Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices

Copyright © 2011 – 2013 The Lûcrum Group, Inc., All Rights Reserved. P a g e | 1
www.compellingpm.com
Performing an Assessment of Your Company’s
Product Management & Product Marketing
Practices
The Product Management and Product Marketing Roles are some of the most strategically
important roles in an organization and when well executed, can help the organization consistently
deliver products and services that are successful in the market and result in increased revenue,
market share and profitability. But unfortunately, these are also some of the most misunderstood
roles and too often are relegated to tactical duties and miss out on delivering the strategic value and
impact that they could deliver to the organization.
How do you ensure that your Product Management & Product Marketing team is consistently
delivering strategic value? How do you know if the structure and process you have in place are
right for your organization? How do you know if your team is doing all of the critical activities
they should be doing? How do you know if you have the right people in these roles?
Performing the Product & Market Management Assessment
The starting point is to do an Assessment of Your Product & Market Management Practices. The
following is a recommended approach for doing this assessment.
1. Choose a Framework: In order to effectively assess your Product & Market Management
Practices, you must have a sound framework to serve as your reference point. This
framework must address all of the critical practices that Product Managers and Product
Marketers in a mature organization should be performing.
2. Perform Assessment: Perform an in-depth assessment of these practices in your
organization. This means assessing the depth and consistency of your organization’s
processes, tools, knowledge and deliverables as it relates to the framework. You will need
to interview everyone that is in a Product Management and Product Marketing role and the
key constituents that they interact with on a regular basis. The key constituents will
typically come from Executive Management, Sales, Marketing, Engineering/Development,
Client Services/Support and Operations. You obviously won’t be able to interview everyone
within these groups, but you should interview the key managers and top contributors in each
group.
3. Rate Performance: Rate your organization’s performance against the framework. You’ll
need to rate each practice based upon the depth & consistency as evidenced by the
processes, tools, knowledge and deliverables. Using a scale of 1 to 5 provides sufficient
granularity to distinguish those areas that are performing well and those areas that need
improvement.
4. Identify Gaps: Summarize the results and prioritize those practices where improvement
will have the highest impact on your organization’s success.
5. Define Training Needs: As you identify gaps, consider what training is necessary for the
organization to improve. If only a few of your team members lack depth and consistency in

their practices, you might want to have them participate in a formal product management
training program. If you lack depth and inconsistency across the organization, then
conducting formal product management training onsite for your whole team and key
constituents at the same time is a great way to create a common understanding of the roles
and get everyone working from the same framework.
6. Create a Plan: More than likely, you’ll have identified a number of areas that need
improvement, but you cannot realistically work on all of these at once. This is where your
prioritization will guide you in identifying quarterly initiatives. You should choose one or
two practice areas to focus on each quarter. Work on improving those practices until you’ve
achieved your target depth and consistency of implementation. At that time, you can move
onto to improving a new practice area.
7. Define Metrics: As part of your improvement initiative, you should identify appropriate
metrics to track how your team is performing. These metrics should cover the range of:
strategic, financial, operational and activity-based metrics. Then monitor these metrics on a
monthly, quarterly or annual basis, as appropriate for each metric.
8. Review Regularly: Finally, conduct this assessment on an annual basis, making sure that
you are improving in all areas and not regressing due to lack of focus or attention. The
metrics will also help to keep you on track towards your improvement goals.
Who should lead and conduct the assessment?
The head(s) of the product management and product marketing teams own(s) this responsibility and
one of their key objectives should be improving the processes, tools, knowledge and deliverables of
the team and making sure these improvements have a positive impact on the organization’s key
metrics.
Because doing an assessment is a time intensive effort and it is often difficult to break away from
the daily grind to conduct an assessment like this, an outside consultant is a valuable resource to
conduct the assessment and to guide the organization through an improvement program. Another
reason for using a consultant is to ensure fairness and objectivity that is not influenced by pre-
conceived notions of the organization and the individual personalities.
What framework should you use?
Here are some questions you should ask as you consider a framework for assessing your product
management and product marketing organization.
1. Is it complete in the definition of the product management and product marketing role?
2. Does it emphasize the strategic aspects of the roles?
3. Is it applicable for companies of all sizes and industries?
4. Can the framework be supported by formal product management training?
5. Does the framework cover the complete life-cycle for products and services, from
opportunity identification to development through launch, maturity and retire?
In the rest of this white paper, we describe a framework that supports all of those questions and has
proven useful in assessing the effectiveness of product management & product marketing
organizations.

