Enviar búsqueda
Cargar
Fiqh us-sunnah
•
0 recomendaciones
•
330 vistas
Noor Al Islam
Seguir
Fiqh us-sunnah
Leer menos
Leer más
Meditación
Denunciar
Compartir
Denunciar
Compartir
1 de 382
Descargar ahora
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Recomendados
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
Tengku Puteh Tippi
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
The rarionale behind gender mainstreaming
The rarionale behind gender mainstreaming
sheila cesario
Excel vba course notes 1 macro basics
Excel vba course notes 1 macro basics
necromen
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
Balzac et la petite tailleuse chinoise
Balzac et la petite tailleuse chinoise
dreamytang
Maria montessori
Maria montessori
elmackay
Recomendados
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
Tengku Puteh Tippi
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
The rarionale behind gender mainstreaming
The rarionale behind gender mainstreaming
sheila cesario
Excel vba course notes 1 macro basics
Excel vba course notes 1 macro basics
necromen
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
Balzac et la petite tailleuse chinoise
Balzac et la petite tailleuse chinoise
dreamytang
Maria montessori
Maria montessori
elmackay
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
L'équipe MIRVOG
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
zakir2012
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Chemtrails Spoter
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
PublicLeaker
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
Razonamientomatematico
Razonamientomatematico
marco gamonal suarez
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Raj Luitel
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
DevansuRathva
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
Twitter Traffic
Twitter Traffic
Michael Mayhew
Plano ubicación
Plano ubicación
zinthia
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Alison Perez
Lucia y miriam
Lucia y miriam
Conchy Gavilán Álvarez
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
Santiago Toribio Ayuga
El kalevala
El kalevala
EMPRESAS Y NEGOCIOS
Más contenido relacionado
La actualidad más candente
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
L'équipe MIRVOG
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
zakir2012
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Chemtrails Spoter
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
PublicLeaker
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
Razonamientomatematico
Razonamientomatematico
marco gamonal suarez
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Raj Luitel
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
DevansuRathva
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
Twitter Traffic
Twitter Traffic
Michael Mayhew
La actualidad más candente
(17)
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
Répertoire des officiers généraux consultants
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
Razonamientomatematico
Razonamientomatematico
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
Twitter Traffic
Twitter Traffic
Destacado
Plano ubicación
Plano ubicación
zinthia
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Alison Perez
Lucia y miriam
Lucia y miriam
Conchy Gavilán Álvarez
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
Santiago Toribio Ayuga
El kalevala
El kalevala
EMPRESAS Y NEGOCIOS
Coltan
Coltan
Alejandro Gonzalez
Es necesario recordar siempre las palabras del concilio Vaticano II: "De nada...
Es necesario recordar siempre las palabras del concilio Vaticano II: "De nada...
Universidad Tecnológica del Perú
Metlit ppt
Metlit ppt
Anie01
Delyfeij procesadora de_yogurt_a_base_de_feijoa
Delyfeij procesadora de_yogurt_a_base_de_feijoa
bettyamile
Programación QI ADI
Programación QI ADI
jhoaramones
UK Brief Overview
UK Brief Overview
bowmaninsurance
Coltan3
Coltan3
claudiagattuso2995
ORANGE SPAGNE
ORANGE SPAGNE
rikardd41
Case of the kichwa indigenous peoples of sarayaku v. ecuador
Case of the kichwa indigenous peoples of sarayaku v. ecuador
Dr Lendy Spires
Temas propuestos
Temas propuestos
lauosorio
Clase 10 accesos
Clase 10 accesos
Naty Espinosa
S Sorensen Design Portfolio Nfm 2011
S Sorensen Design Portfolio Nfm 2011
Steven Sorensen
بعد الفجر
بعد الفجر
Amel Hope
Vanadio
Vanadio
Yessenia Velázquez
Shinjang milliytaristlirining sowit_bilen_bolghan_alaqisi
Shinjang milliytaristlirining sowit_bilen_bolghan_alaqisi
akax001 akax001
Destacado
(20)
Plano ubicación
Plano ubicación
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Wah 10th stakeholders_meeting_final
Lucia y miriam
Lucia y miriam
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
Topchef, Chicote y las nuevas recetas de siempre en los fogones de nuestra cr...
El kalevala
El kalevala
Coltan
Coltan
Es necesario recordar siempre las palabras del concilio Vaticano II: "De nada...
Es necesario recordar siempre las palabras del concilio Vaticano II: "De nada...
Metlit ppt
Metlit ppt
Delyfeij procesadora de_yogurt_a_base_de_feijoa
Delyfeij procesadora de_yogurt_a_base_de_feijoa
Programación QI ADI
Programación QI ADI
UK Brief Overview
UK Brief Overview
Coltan3
Coltan3
ORANGE SPAGNE
ORANGE SPAGNE
Case of the kichwa indigenous peoples of sarayaku v. ecuador
Case of the kichwa indigenous peoples of sarayaku v. ecuador
Temas propuestos
Temas propuestos
Clase 10 accesos
Clase 10 accesos
S Sorensen Design Portfolio Nfm 2011
S Sorensen Design Portfolio Nfm 2011
بعد الفجر
بعد الفجر
Vanadio
Vanadio
Shinjang milliytaristlirining sowit_bilen_bolghan_alaqisi
Shinjang milliytaristlirining sowit_bilen_bolghan_alaqisi
Similar a Fiqh us-sunnah
Module 1.pdf
Module 1.pdf
Mohamedshabana38
Capítulo 8. Los Agentes Químicos sobre las Bacterias
Capítulo 8. Los Agentes Químicos sobre las Bacterias
Rigoberto José Meléndez Cuauro
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
ayshaayyoob2003
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Islamic Homeschooling
Alesandru duţu romania in istoria secolului xx
Alesandru duţu romania in istoria secolului xx
lucianivascu3
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Loveofpeople
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
Islamic Library
La guerra de las plantas alelopatia
La guerra de las plantas alelopatia
unellezvipi
Ontario Handbook - Regular.pdf
Ontario Handbook - Regular.pdf
AsadNaveed22
Module 3.pdf
Module 3.pdf
Mohamedshabana38
Los derechos de los animales - Hector Hidalgo (2xhoja36).pdf
Los derechos de los animales - Hector Hidalgo (2xhoja36).pdf
yenifferdenisseoband1
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Abdulsalam Taha
Devansu rathva life_downloadable_proof and YouTuber life is sad to
Devansu rathva life_downloadable_proof and YouTuber life is sad to
DevansuRathva
Islam Perfectly Complete
Islam Perfectly Complete
Light Upon Light
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
Ari Khozin
IEC 2014_Wera Supa
IEC 2014_Wera Supa
Wera Supa CPC
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
Seneca -de_la_brevedad_de_la_vida[1]
Seneca -de_la_brevedad_de_la_vida[1]
Rafael
Tarification stam jort 1999
Tarification stam jort 1999
Mehdi Maatoug
Similar a Fiqh us-sunnah
(20)
Module 1.pdf
Module 1.pdf
Capítulo 8. Los Agentes Químicos sobre las Bacterias
Capítulo 8. Los Agentes Químicos sobre las Bacterias
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Alesandru duţu romania in istoria secolului xx
Alesandru duţu romania in istoria secolului xx
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
La guerra de las plantas alelopatia
La guerra de las plantas alelopatia
Ontario Handbook - Regular.pdf
Ontario Handbook - Regular.pdf
Module 3.pdf
Module 3.pdf
Los derechos de los animales - Hector Hidalgo (2xhoja36).pdf
Los derechos de los animales - Hector Hidalgo (2xhoja36).pdf
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Devansu rathva life_downloadable_proof and YouTuber life is sad to
Devansu rathva life_downloadable_proof and YouTuber life is sad to
Islam Perfectly Complete
Islam Perfectly Complete
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
IEC 2014_Wera Supa
IEC 2014_Wera Supa
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
Seneca -de_la_brevedad_de_la_vida[1]
Seneca -de_la_brevedad_de_la_vida[1]
Tarification stam jort 1999
Tarification stam jort 1999
Más de Noor Al Islam
رسم المصحف ونقطه
رسم المصحف ونقطه
Noor Al Islam
قصص القران الكيم
قصص القران الكيم
Noor Al Islam
صفات الموؤمنين في القران الكريم
صفات الموؤمنين في القران الكريم
Noor Al Islam
التجويد
التجويد
Noor Al Islam
The path of faith
The path of faith
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 2
Islam and science vol 2
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 3
Islam and science vol 3
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 4
Islam and science vol 4
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 5
Islam and science vol 5
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 7
Islam and science vol 7
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 6
Islam and science vol 6
Noor Al Islam
Islam and science vol 1
Islam and science vol 1
Noor Al Islam
Who is allah and his prophet
Who is allah and his prophet
Noor Al Islam
Honor thy father and mother
Honor thy father and mother
Noor Al Islam
Common questions people ask about islam
Common questions people ask about islam
Noor Al Islam
A call to the real salvation
A call to the real salvation
Noor Al Islam
Human rights in islam
Human rights in islam
Noor Al Islam
Neighbor's rights
Neighbor's rights
Noor Al Islam
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 4
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 4
Noor Al Islam
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 3
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 3
Noor Al Islam
Más de Noor Al Islam
(20)
رسم المصحف ونقطه
رسم المصحف ونقطه
قصص القران الكيم
قصص القران الكيم
صفات الموؤمنين في القران الكريم
صفات الموؤمنين في القران الكريم
التجويد
التجويد
The path of faith
The path of faith
Islam and science vol 2
Islam and science vol 2
Islam and science vol 3
Islam and science vol 3
Islam and science vol 4
Islam and science vol 4
Islam and science vol 5
Islam and science vol 5
Islam and science vol 7
Islam and science vol 7
Islam and science vol 6
Islam and science vol 6
Islam and science vol 1
Islam and science vol 1
Who is allah and his prophet
Who is allah and his prophet
Honor thy father and mother
Honor thy father and mother
Common questions people ask about islam
Common questions people ask about islam
A call to the real salvation
A call to the real salvation
Human rights in islam
Human rights in islam
Neighbor's rights
Neighbor's rights
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 4
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 4
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 3
أسماء وصفات الله عز وجل 3
Fiqh us-sunnah
1.
)LTKXV6XQQDK 6DLG6DDELT )LTK3XULILFDWLRQ
7KHVKDUL DKKDVGLYLGHGZDWHULQWRIRXUNLQGV PXWODTZDWHU XVHGZDWHUIRUSXULILFDWLRQ
2.
ZDWHUPL[HGZLWKSXUHHOHPHQWVDQG ZDWHUPL[HGZLWKLPSXUHHOHPHQWV:HVKDOOGLVFXVVHDFKRIWKHPVHSDUDWHO
)LTKD0XWODTZDWHU 7KLVNLQGRIZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHEHFDXVHRILWVLQKHUHQWSXULWDQGDVVXFKLWFDQEHXVHGEDQ LQGLYLGXDOWRSXULIKLPRUKHUVHOI,WFRQVLVWVRIWKHIROORZLQJFDWHJRULHV )LTKE5DLQZDWHUVQRZDQGKDLO 7KHVHVXEVWDQFHVDUHSXUHEHFDXVH$OODKVDVVR$QGVHQWGRZQZDWHUIURPWKHVNXSRQRXWKDW WKHUHE+HPLJKWSXULIRXDO$QIDO
3.
DQG:HVHQGGRZQSXULILQJZDWHUIURPWKHVNDO )XUTDQ
4.
7KLVLVDOVRVXSSRUWHGEWKHIROORZLQJKDGLWK$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGWREHVLOHQWEHWZHHQWKHRSHQLQJ
5.
WDNELURIWKHSUDHUDQGWKH YHUEDO 4XU DQLF
UHFLWDWLRQ $EX +XUDLUDK DVNHG KLP 20HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD P IDWKHU DQG PRWKHUEHVDFULILFHGIRURXZKGRRXUHPDLQVLOHQWEHWZHHQWKHWDNELUDQGWKHUHFLWDO:KDWGR RXVDVLOHQWOGXULQJWKDWWLPH
6.
