Más contenido relacionado
La actualidad más candente (17)
Similar a Fiqh us-sunnah (20)
Más de Noor Al Islam (20)
Fiqh us-sunnah
- 5. WDNELURIWKHSUDHUDQGWKH
YHUEDO 4XU
DQLF UHFLWDWLRQ $EX +XUDLUDK DVNHG KLP 20HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD P IDWKHU DQG
PRWKHUEHVDFULILFHGIRURXZKGRRXUHPDLQVLOHQWEHWZHHQWKHWDNELUDQGWKHUHFLWDO:KDWGR
RXVDVLOHQWOGXULQJWKDWWLPH
- 9. DUH ODZIXO LH WKH FDQ EH HDWHQ ZLWKRXW DQ SUHVFULEHG VODXJKWHULQJ
- 10. 7KLV KDGLWK LV
UHODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLFDOOVLWKDVVDQVDKLKDQGDO%XNKDULVDVLWLVVDKLK
)LTKD:DWHUIURPWKHZHOORI=DP]DP
$OL QDUUDWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH FDOOHG IRU D EXFNHW WKDW FRQWDLQHG
ZDWHUIURPWKHZHOORI=DP]DP+HGUDQNIURPWKHEXFNHWWKHQPDGHDEOXWLRQZLWKLWVZDWHU
- 11. 7KLV
KDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDG
)LTKE$OWHUHGZDWHU
7KLVLQYROYHVZDWHUZKRVHIRUPKDVEHHQDOWHUHGEHFDXVHRILWVEHLQJLQDSODFHIRUDORQJSHULRGRI
WLPHRUEHFDXVHRIWKHSODFHLQZKLFKLWLVORFDWHGRUEHFDXVHRILWVEHLQJPL[HGZLWKDVXEVWDQFHWKDW
FDQQRW EH FRPSOHWHO UHPRYHG IURP LW LH ZDWHU PL[HG ZLWK DOJDH WUHH OHDYHV DQG VR RQ
- 15. 0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH DVNHG KLP:KHUH KDYH RX EHHQ$EX+XUDLUDK+H
DQVZHUHG,ZDVLQSRVWVH[LPSXULWDQGGLGQRWZDQWWRVLWZLWKRXZKLOH,ZDVLQWKDWFRQGLWLRQ
7KH3URSKHW UHSOLHG*ORUEHWR$OODK7KHEHOLHYHUGRHVQRWEHFRPHLPSXUH7KLVLVUHODWHGE
WKHJURXS
7KLV LV EDVHG RQ WKH UDWLRQDOH WKDW VLQFH D EHOLHYHU QHYHU EHFRPHV LPSXUH WKH ZDWHU KH XVHV IRU
SXULILFDWLRQDOVRGRHVQRWEHFRPHLPSXUH7KXVDSXUHREMHFWWRXFKLQJDSXUHREMHFWFDQQRWUHVXOWLQ
RQH
VEHFRPLQJLPSXUH,EQDO0XQ]KLUVDLGWKDWLWLVUHODWHGWKDW
$OL,EQ
8PDU$EX8PDPDK
$WD
DO+DVVDQ0DNKXODQGDQ1DNKD
LVDLGWKDWLIDSHUVRQIRUJRWWRZLSHKLVKHDGZKLOHPDNLQJDEOXWLRQ
LWLVVXIILFLHQWIRUKLPWRZLSHKLVKHDGZLWKDQZDWHUUHPDLQLQJLQKLVEHDUG,EQDO0XQ]KLUVWDWHG
WKDWWKLVSURYHVWKDWWKHWRRNXVHGZDWHUDVSXUH7KLVRSLQLRQFRPHVIURPRQHRIWKHQDUUDWLRQV
DWWULEXWHG WR 0DOLN DQG DVK6KDI
L ,EQ +D]P DVFULEHV LW WR 6XIDQ DO7KDXUL $EX 7KDXU DQG DOO
VFKRODUVRIWKH=KDKLULVFKRRORIWKRXJKW
)LTK:DWHUPL[HGZLWKSXUHHOHPHQWV
7KLVFDWHJRULQFOXGHVZDWHUWKDWKDVEHHQPL[HGZLWKVXEVWDQFHVOLNHVRDSVDIIURQIORZHUVDQGVR
RQWKDWLVREMHFWVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHEWKHVKDUL
DK6XFKZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHDVORQJDVLWKDVQRW
EHHQVRPL[HGZLWKRWKHUVXEVWDQFHVWKDWRQHFDQQRORQJHUFDOOLWZDWHU,IWKLVLVWKHFDVHWKHZDWHULV
VWLOOFRQVLGHUHGSXUHEXWLWFDQQRWEHXVHGIRUSXULILFDWLRQ8PP
$WLDKQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHU
RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH HQWHUHG KHU KRXVH DIWHU WKH GHDWK RI KLV GDXJKWHU =DLQDE DQG VDLG
:DVKKHUWKUHHRUILYHRUPRUHWLPHVLIRXVHHILWWRGRVRZLWKZDWHUDQGGUWUHHOHDYHV)RUWKH
ILQDOZDVKLQJXVHVRPHNDIRRURUVRPHWKLQJIURPNDIRRU:KHQRXDUHILQLVKHGLQIRUPPH6KH
GLGVRDIWHUZKLFKKHJDYHWKHZRPHQKLVRXWHUJDUPHQWDQGWROGWKHPWRZUDS=DLQDELQLW7KLVZDV
UHODWHGEWKHJURXS
7KHGHFHDVHGVKRXOGEHZDVKHGZLWKVRPHWKLQJWKDWPDSXULIDOLYHSHUVRQ$KPDGDQ1DVD
LDQG
,EQ .KX]DLPDK UHFRUG IURP 8PP +DQL WKDW WKH 0HVVHQDJHU RI $OODK DQG 0DLPXQDK ZDVKHG
WKHPVHOYHVIURPRQHZDWHU
- 16. FRQWDLQHUWKDWKDGDWUDFHRIGRXJKLQLW,QERWKRIWKHVHKDGLWKZHILQG
WKDW WKHZDWHUZDVPL[HG ZLWK DQRWKHU VXEVWDQFHEXWVLQFHWKHRWKHUVXEVWDQFHZDVQRWVXEVWDQWLDO
HQRXJKWRDOWHULWVQDWXUHLWUHPDLQHGILWIRUFRQVXPSWLRQ
)LTKD:DWHUPL[HGZLWKLPSXUHHOHPHQWV
:HFDQGLYLGHWKLVFDWHJRULQWRWZRVXEFDWHJRULHV
7KHLPSXUHVXEVWDQFHDOWHUVWKHWDVWHFRORURURGRURIWKHZDWHU,QWKLVFDVHLW FDQQRWEHXVHGIRU
SXULILFDWLRQ$FFRUGLQJWR,EQDO0XQ]KLUDQG,EQDO0XODTTLQWKHUHLVDFRQVHQVXVRQWKLVSRLQW
7KHOLTXLGLVVWLOOFRQVLGHUHGZDWHUPHDQLQJWKDWWKHLPSXUHVXEVWDQFHKDVQRWDOWHUHGLWVWDVWH
FRORURURGRU6XFKZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHDQGPDEHXVHGIRUSXULILFDWLRQ7KLVLVEDVHGXSRQWKH
IROORZLQJKDGLWK$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWDEHGRXLQXULQDWHGLQWKHPRVTXH7KHSHRSOHVWRRGWR
JHWKLPDQGVWRSKLP
- 18. 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH WROG KLP:DWHU LV SXUH DQG QRWKLQJPDNHV LW
LPSXUH
7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDVK6KDI
L$EX'DZXGDQ1DVD
LDQGDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHGLW
DV KDVVDQ $KPDG VDLG 7KLV KDGLWK LV VDKLK DQG DKD LEQ0D
HHQ DQG0XKDPPDG LEQ +D]P
FODVVLILHGLWDVVXFK7KLVLVDOVRWKHRSLQLRQRI,EQ
$EEDV$EX+XUDLUDKDO+DVVDQDO%DVUL,EQDO
0XVDDE
,NULPDK ,EQ $EX /DLOD DO7KDXUL 'DZXG D]K=KDKLUL DQ1DNKD
L 0DOLN DQG RWKHUV
6DVDO*KD]]DOL,ZLVKDVK6KDI
L
VRSLQLRQZDVOLNH0DOLN
V
7KHUHLVDOVRDKDGLWKIURP
$EGXOODKLEQ
8PDULQZKLFKWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKLVUHSRUWHGWRKDYH
VDLG,IWKHUHDUHDWOHDVWWZREXFNHWVRIZDWHULWZLOOQRWFDUUDQLPSXULW7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHG
EWKHILYH+RZHYHUWKLVKDGLWKLVPX]KWDUDELQLWVFKDLQRIQDUUDWRUVDQGWH[W,EQ
$EGXO%DUU
VDLG LQ DW7DPKHHG $V WR WKH RSLQLRQ RI DVK6KDI
L ZKLFK LV EDVHG RQ WKLV KDGLWK LW LV ZHDN RQ
VFUXWLQDQGLVQRWFRQILUPHGEKLVWRULFDOUHSRUWV
)LTK/HIWRYHUZDWHU
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
- 20. WKLV LV D
UHIHUHQFHQRWWRWKHLUSKVLFDOVWDWHEXWWRWKHLUIDOVHEHOLHIVDQGFUHHG7KHPDFRPHLQWRFRQWDFW
ZLWKGLUWRULPSXULWLHVEXWWKLVGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWWKHLUSRVVHVVLRQVRUERGLHVDUHLPSXUH,QIDFWWKH
XVHGWRPL[ZLWKWKH0XVOLPV7KHLUHPPLVVDULHVDQGGHOHJDWLRQVXVHGWRYLVLWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK
