1. Valerio Cosentino - IBM, AtlanMod, INRIA & EMN, Nantes - valerio.cosentino@fr.ibm.com
Jordi Cabot - AtlanMod, INRIA & EMN, Nantes - jordi.cabot@mines-nantes.fr
Patrick Albert – IBM - albertpa@fr.ibm.com
Philippe Bauquel – IBM - bauquel.p@fr.ibm.com
Jacques Perronnet – IBM - jacques_perronnet@fr.ibm.com
Extracting Business Rules from COBOL:
A Model-Based Framework
1
WCRE 2013, Koblenz, Germany – 14-17 October
© 2009 IBM Corporation

2. Outline
 Introduction
– Problem
– Running example
 Framework overview
– Model Discovery
– Business Term Identification
– Business Rule Identification
– Business Rule Representation
 Early validation
 Conclusion & future work
2
© 2009 IBM Corporation

3. Problem
3
© 2009 IBM Corporation

4. Problem
4
© 2009 IBM Corporation

5. Problem
5
© 2009 IBM Corporation

6. Problem
 Poor/outdated system documentation
6
© 2009 IBM Corporation

7. Problem
 Poor/outdated system documentation
 The original developers/business analysts may have left the
organization
7
© 2009 IBM Corporation

8. Problem
 Poor/outdated system documentation
 The original developers/business analysts may have left the
organization
 Business rules spread in the source code
8
© 2009 IBM Corporation

9. Problem
 Understanding and evolving the business policies together with
the corresponding business rules is not trivial
9
© 2009 IBM Corporation

10. Problem
 Understanding and evolving the business policies together with
the corresponding business rules is not trivial
 Specially true for legacy systems
10
© 2009 IBM Corporation

11. COBOL
 Largely used:
– 200 billion lines of code in existence
– 70%-75% of business and transaction systems
– 90% of global financial transactions
11
© 2009 IBM Corporation

12. COBOL
 Largely used:
– 200 billion lines of code in existence
– 70%-75% of business and transaction systems
– 90% of global financial transactions
 Shortage of COBOL developers:
– Study on 357 Information Technology professionals
– 46% says they already notice a shortage
– 50% says the average age is > 45
– 22% says the age is > 55
12
© 2009 IBM Corporation

13. Running example
Need
Bag
Money

13
Is open
Quantity
Price
Business rules in the program:
–If the shop is open, then the customer can buy products
–If a product P is needed, then the customer buys P
–If the client has enough money, then he can buy products
–If the client has enough room in his bag, he can buy products
–If a product is available, then it may be bought
–If a product is bought, its quantity is decreased by one
© 2009 IBM Corporation

14. Running example

14
Rule embedded in the code:
 if a product is bought, its quantity is decreased by one
© 2009 IBM Corporation

15. Running example

15
Rule embedded in the code:
 if a product is bought, its quantity is decreased by one
© 2009 IBM Corporation

16. Running example

16
Rule embedded in the code:
 if a product is bought, its quantity is decreased by one
© 2009 IBM Corporation

17. Running example

17
Rule embedded in the code:
 if a product is bought, its quantity is decreased by one
© 2009 IBM Corporation

18. Framework overview
 Model Driven Engineering:
– Modular framework
– Internal/external representation of BRs
– Traceability between rules and source code
– Mature tools available for model manipulations, visualizations
and transformations (e.g., ATL, Xtext, ...)
18
© 2009 IBM Corporation

19. COBOL Model Discovery
19
© 2009 IBM Corporation

20. Business Term Identification
 Manually: the user selects the variables
 Automatically: heuristic-based strategy
20
© 2009 IBM Corporation

21. Business Term Identification
 Manually: the user selects the variables
 Automatically: heuristic-based strategy
1) Statements are separated in groups:
– Conditional
– Computational
– ...
21
© 2009 IBM Corporation

22. Business Term Identification
 Manually: the user selects the variables
 Automatically: heuristic-based strategy
1) Statements are separated in groups:
– Conditional
– Computational
– ...
2) Variables in statements are classified in:
– Condition
– Index
– Source
– Target
22
© 2009 IBM Corporation

23. Business Term Identification
 Manually: the user selects the variables
 Automatically: heuristic-based strategy
– all target variables in computational statements
– all variables in conditional statements
– ...
23
© 2009 IBM Corporation

24. Business Rule Identification
24
© 2009 IBM Corporation

25. Business Rule Identification – Rule Discovery

25
Rule Fragment Identification:
© 2009 IBM Corporation

26. Business Rule Identification – Rule Discovery

26
Rule Fragment Identification:
© 2009 IBM Corporation

27. Business Rule Identification – Rule Discovery

27
Rule Fragment Identification:
© 2009 IBM Corporation

28. Business Rule Identification – Rule Discovery

28
Rule Context Identification:
© 2009 IBM Corporation

29. Business Rule Representation
29
© 2009 IBM Corporation

30. Business Rule Representation – Vocabulary Extraction
 Optional and manual step
30
© 2009 IBM Corporation

31. Business Rule Representation – Visualization
 Text-based visualization
31
© 2009 IBM Corporation

32. Business Rule Representation – Visualization
 Text-based visualization
32
© 2009 IBM Corporation

33. Business Rule Representation – Visualization
 Graph-based visualization
33
© 2009 IBM Corporation

34. Business Rule Representation – Visualization
 Graph-based visualization
34
© 2009 IBM Corporation

35. Business Rule Representation – Visualization
 Graph-based visualization
35
© 2009 IBM Corporation

36. Early validation
 Does the framework find complete business rules?
 Are the extracted rules understandable?
36
© 2009 IBM Corporation

37. Early validation
 Does the framework find complete business rules?
 Are the extracted rules understandable?
 Analysis of an IBM COBOL application:
– 14 programs
– 130 variables
– 6500 lines of code
 4 internal IBM COBOL experts:
– They knew the application
– They analysed the business rules generated by our framework
37
© 2009 IBM Corporation

38. Early validation
 Does the framework find complete business rules?
 Are the extracted rules understandable?
 Analysis of an IBM COBOL application:
– 14 programs
– 130 variables
– 6500 lines of code
 4 internal IBM COBOL experts:
– They knew the application
– They analysed the business rules generated by our framework
 The framework is able to identify the complete business rules
– But some extracted rules include technical knowledge
38
© 2009 IBM Corporation

39. Conclusion and future work
 MDE benefits:
– Modular framework
– Internal/external representation of BRs
– Traceability between rules and source code
39
© 2009 IBM Corporation

40. Conclusion and future work
 MDE benefits:
– Modular framework
– Internal/external representation of BRs
– Traceability between rules and source code
 Future work:
– Complete the early validation on a real system
– Extract and unify the rules buried in other layers (presentation,
data, logic)
40
© 2009 IBM Corporation

41. Questions
41
© 2009 IBM Corporation