The Compelling Marketer Model for Product & Market Success™
The ultimate goal of any business is to achieve commercial success and continued profitable
growth. This success is dependent upon a company’s ability to consistently deliver commercially
successful products/services to the market. The proven approach for achieving this success is by
creating and delivering market-driven products and services. To do this, companies must
consistently do the following:
 Identify a Compelling Market Opportunity – identify a problem that is significant enough
that many buyers are willing to pay money to solve it.
 Deliver a Compelling Solution – deliver a competitive solution in a timely manner that
solves the market problem.
 Build a Compelling Market Development Strategy – create market messages and conduct
appropriate marketing activities that resonate with the buyers in the target market,
motivating them to solve their problem by purchasing the products/services.
There are 24 Key Practices that have been identified that, when appropriately implemented, ensure
that companies have a consistent and repeatable methodology for delivering market-driven products
and services that lead to commercial success. The framework for these 24 Key Practices is shown
below and is discussed throughout the rest of this white paper.

Identify a Compelling Market Opportunity
The first goal is to identify a compelling market opportunity. At the end of this, you want to
construct and justify a business case and evaluate that business case against other opportunities
within your company. There are seven key practices to achieve that.
1) Articulate Business Strategy: A company needs a well-defined business strategy to
effectively guide the direction of the company and to make strategic decisions around products
and markets. Without a clear business strategy, how do you know if an opportunity is a good fit
for your corporation? Key elements of a well-defined business strategy include:
 A clear and succinct Vision & Mission;
 Definition of core competencies, target markets, company positioning & brand promise;
 Identification of competitive advantages.
2) Validate the Market Problem: Before pursuing a new market opportunity (new product, new
vertical market, new geographic market), you should validate that you are solving a compelling
market problem. That means that there are many buyers with a problem big enough that they
are willing to pay to solve it. The key elements of market problem validation include:
 Look for market evidence that a problem exists;
 Form a hypothesis on what the problem is and which market segment(s) have this problem;
 Conduct primary research where you speak to many potential customers to really understand
their problems and to understand what their needs are;
 Conduct secondary research to identify key business trends and drivers and to ascertain
potential market size and growth;
 Iterate as necessary until the market problem is well understood and validated.
3) Validate the Product Concept: Once you have validated that a compelling market problem
exists, you now need to create a product concept and validate that the concept solves the market
problem. To validate a product concept, you do not need to actually build the product, but you
need to communicate the vision of the solution sufficiently in order that potential buyers can
visualize how the product will solve the market problem. The key elements of product concept
validation include:
 Create a product concept that maps to your core competencies and business strategy;
 Create a mockup of the product so that potential clients can visualize the usage of the
product. A mockup could be a presentation, story board, wire frames, non-functional
prototype, etc;
 Present the product concept to potential users and receive feedback on the ability of the
product to solve the market problem;
 Iterate as necessary until the product concept is validated as useful in solving the market
problem.

4) Build Profitable Business Model: Your business model must answer the question of how will
you make a profit by selling this solution. The key elements you must evaluate and define
include:
 Define a Delivery Model that matches to the market problem and market need;
 Determine cost to sell & deliver your solution;
 Develop your pricing strategy;
 Define how this results in a profit.
5) Assess Competitive Landscape: Before pursuing a new market opportunity, you also want to
know which competitors exist and what they are offering. A good competitive analysis will
evaluate the competitive strengths and weaknesses of the top 3 to 5 competitors and will include
the following key elements:
 Current offerings, target markets, strategy & positioning;
 Competitive strengths & weaknesses;
 Market share;
 An identification of substitutes & potential new entrants.
6) Justify the Market Opportunity: Before pursuing a new market opportunity, you need to
summarize your work and justify the investment in the business opportunity by showing that it
is a profitable opportunity for your company (The Business Case). The key elements of a well
written Business Case include:
 Description of Market Need & Opportunity;
 Company fit - does it fit your business strategy;
 Definition of Product Concept;
 Market Strategy;
 Market size, revenue potential;
 Investments required;
 Risks & impacts;
 Profit potential.
7) Prioritize Market Opportunities: In most cases, a company has multiple opportunities to
pursue, all which have a valid and profitable business case. These can include new products,
new vertical markets, new geographical markets, etc. Rarely can a company pursue all of these
opportunities, so they must prioritize these opportunities based upon how they support their
corporate objectives and then decide on which ones to invest in. Key elements of prioritizing
and selecting the best investment opportunities include:
 Define ranking criteria for all opportunities;
 Determine available budget to invest in new opportunities;
 Assign executive team to review and make decision;
 Manage trade-offs of budget and opportunity.