DQGHQWHUKLVPRVTXH7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGLGQRWRUGHUWKDWWKHREMHFWVWKHWRXFKHG
EHFOHDQVHG$VIRUPHQVWXUDWLQJZRPHQ
$LVKDKVDLG,XVHGWRGULQNIURPDFRQWDLQHU
- 24. LVQRWLPSXUH7KH
LQWHUPLQJOHZLWKRX
)LTKD:DWHUOHIWLQDSRWDIWHUDSLJRUGRJKDVGUXQNIURPLW
6XFKZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUHDQGPXVWEHDYRLGHG$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLPKDYHUHFRUGHGRQWKH
DXWKRULW RI $EX +XUDLUDK WKDW WKH PHVVHQJHU RI $OODK VDLG ,I D GRJ GULQNV IURP RQH RI RXU
FRQWDLQHUVZDVKLWVHYHQWLPHV$KPDGDQG0XVOLPDOVRKDYHWKLVDGGLWLRQOHDQVHRQHRIRXU
FRQWDLQHUVLIDGRJOLFNVLWEZDVKLQJLWVHYHQWLPHVWKHILUVWZDVKLQJEHLQJZLWKGLUW$VIRUWKH
OHIWRYHUZDWHURIDSLJLWLVFOHDUOFRQVLGHUHGILOWKDQGLPSXUH
)LTKE7SHVRILPSXULWLHV
1DMDVDKUHIHUVWRLPSXUHVXEVWDQFHVWKDWWKH0XVOLPPXVWDYRLGDQGZDVKRIILIWKHVKRXOGKDSSHQWR
FRQWDPLQDWHKLVFORWKHVERGDQGVRRQ6DV$OODKLQWKH4XU
DQ3XULIRXUUDLPHQWDO0XGDWKDU
- 28. OLYHUDQGWKHVSOHHQ
7KLV LV UHODWHG E $KPDG DVK6KDI
L DO%DLKDTL DQG DG'DUDTXWQL 7KH KDGLWK LV ZHDN EXW ,PDP
$KPDGVDVWKDWLWLVDXWKHQWLFLQPDXTRRIIRUP$EX=DU
DKDQG$EX+DWLPKDYHVDLGWKHVDPH6XFK
DUHSRUWKDVWKHLPSOLFDWLRQRIDPDUIX
KDGLWKEHFDXVHDFRPSDQLRQVDLQJ7KLVZDVDOORZHGIRUXV
RU7KLVZDVIRUELGGHQIRUXVLVOLNHRQHRIWKHPVDLQJ:HZHUHRUGHUHGWRGRWKLVRU:HZHUH
IRUELGGHQ WR GR WKLV DQG VR RQ 6XFK VWDWHPHQWV DUH FRQVLGHUHG PDUIX
ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKHLU
UHJXODWLRQV
- 35. 7KHQKHVDLG:KDWLV
IRUELGGHQ LVLWVPHDW$VIRULWVVNLQVNLQXVHGIRUZDWHUVNLQVWHHWKERQHVIXUDQGZRROWKHDUH
SHUPLVVLEOH 7KLV LV QDUUDWHG E ,EQ0XQ]KLU DQG ,EQ +DWLP 6LPLODUO LWV UHQQHW DQG PLON DUH
FRQVLGHUHGSXUH7KLVLVVXSSRUWHGEWKHIDFWWKDWZKHQWKHFRPSDQLRQVFRQTXHUHG,UDTWKHDWHWKH
FKHHVH RI WKH 0DJLDQV ZKLFK ZDV PDGH IURP UHQQHW DOWKRXJK WKHLU VODXJKWHUHG DQLPDOV ZHUH
FRQVLGHUHGWKHVDPHDV
GHDGDQLPDOV
,WLVFRQILUPHGIURP6DOPDQDO)DUVLWKDWZKHQKHZDVDVNHG
DERXWFKHHVHFODULILHGEXWWHUDQGSHOWVKHVDLG:KDWLVSHUPLVVLEOHLVZKDW$OODKPDGHSHUPLVVLEOH
LQ+LVERRN:KDWLVIRUELGGHQLVZKDW$OODKPDGHIRUELGGHQLQ+LVERRN:KDWKHRPLWV+HKDV
SDUGRQHG IRU RX ,W LV ZHOONQRZQ WKDW KH ZDV EHLQJ DVNHG DERXW WKH FKHHVH RI WKH0DJLDQV DV
6DOPDQZDV
8PDU
VGHSXWLQ0DGD
LQ,UDT
)LTK%ORRG
7KLVLQFOXGHVEORRGWKDWSRXUVIRUWKIURPDQDQLPDO
VERGVXFKDVEORRGIURPDVODXJKWHUHGDQLPDO
RU IURP PHQVWUXDWLRQ H[FHSW IRU ZKDW VPDOO DPRXQWV DUH RYHUORRNHG ,EQ -XUDLM VDLG DERXW WKH
4XU
DQLFYHUVHRUEORRGSRXUHGIRUWKDO$Q
DP
- 36. WKDWWKLVLVWKHEORRGWKDWIORZVRXW7KH
EORRG WKDW GRHV QRW IORZ RXW EXW UHPDLQV LQ WKH YHLQV LV SHUPLVVLEOH 7KLV LV UHODWHG E ,EQ DO
0XQ]KLU$QGLWLVDOVRUHODWHGIURP$EX0DMOL]QLQKLVGLVFRXUVHRQEORRGWKDWKHZDVDVNHG:KDW
DERXWWKHEORRGWKDWUHPDLQVLQWKHVODXJKWHUHGVKHHSRUDWWKHWRSRIWKHFRRNLQJSRW+HDQVZHUHG
7KHUHLVQRSUREOHPZLWKLW:KDWLVIRUELGGHQLVWKHEORRGWKDWIORZVRXWRIWKHDQLPDODWWKHWLPH
RIVODXJKWHULQJ
- 38. ,EQ +DMU VDV LQ )DWK DO%DUL D FRPPHQWDU RQ 6DKLK DO%XNKDUL
- 39. $EX +XUDLUDK GLG QRW VHH
DQWKLQJZURQJLQDGURSRUWZRRIEORRGGXULQJWKHSUDHUV%DVHGRQWKLVUHSRUWIURP$EX+XUDLUDK
WKH EORRG RI D IOHH RU WKH EORRG WKDW FRPHV IURP D SLPSOH DUH WR EH RYHUORRNHG$EX0DMOL]QZDV
DVNHG DERXW SXV WKDW JHWV RQ WKH ERG RU WKH FORWKHV+H VDLG
7KHUH LV QRWKLQJ ZURQJ ZLWKWKHP
$OODKPHQWLRQVRQOWKHEORRGQRWWKHSXV
RPPHQWLQJ RQ WKH VXEMHFW ,EQ 7DLPLDK VDV ,W LV REOLJDWRU WR FOHDQ WKH FORWKHV IURP SXV
SXUXOHQW PDWWHU RU VLPLODU IOXLGV+H DOVR VDV 7KHUH LV QR SURRI FRQFHUQLQJ LWV LPSXULW ,W LV
SUHIHUUHGIRUWKHSHUVRQWRDYRLGFRQWDFWDVPXFKDVSRVVLEOHZLWKWKHVHVXEVWDQFHV
)LTK3LJ
VPHDW
$FFRUGLQJ WR WKH YHUVH DO$Q
DP
- 40. TXRWHG HDUOLHU LWHPV PHQWLRQHG WKHUHLQ DUH LPSXUH 7KH
SURQRXQ
WKH
UHIHUVWRDOOWKUHHRIWKHPHQWLRQHGLWHPV,WLVKRZHYHUDOORZHGWRNQLWZLWKWKHKDLURI
DSLJDFFRUGLQJWRPRVWRIWKHVFKRODUV
)LTKD9RPLWLQJRIDSHUVRQXULQHDQGH[FUHPHQW
7KHUHLVDJUHHPHQWDPRQJWKHVFKRODUVWKDWWKHVHREMHFWVDUHLPSXUH%XWDVOLJKWDPRXQWRIYRPLW
FRPPRQO XQGHUVWRRG DV D VPDOO DPRXQW RI OLTXLG
- 41. DQG WKH XULQH RI DQ XQZHDQHG PDOH EDE DUH
RYHUORRNHGDQGSDUGRQHG,WLVVXIILFLHQWMXVWWRVSULQNOHZDWHURYHUWKHXULQHRIDQXQZHDQHGPDOH
EDE 7KLV LV EDVHG RQ WKH KDGLWK RI 8PP 4DLV 6KH FDPH WR WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK ZLWK KHU
XQZHDQHG VRQ $IWHU DZKLOH WKH EDE XULQDWHG LQ WKH 3URSKHW
V ODS 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQZKRP EH
SHDFHFDOOHGIRUVRPHZDWHUZKLFKKHVSULQNOHGRYHUKLVFORWKHVDQGGLGQRWJLYHWKHPDFRPSOHWH
ZDVKLQJ7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
$OLQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG7KHXULQHRIDEDEERVKRXOGKDYHZDWHUVSULQNOHG
XSRQLW7KHXULQHRIDEDEJLUOLVWREHZDVKHGRII6DV4DWDGDK7KLVUHIHUVWRDPDOHEDEWKDW
KDVQRWHWEHJXQWRHDW,IKHDOUHDGHDWVWKHQWKHJDUPHQWLVWREHZDVKHG
7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDW7LUPL]KLDQG,EQ0DMDK,QDO)DWK,EQ+DMUVDVLWV
FKDLQLVVDKLK
6SULQNOLQJ LV VXIILFLHQW DV ORQJ DV WKH ER LV VWLOO QXUVLQJ ,I KH HDWV VROLG IRRG KLV XULQHPXVW EH
ZDVKHGIURPWKHFORWKHVDQGERG7KHUHLVQRGLVDJUHHPHQWRQWKLVODWWHUSRLQW3HUKDSVWKHUHDVRQ
IRUWKLVH[HPSWLRQWRWKHPDOHEDE
VXULQHLVWKDWSHRSOHKDYHDWHQGHQFWRFDUUWKHLUPDOHEDELHV
DURXQGDQGLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQGLIILFXOWWRFOHDQWKHFORWKHVDIWHUWKHLUIUHTXHQWXULQDWLRQV
)LTK$O:DGL
:DGLLVDWKLFNZKLWHVHFUHWLRQGLVFKDUJHGEVRPHSHRSOH
- 44. DQG ZDGL WKH UHTXLUH D FRPSOHWH
SXULILFDWLRQ 7KLV LV UHODWHG E DO$WKUDP $O%DLKDTL KDV LW ZLWK WKHZRUGLQJRQFHUQLQJPD]KL
