiment of the net
Monday Nov. 3rd 2014. The day after the TV Show
Report sent on air a negative reportage on the
Moncler company. Mentions online (among Twitter,
Facebook, Instagram, blog, forum and other social
channels) for the brand raised of about 450%
compared to the average level.
That peak corresponded to a 22% fall in social brand
reputation in just 24 hours (from a positive
sentiment of 75% to a negative of 53%, and 43% on
Twitter alone).
The assets on the stock exchange felt as well by 5%.
Was this due to the
Social Media?
www.voicesfromtheblogs.com | we capture the sentiment of the net
Obviously not,
the negative
trend was totally
predictable and
independent of
the SM sentiment
See the large picture:
the Moncler case study
MIXING OFFICIAL
STATISTICS AND SOCIAL
MEDIA DATA:

!
NOWCASTING
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Wired Next Index
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Official Statistics: “cold data”, backward
looking, low frequency, slow (GDP, import/
export, n. companies, labour force statistics,
ecc)	

!
Surveys: “cold data”, slow, forward looking
(e.g. consumer or entrepreneur expectations’,
ecc)	

!
SM Sentiment: “hot data”, nowcasting,
forward looking
INDEX.WIRED.IT
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
self-!
expectation!
(VOICES)
consumers!
expectation!
(Istat)
entrepreneurs!
expectation!
(Istat)
expectation!
in the country!
(VOICES)
-15 days
-10 days
-18 days
Period: 1 January - 31 March 2014
Cold!
indicators
Hot!
indicators
nowcasting !
=!
anticipation
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Wired Next Index vs. MIB Index!
 VOICES from the Blogs born in October 2010 as a scientific
project to capture opinions expressed on the Web (social
media, blogs, forums, web)
 On 12/12/12 VOICES became a Spin-off of the University of
Milan – Italy; and started operations as an independent
company
 Up to January 2015 VOICES has analyzed more than half
billion of posts written in Italian, English, French, Spanish,
German, Russian, Arabic, Portuguese, Chinese and
Japanese
 In December 2014 VOICES is among the winners of the
contest “Produrre Statistica ufficiale con i Big Data”
promoted by &
About us
www.voicesfromtheblogs.com | we look into the data, not at the data
 Since March 2015 SWG has become a
partner of VOICES
 Thanks to this partnership, the first
integrated group in data science and
business intelligence has born in Italy
About us
www.voicesfromtheblogs.com | we look into the data, not at the data
But remember…
Big Data is likely to contribute so long
as the desired qualities of the data ar
not negatively correlated with the
quantity of data
In a nutshell…
Method DO MATTER!
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
Thx !
For more information, analyses and
white papers about the project visit us at
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com
On Twitter: @blogsvoices
http://voicesfromtheblogs.com

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Gov 2 0 Transparency Collaboration And Participation In Practice Presentation
Gov 2 0  Transparency  Collaboration  And Participation In Practice PresentationGov 2 0  Transparency  Collaboration  And Participation In Practice Presentation
Gov 2 0 Transparency Collaboration And Participation In Practice Presentation
railsconf
 
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mindSharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
Chris Johnson
 
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and TechnologyGeneration 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
kramsey
 

La actualidad más candente (8)

Yammer time
Yammer timeYammer time
Yammer time
 
YaleDHI FtM Talk
YaleDHI FtM TalkYaleDHI FtM Talk
YaleDHI FtM Talk
 
Networked: The New Social Operating System in Civic Life
Networked: The New Social Operating System in Civic LifeNetworked: The New Social Operating System in Civic Life
Networked: The New Social Operating System in Civic Life
 
Gov 2 0 Transparency Collaboration And Participation In Practice Presentation
Gov 2 0  Transparency  Collaboration  And Participation In Practice PresentationGov 2 0  Transparency  Collaboration  And Participation In Practice Presentation
Gov 2 0 Transparency Collaboration And Participation In Practice Presentation
 
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mindSharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
SharePoint Saturday Redmond - Building solutions with the future in mind
 
Break Through with Data: How to Drive Your Nonprofit's Mission Forward by Bui...
Break Through with Data: How to Drive Your Nonprofit's Mission Forward by Bui...Break Through with Data: How to Drive Your Nonprofit's Mission Forward by Bui...
Break Through with Data: How to Drive Your Nonprofit's Mission Forward by Bui...
 