+HVDLG,VD 2$OODKPDNHDGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQPHDQGP VLQVVLPLODUWRWKHGLVWDQFHRXKDYHPDGHEHWZHHQWKH(DVWDQGWKH:HVW2$OODKFOHDQVHPHRIP VLQVLQWKHPDQQHUWKDWDZKLWHJDUPHQWLVFOHDQVHG
7.
IURPGLUW2$OODKZDVKPVLQVIURPPHZLWK VQRZZDWHUDQGKDLO 7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEWKHJURXSH[FHSWIRUDW7LUPL]KL )LTK6HDZDWHU
6HD ZDWHU V SXULW LV EDVHG RQ WKH IROORZLQJ KDGLWK $EX +XUDLUDK UHODWHG WKDW D PDQ DVNHG WKH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH20HVVHQJHURI$OODKZHVDLORQWKHRFHDQDQGZHFDUU RQO D OLWWOHZDWHU ,IZH XVH LW IRU DEOXWLRQZHZLOO KDYH WR JR WKLUVW0DZH XVH VHDZDWHU IRU DEOXWLRQ6DLGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH,WVWKHVHD
8.
ZDWHULVSXUHDQGLWVGHDG DQLPDOV
9.
DUH ODZIXO LH
WKH FDQ EH HDWHQ ZLWKRXW DQ SUHVFULEHG VODXJKWHULQJ
10.
7KLV KDGLWK LV
UHODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLFDOOVLWKDVVDQVDKLKDQGDO%XNKDULVDVLWLVVDKLK )LTKD:DWHUIURPWKHZHOORI=DP]DP $OL QDUUDWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH FDOOHG IRU D EXFNHW WKDW FRQWDLQHG ZDWHUIURPWKHZHOORI=DP]DP+HGUDQNIURPWKHEXFNHWWKHQPDGHDEOXWLRQZLWKLWVZDWHU
11.
7KLV KDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDG )LTKE$OWHUHGZDWHU
7KLVLQYROYHVZDWHUZKRVHIRUPKDVEHHQDOWHUHGEHFDXVHRILWVEHLQJLQDSODFHIRUDORQJSHULRGRI WLPHRUEHFDXVHRIWKHSODFHLQZKLFKLWLVORFDWHGRUEHFDXVHRILWVEHLQJPL[HGZLWKDVXEVWDQFHWKDW FDQQRW EH FRPSOHWHO UHPRYHG IURP LW LH ZDWHU PL[HG ZLWK DOJDH WUHH OHDYHV DQG VR RQ
12.
7KH VFKRODUVDJUHHWKDWWKLVWSHRIZDWHUIDOOVXQGHUWKHKHDGLQJRIPXWODTZDWHU 7KH
UDWLRQDOH LV VLPSOH HYHUWKLQJ WKDW IDOOV XQGHU WKH JHQHUDO WHUP RIZDWHUZLWKRXW DQ IXUWKHU TXDOLILFDWLRQVLVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHIRUWKH4XU DQVDVDQGLIRXILQGQRWZDWHUWKHQJRWRFOHDQ KLJKJURXQGDO0D LGDK
13.
)LTKF8VHGZDWHU 7KLVFDWHJRUUHIHUVWRZDWHUZKLFKGULSVIURPWKHSHUVRQDIWHUKHSHUIRUPVDEOXWLRQRUJKXVO,WLV FRQVLGHUHGSXUHEHFDXVHLWZDVSXUHEHIRUHLWVXVHIRUDEOXWLRQDQGWKHUHLVQREDVLVWRWKLQNWKDWLWKDV
ORVWLWVSXULW7KLVVWDWHPHQWLVVXSSRUWHGEWKHKDGLWKRI5DE LELQW0X ZD]KZKLFKGHVFULEHVWKH DEOXWLRQRIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK6KHVWDWHV+HZLSHGKLVKHDGZLWKWKHZDWHU
14.
UHPDLQLQJRQKLV KDQGVIURPKLVDEOXWLRQ7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQG$EX'DZXG$EX'DZXG VYHUVLRQLV 7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRP
EHSHDFHZLSHGKLVKHDGZLWKWKHH[WUDZDWHUWKDWZDVLQKLV KDQG $EX +XUDLUDK DOVR UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PHW KLP DORQH LQ WKH VWUHHWV RI 0DGLQDKZKLOHKHZDVLQSRVWVH[LPSXULW+HWKHUHIRUHVOLSSHGDZDPDGHJKXVODQGUHWXUQHG7KH
15.
0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP
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
16.
FRQWDLQHUWKDWKDGDWUDFHRIGRXJKLQLW,QERWKRIWKHVHKDGLWKZHILQG WKDW WKHZDWHUZDVPL[HG
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
17.
7KH3URSKHWVDLG/HDYHKLPDQGSRXUDEXFNHWRIZDWHURUDFRQWDLQHURI ZDWHURYHUKLVXULQHRXKDYHEHHQUDLVHGWREHHDVRQWKHSHRSOHQRWWREHKDUGRQWKHP7KLV KDGLWKLVQDUUDWHGEWKHJURXSH[FHSWIRU0XVOLP
$EX6D HHGDO.KXGULDVNHGWKH3URSKHWDQZHPDNHDEOXWLRQIURPWKHZHOORI%XGD DKLH DZHOO LQ0DGLQDK
18.
7KH 3URSKHW XSRQ
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
19.
/HIWRYHUZDWHULVZKDWUHPDLQVLQDSRWDIWHUVRPHKDVEHHQGUXQN7KHUHDUHILYHGLIIHUHQWWSHVRI OHIWRYHUZDWHU )LTKD:DWHUOHIWRYHUDIWHUSHRSOHKDYHGUXQNIURPWKHSRW
$FFRUGLQJWRWKHVKDUL DKVXFKZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGSXUHUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKHRQHZKRGUDQNIURP WKHSRWZDVD0XVOLPDQXQEHOLHYHUDSHUVRQLQSRVWVH[LPSXULWRUDPHQVWUXDWLQJZRPDQ $OWKRXJK$OODK VDV LQ WKH4XU DQ 9HULO WKH LGROZRUVKLSSHUV DUH LPSXUH DW7DXEDK
20.
WKLV LV D
UHIHUHQFHQRWWRWKHLUSKVLFDOVWDWHEXWWRWKHLUIDOVHEHOLHIVDQGFUHHG7KHPDFRPHLQWRFRQWDFW ZLWKGLUWRULPSXULWLHVEXWWKLVGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWWKHLUSRVVHVVLRQVRUERGLHVDUHLPSXUH,QIDFWWKH XVHGWRPL[ZLWKWKH0XVOLPV7KHLUHPPLVVDULHVDQGGHOHJDWLRQVXVHGWRYLVLWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK DQGHQWHUKLVPRVTXH7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGLGQRWRUGHUWKDWWKHREMHFWVWKHWRXFKHG EHFOHDQVHG$VIRUPHQVWXUDWLQJZRPHQ $LVKDKVDLG,XVHGWRGULQNIURPDFRQWDLQHU
21.
ZKLOH,ZDV PHQVWUXDWLQJ,ZRXOGWKHQSDVVLWWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDQGKHZRXOGGULQNIURPWKHVDPHVSRW ZKHUH,KDGSXWPOLSV5HODWHGE0XVOLP
22.
)LTK:DWHUOHIWLQDFRQWDLQHUDIWHUDQDOORZDEOHDQLPDOKDVGUXQNIURPLW 6XFKZDWHULVFRQVLGHUHGSXUH6LQFHWKHDQLPDOTXDOLILHVIRUFRQVXPSWLRQLWVVDOLYDLVDOVRSXUH$EX %DNULEQDO0XQ]KLUVDLG7KHVFKRODUVDUHDJUHHGWKDWVXFKZDWHULVSHUPLVVLEOHWRGULQNRUXVHIRU
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
23.
LVZKDWKHFDUULHGLQKLVVWRPDFKDQG IRUXVLVZKDWKHOHIWZDWHUWREHXVHGIRUGULQNLQJDQGSXULILQJ7KLVLVUHODWHGEDG'DUDTXWQL DKDLEQ6D HHGUHSRUWHGWKDWRQFH 8PDUZDVDPRQJDJURXSWKDWLQFOXGHG $PULEQDO $DV
DQG ZKHQWKHFDPHXSRQDSRQG $PUVDLG2RZQHURIWKHSRQGKDYHWKHEHDVWVRISUHGLVFRYHUHG RXUSRQG 8PDUVDLG'RQRWLQIRUPXVVLQFHWKHSHRSOHGULQNDIWHUWKHZLOGEHDVWVDQGWKHZLOG EHDVWVDIWHUWKHSHRSOH7KLVLVUHODWHGE0DOLNLQ DO0XZDWWD )LTK:DWHUOHIWLQDSRWDIWHUDFDWKDVGUXQNIURPLW 6XFKZDWHULVDOVRFRQVLGHUHGSXUH7KLVLVSURYHQEWKHKDGLWKRI.DEVKDKELQW.D EZKRZKHQVKH ZDVXQGHUWKHFDUHRI$EX4DWDGDKHQWHUHGWKHURRPWRSRXUVRPHZDWHUIRUKLP$FDWFDPHGUDQN VRPHRIWKHZDWHUDQG4DWDGDKSURFHHGHGWRWLOWWKHFRQWDLQHUVRWKHFDWFRXOGGULQNPRUH.DEVKDK VDLG +H QRWLFHG WKDW , ZDVZDWFKLQJ KLP+H DVNHG $UH RX VXUSULVHG 2 QLHFH , DQVZHUHG HV+HVDLG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQ ZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG ,WWKHFDW
24.
LVQRWLPSXUH7KH LQWHUPLQJOHZLWKRX )LTKD:DWHUOHIWLQDSRWDIWHUDSLJRUGRJKDVGUXQNIURPLW
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
25.
DQG$OODKORYHVWKRVHZKRUHSHQWDQGZKRSXULIWKHPVHOYHVDO%DTDUDK
26.
7KH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKDOVRVDLG3XULWLVKDOIRIWKHIDLWK )LTKF'HDGDQLPDOV
7KLV UHIHUV WR DQLPDOV ZKLFK GLH IURP QDWXUDO FDXVHV WKDW LVZLWKRXW WKH SURSHU ,VODPLF ZD RI VODXJKWHULQJ,WDOVRLQFOXGHVDQWKLQJWKDWLVFXWRIIRIDOLYHDQLPDO$EX:DTLGDO/DLWKUHSRUWHG LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
27.
WKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KDWLVFXWRIIRIDOLYHDQLPDOLVFRQVLGHUHGGHDGLH LWLVFRQVLGHUHGOLNHDQDQLPDOWKDWKDVQRWEHHQSURSHUOVODXJKWHUHG7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EX'DZXG DQGEDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHVLWDVKDVVDQDQGVDVWKDWWKHVFKRODUVDFWDFFRUGLQJWRWKLVKDGLWK
)LTK'HDGDQLPDOVRIWKHVHDDQGGHDGORFXVWV ,EQ 8PDUUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG7ZRWSHVRIGHDGDQLPDOVDQGWZRWSHVRI EORRGKDYHEHHQPDGHODZIXOIRUXV7KHWSHVRIGHDGDQLPDOVDUHVHDIRRGDQGORFXVWV7KHWZRWSHV RIEORRGDUHWKHEORRGRIWKH
28.
OLYHUDQGWKHVSOHHQ 7KLV LV
UHODWHG E $KPDG DVK6KDI L DO%DLKDTL DQG DG'DUDTXWQL 7KH KDGLWK LV ZHDN EXW ,PDP $KPDGVDVWKDWLWLVDXWKHQWLFLQPDXTRRIIRUP$EX=DU DKDQG$EX+DWLPKDYHVDLGWKHVDPH6XFK DUHSRUWKDVWKHLPSOLFDWLRQRIDPDUIX KDGLWKEHFDXVHDFRPSDQLRQVDLQJ7KLVZDVDOORZHGIRUXV RU7KLVZDVIRUELGGHQIRUXVLVOLNHRQHRIWKHPVDLQJ:HZHUHRUGHUHGWRGRWKLVRU:HZHUH IRUELGGHQ WR GR WKLV DQG VR RQ 6XFK VWDWHPHQWV DUH FRQVLGHUHG PDUIX ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKHLU UHJXODWLRQV
29.