SURVWDWLFIOXLG
- 45. DQGZDGLKHVDLG
:DVKRXUVH[XDORUJDQVDQGSHUIRUPWKHVDPHWSHRIDEOXWLRQDV
RXSHUIRUPIRUSUDHU
)LTKD$O0D]KLRUSURVWDWLFIOXLG
7KLV LV D ZKLWH VWLFN IOXLG WKDW IORZV IURP WKH VH[XDO RUJDQV EHFDXVH RI WKLQNLQJ DERXW VH[XDO
LQWHUFRXUVHRUIRUHSODDQGVRRQ7KHSHUVRQLVXVXDOOQRWDZDUHRIZKHQH[DFWOLWLVVHFUHWHG,W
FRPHVIURPERWKWKHPDOHDQGWKHIHPDOHVH[XDORUJDQVDOWKRXJKWKHDPRXQWIURPWKHODWWHULVXVXDOO
PRUH WKDQWKHIRUPHU
V6FKRODUVDUHDJUHHGWKDWLWLVLPSXUH,ILWJHWVRQWKHERGLWLVREOLJDWRUWR
ZDVKLWRII,ILWJHWVRQWKHFORWKHVLWVXIILFHVWRVSULQNOHWKHDUHDZLWKZDWHUDVLWLVYHUKDUGWREH
FRPSOHWHOSURWHFWHGIURPWKLVLPSXULWHVSHFLDOOIRUWKHRXQJVLQJOHSHUVRQ
$OLVDLG,XVHGWR
H[FUHWHPD]KLVR,DVNHGDPDQWRDVNWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDERXWLW,ZDV
VKWRGRVREHFDXVHRIPSRVLWLRQZLWKUHVSHFWWRKLVGDXJKWHU
$OLZDVWKH3URSKHW
VVRQLQODZ
- 48. IRUP EHFDXVH RI KLV UHSXWDWLRQ DV RQH ZKR FRPPLWHG WDGOLV %XW LQ WKLV
QDUUDWLRQ KHPDNHV LW FOHDU WKDW KH KHDUG WKH KDGLWK GLUHFWO $O$WKUDP QDUUDWHG WKHVDPH KDGLWK
ZLWKWKHZRUGLQJ,ZDVERWKHUHGEDJUHDWGHDORIPD]KLVR,ZHQWWRWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEH
SHDFHDQGLQIRUPHGKLPRIWKLV+HVDLG
,WLVVXIILFLHQWIRURXWRWDNHDKDQGIXORIZDWHUDQGVSULQNOH
LWRYHUWKHPD]KL
- 50. ,WLVDOVRUHODWHGWKDW,EQ
$EEDVVDLG,DVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHU
RI$OODKDERXWVSHUPRQFORWKHV+HVDLG
,WLVWKHVDPHDVPXFXVDQGVSLWWOH,WLVVXIILFLHQWWRUXEWKH
DUHDZLWKDUDJRUFORWK
7KH KDGLWK ZDV UHODWHG E DG'DUDTXWQL DO%DLKDTL DQG DW7DKDZL 7KHUH LV D GLIIHUHQFH LQ WKH
QDUUDWLRQRYHUZKHWKHULWVKRXOGEHLQPDUIX
RUPDXTRRIIRUP
)LTKD7KHXULQHDQGVWRROVRIDQLPDOVWKDWDUHSHUPLVVLEOHWRHDW
%RWKRIWKHVHDUHFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUH,EQ0DV
XGUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEH
SHDFH ZHQW WR DQVZHU WKH FDOO RI QDWXUH +H DVNHG
$EGXOODK LEQ 0DV
XG WR EULQJ WKUHH VWRQHV
$EGXOODK VDLG , FRXOG QRW ILQG WKUHH VWRQHV VR , IRXQG WZR VWRQHV DQG DQLPDO GXQJ DQG EURXJKW
WKHPWRKLP+HWRRNWKHWZRVWRQHVDQGWKUHZDZDWKHGXQJVDLQJ
,WLVLPSXUH
7KHKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDUL,EQ0DMDKDQG,EQ.KX]DLPDK,QRQHQDUUDWLRQLWVWDWHV,WLV
LPSXUH,WLVWKHVWRRORIDGRQNH$OLWWOHDPRXQWRILWLVSDUGRQHGWKRXJKDVLWLVYHUGLIILFXOWWR
FRPSOHWHOSURWHFWRQH
VVHOIIURPLW$O:DOHHGLEQ0XVOLPVDV,VDLGWRDO$X]D
L
:KDWDERXWWKH
XULQHRIDQLPDOVZKRVHPHDWLVQRWHDWHQOLNHWKHPXOHGRQNHDQGKRUVH
+HVDLGWKDWWKHXVHGWR
FRPH LQWR FRQWDFW ZLWK WKHVH GXULQJ WKHLU EDWWOHV DQG WKDW WKH GLG QRW ZDVK LW RII WKHLU ERGLHV RU
FORWKHV$VIRUWKHXULQHDQGVWRROVRIDQLPDOVZKRVHPHDWLVSHUPLVVLEOH0DOLN$KPDGDQGDJURXS
RIWKH6KDLILDKVDVWKDWLWLVSXUHRPPHQWLQJRQWKHVXEMHFW,EQ7DLPLDKVDV1RQHRIWKH
FRPSDQLRQVKHOGWKDWLWLVLPSXUH,QIDFWWKHVWDWHPHQWWKDWLWLVLPSXUHLVRIUHFHQWRULJLQDQGQRW
IURPWKHHDUOJHQHUDWLRQVRIWKHFRPSDQLRQV
6DLG$QDV$JURXSRISHRSOHIURPWKHWULEHVRI8NXORU
8UDLQDFDPHWR0DGLQDKDQGEHFDPHLOOLQ
WKHLUVWRPDFK7KH3URSKHWRUGHUHGWKHPWRJHWDPLONLQJVKHFDPHODQGGULQNDPL[WXUHRILWVPLON
DQGXULQH7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLPDQGSRLQWVWRDFDPHO
VXULQHDV
EHLQJSXUH7KHUHIRUHEDQDORJRWKHUSHUPLVVLEOHDQLPDOV
XULQHPDDOVREHFRQVLGHUHGSXUH6DV
,EQ DO0XQ]KLU 7KRVH ZKR FODLP WKDW WKDW ZDV SHUPLVVLEOH RQO IRU WKRVH SHRSOH DUH LQFRUUHFW
6SHFLILFDWLRQLVRQO FRQILUPHGEVRPHVSHFLILFSURRI+HDOVRVDV7KHVFKRODUVSHUPLWZLWKRXW
DQREMHFWLRQWKHVDOHRIVKHHS
VVWRROVDQGWKHXVHRIFDPHO
VXULQHLQWKHLUPHGLFLQHERWKLQWKHSDVW
DQGLQWKHSUHVHQWDJDLQZLWKRXWDQREMHFWLRQ7KLVVKRZVWKDWWKH DUHFRQVLGHUHGSXUH6DVDVK
6KDXNDQL$SSDUHQWOWKHXULQHDQGVWRROVRIHYHUOLYLQJDQLPDOSHUPLVVLEOHWRHDWLVSXUH7KHUHLV
QRWKLQJWRSURYHRWKHUZLVH
)LTK-DOODODK
-DOODODKUHIHUVWRDQDQLPDOWKDWHDWVWKHZDVWHRUIOHVKRIRWKHUDQLPDOVVXFKDVFDPHOVFRZVVKHHS
FKLFNHQVJHHVHDQGVRRQ,EQ
$EEDVUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKIRUEDGHWKHGULQNLQJRI
VXFKDQLPDOV
PLON
7KLV KDGLWK LV UHODWHG E WKH ILYH H[FHSW IRU ,EQ0DMDK $W7LUPL]KL JUDGHV LW DV VDKLK ,Q RQH
QDUUDWLRQ LW VWDWHV ,WLVDOVRSURKLELWHGWRULGHXSRQDMDOODODK5HODWHGE$EX'DZXG
- 51. $PULEQ
6KX
DLE UHODWHG RQ WKH DXWKRULW RI KLV IDWKHU IURP KLV JUDQGIDWKHU WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK
SURKLELWHG WKHPHDW RIGRPHVWLF GRQNHV$V IRU WKH MDOODODK KH SURKLELWHG ULGLQJ RU HDWLQJ WKHP
5HODWHGE$KDPDGDQ1DVD
LDQG$EX'DZXG
- 53. $FFRUGLQJWRPRVWVFKRODUVDOFRKROLVLPSXUH6DV$OODKLQWKH4XU
DQ$OFRKROJDPHVRIFKDQFH
LGROVDQGGLYLQLQJDUURZVDUHRQODQLQIDPRI6DWDQ
VKDQGLZRUN6RPHVFKRODUVVDWKDWLWLVSXUH
IRUWKHWDNHWKHPHDQLQJRIUDMLVLQLWVDEVWUDFWVHQVHDVGHVFULELQJDOFRKRODQGZKDWHYHULVUHODWHGWR
LW7KLVLVQRWODEHOHGDVLPSXUHLQDGHILQLWHVHQVRUZD6DV$OODK6WDDZDIURPWKHLPSXULWLHV
RILGROV,GROVDUHLPSXUHLQWKHDEVWUDFWVHQVHDQGWKHDUHFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUHLIRQHWRXFKHVWKHP
7KH H[SODQDWLRQ RI WKH SUHFHGLQJ YHUVH LV WKDW WKH DUH D WRRO RI 6DWDQ IRU WKH FDXVH HQPLW DQG
KDWUHGDQGNHHSSHRSOHDZDIURPWKHUHPHPEUDQFHRI$OODKDQGSUDHU,Q6XEXODV6DODDPLWVDV
7KHLU RULJLQ LV SXUH DQG WKHLU EHLQJ SURKLELWHG GRHV QRWPHDQ WKDW WKH REMHFW LWVHOI LV LPSXUH )RU
H[DPSOH KDVKLVK LV SURKLELWHG EXW LW LV SXUH %XW VRPHWKLQJ LPSXUH LV QRW QHFHVVDULO SURKLELWHG
(YHU LPSXUH WKLQJ LV SURKLELWHG EXW QRW YLFHYHUVD 7KDW LV EHFDXVH RI WKH UXOLQJ WKDW VRPHWKLQJ
LPSXUHFDQQRWEHWRXFKHGXQGHUDQFLUFXPVWDQFHV,IDUXOLQJVDVWKDWVRPHWKLQJLVLPSXUHLWLVDOVR
SURKLELWHG7KLVGLIIHUVIURPDUXOLQJWKDWVRPHWKLQJLVSURKLELWHG)RUH[DPSOHLWLVIRUELGGHQWRZHDU