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and TechnologyGeneration 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
Generation 4.0: Working at the Intersection of People and Technology
 
Big data is not just about the data
Big data is not just about the dataBig data is not just about the data
Big data is not just about the data
 

Destacado

Homenaje a santa rosa de lima
Homenaje a santa rosa de limaHomenaje a santa rosa de lima
Homenaje a santa rosa de lima
Carolina Colan
 
57ea49327729
57ea4932772957ea49327729
57ea49327729
ssharec
 
Apresentação completa vivo en cena
Apresentação completa   vivo en cenaApresentação completa   vivo en cena
Apresentação completa vivo en cena
vivoencena
 
MEF Orientation Presentation
MEF Orientation PresentationMEF Orientation Presentation
MEF Orientation Presentation
Jennifer Chang
 
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
William Wright
 

Destacado (20)

Cash Flow 2013
Cash Flow 2013Cash Flow 2013
Cash Flow 2013
 
Lesson one-basic super mario
Lesson one-basic super marioLesson one-basic super mario
Lesson one-basic super mario
 
Câu đố
Câu đốCâu đố
Câu đố
 
Trabalho escolar biblioteca_2_0
Trabalho escolar biblioteca_2_0Trabalho escolar biblioteca_2_0
Trabalho escolar biblioteca_2_0
 
Nepse Technical Analysis July 05 - July 09, 2015
Nepse Technical Analysis July 05 - July 09, 2015Nepse Technical Analysis July 05 - July 09, 2015
Nepse Technical Analysis July 05 - July 09, 2015
 
CV 2014
CV 2014CV 2014
CV 2014
 
Diploma
DiplomaDiploma
Diploma
 
Homenaje a santa rosa de lima
Homenaje a santa rosa de limaHomenaje a santa rosa de lima
Homenaje a santa rosa de lima
 
Elegance
EleganceElegance
Elegance
 
57ea49327729
57ea4932772957ea49327729
57ea49327729
 
Apresentação completa vivo en cena
Apresentação completa   vivo en cenaApresentação completa   vivo en cena
Apresentação completa vivo en cena
 
Lailathulqadar
Lailathulqadar Lailathulqadar
Lailathulqadar
 
Documentação de uma linguagem de progração
Documentação de uma linguagem de prograçãoDocumentação de uma linguagem de progração
Documentação de uma linguagem de progração
 
MEF Orientation Presentation
MEF Orientation PresentationMEF Orientation Presentation
MEF Orientation Presentation
 
Redes Sociais - PDF
Redes Sociais - PDFRedes Sociais - PDF
Redes Sociais - PDF
 
Jacaré cup
Jacaré cupJacaré cup
Jacaré cup
 
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
PsychSignal_IntroductoryAnalysis-2
 
Serv archiv abril 2010 segunda sesion
Serv archiv abril 2010 segunda sesionServ archiv abril 2010 segunda sesion
Serv archiv abril 2010 segunda sesion
 
Apresentaçãocurso
ApresentaçãocursoApresentaçãocurso
Apresentaçãocurso
 
Korea graphicskorea lgn-sys_anmujung_0728
Korea graphicskorea lgn-sys_anmujung_0728Korea graphicskorea lgn-sys_anmujung_0728
Korea graphicskorea lgn-sys_anmujung_0728
 

Similar a Distinguere grano e loglio segnali, rumore e altre storie in un big (data) world luigi curini

Digital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
Digital Day Presentation Social Media MonitoringDigital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
Digital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
propertynews.com
 

Similar a Distinguere grano e loglio segnali, rumore e altre storie in un big (data) world luigi curini (20)

Ai, social media and political polarization
Ai, social media and political polarizationAi, social media and political polarization
Ai, social media and political polarization
 