$QGZHKDYHDOUHDGPHQWLRQHGWKH3URSKHW VVWDWHPHQWFRQFHUQLQJWKHRFHDQ,WVZDWHU LVSXUHDQGLWV GHDGDQLPDOV DUHDOORZDEOHWRHDW
30.
)LTKD'HDGDQLPDOVWKDWKDYHQRUXQQLQJEORRG 7KDWLV
31.
EHHVDQWVDQGVRRQ7KHDUHFRQVLGHUHGSXUH,IWKHIDOOLQWRVRPHVXEVWDQFHDQGGLHWKH VXEVWDQFH ZLOO
QRW EHFRPH LPSXUH ,EQ DO0XQ]KLU VDLG , GR QRW NQRZ RI DQ GLVDJUHHPHQW FRQFHUQLQJWKHSXULWRIVXFKZDWHUVDYHZKDWKDVEHHQUHODWHGIURPDVK6KDI L,WLVZHOONQRZQWKDW KH YLHZV WKHP DV EHLQJ LPSXUH 1HYHUWKHOHVV LW GRHV QRW ERWKHU KLP LI WKH REMHFW IDOOLQJ LQWR D VXEVWDQFHGRHVQRWDOWHULWLQDQZD
32.
)LTKE%RQHVKRUQVFODZVIXUIHDWKHUVDQGVNLQDQGVRRQRIGHDGDQLPDOV $OORIWKHVHDUHFRQVLGHUHGSXUHRQFHUQLQJWKHERQHVRIGHDGDQLPDOVD]=XKULVDLG,KDYHPHW VRPHVFKRODUVRIWKHSUHFHHGLQJJHQHUDWLRQVZKRXVHGVXFKREMHFWVIRUFRPEVDQGSRWVIRURLODQG
WKHGLGQRWVHHDQWKLQJZURQJLQWKDW7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDUL6DLG,EQ $EEDV7KHFOLHQWRI 0DLPXQDKZDVJLYHQDVKHHSDVFKDULWDQGLWGLHG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH SDVVHGELWDQGVDLG :KGRRXQRWUHPRYHLWVVNLQWUHDWLWDQGSXWLWWRXVH 6KHVDLG ,WLVGHDG LHLWKDVQRWEHHQVODXJKWHUHGSURSHUO
33.
+HVDLGWRKHU 2QOHDWLQJLWLVIRUELGGHQ 7KLVLVUHODWHG EWKHJURXS,EQ0DMDKDWWULEXWHVWKHLQFLGHQWWR0DLPXQDKDQGKHUFOLHQW$O%XNKDULDQGDQ1DVD L GRQRWPHQWLRQWUHDWLQJWKHVNLQ,WLVUHSRUWHGIURP,EQ $EEDVWKDWKHUHFLWHG6D20XKDPPDG
34.
,QDOOWKDWKDVEHHQUHYHDOHGWRPH,GRQRWILQGDQWKLQJIRUELGGHQWRHDWLIRQHZDQWVWRHDWWKHUHRI XQOHVVLWEHFDUULRQRUEORRGSRXUHGIRUWKRUVZLQHIOHVKDO$Q DP
35.
7KHQKHVDLG:KDWLV IRUELGGHQ LVLWVPHDW$VIRULWVVNLQVNLQXVHGIRUZDWHUVNLQVWHHWKERQHVIXUDQGZRROWKHDUH
SHUPLVVLEOH 7KLV LV QDUUDWHG E ,EQ0XQ]KLU DQG ,EQ +DWLP 6LPLODUO LWV UHQQHW DQG PLON DUH FRQVLGHUHGSXUH7KLVLVVXSSRUWHGEWKHIDFWWKDWZKHQWKHFRPSDQLRQVFRQTXHUHG,UDTWKHDWHWKH FKHHVH RI WKH 0DJLDQV ZKLFK ZDV PDGH IURP UHQQHW DOWKRXJK WKHLU VODXJKWHUHG DQLPDOV ZHUH FRQVLGHUHGWKHVDPHDV GHDGDQLPDOV ,WLVFRQILUPHGIURP6DOPDQDO)DUVLWKDWZKHQKHZDVDVNHG DERXWFKHHVHFODULILHGEXWWHUDQGSHOWVKHVDLG:KDWLVSHUPLVVLEOHLVZKDW$OODKPDGHSHUPLVVLEOH LQ+LVERRN:KDWLVIRUELGGHQLVZKDW$OODKPDGHIRUELGGHQLQ+LVERRN:KDWKHRPLWV+HKDV SDUGRQHG IRU RX ,W LV ZHOONQRZQ WKDW KH ZDV EHLQJ DVNHG DERXW WKH FKHHVH RI WKH0DJLDQV DV 6DOPDQZDV 8PDU VGHSXWLQ0DGD LQ,UDT )LTK%ORRG 7KLVLQFOXGHVEORRGWKDWSRXUVIRUWKIURPDQDQLPDO VERGVXFKDVEORRGIURPDVODXJKWHUHGDQLPDO RU IURP PHQVWUXDWLRQ H[FHSW IRU ZKDW VPDOO DPRXQWV DUH RYHUORRNHG ,EQ -XUDLM VDLG DERXW WKH 4XU DQLFYHUVHRUEORRGSRXUHGIRUWKDO$Q DP
36.
WKDWWKLVLVWKHEORRGWKDWIORZVRXW7KH EORRG WKDW
GRHV QRW IORZ RXW EXW UHPDLQV LQ WKH YHLQV LV SHUPLVVLEOH 7KLV LV UHODWHG E ,EQ DO 0XQ]KLU$QGLWLVDOVRUHODWHGIURP$EX0DMOL]QLQKLVGLVFRXUVHRQEORRGWKDWKHZDVDVNHG:KDW DERXWWKHEORRGWKDWUHPDLQVLQWKHVODXJKWHUHGVKHHSRUDWWKHWRSRIWKHFRRNLQJSRW+HDQVZHUHG 7KHUHLVQRSUREOHPZLWKLW:KDWLVIRUELGGHQLVWKHEORRGWKDWIORZVRXWRIWKHDQLPDODWWKHWLPH RIVODXJKWHULQJ
37.
7KLVZDVUHFRUGHGE $EGLEQ+DPHHGDQGE$EXDVK6KDLNK,WLVDOVRUHODWHG IURP $LVKDK
WKDW VKH VDLG:H XVHG WR HDW WKH PHDW ZKHQ WKH EORRG ZDV VWUHDNLQJ WKH SRW $O +DVVDQVDLG7KH0XVOLPVDOZDVSUDHGHYHQZKLOHWKHZHUHEOHHGLQJ7KLVZDVPHQWLRQHGE DO%XNKDUL,WLVFRQILUPHGWKDW 8PDUSUDHGZKLOHKLVZRXQGZDVEOHHGLQJ(OXFLGDWLQJWKHSRLQW LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
38.
,EQ +DMU VDV
LQ )DWK DO%DUL D FRPPHQWDU RQ 6DKLK DO%XNKDUL
39.
$EX +XUDLUDK GLG
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
40.
TXRWHG HDUOLHU
LWHPV PHQWLRQHG WKHUHLQ DUH LPSXUH 7KH SURQRXQ WKH UHIHUVWRDOOWKUHHRIWKHPHQWLRQHGLWHPV,WLVKRZHYHUDOORZHGWRNQLWZLWKWKHKDLURI DSLJDFFRUGLQJWRPRVWRIWKHVFKRODUV )LTKD9RPLWLQJRIDSHUVRQXULQHDQGH[FUHPHQW 7KHUHLVDJUHHPHQWDPRQJWKHVFKRODUVWKDWWKHVHREMHFWVDUHLPSXUH%XWDVOLJKWDPRXQWRIYRPLW FRPPRQO XQGHUVWRRG DV D VPDOO DPRXQW RI OLTXLG
41.
DQG WKH XULQH
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
42.
DIWHUXULQDWLRQ,WLVFRQVLGHUHGLPSXUH $LVKDKVDLG:DGLFRPHVRXWDIWHUXULQDWLRQ7KHSHUVRQVKRXOGZDVKWKHSULYDWHSDUWVDQGSHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ,WLVQRWQHFHVVDUWRSHUIRUPJKXVO7KLVLVUHODWHGE,EQDO0XQ]KLU,EQ $EEDVUHODWHG
WKDW PDQL VSHUP
43.
UHTXLUHV JKXVO $V
IRU PD]KL VHPHQ
44.
DQG ZDGL WKH
UHTXLUH D FRPSOHWH SXULILFDWLRQ 7KLV LV UHODWHG E DO$WKUDP $O%DLKDTL KDV LW ZLWK WKHZRUGLQJRQFHUQLQJPD]KL SURVWDWLFIOXLG
45.
DQGZDGLKHVDLG :DVKRXUVH[XDORUJDQVDQGSHUIRUPWKHVDPHWSHRIDEOXWLRQDV RXSHUIRUPIRUSUDHU )LTKD$O0D]KLRUSURVWDWLFIOXLG
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
46.
+HVDLG 0DNHDEOXWLRQDQGZDVKRXUSHQLV7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQGRWKHUV6DKOLEQ+DQLI VDLG,XVHGWRVXIIHUIURPH[FHVVLYHDPRXQWVRIPD]KL,XVHGWRPDNHORWVRIJKXVOEHFDXVHRILW6R ,PHQWLRQHGWKLVWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK
XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGKHVDLG ,WLVVXIILFLHQWWRWDNHD KDQGIXORIZDWHUDQGVSULQNOHLWRYHURXUFORWKHVZKHUHYHUWKHIOXLGDSSHDUV 7KH KDGLWK LV UHODWHG E $EX 'DZXG ,EQ0DMDK DQG DW7LUPL]KL 7KH ODWWHU VDV 7KH KDGLWK LV KDVVDQ VDKLK ,Q WKH FKDLQ LV0XKDPPDG LEQ ,VKDT ZKR LV FRQVLGHUHG ZHDN ZKHQ KH UHODWHV LQ LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
47.
PX DQ DQ KDQGHGGRZQ
48.
IRUP EHFDXVH RI
KLV UHSXWDWLRQ DV RQH ZKR FRPPLWHG WDGOLV %XW LQ WKLV QDUUDWLRQ KHPDNHV LW FOHDU WKDW KH KHDUG WKH KDGLWK GLUHFWO $O$WKUDP QDUUDWHG WKHVDPH KDGLWK ZLWKWKHZRUGLQJ,ZDVERWKHUHGEDJUHDWGHDORIPD]KLVR,ZHQWWRWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEH SHDFHDQGLQIRUPHGKLPRIWKLV+HVDLG ,WLVVXIILFLHQWIRURXWRWDNHDKDQGIXORIZDWHUDQGVSULQNOH LWRYHUWKHPD]KL
49.
)LTK6SHUP$O0DQL 6RPHVFKRODUVVDWKDWVSHUPLVLPSXUHEXWDSSDUHQWOLWLVSXUHIRULWLVRQOUHFRPPHQGHGWRZDVK LWRIILILWLVVWLOOZHWDQGWRVFUDWFKLWRIILILWLVGU6DLG $LVKDK,XVHGWRVFUDWFKWKHVSHUPRIIWKH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK VFORWKHVLILWZDVGUDQGZDVKLWRIILILWZDVVWLOOZHW7KLVLVUHODWHGEDG 'DUDTXWQL$EX $ZDQDKDQGDO%D]]DU
50.