VLONDQGJROGEXWWKHDUHDEVROXWHOSXUHEFRQVHQVXV,IRQHXQGHUVWDQGVWKDWWKHQWKHSURKLELWLRQ
RIDOFRKROGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULOHQWDLOLWVDOVREHLQJFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUHLWQHHGVVRPHRWKHUHYLGHQFH
WRSURYHWKDWLWLVLPSXUH,IQRWWKHQZHDUHOHIWZLWKWKHRULJLQDOSRVLWLRQWKDWLWLVSXUH,IRQHFODLPV
RWKHUWKDQWKDWKHPXVWVXEVWDQWLDWHLW
)LTK3XULILQJWKHERGDQGFORWKHV
,IWKHFORWKHVRUERGDUHFRQWDPLQDWHGZLWKLPSXULWLHVLWLVREOLJDWRUWRZDVKWKHPZLWKZDWHUXQWLO
WKHDUHFOHDQVHGRIWKHLPSXULWLHV7KLVLVHVSHFLDOOWKHFDVHLIWKHLPSXULWLVYLVLEOHVXFKDVEORRG
,IWKHUHDUHVRPHVWDLQVWKDWUHPDLQDIWHUZDVKLQJZKLFKZRXOGEHH[WUHPHOGLIILFXOWWRUHPRYHWKH
FDQ EH RYHUORRNHG ,I WKHLPSXULWLVQRWYLVLEOHVXFKDVXULQHLWLVVXIILFLHQWWRZDVKLWRQHWLPH
$VPDELQW$EX%DNUUHODWHGWKDWDZRPDQFDPHWRWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGVDLG2XU
FORWKHVDUHFRQWDPLQDWHGZLWKPHQVWUXDOEORRG:KDWVKRXOGZHGRDERXWWKLV+HVDLG6FUDSHLW
UXELWZLWKZDWHUSRXUZDWHURYHULWDQGWKHQSUDLQLW7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
- 54. ,I
LPSXULWLHVJHWRQWKHORZHUSRUWLRQRIDZRPDQ
VGUHVVLWLVSXULILHGEGXVWDVVKHWUDLOVDORQJ$
ZRPDQ VDLG WR 8PP 6DODPDK , KDYH D ORQJ GUHVV WKDW GUDJV RQ WKH JURXQG HYHQ ZKHQ , ZDON
WKURXJK SODFHV WKDW FRQWDLQ ILOWK:KDW VKRXOG , GR DERXW LW 8PP 6DODPDK DQVZHUHG KHU 7KH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG
:KDWFRPHVDIWHULWSXULILHVLW
7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQG$EX'DZXG
)LTKD'RJV
'RJVDUHFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUH$QFRQWDLQHUWKDWDGRJKDVOLFNHGPXVWEHZDVKHGVHYHQWLPHVWKHILUVW
WLPH ZLWK GLUW $EX +XUDLUDK UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQDJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG
3XULILQJDFRQWDLQHUWKDWDGRJKDVOLFNHGLVGRQHEZDVKLQJLWVHYHQWLPHVWKHILUVWZDVKLQJEHLQJ
ZLWK GLUW WKDW LV ZDWHU PL[HG ZLWK GLUW XQWLO LW EHFRPHV PXGG
- 55. 7KLV ZDV UHODWHG E0XVOLP
$KPDG$EX'DZXGDQGDO%DLKDTL,IDGRJOLFNVDSRWWKDWKDVGUIRRGLQLWZKDWLWWRXFKHGDQG
ZKDWVXUURXQGVLWPXVWEHWKURZQDZD7KHUHPDLQGHUPDEHNHSWDVLWLVVWLOOSXUH$VIRUDGRJ
V
IXULWLVFRQVLGHUHGSXUH
)LTK3XULILQJWKHJURXQG
,IWKHUHDUHLPSXULWLHVRQWKHJURXQGLWLVSXULILHGESRXULQJZDWHURYHULW7KLVLVSURYHQE$EX
+XUDLUDK
V KDGLWKPHQWLRQHG HDUOLHU DERXW WKH EHGRXLQZKR XULQDWHG LQ WKHPRVTXH 7KH 3URSKHW
XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLGDOOWKDWQHHGHG WREHGRQHIRUSXULILFDWLRQZDVWRSRXUZDWHURYHULW6DLG
$EX4XODEDK 7KH GULQJ RI WKH JURXQG LV LWV SXULILFDWLRQ
$LVKDK VDLG 7KH SXULILFDWLRQ RI WKH
JURXQGLVLWVEHFRPLQJGU5HODWHGE,EQ$EL6KDLEDK
- 58. RXUFODULILHGEXWWHU7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDUL
RPPHQWLQJ RQ WKH VXEMHFW DO+DIH]K ,EQ +DMU VDV ,EQ
$EGXO %DUU UHSRUWHG WKDW WKHUH LV
DJUHHPHQWWKDWLIDGHDGDQLPDOIDOOVLQWRDVROLGPDWWHUZKDWWKHGHDGDQLPDOWRXFKHVDQGZKDWLV
DURXQGLWPXVWEHWKURZQDZDSURYLGHGWKDWRQHFDQPDNHVXUHWKDWWKHDQLPDOGLGQRWWRXFKWKH
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
- 60. )LTKD3XULILQJPLUURUVDQGVLPLODUREMHFWV
0LUURUVNQLYHVVZRUGVQDLOVERQHVJODVVSDLQWHGSRWVDQGRWKHUVPRRWKVXUIDFHVWKDWKDYHQRSRUHV
DUH SXULILHG E VLPSO ZLSLQJ WKHP DQG UHPRYLQJ DQ LPSXUH UHPDLQV 7KH FRPSDQLRQV RI WKH
3URSKHWXVHGWRSUDZKLOHZHDULQJVZRUGVVPHDUHGZLWKEORRGDQGWKHXVHGWRMXVWZLSHWKHVZRUGV
WRSXULIWKHP
)LTKE3XULILQJVKRHV
6KRHVPDEHSXULILHGEUXEELQJWKHPDJDLQVWWKHJURXQGDVORQJDVWKHUHPDLQVRIWKHLPSXULWDUH
UHPRYHG$EX+XUDLUDKQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG,IRQHRI
RXVWHSSHGLQVRPHILOWKWKHGLUWZLOOSXULIKLVVKRHV5HODWHGE$EX'DZXG,QDQRWKHUQDUUDWLRQ
LWVWDWHV,IRQHRIRXVWHSVLQVRPHILOWKZLWKKLVVKRHVRQWKHGLUWZLOOSXULIWKHP$EX6D
HHG
UHSRUWHGWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLQJ:KHQDSHUVRQFRPHVWRWKHPRVTXHKHVKRXOG
ORRNDWKLVVKRHV,IKHILQGVDQILOWKRQWKHPKHVKRXOGZLSHWKHPDJDLQVWWKHJURXQGDQGSUDLQ
WKHP 5HODWHG E $KPDG DQG $EX 'DZXG
- 61. 6LQFH VKRHV DUH UHSHDWHGO H[SRVHG WR ILOWK LW LV
VXIILFLHQWMXVWWRZLSHWKHPDJDLQVWWKHJURXQG7KLVLVVLPLODUWRWKHFDVHRIGHIHFDWLRQ,QIDFWLWLV
VWURQJHUWKDQWKDWFDVHDVGHIHFDWLRQXVXDOORFFXUVRQOWZRRUWKUHHWLPHVDGD
)LTKF8VHIXOSRLQWVWKDWDUHJUHDWOQHHGHGFRQFHUQLQJSXULILFDWLRQ
5RSH XVHG IRU KDQJLQJ FORWKHV ZLWK LPSXULWLHV RQ WKHPPD DIWHUZDUGV EH XVHG IRU KDQJLQJ SXUH
FORWKHV
,IDOLTXLGIDOOVRQDSHUVRQDQGKHGRHVQRWNQRZLILWZDVZDWHURUXULQHKHQHHGQRWLQTXLUHDERXWLW
,I KH GRHV LQTXLUH WKH RQHZKR LV DVNHG QHHG QRW DQVZHU KLP HYHQ LI KH NQRZV WKDW WKH OLTXLG LV
LPSXUH,QWKDWFDVHWKHSHUVRQQHHGQRWZDVKKLVFORWKHV
,IDSHUVRQILQGVVRPHWKLQJPRLVWRQKLVERGRUFORWKHVDWQLJKWDQGKHGRHVQRWNQRZZKDWLWLVKH
QHHGQRWVPHOOLWWRGLVFRYHUZKDWLWPLJKWEH,WLVUHODWHGWKDW
8PDUSDVVHGEDJXWWHUDQGJRWZHW
- 62. 8PDU
V FRPSDQLRQ DVNHG WKHRZQHU RI WKH JXWWHU LI WKH ZDWHU ZDV SXUH RU LPSXUH
8PDU WROG WKH
RZQHUQRWWRDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQDQGZHQWRQKLVZD
ORWKHVWKDWKDYHVWUHHWPXGRQ WKHPQHHGQRWEHZDVKHG5HSRUWHG.DPDOLEQ=LDG,VDZ
$OL
ZDGLQJWKURXJKWKHPXGDIWHUZKLFKKHHQWHUHGWKHPRVTXHDQGSUDHGZLWKRXWZDVKLQJKLVOHJV
,IDSHUVRQILQLVKHVKLVSUDHUDQGVHHVVRPHLPSXULWLHVRQKLVFORWKHVRUERGRIZKLFKKHZDV QRW
SUHYLRXVODZDUHRUKHZDVDZDUHRIWKHPEXWIRUJRWDERXWWKHPRUKHGLGQRWIRUJHWDERXWWKHPEXW
KHZDVQRWDEOHWRUHPRYHWKHPWKHQKLVSUDHULVVWLOOYDOLGDQGKHQHHGQRWUHSHDWLW7KLVRSLQLRQLV
VXSSRUWHG E $OODK
V VWDWHPHQW $QG WKHUH LV QR VLQ IRU RX LQ WKH PLVWDNHV RX PDNH
XQLQWHQWLRQDOODO$K]DE
- 67. D WSH RI ZHDN KDGLWK KDYLQJ D GHIHFW
- 74. ZDV