PRSA: Social Media - "Strategies instead of Tools"
PRSA: Social Media - "Strategies instead of Tools"PRSA: Social Media - "Strategies instead of Tools"
PRSA: Social Media - "Strategies instead of Tools"
 
Future Social Media Research
Future Social Media ResearchFuture Social Media Research
Future Social Media Research
 
Future Social Media Research
Future Social Media ResearchFuture Social Media Research
Future Social Media Research
 
What We Learned From Social Media
What We Learned From Social MediaWhat We Learned From Social Media
What We Learned From Social Media
 
The Next Wave: Emerging Trends in Nonprofit Social Media Marketing
The Next Wave: Emerging Trends in Nonprofit Social Media MarketingThe Next Wave: Emerging Trends in Nonprofit Social Media Marketing
The Next Wave: Emerging Trends in Nonprofit Social Media Marketing
 
Citizen Sensing: Opportunities and Challenges in Mining Social Signals and Pe...
Citizen Sensing: Opportunities and Challenges in Mining Social Signals and Pe...Citizen Sensing: Opportunities and Challenges in Mining Social Signals and Pe...
Citizen Sensing: Opportunities and Challenges in Mining Social Signals and Pe...
 
News 2 online and representation
News 2 online and representationNews 2 online and representation
News 2 online and representation
 
A changing media landscape
A changing media landscapeA changing media landscape
A changing media landscape
 
Кай Дикманн, издатель Bild. «Как мы преобразовали крупнейшую газету Европы в ...
Кай Дикманн, издатель Bild. «Как мы преобразовали крупнейшую газету Европы в ...Кай Дикманн, издатель Bild. «Как мы преобразовали крупнейшую газету Европы в ...
Кай Дикманн, издатель Bild. «Как мы преобразовали крупнейшую газету Европы в ...
 
The Web We Want: Dealing with the dark side of social media (work in progress)
The Web We Want: Dealing with the dark side of social media (work in progress)The Web We Want: Dealing with the dark side of social media (work in progress)
The Web We Want: Dealing with the dark side of social media (work in progress)
 
It's Not the Technology, Stupid: How the ‘Echo Chamber’ and ‘Filter Bubble’ M...
It's Not the Technology, Stupid: How the ‘Echo Chamber’ and ‘Filter Bubble’ M...It's Not the Technology, Stupid: How the ‘Echo Chamber’ and ‘Filter Bubble’ M...
It's Not the Technology, Stupid: How the ‘Echo Chamber’ and ‘Filter Bubble’ M...
 
Manichean Progress: Positive and Negative States of the Art in Web-Scale Data...
Manichean Progress: Positive and Negative States of the Art in Web-Scale Data...Manichean Progress: Positive and Negative States of the Art in Web-Scale Data...
Manichean Progress: Positive and Negative States of the Art in Web-Scale Data...
 
Data! Action! Data journalism issues to watch in the next 10 years
Data! Action! Data journalism issues to watch in the next 10 yearsData! Action! Data journalism issues to watch in the next 10 years
Data! Action! Data journalism issues to watch in the next 10 years
 
15 fines_in_social_media-lampathaki
15 fines_in_social_media-lampathaki15 fines_in_social_media-lampathaki
15 fines_in_social_media-lampathaki
 
Digital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
Digital Day Presentation Social Media MonitoringDigital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
Digital Day Presentation Social Media Monitoring
 
Future of the Web for Ayrshire Business Week
Future of the Web for Ayrshire Business WeekFuture of the Web for Ayrshire Business Week
Future of the Web for Ayrshire Business Week
 
The Mobile Consumer Age from SourceDigital13 (June 2013)
The Mobile Consumer Age from SourceDigital13 (June 2013)The Mobile Consumer Age from SourceDigital13 (June 2013)
The Mobile Consumer Age from SourceDigital13 (June 2013)
 
Everyone is "The Media," Especially Us!
Everyone is "The Media," Especially Us!Everyone is "The Media," Especially Us!
Everyone is "The Media," Especially Us!
 