,WLVDOVRUHODWHGWKDW,EQ $EEDVVDLG,DVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKDERXWVSHUPRQFORWKHV+HVDLG ,WLVWKHVDPHDVPXFXVDQGVSLWWOH,WLVVXIILFLHQWWRUXEWKH DUHDZLWKDUDJRUFORWK
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
51.
$PULEQ 6KX DLE UHODWHG
RQ WKH DXWKRULW RI KLV IDWKHU IURP KLV JUDQGIDWKHU WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK SURKLELWHG WKHPHDW RIGRPHVWLF GRQNHV$V IRU WKH MDOODODK KH SURKLELWHG ULGLQJ RU HDWLQJ WKHP 5HODWHGE$KDPDGDQ1DVD LDQG$EX'DZXG
52.
,IWKHMDOODODKDQLPDOLVNHSWDZDIURPWKHRWKHU DQLPDOVIRUVRPHWLPHDQGLVJLYHQFOHDQIRRGWRHDWWKHQLWEHFRPHVSXUHDQGLVQRORQJHUFDOOHG MDOODODK
,I WKLV LV WKH FDVH LW EHFRPHV SHUPLVVLEOH WR HDW DV WKH UHDVRQ IRU LWV SURKLELWLRQZDV WKH FKDQJHLWXQGHUZHQWGXHWRHDWLQJILOWKDVWDWHZKLFKZRXOGQRORQJHUEHSUHVHQW )LTKD$OFRKRO LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
53.
$FFRUGLQJWRPRVWVFKRODUVDOFRKROLVLPSXUH6DV$OODKLQWKH4XU DQ$OFRKROJDPHVRIFKDQFH LGROVDQGGLYLQLQJDUURZVDUHRQODQLQIDPRI6DWDQ VKDQGLZRUN6RPHVFKRODUVVDWKDWLWLVSXUH IRUWKHWDNHWKHPHDQLQJRIUDMLVLQLWVDEVWUDFWVHQVHDVGHVFULELQJDOFRKRODQGZKDWHYHULVUHODWHGWR
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
54.
,I LPSXULWLHVJHWRQWKHORZHUSRUWLRQRIDZRPDQ VGUHVVLWLVSXULILHGEGXVWDVVKHWUDLOVDORQJ$ ZRPDQ
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
55.
7KLV ZDV UHODWHG
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
56.
7KLVRIFRXUVHUHIHUVWRWKHFDVHZKHUH WKHLPSXULWLVDOLTXLG,IWKHLPSXULWLVDVROLGWKHJURXQGZLOORQOEHFRPHSXUHELWVUHPRYDORU GHFD
)LTKD3XULILQJFODULILHGEXWWHUDQGRWKHUVLPLODUVXEVWDQFHV ,EQ $EEDVUHODWHVIURP0DLPXQDKWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZDVDVNHGDERXWDPRXVH WKDWIHOOLQWRDSRWRIFODULILHGEXWWHU+HVDLG7DNHWKHPRXVH
57.
DQGZKDWLVDURXQGLWRXWDQGWKURZ LWDZD7KHQHDWWKHUHVWRI
58.
RXUFODULILHGEXWWHU7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDUL RPPHQWLQJ RQ
WKH VXEMHFW DO+DIH]K ,EQ +DMU VDV ,EQ $EGXO %DUU UHSRUWHG WKDW WKHUH LV DJUHHPHQWWKDWLIDGHDGDQLPDOIDOOVLQWRDVROLGPDWWHUZKDWWKHGHDGDQLPDOWRXFKHVDQGZKDWLV DURXQGLWPXVWEHWKURZQDZDSURYLGHGWKDWRQHFDQPDNHVXUHWKDWWKHDQLPDOGLGQRWWRXFKWKH LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
59.
UHPDLQGHU$VIRUDOLTXLGVXEVWDQFHWKHUHLVVRPHGLIIHUHQFHRIRSLQLRQ7KHPDMRULWVDWKDWWKH HQWLUHOLTXLGEHFRPHVLPSXUHD]=XKULDO$X]D LDQGVRPHRWKHUVGLVDJUHHZLWKWKDWRSLQLRQ )LTK3XULILQJWKHVNLQRIGHDGDQLPDOV
7DQQLQJSXULILHVWKHVNLQDQGWKHIXURIDGHDGDQLPDO7KLVLVEDVHGRQWKHKDGLWKRI,EQ $EEDVLQ ZKLFK WKH 3URSKHW VDLG ,I WKH DQLPDO V VNLQ LV WDQQHG LW LV SXULILHG 5HODWHG E DO%XNKDUL DQG 0XVOLP
60.
)LTKD3XULILQJPLUURUVDQGVLPLODUREMHFWV 0LUURUVNQLYHVVZRUGVQDLOVERQHVJODVVSDLQWHGSRWVDQGRWKHUVPRRWKVXUIDFHVWKDWKDYHQRSRUHV DUH
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
61.
6LQFH VKRHV DUH
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
62.
8PDU V FRPSDQLRQ DVNHG
WKHRZQHU RI WKH JXWWHU LI WKH ZDWHU ZDV SXUH RU LPSXUH 8PDU WROG WKH RZQHUQRWWRDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQDQGZHQWRQKLVZD ORWKHVWKDWKDYHVWUHHWPXGRQ WKHPQHHGQRWEHZDVKHG5HSRUWHG.DPDOLEQ=LDG,VDZ $OL ZDGLQJWKURXJKWKHPXGDIWHUZKLFKKHHQWHUHGWKHPRVTXHDQGSUDHGZLWKRXWZDVKLQJKLVOHJV ,IDSHUVRQILQLVKHVKLVSUDHUDQGVHHVVRPHLPSXULWLHVRQKLVFORWKHVRUERGRIZKLFKKHZDV QRW SUHYLRXVODZDUHRUKHZDVDZDUHRIWKHPEXWIRUJRWDERXWWKHPRUKHGLGQRWIRUJHWDERXWWKHPEXW KHZDVQRWDEOHWRUHPRYHWKHPWKHQKLVSUDHULVVWLOOYDOLGDQGKHQHHGQRWUHSHDWLW7KLVRSLQLRQLV VXSSRUWHG E $OODK V VWDWHPHQW $QG WKHUH LV QR VLQ IRU RX LQ WKH PLVWDNHV RX PDNH XQLQWHQWLRQDOODO$K]DE
63.
0DQRIWKHFRPSDQLRQVDQGWKRVHRIWKHIROORZLQJJHQHUDWLRQJDYH WKLVOHJDOYHUGLFW ,IDSHUVRQFDQQRWGHWHUPLQHZKDWSDUWRIKLVFORWKHVFRQWDLQWKHLPSXULWKHVKRXOGZDVKWKHZKROH
JDUPHQW 7KLV LV EDVHG RQ WKH D[LRP ,I DQ REOLJDWLRQ FDQQRW EH IXOILOOHG H[FHSW E SHUIRUPLQJ DQRWKHUUHODWHGDFWWKHQWKDWDFWDOVREHFRPHVREOLJDWRU ,I D SHUVRQ PL[HV KLV SXUH FORWKHV ZLWK KLV LPSXUH FORWKHV DQG JHWV FRQIXVHG EHWZHHQ WKHP
64.
KH VKRXOGLQYHVWLJDWHWKHPDWWHUDQGSUDRQFHLQRQHRIWKHFORWKHV7KLVLVVLPLODUWRWKHTXHVWLRQRIWKH H[DFWGLUHFWLRQRIWKHTLEODK,WGRHVQRWPDWWHULIWKHSURSRUWLRQRISXUHFORWKHVZDVODUJHRUVPDOO
)LTK,WLVQRWSURSHUIRURQHWRFDUUVRPHWKLQJWKDWKDV$OODK VQDPHXSRQLWZKLOHKHLVJRLQJ WRWKHEDWKURRP ,WLVQRWSURSHUIRURQHWRFDUUVRPHWKLQJWKDWKDV$OODK VQDPHXSRQLWXQOHVVKHLVDIUDLGRIORVLQJLW RUKDYLQJLWVWROHQ
65.
ZKLOHKHLVJRLQJWRWKHEDWKURP$QDVUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQ ZKRPEHSHDFHKDGDULQJHQJUDYHGZLWK0XKDPPDG5DVRROXOODK0XKDPPDGWKH0HVVHQJHURI $OODK
66.
ZKLFKKHZRXOGUHPRYHZKHQKHZHQWWRWKHEDWKURRP,EQ+DMUVDVWKDWWKLVKDGLWKLVPDOXO LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
67.
D WSH RI
ZHDN KDGLWK KDYLQJ D GHIHFW
68.
DQG$EX'DZXG VDV LW
LV P XQNDU VLQJXODUO UHODWHG E SHRSOHZKRDUHQRWWUXVWZRUWK
69.
7KHILUVWSRUWLRQRIWKHKDGLWKLVDXWKHQWLFKRZHYHU )LTK+HVKRXOGPRYHDQGKLGHKLPVHOIIURPRWKHUVZKLOHJRLQJWRWKHEDWKURRP 7KLVLVHVSHFLDOOWUXH
LQWKHFDVHRIGHIHFDWLRQVRRWKHUVFDQQRWKHDUQR[LRXVVRXQGVRUVPHOOEDG RGRUV6DLG-DELU:HZHUHMRXUQHLQJZLWKWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGKH ZRXOGRQOUHOLHYHKLPVHOIZKHQKHZDVRXWRIVLJKW7KLVLVUHODWHGE,EQ0DMDK
70.
$EX'DZXG UHFRUGVWKDW:KHQKHZDQWHGWRUHOLHYHKLPVHOIKHZRXOGJRZKHUHQRRQHFRXOGVHHKLP+HDOVR UHODWHG:KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZHQWRXWKHZRXOGJRYHUIDUDZD
)LTKD2QHVKRXOGPHQWLRQWKHQDPHRI$OODKDQGVHHNUHIXJHLQ+LPZKHQHQWHULQJWKHSULYRU UHPRYLQJKLVFORWKHVWRUHOLHYHKLPVHOI $QDVUHSRUWHGWKDWZKHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHHQWHUHGWKHSULYKHZRXOG VD ,Q WKH QDPH RI $OODK 2 $OODK , VHHN UHIXJH LQ RX IURPPDOH DQG IHPDOH QR[LRXV EHLQJV GHYLOV
71.
7KLVLVUHODWHGEWKHJURXS )LTKE2QHVKRXOGQRWWDONZKHQJRLQJWRWKHEDWKURRP 2QHVKRXOGQRWUHVSRQGWRDJUHHWLQJRUUHSHDWZKDWWKHFDOOHUWRSUDHULVVDLQJ+HPDVSHDNLI
WKHUH LV VRPH QHFHVVLW LH WRJXLGHDEOLQGPDQZKRIHDUVKHPDEHKDUPHG
72.
,IKHVQHH]HVKH VKRXOGSUDLVH$OODKWRKLPVHOIDQGVLPSOPRYHKLVOLSVZLWKRXWPDNLQJDVRXQG
73.
,EQ 8PDUUHODWHG WKDWDPDQSDVVHGEWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGJUHHWHGKLPZKLOHKHWKH3URSKHW
74.
ZDV XULQDWLQJ 7KH
3URSKHW GLG QRW UHWXUQ KLV JUHHWLQJ 7KLV LV UHODWHG E WKH JURXS H[FHSW IRU DO %XNKDUL
75.
$EX6D HHGUHSRUWHGWKDWKHKHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVD,VQ W LW WUXH
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
76.
EHWZHHQRXDQGWKHTLEODKWKHUHLVQRWKLQJZURQJ ZLWKLW 7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EX'DZXG,EQ.KX]DLPDKDQGDO+DNLP,WVFKDLQLVKDVVDQDV,EQ+DMUVDLGLQ
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
77.