XULQDWLQJ 7KH 3URSKHW GLG QRW UHWXUQ KLV JUHHWLQJ 7KLV LV UHODWHG E WKH JURXS H[FHSW IRU DO
%XNKDUL
- 75. $EX6D
HHGUHSRUWHGWKDWKHKHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVD,VQ
W
LW WUXH WKDW$OODK GHWHVWV WKRVHZKR FRQYHUVH ZKLOH WKH UHOLHYH WKHPVHOYHV 7KLV ZDV UHODWHG E
$KPDG$EX'DZXGDQG,EQ0DMDK
7KLVKDGLWKVHHPVWRVXSSRUWWKHSRVLWLRQWKDWLWLVIRUELGGHQWRWDON0DQVFKRODUVKRZHYHUVDWKDW
LWLVRQOGLVOLNHGQRWIRUELGGHQ
)LTK2QHVKRXOGQHLWKHU IDFHQRUWXUQKLVEDFNRQWKHTLEODKZKLOHUHOLHYLQJKLPVHOI
$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KHQRQHRIRX
UHOLHYHVKLPVHOIKHVKRXOGQHLWKHUIDFHWKHTLEODKQRUWXUQKLVEDFNRQLW7KLVZDVUHODWHGE$KPDG
DQG0XVOLP
7KHSURKLELWLRQLPSOLHVWKDWLWLVRQOGLVOLNHG$V,EQ
8PDUUHODWHGWKDWKHRQFHZHQWWR+DIVDK
V
KRPHZKHUHKHVDZWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKUHOLHYLQJKLPVHOIZKLOHIDFLQJ6ULDZLWKKLVEDFNWRWKH
.D
EDK7KLVLVUHODWHGEWKHJURXS 6RPHUHFRQFLOLDWHWKHVHKDGLWKEVDLQJWKDWLQWKHGHVHUWLWLV
IRUELGGHQWRIDFHRUWXUQRQH
VEDFNRQWKH.D
EDKZKLOHLWLVSHUPLWWHGLQEXLOGLQJV6DLG0DUZDQDO
$VJKDU,VDZ
8PDUVLWWLQJRQKLVVKHFDPHODQGIDFLQJWKHTLEODKZKLOHXULQDWLQJ, VDLG
2IDWKHU
RI
$EGXUDKPDQLVWKLVQRWIRUELGGHQ
+HVDLG
HUWDLQOQRW7KLVKDVEHHQSURKLELWHGRQOLQ
RSHQDUHDV,IWKHUHLVDEDUULFDGHRUVHSDUDWRU
- 76. EHWZHHQRXDQGWKHTLEODKWKHUHLVQRWKLQJZURQJ
ZLWKLW
7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EX'DZXG,EQ.KX]DLPDKDQGDO+DNLP,WVFKDLQLVKDVVDQDV,EQ+DMUVDLGLQ
)DWKDO%DUL
)LTKD2QHVKRXOGVHHNDVRIWDQGORZSLHFHRIJURXQGWRSURWHFWKLPVHOIIURPLPSXULWLHV
$EX0XVDUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKFDPHWRDORZDQGVRIWSDUW RIWKHJURXQGDQGXULQDWHG
+HWKHQVDLG:KHQRQHRIRXXULQDWHVKHVKRXOGFKRRVHWKHSURSHUSODFHWRGRVR
7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQG$EX'DZXG2QHRILWVQDUUDWRUVLVXQNQRZQEXWLWVPHDQLQJLVVRXQG
)LTKE2QHVKRXOGQRWXVHDKROHLQWKHJURXQG
4DWDGDKUHODWHGIURP
$EGXOODKLEQ6DUMDVZKRVDLG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKIRUEDGHXULQDWLRQLQWRD
KROH6DLG4DWDGDK:KDWLVGLVOLNHGDERXWXULQDWLQJLQWRDKROH6DLGKH,WLVWKHUHVLGHQFHRIWKH
MLQQ
7KLV KDGLWK LV UHODWHG E$KPDG DQ1DVD
L$EX'DZXG DO+DNLP DQG DO%DLKDTL ,EQ.KX]DLPDK
DQG,EQDV6DNLQFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
)LTKF2QHVKRXOGDYRLGVKDGHGSODFHVDQGWKRVHSODFHVZKHUHSHRSOHZDONDQGJDWKHU
$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG%HZDUHRIWKRVHDFWV
ZKLFKFDXVHRWKHUVWRFXUVH7KHDVNHG:KDWDUHWKRVHDFWV+HVDLG5HOLHYLQJRXUVHOILQWKH
SHRSOH
VZDONZDVRULQWKHLUVKDGH7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDG0XVOLPDQG$EX'DZXG
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
- 78. ,Q 0DMPD D]=XZDLG LW VWDWHV 7KLV ZDV UHODWHG E DW7DEDUDQL DQG LWV
QDUUDWRUVDUHWUXVWZRUWK
,IWKHUHLVDGUDLQLQWKHEDWKLQJSODFHLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRXULQDWHLQWRLW
)LTKD2QHPDQRWXULQDWHZKLOHVWDQGLQJ
,IDSHUVRQFDQJXDUDQWHHWKDWQRLPSXULWLHVZLOOWRXFKKLVFORWKHVLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRXULQDWHZKLOH
VWDQGLQJ 6DLG
$LVKDK ,I VRPHRQH UHODWHV WR RX WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XULQDWHG ZKLOH
VWDQGLQJ GR QRW EHOLHYH KLP+H RQO XULQDWHG ZKLOH VLWWLQJ 7KLV KDGLWK LV UHODWHG E WKH ILYH
H[FHSWIRU$EX'DZXG$W7LUPL]KL
VFRPPHQWLV,WLVWKHEHVWWKLQJUHODWHGRQWKLVSRLQWDQGLWLV
WKHPRVWDXWKHQWLF
2QH VKRXOG QRW IRUJHW WKDW ZKDW
$LVKDK VDLG LV EDVHG RQ WKH NQRZOHGJH WKDW VKH KDG+X]KDLIDK
UHODWHVWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZHQWWRDSXEOLFJDUEDJHGXPSDQGXULQDWHG
ZKLOH VWDQGLQJ +X]KDLIDK ZHQW DZD DQG WKH 3URSKHW WKHQ FDOOHG KLP RYHU 7KH 3URSKHW PDGH
DEOXWLRQDQGZLSHGRYHUKLVVKRHV7KLVLVUHODWHGEWKHJURXS
RPPHQWLQJ XSRQ WKH LVVXH DQ1DZDZL VDV 7R XULQDWH ZKLOH VLWWLQJ LV PRVW GHVLUDEOH LQ P
RSLQLRQ EXW WR GR VR VWDQGLQJ LV SHUPLVVLEOH %RWK DFWV DUH FRQILUPHG E WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK
XSRQZKRPEHSHDFH
)LTKE2QHPXVWUHPRYHDQLPSXULWLHVIURPKLVFORWKHVDQGERG
7RGRVRKHFDQXVHDURFNVWRQHRUDQRWKHUSXUHPDWWHU2QHPDXVHRQOZDWHUWRFOHDQWKHDUHD
RUDQFRPELQDWLRQVRISXULILQJDJHQWV
$LVKDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEH
SHDFH VDLG:KHQ RQH RI RX JRHV WR UHOLHYH KLPVHOIKHVKRXOGFOHDQKLPVHOIZLWKWKUHHVWRQHV
5HODWHGE$KPDGDQ1DVD
L$EX'DZXGDQGDG'DUDTXWQL
- 82. $QDV DOVR UHODWHG WKH 3URSKHW DV VDLQJ 3XULI RXUVHOYHV IURP XULQH DVPRVW SXQLVKPHQW LQ WKH
JUDYHLVGXHWRLW
)LTK2QHVKRXOGQRWFOHDQKLPVHOIZLWKKLVULJKWKDQG
$EGXUDKPDQ LEQ =DLG UHODWHG WKDW 6DOPDQZDV DVNHG RXU3URSKHW WHDFKHV RX HYHUWKLQJ HYHQ
KRZ WR UHOLHYH RXUVHOYHV 6DOPDQ VDLG HUWDLQO +H IRUEDGHXVIURPIDFLQJWKHTLEODKZKLOH
GRLQJ VR IURP FOHDQLQJ RXUVHOYHV ZLWK RXU ULJKW KDQG DQG IURP FOHDQLQJ RXUVHOYHV ZLWK OHVV WKDQ
WKUHHVWRQHV:HDOVRVKRXOGQRWXVHDQLPSXUHVXEVWDQFHRUDERQHWRFOHDQRXUVHOYHV5HODWHGE
0XVOLP$EX'DZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL
- 93. ,W GRHV QRW PHQWLRQ ZKLFK RQH ZRXOG VSHFLILFDOO IXOILOO WKH
VXQQDK2QH VKRXOGPDNH VXUH WKDW KLVPRXVWDFKH LV QRW VR ORQJ WKDW IRRGSDUWLFOHVGULQNDQGGLUW
DFFXPXODWHLQLW=DLGLEQ$UTDPUHODWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KRHYHUGRHV
QRWWDNHRII
- 106. 7KHUH DUH VRPH QDUUDWLRQV WKDW VWDWH WKDW GLQJ LV GLVOLNHG EXW LW LV REYLRXV WKDW WKHVH QDUUDWLRQV
FRQIOLFWZLWKWKHVXQQDKDQGFXVWRP,WLVUHODWHGIURPVRPHRIWKHFRPSDQLRQVWKDWLWLVEHWWHUQRWWR
GHZKLOHRWKHUVVDLWLVEHWWHUWRGRLW6RPHXVHGDHOORZGHZKLOHRWKHUVXVHGKHQQDRUNDWP
2WKHUVXVHGVDIIURQDQGDJURXSRIWKHPXVHGDEODFNGH,EQ+DMUPHQWLRQHGLQ)DWKDO%DULWKDWD]