"The Case for NewMR" by Ray Poynter
"The Case for NewMR" by Ray Poynter"The Case for NewMR" by Ray Poynter
"The Case for NewMR" by Ray Poynter
 

Más de SocialMediaDayMI

No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostroNo haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
SocialMediaDayMI
 
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
SocialMediaDayMI
 

Más de SocialMediaDayMI (20)

On line & off line marketing integrated marketing strategy mashable social me...
On line & off line marketing integrated marketing strategy mashable social me...On line & off line marketing integrated marketing strategy mashable social me...
On line & off line marketing integrated marketing strategy mashable social me...
 
Linked in analytics_profile_dashboard_leonardo bellini
Linked in analytics_profile_dashboard_leonardo belliniLinked in analytics_profile_dashboard_leonardo bellini
Linked in analytics_profile_dashboard_leonardo bellini
 
Il caso do lab school futura pagano
Il caso do lab school  futura paganoIl caso do lab school  futura pagano
Il caso do lab school futura pagano
 
Hootsuite enrico giubertoni matteo levi
Hootsuite enrico giubertoni matteo leviHootsuite enrico giubertoni matteo levi
Hootsuite enrico giubertoni matteo levi
 
China luxury social media marcello coppa
China luxury social media  marcello coppaChina luxury social media  marcello coppa
China luxury social media marcello coppa
 
Social google marketing e google my business e delle opportunità che esso off...
Social google marketing e google my business e delle opportunità che esso off...Social google marketing e google my business e delle opportunità che esso off...
Social google marketing e google my business e delle opportunità che esso off...
 
Queboutique un nuovo modo di fare gli acquisti online la nuova frontiera de...
Queboutique un nuovo modo di fare gli acquisti online   la nuova frontiera de...Queboutique un nuovo modo di fare gli acquisti online   la nuova frontiera de...
Queboutique un nuovo modo di fare gli acquisti online la nuova frontiera de...
 
Pmi e cultura digitale come difendendersi dall'improvvisazione e fare scelte ...
Pmi e cultura digitale come difendendersi dall'improvvisazione e fare scelte ...Pmi e cultura digitale come difendendersi dall'improvvisazione e fare scelte ...
Pmi e cultura digitale come difendendersi dall'improvvisazione e fare scelte ...
 
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostroNo haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
 
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
 
Futuro e nuovi trends dell'era digitale. un'analisi su chi siamo oggi per ca...
Futuro e nuovi trends dell'era digitale.  un'analisi su chi siamo oggi per ca...Futuro e nuovi trends dell'era digitale.  un'analisi su chi siamo oggi per ca...
Futuro e nuovi trends dell'era digitale. un'analisi su chi siamo oggi per ca...
 
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
 
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
 
Video. illusioni. come sono nati e come vivono i video dipendenti, youtubers ...
Video. illusioni. come sono nati e come vivono i video dipendenti, youtubers ...Video. illusioni. come sono nati e come vivono i video dipendenti, youtubers ...
Video. illusioni. come sono nati e come vivono i video dipendenti, youtubers ...
 
Tweeting strategy e case study #ekis bday francesca borghi_gian marco cattini
Tweeting strategy e case study #ekis bday francesca borghi_gian marco cattiniTweeting strategy e case study #ekis bday francesca borghi_gian marco cattini
Tweeting strategy e case study #ekis bday francesca borghi_gian marco cattini
 
Social media branding la miglior occasione di marketing sociale marco apadula
Social media branding la miglior occasione di marketing sociale marco apadulaSocial media branding la miglior occasione di marketing sociale marco apadula
Social media branding la miglior occasione di marketing sociale marco apadula
 
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
“Da instagram a periscope, diventa uno storyteller pro” orazio spoto
 
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostroNo haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
No haters, siamo social il caso milano weekend andrea paternostro
 
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
La storia della prima community italiana di storytelling su g+ storytelling i...
 
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
Fare networking il modo più efficace e divertente per fare business angela bi...
 

Distinguere grano e loglio segnali, rumore e altre storie in un big (data) world luigi curini