Deliver a Compelling Solution
The second goal is to deliver a compelling solution that addresses the compelling market problem.
Without a clear process for defining and building the solution, the resulting solution will quite likely
miss the mark. There are six key practices to make sure you get the right solution.
8) Define Clear Product Vision & Strategy: One you have identified a compelling market
opportunity, understand the problems that you need to solve for the target buyers and users and
have defined a product concept, you need to establish how you are going compete in the market
and then create a long-term vision and plan for the solution that supports that strategy. This
helps you communicate the vision internally and to the market place. Key elements of a good
product vision and strategy include:
 Description of the market (trends, opportunity, needs, competition);
 Definition of how product competes (positioning, value proposition, differentiation);
 Mapping of product strategy to business strategy;
 Definition of the product (or product line) vision and growth strategy;
 High level roadmap.
9) Solicit Market Requirements: You must solicit market requirements on a continual basis as
the market needs evolve. You must continue to focus on problems that your target market needs
to solve and not on features/functions. That is, you can’t define the solution until you know
what problem you are solving. The keys to doing successful solicitation of market requirements
include:
 Solicit needs from all buyer and user types;
 Solicit from all internal stakeholders (those that sell, implement and support the solution);
 Use various methods, to include: Advisory councils, customer visits, user groups, sales
feedback, focus groups, observation, etc.;
 Define a process for how market feedback is validated and prioritized;
 Do this on a regular basis.
10) Clearly Specify the Solution: To ensure you get a solution that meets the market needs and is
competitive, you need to clearly specify the solution so that
engineering/development/manufacturing delivers the right solution. Key elements of a well
specified solution include the following documents:
 Market Requirements Document (MRD) - describes the market needs, without defining the
solution;
 User Personas - describes profiles of the typical users;
 Problem Scenarios - describes situations/context of persona’s need(s);
 Product Requirements Document (PRD) - defines the functionality of the solution necessary
to meet the market needs/requirements.

11) Manage Scope & Schedule: In order to deliver the right solution capabilities on schedule, you
must manage the trade-off between all capabilities that you want to develop for the solution and
the amount of time it takes. The key to this is prioritizing requirements and then negotiating the
release plan with engineering/development/manufacturing so that you get a suitable solution in a
practical time frame. The key elements to successfully negotiate and achieve a good release
plan include:
 Definition of minimum feature set necessary to deliver value to meet the market need (often
called the minimum viable product);
 Estimation of how soon you need a solution to meet the market need (based upon market
trends & competitive threats);
 Criteria to prioritize requirements;
 A repeatable process to negotiate scope v. schedule;
 A process for managing scope changes;
 Clear ownership of scope decisions (typically a product manager).
12) Ensure Whole Product Readiness: In order to make your solution fully usable and to solve
the complete market problem for the “majority market”, you need to ensure the Whole Product
is ready. The Whole Product, being the total effective solution in the eyes of the buyer/user,
may be more than just the core product that you're developing and producing and you often need
to provide supplementary services or have partners provide complementary products or services
to deliver the full solution. The key elements of the Whole Product that need to be ready at
launch include:
 Core Product (the solution that you are developing, delivering);
 Packaging – documentation, training, implementation & support services and other internal
infrastructure to make the solution deliverable and supportable;
 Augmentation & Infrastructure – typically 3rd party tools, applications, systems and
infrastructure that augment the offering and make it more usable and competitive.
13) Test Market Readiness: Before launching your product/service to market, you should test the
product’s ability to solve the market problem by conducting market testing. This typically
includes testing of product functionality by market users but can also serve as an opportunity to
test your marketing strategy and tactics. The key elements of test market readiness include:
 Test that the product functions as planned within the planned usage environment;
 Test that product solves the buyers’ and users’ problem(s);
 Test the market strategy, including messages, channel, marketing tools, marketing
techniques.