=XKULVDLG:HXVHGEODFNGHLIRXUIDFHZDVRXWKIXOEXWLIZULQNOHVZHUHSUHVHQWDQGWKHWHHWK
ZHUH JRQHZHZRXOG QRW XVH LW 6DLG -DELU$EX4XKDIDK$EX%DNU
VIDWKHU
- 107. ZDVEURXJKWWRWKH
3URSKHW GXULQJ WKH FRQTXHVW RI0DNNDK ZKLOH KLV KHDG ZDV ZKLWH 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQZKRP EH
SHDFHVDLG7DNHKLPWRRQHRIKLVZLYHVDQGOHWKHUFKDQJHWKHFRORURIKLVKDLUZLWKVRPHWKLQJEXW
VKH VKRXOG DYRLG PDNLQJ KLV KDLU
- 117. 7KHRQVHQVXV 7KHUH LV D FRQVHQVXV RI VFKRODUO RSLQLRQ WKDW DEOXWLRQ LV SDUW RI ,VODPLF ODZ
7KHUHIRUHLWLVDUHFRJQL]HGIDFWRIWKHUHOLJLRQ
)LTKE,WVYLUWXHV
0DQKDGLWKVWDWHWKHYLUWXHVRIDEOXWLRQ:HVKDOOPHQWLRQMXVWDIHZ
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
- 121. EZKLFK
$OODK HUDVHV VLQV DQG UDLVHV GHJUHHV 7KH VDLG HUWDLQO 2 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK +H VDLG
3HUIHFWLQJWKHDEOXWLRQXQGHUGLIILFXOWFLUFXPVWDQFHVWDNLQJPDQVWHSVWRWKHPRVTXHDQGZDLWLQJ
IRU WKH QH[W
- 123. SUDHU KDV EHHQ SHUIRUPHG 7KDW LV ULEDW 5HODWHG E0DOLN
0XVOLPDW7LUPL]KLDQGDQ1DVD
L
- 130. )LTKE:DVKLQJWKHIDFH
7KLVLQYROYHVSRXULQJRUUXQQLQJZDWHUIURPWKHWRSRIWKHIRUHKHDGWRWKHERWWRPRIWKHMDZVDQG
IURPRQHHDUWRWKHRWKHU
)LTKF:DVKLQJWKHDUPVWRWKHHOERZ
7KHHOERZVPXVWEHZDVKHGIRUWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGLGVR
)LTKG:LSLQJWKHKHDG
7KLVPHDQVWRZLSHRQH
VKHDGZLWKKLVKDQG,WLVQRWVXIILFLHQWMXVWWRSODFHWKHKDQGRQWKHKHDGRU
WRWRXFKWKHKHDGZLWKDZHWILQJHU7KHDSSDUHQW PHDQLQJRIWKH4XU
DQLFZRUGVDQGZLSHRYHU
RXU KHDGV GRHV QRW LPSO WKDW DOO RI WKH KHDG QHHGV WR EH ZLSHG ,W KDV EHHQ UHFRUGHG WKDW WKH
3URSKHWXVHGWRZLSHKLVKHDGWKUHHGLIIHUHQWZDV
:LSLQJDOORIKLVKHDG
$EGXOODKLEQ=DLGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZLSHG
KLVHQWLUHKHDGZLWKKLVKDQGV+HVWDUWHGZLWKWKHIURQWRIKLVKHDGWKHQPRYHGWRWKHEDFNDQGWKHQ
UHWXUQHGKLVKDQGVWRWKHIURQW5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
- 131. :LSLQJ RYHU WKH WXUEDQ RQO 6DLG
$PUX LEQ8PDDK , VDZ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQ
ZKRP EH SHDFH ZLSH RYHU KLV WXUEDQ DQG VKRHV 5HODWHG E$KPDG DO%XNKDUL DQG ,EQ0DMDK
- 135. 7KHUHLV
KRZHYHU QR VWURQJ KDGLWKWKDW KH ZLSHG RYHU SDUW RI KLV KHDG HYHQ WKRXJK DO0D
LGDK DSSDUHQWO
LPSOLHVLW,WLVDOVRQRWVXIILFLHQWMXVWWRZLSHRYHUORFNVRIKDLUWKDWSURFHHGIURPWKHKHDGRUDORQJ
WKHVLGHVRIWKHKHDG
)LTK:DVKLQJWKHIHHWDQGWKHKHHOV
7KLVKDVEHHQFRQILUPHGLQPXWDZDWLUFRQWLQXRXV
- 138. )LTKD)ROORZLQJWKHSUHVFULEHGVHTXHQFH
$OODKPHQWLRQHGWKHREOLJDWLRQVLQDVSHFLILFRUGHU+HDOVRGLIIHUHQWLDWHGWKHOHJVIURPWKHKDQGV
WKRXJKERWKRIWKHPKDYHWREHZDVKHGIURPWKHKHDGZKLFKRQOQHHGVWREHZLSHG7KHSROWKHLVWV
RI $UDELDZRXOG QRW GLIIHUHQWLDWH LWHPV XQOHVV WKHUHZDV VRPH EHQHILW LQ GRLQJ VR 7KHZD$OODK
VWUXFWXUHG WKH DEOXWLRQ PDGH LW HDVLHU IRU WKHP WR FRPSUHKHQG LW $O0D
LGDK H[SODLQV ZKDW LV
REOLJDWRUDQGLWIDOOVXQGHUWKHJHQHUDOLWRIWKH3URSKHW
VVWDWHPHQW%HJLQZLWKZKDW$OODKEHJDQ
ZLWK 7KH 3URSKHW XVHG WR IROORZ WKDW VHTXHQFH DV RQH RI DEOXWLRQ
V SULQFLSOHV 7KHUH LV QR VXFK
UHSRUWWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHHYHUGHSDUWHGIURPWKDWVHTXHQFH$EOXWLRQLVSDUWRI
ZRUVKLS DQG LQ PDWWHUV RI ZRUVKLS WKHUH LV QR URRP IRU DQWKLQJ H[FHSW GRLQJ ZKDW KDV EHHQ
FRPPDQGHG
)LTKF
7KLVVHFWLRQGHDOVZLWKWKRVHDFWVFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHDEOXWLRQEXWZKLFKDUHQRWREOLJDWRUDVWKH
3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGLGQRWULJRURXVOVWLFNWRWKHPRUFHQVXUHDQRQHIRUQRWGRLQJWKHP
7KHDUHDVIROORZV
)LTK0HQWLRQLQJWKHQDPHRI$OODKDWWKHEHJLQQLQJ
7KHUHDUHVRPHZHDNKDGLWKWKDWPHQWLRQWKLVDFWDQGDOORIWKHFKDLQVRIWKHVHKDGLWKSRLQWWRWKHIDFW
WKDWWKHUHLVVRPHEDVLVIRUWKLVDFW,QDQFDVHLWLVDJRRGDFWLQDQGRILWVHOIDQGLQJHQHUDOLWLV
SDUWRIWKH,VODPLFODZ
)LTKD'HQWDO+JLHQH
7KLVLQYROYHVXVLQJDVWLFNRUVLPLODUREMHFWWRFOHDQRQH
VWHHWK7KHEHVWWSHWRXVHLVWKDWRIWKHDUDN
WUHHIRXQGLQWKH+HMD]6XFKDSUDFWLFHVWUHQJWKHQVWKHJXPVSUHYHQWVWRRWKGLVHDVHKHOSVGLJHVWLRQ
DQGIDFLOLWDWHVWKHIORZRIXULQH7KLVVXQQDKLVIXOILOOHGEXVLQJDQREMHFWZKLFKUHPRYHVHOORZ
VWDLQVRQWKHWHHWKDQGFOHDQVWKHPRXWKVXFKDVDWRRWKEUXVKDQGVRRQ$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDW
WKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:HUHLWQRWWREHDKDUGVKLSRQPFRPPXQLW,ZRXOGKDYH
RUGHUHGWKHPWRXVHDWRRWKEUXVKIRUHYHUDEOXWLRQ5HODWHGE0DOLNDVK6KDI
L DO%DLKDTLDQGDO
+DNLP
- 142. :KHQ RQH XVHV D WRRWKEUXVK LW LV VXQQDK WR FOHDQ LW DIWHUZDUGV 6DLG
$LVKDK:KHQ WKH3URSKHW
XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGKLVWRRWKEUXVKKHZRXOGJLYHLWWRPH,ZRXOGZDVKLWXVHLWZDVKLW
DJDLQDQGJLYHLWEDFNWRKLP5HODWHGE$EX'DZXGDQGDO%DLKDTL
- 143. ,W LV SDUW RI WKH VXQQDK WKDW RQHZKR KDV QR WHHWK PD XVH KLV ILQJHUV WR FOHDQ KLVPRXWK$VNHG
$LVKDK20HVVHQJHURI$OODKKRZVKRXOGDWRRWKOHVVSHUVRQFOHDQVHKLVPRXWK%SXWWLQJKLV
ILQJHUVLQWRKLVPRXWKKHUHSOLHG5HODWHGEDW7DEDUDQL
- 145. $EX+XUDLUDK
UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG :KHQ RQH RI RX ULVHV IURP KLV VOHHS KH
VKRXOGQRWSXWKLVKDQGLQWRDSRWXQWLOKHKDVZDVKHGLWWKUHHWLPHVIRUKHGRHVQRWNQRZZKHUHKLV
KDQGZDVZKLOHKHVOHSW
- 158. ,W LV DOVR UHODWHG WKDW LW LV
SUHIHUDEOH WR UHPRYH MHZHOU IRU H[DPSOH ULQJV EUDFHOHWV DQG VR RQ ZKLOH SHUIRUPLQJ DEOXWLRQ
(YHQ WKRXJK WKHVH UHSRUWV DUH QRW DFFHSWHG DV IXOO DXWKHQWLF RQHPXVW IROORZ WKHP IRU WKH IDOO
XQGHUWKHJHQHUDOFDWHJRURIFRPSOHWLQJ DQGSHUIHFWLQJWKHDEOXWLRQ
)LTKE5HSHDWLQJHDFKZDVKLQJWKUHHWLPHV
7KLV LV D VXQQDK WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH DOPRVW DOZDV IROORZHG ,I KH DFWHG