)LTK2QHVKRXOGQRW XULQDWHLQEDWKLQJSODFHVRULQVWLOORUUXQQLQJZDWHU $EGXOODKLEQ0XJKDIIDOQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG1RQHRIRXVKRXOGXULQDWHLQDEDWKLQJSODFH
DQGWKHQPDNHDEOXWLRQLQWKHZDWHU7KHPDMRULWRIZDVZDVFRPHVIURPWKDW7KLVLVUHODWHGEWKH ILYHEXWWKHVWDWHPHQWDQGWKHQPDNHDEOXWLRQLQLWZDVRQOUHODWHGE$KPDGDQG$EX'DZXG -DELU VDLG WKH 3URSKHW IRUEDGH XULQDWLQJ LQ VWLOO DV ZHOO DV UXQQLQJZDWHU 5HODWHG E$KPDG DQ 1DVD L DQG ,EQ 0DMDK
78.
,Q 0DMPD D]=XZDLG
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
79.
$QDVUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZRXOGHQWHUWKHSULYDQGWKDW$QDVDQGDQRWKHUERZRXOG FDUUWKHZDWHUFRQWDLQHUDQGVSHDUIRUKLP7KH3URSKHWZRXOGFOHDQKLPVHOIZLWKZDWHU5HODWHGE DO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
80.
,EQ $EEDVUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHSDVVHGEWZRJUDYHVDQGVDLG 7KHDUHEHLQJSXQLVKHG%XWWKHDUHQRWEHLQJSXQLVKHGIRUDJUHDWPDWWHURQWKHLUSDUW
81.
2QHRI WKHPGLG QRWFOHDQKLPVHOIIURPXULQHDQGWKHRWKHUXVHGWRVSUHDGVODQGHU5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
82.
$QDV DOVR UHODWHG
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
83.
+DIVDKUHSRUWHG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHUHVHUYHGKLVULJKWKDQGIRUHDWLQJ GULQNLQJSXWWLQJRQKLVFORWKHVWDNLQJDQGJLYLQJ+HXVHGKLVOHIWKDQGIRURWKHUDFWLRQV5HODWHG E$KPDG$EX'DZXG,EQ0DMDK,EQ+LEEDQDO+DNLPDQGDO%DLKDTL
84.
)LTKD2QHVKRXOGUHPRYHDQEDGVPHOOIURP KLVKDQGVDIWHUFOHDQLQJKLPVHOI $EX+XUDLUDKVDLG:KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHUHOLHYHGKLPVHOI,XVHGWR
EULQJ KLP D FRQWDLQHU RI ZDWHU +H ZRXOG FOHDQVH KLPVHOI WKHQ UXE KLV KDQGV DJDLQVW WKH VRLO 5HODWHGE$EX'DZXGDQ1DVD LDO%DLKDTLDQG,EQ0DMDK
85.
)LTKE2QHVKRXOGVSULQNOHKLVSHQLVDQGXQGHUZHDUZLWKZDWHUDIWHUXULQDWLRQ 0DNHVXUHWKDWKHKDVFOHDQVHGKLPVHOI,IRQHILQGVVRPHGDPSQHVVLQKLVFORWKHVDIWHUVRGRLQJKH FDQFRQWHQWKLPVHOIEVDLQJ7KDWLV
MXVWZDWHU7KLVLVEDVHGRQWKHKDGLWKUHODWHGEDO+DNLP LEQ6XIDQRU6XIDQLEQDO+DNLPZKRVDLG:KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH XULQDWHGKHZRXOGZDVKDQGVSULQNOHKLVSHQLV
86.
,QDQRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLWVWDWHV,VDZWKH0HVVHQJHU LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
87.
RI$OODKXULQDWHDIWHUZKLFKKHVSULQNOHGZDWHURYHUKLVSHQLV,EQ 8PDUXVHGWRVSULQNOHKLVSHQLV XQWLOKLVXQGHUZHDUEHFDPHZHW )LTKF(QWHULQJWKHEDWKURRP
2QHVKRXOGHQWHUWKHEDWKURRPRUDSULYZLWKKLVOHIWIRRWDQGH[LWZLWKKLVULJKWIRRWVDLQJ2 $OODK,VHHNRXUIRUJLYHQHVV $LVKDKUHODWHGWKDWZKHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKOHIWWKHEDWKURRP KHZRXOGVDWKLVVXSSOLFDWLRQ5HODWHGEWKHILYHH[FHSWIRUDQ1DVD L
88.
:KDW $LVKDKVWDWHGLVWKH VRXQGHVWVWDWHPHQWRQWKLVWRSLF,WLVUHODWHGWKURXJKDQXPEHURIZHDNFKDLQVWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQ ZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGWRVD3UDLVHEHWR$OODKZKRPDGHWKHILOWKOHDYHPHDQGZKRKDVJLYHQPH
KHDOWK DQG 3UDLVH EH WR$OODKZKR OHWPHHQMRLWNHSWIRUPHLWVHQHUJDQGUHOLHYHGPHRILWV KDUP )LTK$FWVWKDWFRUUHVSRQGWRWKH1DWXUHRI0DQNLQG $OODK KDV FKRVHQ FHUWDLQ DFWV IRU DOO RI +LV SURSKHWV DQG WKHLU IROORZHUV WR SHUIRUP 7KHVH DFWV GLVWLQJXLVKWKHPIURPWKHUHVWRIPDQNLQGDQGDUHNQRZQDVVXQDQDOILWUDWKH DFWVWKDWFRUUHVSRQG WRWKHQDWXUHRIPDQNLQG
89.
)LTKDLUFXPFLVLRQ 7KLVSUHYHQWVGLUWIURPJHWWLQJRQRQH VSHQLVDQGDOVRPDNHVLWHDVWRNHHSLWFOHDQ)RUZRPHQLW LQYROYHVFXWWLQJWKHRXWHUSRUWLRQRIWKHFOLWRULV$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDW
WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK VDLG ,EUDKLP FLUFXPFLVHG KLPVHOI DIWHU KH ZDV HLJKW HDUV ROG 5HODWHG E DO%XNKDUL
90.
0DQ VFKRODUVVDWKDWLWLVREOLJDWRU Ì7KH6KDI LDKPDLQWDLQWKDWLWVKRXOGEHGRQHRQWKHVHYHQWKGD 6DVDVK6KDXNDQL7KHUHLVQRWKLQJWKDWVWDWHVH[SOLFLWOLWVWLPHRULQGLFDWHVWKDWLWLVREOLJDWRU
)LTKE6KDYLQJSXELFKDLUVDQGSXOOLQJRXWXQGHUDUPKDLUV 7KHDUHWZRVXQDQDFWV,IWKHKDLULVRQOWULPPHGRUSXOOHGRXWLWZLOOVXIILFH )LTKFOLSSLQJRQH VILQJHUQDLOVWULPPLQJDQGVKDYLQJKLVPRXVWDFKH ,EQ 8PDU UHODWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK VDLG 'LIIHU IURP WKH SROWKHLVWV OHW RXU EHDUGV JURZ
91.
DQGVKDYHRXUPRXVWDFKH5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
92.
$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDW WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG)LYHWKLQJVDUHSDUWRIRQH VILWUD6KDYLQJWKH SXELFKDLUVFLUFXPFLVLRQWULPPLQJWKHPRXVWDFKHUHPRYLQJWKHKDLUXQGHUWKHDUPVDQGWULPPLQJ
WKH QDLOV 5HODWHG E WKH JURXS
93.
,W GRHV QRW
PHQWLRQ ZKLFK RQH ZRXOG VSHFLILFDOO IXOILOO WKH VXQQDK2QH VKRXOGPDNH VXUH WKDW KLVPRXVWDFKH LV QRW VR ORQJ WKDW IRRGSDUWLFOHVGULQNDQGGLUW DFFXPXODWHLQLW=DLGLEQ$UTDPUHODWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KRHYHUGRHV QRWWDNHRII
94.
VRPHRIKLVPRXVWDFKHLVQRWRQHRIXV5HODWHGE$KPDGDQ1DVD LDQGDW7LUPL]KL ZKRFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
95.
,WLVSUHIHUUHGWRFXWWKHSXELFKDLUVSOXFNRXWWKHXQGHUDUPKDLUVFXWWKH QDLOVDQGWULPWKHPRXVWDFKHRQDZHHNOEDVLVDSUDFWLFHZKLFKLVPRVWKJHQLF ,IVRPHXQQHFHVVDU
KDLU LV OHIW RQ WKH ERG IRU D ORQJHU SHULRG RI WLPH LWPD GLVWXUE WKH SHUVRQ2QHPD OHDYH WKLV DFWLRQIRUIRUWGDVEXWQRORQJHU6DLG$QDV7KHWLPHSHULRGIRUXVWRWULPWKHPRXVWDFKHFXWWKH QDLOVSOXFNRXWWKHXQGHUDUPKDLUVDQGFXWWKHSXELFKDLUVZDVIRUWQLJKWV5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX 'DZXGDQGRWKHUV
96.
)LTK/HWWLQJRQH VEHDUGJURZDQGEHFRPHWKLFN 7KLVLVDIHDWXUHRIGLJQLW,WVKRXOGQRWEHFXWVRVKRUWWKDWLWDSSHDUVOLNHDVKDYHGEHDUGQRUVKRXOG LWEH
OHIWVRORQJWKDWLWEHFRPHVXQWLG,WLVDOVRDVLJQRIPDQKRRG6DVDO%XNKDUL:KHQHYHU,EQ 8PDUPDGHWKHKDMMRU XPUDKKHZRXOGKROGKLVEHDUGLQKLVILVWDQGZKDWHYHUH[FHHGHGKLVILVWKH ZRXOGFXWRII )LTKD2LOLQJDQGFRPELQJRQH VKDLU $EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDVVDLQJ:KRHYHUKDVKDLUVKRXOGKRQRU LW5HODWHGE$EX'DZXG
97.
6DLG $WDLEQDVDU$PDQFDPHWRWKH3URSKHWZLWKXQNHPSWKDLUDQGDQXQWLGEHDUG7KH3URSKHW SRLQWHGWRKLPDVLIRUGHULQJKLPWRVWUDLJKWHQKLVKDLUDQGEHDUG+HGLGVRDQGUHWXUQHG7KHUHXSRQ WKH3URSKHWREVHUYHG ,VWKDWQRWEHWWHUWKDQRQHRIRXFRPLQJZLWKKLVKDLUXQNHPSWDVLIKHZHUHD
GHYLO 5HODWHGE0DOLN
98.
$EX4DWDGDKUHODWHGWKDWKHKDGDJUHDWDPRXQW RIKDLU+HDVNHGWKH3URSKHW20HVVHQJHURI$OODK ,KDYHORWVRIKDLU6KRXOG,FRPELW+HDQVZHUHGHVDQGKRQRULW$EX4DWDGDKXVHGWRRLOLW
WZLFHDGDGXHWRWKH3URSKHW VZRUGVDQGKRQRULW LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
99.
XWWLQJRQH VKDLURIILVSHUPLVVLEOHDQGVRLVOHWWLQJLWJURZLIRQHKRQRUVLW,EQ 8PDUQDUUDWHGWKDW WKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG6KDYHLWDOORUOHDYHLWDOO5HODWHGE$KPDG0XVOLP $EX'DZXGDQGDQ1DVD L
100.
7RVKDYHSDUWRILWDQGOHDYHSDUWRILWLVJUHDWOGLVOLNHG1DID UHODWHG IURP,EQ 8PDUWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKSURKLELWHGTL]D 1DID DVNHG:KDWLVTL]D +HVDLG ,WLVWRVKDYHRIISDUWRIWKHKDLURIDRXWKDQGWROHDYHSDUW$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
101.
)LTK/HDYLQJJUHKDLUVLQSODFH 7KLVDSSOLHVWRERWKPHQDQGZRPHQ $PULEQ6KX DLEUHODWHGRQWKHDXWKRULWRIKLVIDWKHUIURPKLV JUDQGIDWKHUWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG'RQRWSOXFNWKHJUHKDLUVDVWKHDUHD0XVOLP VOLJKW1HYHUD
0XVOLPJURZVJUHLQ,VODPH[FHSWWKDW$OODKZULWHVIRUKLPGXHWRWKDWDJRRGGHHG$QGKHUDLVHV KLPDGHJUHH$QGKHHUDVHVIRUKLPGXHWRWKDWRQHRIKLVVLQV5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXG DW7LUPL]KLDQ1DVD LDQG,EQ0DMDK
102.