Build a Compelling Market Development Strategy
You’ve identified a compelling marketing opportunity and delivered a compelling solution that
solves the market problem, but you now must inform your target market that you can help them
solve their problem. You do this by building a compelling market development strategy. There are
seven key practices for building an effective market strategy that leads to effective marketing and
sales execution.
14) Define Targeted Market Development Plan: In launching a new product or entering a new
market, you must focus your market development efforts on the market segment(s) that offers
you the best opportunity for success and create market messages that resonate with those buyers.
Once defined, this Market Development Plan guides the rest of your marketing and sales
activities and must be clearly communicated to the rest of the company. A well-defined market
development plan will include the following key elements:
 Well defined target market segments:
 Description of buyer, influencer and user personas for those segments and their
challenges/goals/needs (that your product can solve);
 Clear messages to communicate to each target persona. These are based upon your
positioning and should include the Value Proposition (what benefit your solution delivers to
the target persona) and the Differentiation (why should they buy your solution “v. others”).
15) Establish Effective Channel Strategy: Your channel strategy is defining the best way to reach
your target market. This is dependent upon how your customers want to buy your
products/services and your overall business model. Key elements that must be evaluated and
defined include:
 Decision on the best sales model to use – Direct, Indirect (channel partners);
 The required profile/skills of your sales team or channel partner;
 How you manage potential channel conflict;
 The sales methodology to adopt and use to train your sales team (or channel);
 The right sales tools to support your sales strategy.
16) Align & Create Marketing/Sales Tools: You need to ensure that your marketing & sales tools
support and align with your market & channel strategy and that your tools help buyers reach the
buying decision. When evaluating this, you should consider the following key elements:
 Which marketing/sales tools are required for:
o Different market segments;
o Different buyer, influencers and user personas in each market;
o To help move them through the buying process based upon their needs & concerns at
each stage of the buying process.
17) Create & Manage Launch Plan: A Launch Plan is a defined set of activities to ensure that all
key elements of the solution and company are ready for the launch and that you have defined
marketing and sales activities that will make an initial impact on sales. Failing to execute a

proper launch can severely impede the future success of the product and damage the reputation
of your company. The key areas you must address and manage in the launch plan include:
 Product Readiness (ensure whole product is ready);
 Marketing & Channel Readiness (market plan established, marketing/sales tools ready and
sales channel enabled);
 Company Readiness (all infrastructure, support, production capability, etc);
 Launch strategy (defined marketing & sales activities to achieve initial sales).
18) Enable Channel (Sales Enablement): To ensure that your sales channel can effectively sell to
your target market, you must prepare them via a sales enablement process. This makes sure that
the sales channel is selling to the right buyers, uncovering needs your solution can solve and
communicating the right messages. Key components of sales enablement includes:
 Effective sales tools (Executive level presentation, product backgrounder, needs discovery
guide, message driven demo, etc.) that enable the sales team to identify needs and
communicate the key messages;
 Process to enable (train) and test the knowledge (certification) of your sales channel.
19) Generate Awareness: When launching a new product or going into a new market, you must
create market awareness (“buzz”) around the need, why it’s important to solve that need and
how to solve it. Awareness programs are often effectively done via speaking and writing
engagements of various forms that establishes the market need and your company’s ability to
solve the need. Typical key elements of awareness programs include:
 Product evangelism, such as speaking engagements at tradeshows, conferences & other trade
events as well as webinars;
 Public relations to get 3rd party validation via trade journals, newspapers and other forms of
the press;
 Analyst relations to share and validate your message with analysts and get them to speak &
write about it;
 Proper marketing/sales tools to support this, such as white papers, presentations, press kits,
blogging, etc.
20) Feed & Manage Sales Funnel: Starting with the launch of a new product, you must conduct
market activities that continuously & effectively feed your sales funnel and manage the leads
through the funnel until they result in sales. To accomplish this, key elements include:
 Demand generation strategies that move well qualified leads into the sales funnel (e.g.,
webinars, direct mail, telemarketing, advertising, trade shows, conferences, internet
marketing, social media, etc.);
 Score, qualify and prioritize leads;
 Conduct marketing programs and sales activities that move them through the funnel until the
sale is complete;
 Evaluate funnel metrics (conversion rates, time to sale, cost of leads, etc.) and identify
opportunities to improve on these.