RWKHUZLVH LW ZDV MXVW WR VKRZ WKDW WKH RWKHU DFWV DUH SHUPLVVLEOH
$PU LEQ 6KX
DLE UHODWHG RQ WKH
DXWKRULWRIKLVIDWKHUIURPKLVJUDQGIDWKHUZKRVDLG$EHGRXLQFDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK
XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGDVNHGKLPDERXWWKHDEOXWLRQ+HVKRZHGKLPKRZWRZDVKHDFKSDUWWKUHH
WLPHVDQGVDLG
7KLVLVWKHDEOXWLRQ:KRHYHUGRHVPRUHWKDQWKDWKDVGRQHZURQJWUDQVJUHVVHGDQG
FRPPLWWHG HYLO 5HODWHG E $KPDG DQ1DVD
L DQG ,EQ 0DMDK
- 160. 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK ZRXOG UHSHDW HDFK ZDVKLQJ WKUHH WLPHV 5HODWHG E $KPDG 0XVOLP DQG DW
7LUPL]KL
- 163. $EX
+XUDLUDK UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW VDLG:KHQ RX FORWKH RUZDVK RXUVHOI EHJLQ ZLWK RXU ULJKW
VLGH5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDW7LUPL]KLDQGDQ1DVD
L
- 164. )LTK5XEELQJWKHOLPEVZLWKZDWHU
7KLVPHDQV WR UXE WKH KDQGV RYHU WKH ERGLO SDUWVZLWKZDWHU
$EGXOODKLEQ=DLGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZDVEURXJKWDSRWRIZDWHUZKLFKKHXVHGWRSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQDQGWKHQUXEEHG
KLV DUPV 5HODWHG E ,EQ .KX]DLPDK
- 165. +H DOVR UHODWHG WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK SHUIRUPHG
DEOXWLRQ WKHQ UXEEHG KLV OLPEV 5HODWHG E$EX'DZXG DW7DDOLVL$KPDG ,EQ+LEEDQ DQG$EX
D
OD
- 167. 7KLVLVWKHFXVWRPDUSUDFWLFHRI
WKHHDUODQGODWHUJHQHUDWLRQVRI0XVOLPV
)LTKE:LSLQJWKHHDUV
7KHVXQQDKLVWRZLSHWKHLQWHULRURIWKHHDUVZLWKWKHLQGH[ILQJHUVDQGWKHH[WHULRUSRUWLRQVZLWKWKH
WKXPEV7KHZDWHUXVHGWRZLSHWKHKHDGLVDOVRXVHGIRUWKHHDUVDVWKHHDUVDUHSDUWRIWKHKHDG$O
0LTGDPLEQ0D
GDNULKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZLSHGKLVKHDGDQGKLVHDUV
WKHLQWHULRUDQGH[WHULRUZKLOHPDNLQJDEOXWLRQ+HDOVRSXWKLVILQJHULQVLGHKLVHDU5HODWHGE$EX
'DZXGDQGDW7DKDZL
- 170. ,W DOVR UHIHUV WR
ZDVKLQJDERYHWKHHOERZVDQGDQNOHV$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG0
QDWLRQZLOOFRPHZLWKEULJKWVWUHDNVRIOLJKWIURPWKHWUDFHVRIDEOXWLRQ$EX+XUDLUDKWKHQVDLG,I
RQHFDQOHQJWKHQKLVVWUHDNRIOLJKWKHVKRXOGGRVR5HODWHGE$KPDGDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
- 181. 6DVDO%XNKDUL7KHVFKRODUV GRQRWOLNHRQHWRXVHZDWHUEHRQGZKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEH
SHDFHXVHGIRUDEOXWLRQ
)LTK6XSSOLFDWLRQZKLOHSHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ
7KHUHLVQRWKLQJFRQILUPHGIURPWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHUHJDUGLQJVXSSOLFDWLRQVGXULQJ
DEOXWLRQVDYHWKHKDGLWKRI$EX0XVDDO$VK
DULZKRVDLG,FDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZLWK
ZDWHU:KLOHKHZDVSHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ,KHDUGKLPVXSSOLFDWH
2$OODKIRUJLYHPVLQV0DNHP
UHVLGHQFH VSDFLRXV IRUPH DQG EOHVVPH LQP SURYLVLRQV
, VDLG
23URSKHWRI$OODK,KHDUGRX
VXSSOLFDWLQJ VXFK DQG VXFK
+H VDLG
'LG , OHDYH DQWKLQJ RXW 5HODWHGEDQ1DVD
LDQG,EQDV
6XQQLZLWKDVDKLKFKDLQ
- 186. 8TEDK LEQ
$DPU UHODWHG WKDW WKH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG,IRQHSHUIRUPVDQGSHUIHFWVKLVDEOXWLRQDQGSUDV
WZR UDN
DK ZLWK KLV KHDUW DQG IDFH FRPSOHWHO RQ KLV SUDHU
- 188. .KXPUDQWKHFOLHQWRI
8WKPDQ
DGGHG,VDZ
8WKPDQFDOOIRUZDWHUIRUDEOXWLRQSRXULWIURPWKHSRWRQWRKLVULJKWKDQGDQGZDVKLW
WKUHH WLPHV+H WKHQ SXW KLV ULJKW KDQG LQWR WKH FRQWDLQHUULQVHGKLVPRXWKDQGQRVHDQGEOHZWKH
ZDWHU RXW 7KHQ KHZDVKHG KLV IDFH WKUHH WLPHV IROORZHG E KLV DUPV XS WR WKH HOERZV 7KHQ KH
ZDVKHG KLV IHHW WKUHH WLPHV DQG VDLG
, VDZ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH PDNH
DEOXWLRQ OLNH WKLV
$QG WKHQ KHZRXOG VD
:KRHYHU PDNHV DEOXWLRQ OLNH WKLV DQG WKHQ SUDV WZR
UDN
DKZLWKRXWKDYLQJDQRWKHUFRQFHUQRQKLVPLQGDOOKLVSDVWVLQVZLOOEHIRUJLYHQ5HODWHGE
DO%XNKDUL0XVOLPDQGRWKHUV
- 193. UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK VDLG $OODK GRHV QRW DFFHSW WKH SUDHU RI D SHUVRQZKR KDV
UHOHDVHGJDVXQWLOKHPDNHVDQHZDEOXWLRQ$SHUVRQIURP+D]KUDPDXWDVNHG$EX+XUDLUDK:KDW
GRHVUHOHDVLQJJDVPHDQ+HDQVZHUHG:LQGZLWKRUZLWKRXWVRXQG5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG
0XVOLP
- 196. WKH 3URSKHW VDLG 0DNH
DEOXWLRQRQFHUQLQJVSHUPRUDOPDQLVDLG,EQ
$EEDV,WUHTXLUHVJKXVODQGIRUDOPD]KLDQGDO
ZDGLZDVKRXUVH[RUJDQVDQGPDNHDEOXWLRQ7KLVZDVUHODWHGEDO%DLKDTLLQKLV6XQDQ
)LTKE'HHSVOHHSWKDWPDNHVDSHUVRQFRPSOHWHOXQDZDUHRIKLVVXUURXQGLQJV
,IWKHSHUVRQGLGQRWNHHSKLVERWWRFNVILUPOVHDWHGRQWKHIORRUZKLOHVOHHSLQJKHPXVWPDNHDQHZ
DEOXWLRQ6DIZDQLEQ
$VDOVDLG7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGWRRUGHUXVZKLOHZHZHUH
WUDYHOOLQJ QRW WR WDNH RXU VRFNV RII XQOHVV ZH ZHUH LQ SRVWVH[ LPSXULW LH QRW IRU GHIHFDWLRQ
XULQDWLRQ RU VOHHS
- 198. ,I RQH
V
EXWWRFNV KDV UHPDLQHG ILUPO RQ WKH IORRU GXULQJ KLV VOHHS QR QHZ DEOXWLRQ LV QHFHVVDU 7KLV LV
LPSOLHGEWKHKDGLWKRI$QDVZKRVDLG7KHFRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHWZHUHZDLWLQJIRUWKHGHODHG
QLJKWSUDHUXQWLOWKHLUKHDGVEHJDQQRGGLQJXSDQGGRZQIURPGURZVLQHVVDQGVOHHS
- 199. 7KHZRXOG
WKHQ SUD ZLWKRXW SHUIRUPLQJ DEOXWLRQ 5HODWHG E DVK6KDLIL 0XVOLP $EX 'DZXG DQG DW
7LUPL]KL
- 200. 7KH ZRUGLQJ WKDW DW7LUPL]KL UHFRUGHG IURP WKH FKDLQ RI 6KX
EDK LV , KDYH VHHQ WKH
FRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHWVOHHSLQJWRWKHH[WHQWWKDWRQHFRXOGKHDUVRPHRIWKHPVQRULQJ%XWWKH
ZRXOGVWDQGIRUSUDHUZLWKRXWDQHZDEOXWLRQ6DLG,EQDO0XEDUDN,QRXURSLQLRQWKLVKDSSHQHG
ZKHQWKHZHUHVLWWLQJ
)LTK/RVVRIFRQVFLRXVQHVV