$QG$QDVVDLG:HXVHGWRKDWHWKDWDPDQVKRXOGSOXFNRXW KLVZKLWHKDLUVIURPKLVKHDGRUEHDUG5HODWHGE0XVOLP
103.
)LTKDKDQJLQJWKHFRORURIJUHKDLUEXVLQJKHQQDUHGGHHOORZGHDQGVRRQ $EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG7KH-HZVDQGKULVWLDQVGRQRW GHVRGLIIHUIURPWKHP5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
104.
$EX=KDUUUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK VDLG7KHEHVWWKLQJWKDWRQHFDQXVHWRFKDQJHWKHFRORURIJUHKDLUVLVKHQQDDQGNDWPDUHGGLVK GH
105.
5HODWHGEWKHILYH
106.
7KHUH DUH VRPH
QDUUDWLRQV WKDW VWDWH WKDW GLQJ LV GLVOLNHG EXW LW LV REYLRXV WKDW WKHVH QDUUDWLRQV FRQIOLFWZLWKWKHVXQQDKDQGFXVWRP,WLVUHODWHGIURPVRPHRIWKHFRPSDQLRQVWKDWLWLVEHWWHUQRWWR GHZKLOHRWKHUVVDLWLVEHWWHUWRGRLW6RPHXVHGDHOORZGHZKLOHRWKHUVXVHGKHQQDRUNDWP 2WKHUVXVHGVDIIURQDQGDJURXSRIWKHPXVHGDEODFNGH,EQ+DMUPHQWLRQHGLQ)DWKDO%DULWKDWD] =XKULVDLG:HXVHGEODFNGHLIRXUIDFHZDVRXWKIXOEXWLIZULQNOHVZHUHSUHVHQWDQGWKHWHHWK ZHUH JRQHZHZRXOG QRW XVH LW 6DLG -DELU$EX4XKDIDK$EX%DNU VIDWKHU
107.
ZDVEURXJKWWRWKH 3URSKHW GXULQJ
WKH FRQTXHVW RI0DNNDK ZKLOH KLV KHDG ZDV ZKLWH 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQZKRP EH SHDFHVDLG7DNHKLPWRRQHRIKLVZLYHVDQGOHWKHUFKDQJHWKHFRORURIKLVKDLUZLWKVRPHWKLQJEXW VKH VKRXOG DYRLG PDNLQJ KLV KDLU
108.
EODFN 5HODWHG E
WKH JURXS H[FHSW IRU DO%XNKDUL DQG DW 7LUPL]KL
109.
7KLVGHDOWZLWKDFHUWDLQLQFLGHQWDQGFDQQRWEHJHQHUDOL]HG)XUWKHUPRUHEODFNZRXOGQRW EHSURSHUIRUVRPHRQHDVROGDV$EX4XKDIDK )LTK7RXVHPXVNDQGRWKHUWSHVRISHUIXPH
7KHVHDUHSOHDVLQJWRWKHVRXODQGEHDXWLIWKHDWPRVSKHUH$QDVUHSRUWHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDV VDLQJ$PRQJWKHWKLQJVRIWKLVZRUOG,ORYHZRPHQDQGSHUIXPHDQGWKHFRROQHVVRIPHHVLV SUDHU5HODWHGE$KPDGDQGDQ1DVD L
110.
$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG ,IVRPHRQHRIIHUVSHUIXPHGRQRWUHMHFWLWIRULWLVOLJKWWRFDUUDQGKDVDVZHHWVFHQW5HODWHGE 0XVOLPDQ1DVD LDQG$EX'DZXG
111.
$EX6D HHGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLGDERXW PXVN,WLVWKH EHVWRISHUIXPHV5HODWHGEWKHJURXSH[FHSWIRUDO%XNKDULDQG,EQ0DMDK
112.
1DID QDUUDWHGWKDW,EQ 8PDUXVHGWREXUQDQGLQKDOHDEUDQFKFDOOHGDOXZDKWKDWKDVDQLFHVPHOO+H DOVRXVHGFDPSKRU+HXVHGWRVD7KLVLVWKHZDWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKLQKDOHGVXFKVFHQWVWKDW LVEEXUQLQJWKHP
113.
5HODWHGE0XVOLPDQGDQ1DVD L
114.
)LTK$EOXWLRQPHDQVWRZDVKRQH VIDFHKDQGVDUPVKHDGDQGIHHWZLWKZDWHU )LTKD3DUWRI,VODPLFODZ 7KLVLVSURYHQIURPWKHWKUHHPDMRUVRXUFHVRI,VODPLFODZ
7KH4XU DQ6DV$OODKLQWKH4XU DQ2RXZKREHOLHYHZKHQRXULVHIRUSUDHUZDVKRXU IDFHVDQGRXUKDQGVXSWRWKHHOERZVDQGOLJKWOUXERXUKHDGVDQGZDVK
115.
RXUIHHWXSWRWKHDQNOHV DO0DL GDK
116.
7KH6XQQDK$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG$OODKGRHVQRWDFFHSWWKH SUDHURIRQHZKRQXOOLILHGKLVDEOXWLRQXQWLOKHSHUIRUPVLWDJDLQ5HODWHGEDO%XNKDUL0XVOLP $EX'DZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL
117.
7KHRQVHQVXV 7KHUH LV
D FRQVHQVXV RI VFKRODUO RSLQLRQ WKDW DEOXWLRQ LV SDUW RI ,VODPLF ODZ 7KHUHIRUHLWLVDUHFRJQL]HGIDFWRIWKHUHOLJLRQ )LTKE,WVYLUWXHV 0DQKDGLWKVWDWHWKHYLUWXHVRIDEOXWLRQ:HVKDOOPHQWLRQMXVWDIHZ LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
118.
$EGXOODKLEQDV6XQQDELMLVWDWHGWKDWWKH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG:KHQDVODYHPDNHVDEOXWLRQ DQGULQVHVKLVPRXWKKLVZURQJGHHGVIDOOIURPLW$VKHULQVHVKLVQRVHKLVZURQJGHHGVIDOOIURPLW
:KHQ KHZDVKHV KLV IDFH KLV ZURQJ GHHGV IDOO IURP LW XQWLO WKH IDOO IURP EHQHDWK KLV HHODVKHV :KHQ KH ZDVKHV KLV KDQGV KLV ZURQJ GHHGV IDOO IURP WKHP XQWLO WKH IDOO IURP EHQHDWK KLV ILQJHUQDLOV:KHQKHZLSHVKLVKHDGKLVZURQJGHHGVIDOOIURPLWXQWLOWKHIDOOIURPKLVHDUV:KHQ KHZDVKHVKLVIHHWKLVZURQJGHHGVIDOOIURPWKHPXQWLOWKHIDOOIURPEHQHDWKKLVWRHQDLOV7KHQKLV ZDONLQJWRWKHPRVTXHDQGKLVSUDHUJLYHKLPH[WUDUHZDUG5HODWHGE0DOLNDQ1DVD L,EQ0DMDK DQGDO+DNLP
119.
$QDVUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG,IJRRGFKDUDFWHULVWLFVH[LVWLQDSHUVRQ$OODK PDNHVDOORIKLVDFWVJRRG,IDSHUVRQSXULILHVKLPVHOIIRUSUDHUKHH[SLDWHVDOORIKLVVLQVDQGKLV SUDHULVFRQVLGHUHGDQH[WUDUHZDUGIRUKLP5HODWHGE$EXD ODDO%D]]DUDQGDW7DEDUDQLLQDO
$XVDW
120.
$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG 6KDOO,LQIRUPRXRIDQDFW
121.
EZKLFK $OODK HUDVHV
VLQV DQG UDLVHV GHJUHHV 7KH VDLG HUWDLQO 2 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK +H VDLG 3HUIHFWLQJWKHDEOXWLRQXQGHUGLIILFXOWFLUFXPVWDQFHVWDNLQJPDQVWHSVWRWKHPRVTXHDQGZDLWLQJ IRU WKH QH[W
122.
SUDHU DIWHU WKH
ODVW
123.
SUDHU KDV EHHQ
SHUIRUPHG 7KDW LV ULEDW 5HODWHG E0DOLN 0XVOLPDW7LUPL]KLDQGDQ1DVD L
124.
$EX+XUDLUDKDOVRUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHSDVVHGEDJUDYH VLWHDQGVDLG3HDFHEHXSRQRX2KRPHRIEHOLHYLQJSHRSOH$OODKZLOOLQJZHVKDOOPHHWRXVRRQ DOWKRXJK
, ZLVK , FRXOG VHHP EURWKHUV 7KH DVNHG$UHZHQRWRXUEURWKHUV20HVVHQJHURI $OODK+HVDLGRXDUHPFRPSDQLRQV0EURWKHUVDUHWKHRQHVZKRZLOOFRPHDIWHUXV
125.
7KH VDLG+RZZLOORXNQRZWKHSHRSOHRIRXUQDWLRQZKRZLOOFRPHDIWHURX20HVVHQJHURI$OODK +HVDLG,IDPDQKDVDJURXSRIKRUVHVZLWKZKLWHIRUHORFNVDPLGVWDJURXSRIKRUVHVZLWKEODFN
IRUHORFNV ZLOO KH UHFRJQL]H KLV KRUVHV 7KH VDLG HUWDLQO 20HVVHQJHU RI $OODK +H VDLG 7KHPEURWKHUV
126.
ZLOOFRPHZLWKZKLWHVWUHDNVIURPWKHLUDEOXWLRQVDQG,ZLOOUHFHLYHWKHPDWP FLVWHUQ%XWWKHUHZLOOEHVRPHZKRZLOOEHGULYHQDZDIURPPFLVWHUQDVDVWUDFDPHOLVGULYHQ DZD,ZLOOFDOOWKHPWRFRPH,WZLOOEHVDLG 7KHFKDQJHGPDWWHUVDIWHURX WKHQ,ZLOOVD %H
RIIEHRII 5HODWHGE0XVOLP
127.
)LTK7KHREOLJDWRUSDUWVRIWKHDEOXWLRQ $EOXWLRQKDVFHUWDLQFRPSRQHQWVZKLFKLIQRWIXOILOOHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRUUHFW,VODPLFSURFHGXUHV PDNHRQH VDEOXWLRQYRLG
)LTKD,QWHQWLRQ 7KLVLVWKHGHVLUHWRGRWKHDFWLRQDQGWRSOHDVH$OODKEIROORZLQJ+LVFRPPDQG,WLVSXUHODQDFWRI WKHKHDUWIRUWKHWRQJXHYHUEDOSURQRXQFHPHQWDQGVRRQ
128.
KDVQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKLW7RSURQRXQFHLW LVQRWSDUWRIWKH,VODPLFODZ7KDWWKHLQWHQWLRQLVREOLJDWRULVVKRZQLQWKHIROORZLQJ 8PDUUHODWHG WKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG(YHUDFWLRQLVEDVHGRQWKHLQWHQWLRQEHKLQGLW
129.
DQG HYHURQHVKDOOKDYHZKDWKHLQWHQGHG5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
130.
)LTKE:DVKLQJWKHIDFH 7KLVLQYROYHVSRXULQJRUUXQQLQJZDWHUIURPWKHWRSRIWKHIRUHKHDGWRWKHERWWRPRIWKHMDZVDQG IURPRQHHDUWRWKHRWKHU
)LTKF:DVKLQJWKHDUPVWRWKHHOERZ 7KHHOERZVPXVWEHZDVKHGIRUWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGLGVR )LTKG:LSLQJWKHKHDG 7KLVPHDQVWRZLSHRQH VKHDGZLWKKLVKDQG,WLVQRWVXIILFLHQWMXVWWRSODFHWKHKDQGRQWKHKHDGRU WRWRXFKWKHKHDGZLWKDZHWILQJHU7KHDSSDUHQW PHDQLQJRIWKH4XU DQLFZRUGVDQGZLSHRYHU RXU KHDGV GRHV QRW LPSO WKDW DOO RI WKH KHDG QHHGV WR EH ZLSHG ,W KDV EHHQ UHFRUGHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHWXVHGWRZLSHKLVKHDGWKUHHGLIIHUHQWZDV :LSLQJDOORIKLVKHDG $EGXOODKLEQ=DLGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZLSHG KLVHQWLUHKHDGZLWKKLVKDQGV+HVWDUWHGZLWKWKHIURQWRIKLVKHDGWKHQPRYHGWRWKHEDFNDQGWKHQ UHWXUQHGKLVKDQGVWRWKHIURQW5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
131.