Process and Portfolio Management
There are four more key practices that help you manage your product delivery process and the
overall profitability of your portfolio of products/services. These include:
21) Manage Product Life Cycle Profitability: As products/services go through the product life
cycle (introduction, growth, maturity, decline), market conditions and buyers change and each
stage requires different strategies to maximize the profitability of the product and to extend the
life cycle. Key elements of doing this include:
 Determining where the product is in the lifecycle;
 Analyzing the changing market conditions and buyer profiles/needs in each stage;
 Adjusting the product or product line to effectively compete in that stage;
 Adapting the market strategy to the buying motives for that stage of the life cycle.
22) Optimize Product Portfolio Profitability: As your company grows and evolves, you need a
methodology to manage the product portfolio, helping you make decisions on where to and how
to invest your limited resources in current & new products/services in order to maximize
portfolio value. Key elements of doing this are:
 Using appropriate tools (e.g., BCG matrix, GE matrix, SWOT, etc.) to analyze the balance,
alignment & competitiveness of your product portfolio;
 Using appropriate tools (e.g., prioritization, optimization, etc.) to determine which product
investments will best support the business strategy, create balance and result in maximum
portfolio value.
23) Measure Success (Metrics): The key to improving is being able to measure critical factors of
your strategy and operations and to adjust and improve upon these. The key elements to do this
include:
 Defining measurable metrics at both the strategic and operational level;
 Measuring and tracking metrics on a regular basis (weekly, monthly, quarterly, yearly, etc.),
as is suitable for the metric;
 Determining where improvement is needed and make the appropriate corrective actions to
your strategies and tactics.

24) Manage Investment/Risk Decisions (Decision Checkpoints): There are many activities that a
company must accomplish to take a product from conception to launch. As it moves along the
product delivery timeline, a company’s investment and risk increases significantly. Decision
checkpoints are placed at critical points of the process to evaluate if the company should make
the next level of investment in a certain product/service, helping to ensure that the right
opportunities receive the right level of investment. The key elements to do this include:
 At a minimum, major checkpoints should occur at the business case (before investing in
product development) and before launching the product;
 As the product moves through its life cycle, you should have a checkpoints to make End-of-
Life (EOL) decisions (e.g., retire or divest of the product);
 Each checkpoint should include a defined set of deliverables which will serve as a basis of
the decision and the authority level for making the decision.
Free Self-Assessment & Consulting Call
To help you start through the assessment process, CompellingPM offers a free online self-
assessment, which includes a thirty minute consulting call to review your assessment and make
recommendations.
To request a link to the free self-assessment, please contact us via our website:
http://compellingpm.com/about/contact-us/

Product & Market Management Excellence
For a complete assessment process, CompellingPM offers the Product & Market Management
Excellence service to help companies improve the strategic value and the execution of the product
management & product marketing roles. This service is delivered by identifying areas for
improvement via a formal assessment process and then improving these areas via formal training,
workshops and coaching.
The Product & Market Management Excellence services are delivered in four stages:
Assessment
The goal of the assessment phase is to evaluate and understand the depth and consistency of
implementation of Product Management & Product Marketing best practices throughout the
organization and to identify areas of weaknesses that can be improved. During this phase,
CompellingPM evaluates processes, tools, deliverables and market and product knowledge.
Training
CompellingPM has partnered with 280 Group to offer the Optimal Product Management &
Product Marketing™ (OPM) training program. The OPM training program trains participants in
the full role of product management and product marketing across the complete product life-cycle
and has proven effective across all industries. It is based upon the industry standard framework
defined by the Association of International Product Marketing and Management (AIPMM) and the
training begins the preparation for taking the exam to receive the prestigious AIPMM certifications:
Certified Product Manager (CPM®) and Certified Product Marketing Manager (CPMM®).
Implementation
The Product & Market Management Excellence Implementation involves an Implementation
Workshop where all relevant players participate and create a specific plan for the quarterly focus
initiative. During the quarter, progress is reviewed on a regular basis as part of the Implementation
Coaching. The quarter is ended with a final review of the initiative.
Performance Monitoring
CompellingPM will work with the executive team and product management/marketing team to
identify metrics by which the product management & product marketing roles can be evaluated and
improvement tracked. We continue to support the process of evaluating these metrics on a regular
basis.
For more information, please contact us via our website:
http://compellingpm.com/about/contact-us/

Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices

Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices

Recomendados

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

La actualidad más candente(19)

Destacado

Destacado(11)

Similar a Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices

Similar a Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices(20)

Más de CompellingPM

Más de CompellingPM(16)

Último

Último(20)

Introduction to performing an assessment of your company's product management & product marketing practices