7KLV QXOOLILHV WKH DEOXWLRQ UHJDUGOHVV RIZKHWKHU LWZDVRZLQJ WRLQVDQLWIDLQWLQJGUXQNHQQHVVRU
VRPHPHGLFLQH,WDOVRGRHVQRWPDWWHULIRQHZDVXQFRQVFLRXVIRUDVKRUWRUORQJSHULRGRIWLPHRULI
RQHZDVVLWWLQJRUIHOOWRWKHHDUWKDQGVRRQ7KHDVSHFWRIXQDZDUHQHVVKHUHLVJUHDWHUWKDQWKDWRI
VOHHSLQJ7KHVFKRODUVDUHDJUHHGRQWKLVSRLQW
)LTKD7RXFKLQJWKHVH[XDORUJDQZLWKRXWDQEDUULHUEHWZHHQWKHKDQGDQGWKH RUJDQ
%XVUDK ELQW 6DIZDQ QDUUDWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG :KRHYHU WRXFKHV KLV
VH[XDORUJDQFDQQRWSUDXQWLOKHSHUIRUPVDEOXWLRQ
7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLKDQGDO%XNKDULFDOOHGLWWKHPRVW
DXWKHQWLFUHSRUWRQWKDWWRSLF0DOLNDVK6KDLIL$KPDGDQGRWKHUVDOVRQDUUDWHGLW$EX'DZXGVDLG
, DVNHG $KPDG
,V WKH KDGLWK RI %XVUDK DXWKHQWLF
+H VDLG
HUWDLQO LW LV DXWKHQWLF ,Q WKH
QDUUDWLRQRI$KPDGDQGDQ1DVD
L%XVUDKKHDUGWKH3URSKHWVDLQJ$EOXWLRQLVWREHPDGHEWKH
RQH ZKR WRXFKHV KLV VH[XDO RUJDQ 7KLV LV JHQHUDO DQG HQFRPSDVVHV WRXFKLQJ RQH
V RZQ VH[XDO
RUJDQVRUWRXFKLQJVRPHERGHOVH
V$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKH3URSKHWDVVDLQJ:KRHYHUWRXFKHV
KLVVH[XDORUJDQZLWKRXWDQFRYHULQJEHWZHHQWKHP
- 208. :KHQ KH PDGH SURVWUDWLRQV KHZRXOG WRXFK PH DQG ,ZRXOGPRYHP IHHW ,Q
DQRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLWVDV:KHQKHZDQWHGWRSURVWUDWHKHZRXOGWRXFKPOHJV
)LTK%OHHGLQJIURPDQXQXVXDOSODFH
7KLVLQYROYHVEOHHGLQJGXHWRDZRXQGFXSSLQJRUDQRVHEOHHGDQGUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKHDPRXQW
RIEORRGLVVPDOORUODUJH
6DLG DO+DVVDQ 7KH0XVOLPV VWLOO SUDHG HYHQZKLOHZRXQGHG 5HODWHG E DO%XNKDUL
- 210. )LTKD9RPLW
5HJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKH DPRXQWRIYRPLWZDVJUHDWRUVPDOOWKHUHLVQRVRXQGKDGLWKWKDWLWQXOOLILHV
DEOXWLRQ
)LTKE(DWLQJFDPHOPHDW
7KDW WKLV GRHV QRW QXOOLI WKH DEOXWLRQ ZDV WKH RSLQLRQ RI WKH IRXU ULJKWO JXLGHG FDOLSKV WKH
FRPSDQLRQVDQGWKHIROORZLQJJHQHUDWLRQDOWKRXJKWKHUHLVDQDXWKHQWLFKDGLWKWKDWVWDWHVRQHVKRXOG
PDNHDEOXWLRQDIWHULW
6DLG-DELULEQ6XPUDK$PDQDVNHGWKH3URSKHW
6KRXOGZHPDNHDEOXWLRQDIWHUHDWLQJPXWWRQ
+H
VDLG
,IRXZLVKPDNHDEOXWLRQ,IRXGRQRWGRQRWPDNHDEOXWLRQ
7KHPDQDVNHG
6KRXOGZH
PDNH DEOXWLRQ DIWHU HDWLQJ FDPHOPHDW
+H VDLG
HV
$O%DUUD
LEQ
$D]LE UHODWHG WKDW VRPHRQH
DVNHGWKH3URSKHWDERXWSUDLQJLQWKHGHQVRIFDPHOVDQGKHVDLG'RQRWSUDWKHUHLQIRUWKHDUH
RIWKHGHYLOV+HDVNHGDERXWWKHGHQVRIVKHHSDQGKHVDLG3UDWKHUHLQIRUWKHDUHEOHVVLQJV
5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDQG,EQ+LEEDQ
- 218. )LTKLUFXPDPEXODWLQJWKH.D
EDK
,EQ
$EEDV UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK VDLG LUFXPDPEXODWLRQ LV D WSH RI SUDHU EXW
$OODKKDVSHUPLWWHGVSHDNLQJGXULQJLW:KRHYHUVSHDNVGXULQJLWVKRXOGRQOVSHDNJRRG
7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEDW7LUPL]KLDG'DUDTXWQLDO+DNLP,EQDV6DNLQDQG,EQ.KX]DLPDKZKR
FODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
)LTKD7RXFKLQJDFRSRIWKH4XU
DQ
$EX%DNULEQ0XKDPPDGUHODWHGIURPKLVIDWKHURQWKHDXWKRULWRIKLVJUDQGIDWKHUWKDWWKH3URSKHW
XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VHQW D OHWWHU WR WKH SHRSOH RI HPHQZKLFK VWDWHG 1R RQH LV WR WRXFK WKH
4XU
DQH[FHSWRQHZKRLVSXULILHG
7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEDQ1DVD
LDG'DUDTXWQLDO%DLKDTLDQGDO$WKUDP2ILWVFKDLQ,EQ
$EGXO
%DUUVDV,WDSSHDUVWREHDFRQWLQXRXVWUDQVPLVVLRQ
$EGXOODKLEQ
8PDUUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW
XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG 1R RQH LV WR WRXFK WKH 4XU
DQ XQOHVV KH KDV SXULILHG KLPVHOI $O
+DLWKDPLPHQWLRQHGLWLQ0DMPD
D]=DZDLGDQGVDLGLWVQDUUDWRUVDUHWUXVWZRUWK
- 221. DQG WKDW LV WKH ZHOOSUHVHUYHG WDEOHW DQG WKH
SXULILHGUHIHUVWRWKHDQJHOVZKLFKLVVLPLODUWRWKHYHUVHV2QKRQRUHGVFUROOVH[DOWHGSXULILHG
VHWGRZQ
- 225. 7KLV DFWLRQ ZDV RQH RI
SUHIHUHQFHQRWRIREOLJDWLRQ0HQWLRQLQJWKHQDPHRI$OODKLVSHUPLVVLEOHIRUWKHRQHZKRLVLQDVWDWH
RISXULWRQHZKRKDVDPLQRULPSXULWDSHUVRQLQSRVWVH[LPSXULWRURQHZKRLVVWDQGLQJVLWWLQJ
DQGVRRQ6DLG
$LVKDK7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXVHGWR UHPHPEHU$OODKDWDOOWLPHV5HODWHGE
WKH ILYH H[FHSW IRU DQ1DVD
L
- 227. 5HSRUWHG
$OL 7KH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZRXOGFRPHIURPUHOLHYLQJKLPVHOIUHFLWHWRXVDQGHDWPHDWZLWKXV1RWKLQJ
ZRXOGVWRSKLPIURP WKH4XU
DQH[FHSWSRVWVH[LPSXULW5HODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLDQG
,EQDV6DNLQFDWHJRUL]HGLWDVVDKLK
- 232. )LTKD7RUHPRYHDVH[XDOLPSXULW
,I D SHUVRQ LQ D VWDWH RI SRVWVH[ LPSXULWZDQWV WR HDW GULQN RU KDYH LQWHUFRXUVH DJDLQ KH VKRXOG
SHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ
6DLG
$LVKDK :KHQ WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH ZDV LQ D VWDWH RI LPSXULW EHFDXVH RI
LQWHUFRXUVHDQGZDQWHGWRHDWRUVOHHSKHZRXOGSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ
$PPDULEQDVDUUHSRUWHGWKDW
WKH 3URSKHW SHUPLWWHG D SHUVRQ LQ SRVWVH[LPSXULW WR HDW GULQN RU VOHHS LI KH SHUIRUPHG DEOXWLRQ
ILUVW5HODWHGE$KPDGDQGDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
- 234. )LTK%HIRUHSHUIRUPLQJJKXVO
,W LV SUHIHUUHG WR SHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ EHIRUH JKXVO UHJDUGOHVV RIZKHWKHU WKDW SDUWLFXODU JKXVO ZDV DQ
REOLJDWRU RU D SUHIHUUHG DFW 6DLG
$LVKDK:KHQ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH
SHUIRUPHGSRVWVH[JKXVOKHZRXOGEHJLQEZDVKLQJKLVKDQGVDQGWKHQSRXUZDWHUIURPKLVULJKW
KDQG WR KLV OHIW DQG ZDVK KLV SULYDWH SDUWV +H ZRXOG WKHQ SHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ 5HODWHG E WKH
JURXS