:LSLQJ RYHU WKH
WXUEDQ RQO 6DLG $PUX LEQ8PDDK , VDZ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH ZLSH RYHU KLV WXUEDQ DQG VKRHV 5HODWHG E$KPDG DO%XNKDUL DQG ,EQ0DMDK
132.
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
133.
%LODOUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:LSHRYHURXUVKRHVDQGKHDGFRYHULQJ 5HODWHGE$KPDG
134.
8PDURQFHVDLG0D$OODKQRWSXULIWKHRQHZKRGRHVQRWFRQVLGHUZLSLQJ RYHUWKHWXUEDQWREHSXULILQJ0DQKDGLWKKDYHEHHQUHODWHGRQWKLVWRSLFEDO%XNKDUL0XVOLP DQGRWKHUV0RVWRIWKHVFKRODUVDJUHHZLWKWKHP
:LSLQJRYHUWKHIURQWSRUWLRQRIWKHVFDOSDQGWKHWXUEDQ $O0XJKLUDKLEQ6KX EDKVDLGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHPDGHDEOXWLRQDQG ZLSHG RYHU WKH IURQW SRUWLRQ RI KLV VFDOS KLV WXUEDQ DQG KLV VRFNV 5HODWHG E0XVOLP
135.
7KHUHLV KRZHYHU QR
VWURQJ KDGLWKWKDW KH ZLSHG RYHU SDUW RI KLV KHDG HYHQ WKRXJK DO0D LGDK DSSDUHQWO LPSOLHVLW,WLVDOVRQRWVXIILFLHQWMXVWWRZLSHRYHUORFNVRIKDLUWKDWSURFHHGIURPWKHKHDGRUDORQJ WKHVLGHVRIWKHKHDG )LTK:DVKLQJWKHIHHWDQGWKHKHHOV 7KLVKDVEHHQFRQILUPHGLQPXWDZDWLUFRQWLQXRXV
136.
UHSRUWVIURPWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH FRQFHUQLQJKLVDFWLRQVDQGVWDWHPHQWV,EQ 8PDUVDLG7KH3URSKHWODJJHGEHKLQGXVLQRQHRIRXU WUDYHOV+HFDXJKWXSZLWKXVDIWHUZHKDGGHODHGWKHDIWHUQRRQSUDHU:HVWDUWHGWRPDNHDEOXWLRQ
DQGZHUHZLSLQJRYHURXUIHHWZKHQWKH3URSKHWVDLG :RHWRWKHKHHOVVDYHWKHPIURPWKH+HOOILUH UHSHDWLQJLWWZRRUWKUHHWLPHV5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
137.
1HHGOHVVWRVDWKHSUHFHGLQJREOLJDWLRQVDUHWKHRQHVWKDW$OODKKDVPHQWLRQHGLQDO0D LGDK
138.
)LTKD)ROORZLQJWKHSUHVFULEHGVHTXHQFH $OODKPHQWLRQHGWKHREOLJDWLRQVLQDVSHFLILFRUGHU+HDOVRGLIIHUHQWLDWHGWKHOHJVIURPWKHKDQGV WKRXJKERWKRIWKHPKDYHWREHZDVKHGIURPWKHKHDGZKLFKRQOQHHGVWREHZLSHG7KHSROWKHLVWV
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
139.
$LVKDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG7KHWRRWKEUXVKSXULILHVWKHPRXWKDQGLVSOHDVLQJWR WKH/RUG5HODWHGE$KPDGDQ1DVD LDQGDW7LUPL]KL
140.
8VLQJDWRRWKEUXVKLVOLNHGDWDQWLPHEXWWKHUHDUHILYHWLPHVLQZKLFKLW LVHVSHFLDOOOLNHG
DEOXWLRQ SUDHU UHDGLQJWKH4XU DQ ULVLQJIURPVOHHSDQG ZKHQ WKH WDVWH LQ RQH VPRXWK KDV FKDQJHG )DVWLQJ DQG QRQIDVWLQJ SHRSOH PD XVH LW DW WKH EHJLQQLQJ WKH HQG RU DW DQ RWKHU WLPH GXULQJ WKH GD $PU LEQ 5DEL DK VDLG , KDYH VHHQ WKH LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
141.
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHRQFRXQWOHVVRFFDVLRQVXVLQJDWRRWKEUXVKZKLOHIDVWLQJ 5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL
142.
:KHQ RQH XVHV
D WRRWKEUXVK LW LV VXQQDK WR FOHDQ LW DIWHUZDUGV 6DLG $LVKDK:KHQ WKH3URSKHW XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGKLVWRRWKEUXVKKHZRXOGJLYHLWWRPH,ZRXOGZDVKLWXVHLWZDVKLW DJDLQDQGJLYHLWEDFNWRKLP5HODWHGE$EX'DZXGDQGDO%DLKDTL
143.
,W LV SDUW
RI WKH VXQQDK WKDW RQHZKR KDV QR WHHWK PD XVH KLV ILQJHUV WR FOHDQ KLVPRXWK$VNHG $LVKDK20HVVHQJHURI$OODKKRZVKRXOGDWRRWKOHVVSHUVRQFOHDQVHKLVPRXWK%SXWWLQJKLV ILQJHUVLQWRKLVPRXWKKHUHSOLHG5HODWHGEDW7DEDUDQL
144.
)LTK:DVKLQJWKHKDQGVWKUHHWLPHVDWWKHEHJLQQLQJ 7KLVLVEDVHGRQWKHKDGLWKRI$XVLEQ$XVDO7KDTDILZKRVDLG,VDZWKH0HVVHQDJHURI$OODKPDNH DEOXWLRQ
DQG KHZDVKHG KLV KDQGV WKUHH WLPHV 5HODWHG E$KPDG DQG DQ1DVD L
145.
$EX+XUDLUDK UHSRUWHG WKDW
WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG :KHQ RQH RI RX ULVHV IURP KLV VOHHS KH VKRXOGQRWSXWKLVKDQGLQWRDSRWXQWLOKHKDVZDVKHGLWWKUHHWLPHVIRUKHGRHVQRWNQRZZKHUHKLV KDQGZDVZKLOHKHVOHSW
146.
5HODWHGEWKHJURXSDO%XNKDULGLGQRWPHQWLRQWKHQXPEHURIWLPHV
147.
)LTKD5LQVLQJWKHPRXWKWKUHHWLPHV /DTLW LEQ
6DEUDK UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW VDLG:KHQ RQH SHUIRUPV DEOXWLRQ KH VKRXOG ULQVH KLV PRXWK5HODWHGE$EX'DZXGDQGDO%DLKDTL
148.
)LTKE6QLIILQJXSDQGEORZLQJRXWZDWHUWKUHHWLPHV $EX +XUDLUDK
UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG :KHQ RQH RI RX SHUIRUPV DEOXWLRQKHVKRXOGVQLIIZDWHUXSKLVQRVWULOVDQGWKHQEORZLWRXW5HODWHGEDO%XNKDUL0XVOLP DQG$EX'DZXG
149.
7KHVXQQDKLVWRSXWWKHZDWHULQWRWKHQRVWULOVZLWKWKHULJKWKDQGDQGEORZLWRXWZLWKWKHOHIW $OL RQFHFDOOHGIRUZDWHUIRUDEOXWLRQULQVHGKLVPRXWKVQLIIHGXSZDWHULQWRKLVQRVWULOVDQGEOHZLWRXW ZLWKKLVOHIWKDQG+HGLGWKDWWKUHHWLPHVDQGWKHQVDLG7KDWLVKRZWKH3USRKHWXSRQZKRPEH
SHDFHZRXOGSXULIKLPVHOI5HODWHGE$KPDGDQGDQ1DVD L
150.
7KLVVXQQDKLVIXOILOOHGESXWWLQJZDWHULQWRWKHPRXWKDQGQRVWULOVLQDQZD7KHSUDFWLFHRIWKH 3URSKHWZDVWRGRERWKDFWVDWWKHVDPHWLPH $EGXOODKLEQ=DLGVDLG7KH3URSKHWZRXOGULQVHKLV PRXWKDQGQRVHZLWKMXVWRQHKDQGDWRQHWLPHWRJHWKHU
151.
+HGLGWKDWWKUHHWLPHV,QRQHQDUUDWLRQLW VDV+HZRXOGULQVHKLVPRXWKDQGQRVHZLWKWKUHHVFRRSVRIZDWHU5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG 0XVOLP
152.
,WLVDOVRVXQQDKWREHSOHQWLIXOZLWKZDWHU
153.
ZKLOHSHUIRUPLQJWKLVVXQQDKH[FHSWLIRQHLV IDVWLQJ/DTLWDVNHGWKH3URSKHW,QIRUPPHDERXWRXUDEOXWLRQ+HUHSOLHGRPSOHWHDQGSHUIHFW WKHDEOXWLRQDQGSXWZDWHU
154.
EHWZHHQRXUILQJHUV8VHORWVRIZDWHUZKLOHVQLIILQJLWXSRXUQRVWULOV XQOHVVRXDUHIDVWLQJ5HODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLVDLGLWLVVDKLK
155.
)LTK5XQQLQJRQH VILQJHUVWKURXJKKLVEHDUG $LVKDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZRXOGUXQKLVILQJHUVWKURXJKKLVEHDUG5HODWHGE,EQ 0DMDKDQGDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
156.
$QDVVDLGWKDWZKHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKSHUIRUPHGDEOXWLRQKHZRXOGWDNHDKDQGIXORIZDWHUDQG SXWLWXQGHUKLVMDZVDQGSDVVLWWKURXJKKLVEHDUG+HVDLG7KLVLVZKDWP/RUG$OODKRUGHUHGPH WRGR5HODWHGE$EX'DZXGDO%DLKDTLDQGDO+DNLP
157.
)LTKD5XQQLQJZDWHUWKURXJKRQH VILQJHUVDQGWRHV ,EQ $EEDV
VDLG WKDW ZKHQ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK SHUIRUPHG DEOXWLRQ KH ZRXOG UXQ KLV ILQJHUV WKURXJK KLV ILQJHUV DQG WRHV 5HODWHG E WKH ILYH H[FHSW $KPDG
158.
,W LV DOVR
UHODWHG WKDW LW LV SUHIHUDEOH WR UHPRYH MHZHOU IRU H[DPSOH ULQJV EUDFHOHWV DQG VR RQ ZKLOH SHUIRUPLQJ DEOXWLRQ (YHQ WKRXJK WKHVH UHSRUWV DUH QRW DFFHSWHG DV IXOO DXWKHQWLF RQHPXVW IROORZ WKHP IRU WKH IDOO XQGHUWKHJHQHUDOFDWHJRURIFRPSOHWLQJ DQGSHUIHFWLQJWKHDEOXWLRQ )LTKE5HSHDWLQJHDFKZDVKLQJWKUHHWLPHV 7KLV LV D VXQQDK WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH DOPRVW DOZDV IROORZHG ,I KH DFWHG RWKHUZLVH LW ZDV MXVW WR VKRZ WKDW WKH RWKHU DFWV DUH SHUPLVVLEOH $PU LEQ 6KX DLE UHODWHG RQ WKH DXWKRULWRIKLVIDWKHUIURPKLVJUDQGIDWKHUZKRVDLG$EHGRXLQFDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK XSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGDVNHGKLPDERXWWKHDEOXWLRQ+HVKRZHGKLPKRZWRZDVKHDFKSDUWWKUHH WLPHVDQGVDLG 7KLVLVWKHDEOXWLRQ:KRHYHUGRHVPRUHWKDQWKDWKDVGRQHZURQJWUDQVJUHVVHGDQG FRPPLWWHG HYLO 5HODWHG E $KPDG DQ1DVD L DQG ,EQ 0DMDK
159.
8WKPDQ DOVR UHSRUWHG
WKDW WKH LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
160.
0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK
ZRXOG UHSHDW HDFK ZDVKLQJ WKUHH WLPHV 5HODWHG E $KPDG 0XVOLP DQG DW 7LUPL]KL
161.
,WLVDOVR SURYHQWKDWKHSHUIRUPHGHDFKZDVKLQJRQORQFHRUWZLFH$FFRUGLQJWRPRVWRI WKHUHSRUWVKHZLSHGKLVKHDGRQORQFH
)LTKF%HJLQQLQJHDFKDFWLRQZLWKWKHULJKWVLGH 6DLG $LVKDK7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKORYHGWREHJLQZLWKKLVULJKWVLGHZKLOHSXWWLQJRQKLVVKRHV VWUDLJKWHQLQJKLVKDLUDQGFOHDQLQJRUSXULILQJ
162.
KLPVHOI5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVLOP
163.
$EX +XUDLUDK UHSRUWHG
WKDW WKH 3URSKHW VDLG:KHQ RX FORWKH RUZDVK RXUVHOI EHJLQ ZLWK RXU ULJKW VLGH5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDW7LUPL]KLDQGDQ1DVD L
164.
)LTK5XEELQJWKHOLPEVZLWKZDWHU 7KLVPHDQV WR
UXE WKH KDQGV RYHU WKH ERGLO SDUWVZLWKZDWHU $EGXOODKLEQ=DLGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZDVEURXJKWDSRWRIZDWHUZKLFKKHXVHGWRSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQDQGWKHQUXEEHG KLV DUPV 5HODWHG E ,EQ .KX]DLPDK
165.
+H DOVR UHODWHG
WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK SHUIRUPHG DEOXWLRQ WKHQ UXEEHG KLV OLPEV 5HODWHG E$EX'DZXG DW7DDOLVL$KPDG ,EQ+LEEDQ DQG$EX D OD
166.
)LTKDORVHVHTXHQFH (DFKERGLOSDUWPXVWEHZDVKHGULJKWDIWHUWKHRWKHULQWKHSUHVFULEHGVHTXHQFHZLWKRXWVHSDUDWLQJ WKHZDVKLQJRIWKHGLIIHUHQWSDUWVRIDFWVQRWUHODWHGWRWKHDEXWLRQ
167.
7KLVLVWKHFXVWRPDUSUDFWLFHRI WKHHDUODQGODWHUJHQHUDWLRQVRI0XVOLPV )LTKE:LSLQJWKHHDUV
7KHVXQQDKLVWRZLSHWKHLQWHULRURIWKHHDUVZLWKWKHLQGH[ILQJHUVDQGWKHH[WHULRUSRUWLRQVZLWKWKH WKXPEV7KHZDWHUXVHGWRZLSHWKHKHDGLVDOVRXVHGIRUWKHHDUVDVWKHHDUVDUHSDUWRIWKHKHDG$O 0LTGDPLEQ0D GDNULKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZLSHGKLVKHDGDQGKLVHDUV WKHLQWHULRUDQGH[WHULRUZKLOHPDNLQJDEOXWLRQ+HDOVRSXWKLVILQJHULQVLGHKLVHDU5HODWHGE$EX 'DZXGDQGDW7DKDZL
168.
:KLOHGHVFULELQJWKHDEOXWLRQRIWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH,EQ 8PDUVDLG+HZLSHGKLV KHDGDQGHDUVZLWKRQHZLSH5HODWHGE$KPDGDQG$EX'DZXG
169.
,QRQHQDUUDWLRQLWVWDWHV+H ZLSHGWKHLQQHUSRUWLRQRIKLVHDUVZLWKKLVLQGH[ILQJHUDQGWKHRXWHUSRUWLRQZLWKKLVWKXPE )LTKF(ORQJDWLQJWKHVWUHDNVRIOLJKW
7KLV UHIHUV WRZDVKLQJ WKH FRPSOHWH IRUHKHDG D SUDFWLFHZKLFK LVPRUH WKDQZKDW LV REOLJDWRU LQ ZDVKLQJ WKH IDFH DQGZLOO LQFUHDVH WKH VWUHDN RI OLJKW RQ WKH'D RI -XGJHPHQW
170.
,W DOVR UHIHUV
WR ZDVKLQJDERYHWKHHOERZVDQGDQNOHV$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLG0 QDWLRQZLOOFRPHZLWKEULJKWVWUHDNVRIOLJKWIURPWKHWUDFHVRIDEOXWLRQ$EX+XUDLUDKWKHQVDLG,I RQHFDQOHQJWKHQKLVVWUHDNRIOLJKWKHVKRXOGGRVR5HODWHGE$KPDGDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP
171.
$EX=DU DK UHODWHGWKDWZKHQ$EX+XUDLUDKPDGHDEOXWLRQKHZDVKHGKLVDUPVDERYHKLVHOERZVDQG KLV
IHHW XS WR KLV FDOYHV+HZDVDVNHG:KGRRXGRWKLV+HVDLG7KLVLVWKHH[WHQWRIWKH HPEHOOLVKPHQW5HODWHGE$KPDG
172.
$FFRUGLQJWRDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLPLWVFKDLQLVVDKLK )LTKG(FRQRPL]LQJWKHXVHRIZDWHUHYHQLIRQHLVLQIURQWRIWKHVHD $QDVVDLG7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGWRSHUIRUPJKXVOWKHFRPSOHWHEDWKLQJ
173.
ZLWKD VD DRIZDWHUFP
174.
WRPDGGHDFKPDGGHTXDOVRQHVD D
175.
+HDOVRXVHGWRPDNHDEOXWLRQ ZLWKRQHPDGGFP
176.
RIZDWHU5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG0XVLP
177.
8EDLGXOODKLEQ$EXD]LG QDUUDWHGWKDWDPDQDVNHG,EQ $EEDV+RZPXFKZDWHULVVXIILFLHQWIRUJKXVO+HDQVZHUHG2QH PDGG
$QG KRZ PXFK LV VXIILFLHQW IRU JKXVO+H VDLG 2QH VD D 7KH PDQ VDLG 7KDW LV QRW VXIILFLHQWIRUPH,EQ $EEDVVDLG1R,WZDVVXIILFLHQWIRURQHEHWWHUWKDQRXWKH0HVVHQJHURI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH 5HODWHG E $KPDG DO%D]DDU DQG DW7DEDUDQL LQ DO.DEHHU ,WV QDUUDWRUVDUHWUXVWZRUWK
178.
$EGXOODKLEQ 8PDUQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKSDVVHGE6D G ZKLOH KH
ZDV SHUIRUPLQJ DEOXWLRQ DQG VDLG :KDW LV WKLV H[WUDYDJDQFH 6D G +H VDLG ,V WKHUH H[WUDYDJDQFH LQ WKH XVH RIZDWHU+HVDLGHVHYHQLIRXDUHDWDIORZLQJULYHU5HODWHGE $KPDGDQG,EQ0DMDKZLWKDZHDNFKDLQ
179.
([WUDYDJDQFHLVWRXVHZDWHUZLWKRXWDQEHQHILWOLNHZDVKLQJWKHSDUWVPRUHWKDQWKUHHWLPHV,EQ 6KX DLE VKDGLWKTXRWHGHDUOLHULOOXVWUDWHVWKHSRLQWLQTXHVWLRQ $EGXOODKLEQ0XJKDIIDOQDUUDWHGWKDW KH
KHDUG WKH 3URSKHW VD 7KHUH ZLOO EH SHRSOH IURP P QDWLRQ ZKR ZLOO WUDQVJUHVV LQ PDNLQJ VXSSOLFDWLRQVDQGLQSXULILQJWKHPVHOYHV5HODWHGE$KPDG$EX'DZXGDQGDQ1DVD L
180.
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
181.
6DVDO%XNKDUL7KHVFKRODUV GRQRWOLNHRQHWRXVHZDWHUEHRQGZKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEH SHDFHXVHGIRUDEOXWLRQ
)LTK6XSSOLFDWLRQZKLOHSHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ 7KHUHLVQRWKLQJFRQILUPHGIURPWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHUHJDUGLQJVXSSOLFDWLRQVGXULQJ DEOXWLRQVDYHWKHKDGLWKRI$EX0XVDDO$VK DULZKRVDLG,FDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZLWK ZDWHU:KLOHKHZDVSHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ,KHDUGKLPVXSSOLFDWH 2$OODKIRUJLYHPVLQV0DNHP UHVLGHQFH VSDFLRXV IRUPH DQG EOHVVPH LQP SURYLVLRQV , VDLG 23URSKHWRI$OODK,KHDUGRX VXSSOLFDWLQJ VXFK DQG VXFK +H VDLG 'LG , OHDYH DQWKLQJ RXW 5HODWHGEDQ1DVD LDQG,EQDV 6XQQLZLWKDVDKLKFKDLQ
182.
$Q1DZDZLLQFOXGHVWKLVHYHQWXQGHUWKHFKDSWHU:KDWLVWREHVDLGDIWHU RQHFRPSOHWHVWKHDEOXWLRQDQG,EQDV6XQQLKDVLWXQGHU:KDWLVWREHVDLGZKHQRQHLVLQWKHVWDWH RIDEOXWLRQ
$Q1DZDZLKROGVWKDWERWKPHDQLQJVPDEHLPSOLHGIURPWKHKDGLWK )LTK6XSSOLFDWLRQDIWHUDEOXWLRQ 8PDU UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG ,I RQH FRPSOHWHV DQG SHUIHFWV
183.
WKH DEOXWLRQDQGWKHQVDV ,WHVWLIWKDWWKHUHLVQRJRGH[FHSW$OODKWKH2QH:KRKDVQRSDUWQHUDQG WKDW0XKDPPDGLV+LVVODYHDQG0HVVHQJHUWKHHLJKWJDWHVRISDUDGLVHZLOOEHRSHQHGIRUKLPDQG
KHPDHQWHUDQRIWKHPWKDWKHZLVKHV5HODWHGE0XVOLP
184.
$EX6D HHGDO.KXGULUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG:KRHYHUPDNHVDEOXWLRQDQGVDV *ORUEHWR 7KHH2$OODKDQGWKHSUDLVHEHWR7KHH,EHDUZLWQHVVWKDWWKHUHLVQRJRGH[FHSWRX,EHJRXU IRUJLYHQHVVDQG,UHSHQWXQWRRX ZLOOKDYHLWZULWWHQIRUKLPDQGSODFHGRQDWDEOHWZKLFKZLOOQRW
EHEURNHQXQWLOWKH'DRI5HVXUUHFWLRQ7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEDW7DEDUDQLLQDO$XVDW,WVQDUUDWRUV DUHRIWKHVDKLK$Q1DVD LKDVLWZLWKWKHZRUGLQJ,WZLOOEH VWDPSHGZLWKDVHDOSODFHGEHORZWKH WKURQH DQG LWZLOO QRW EH EURNHQ XQWLO WKH'D RI5HVXUUHFWLRQ7KH FRUUHFW VWDWHPHQW LV WKDW LW LV PDXTRRI $VIRUWKHVXSSOLFDWLRQ$OODKFDXVHPHWREHIURPDPRQJWKHUHSHQWDQWDQGFDXVHPHWREHIURP DPRQJWKHSXUHLWKDVEHHQQDUUDWHGEDW7LUPL]KLZKRVDLG,WVFKDLQLVPX]KWDULEDQGWKHUHLV QRWKLQJDXWKHQWLFFRQFHUQLQJWKLVVXSSOLFDWLRQ
185.
)LTKD3UDLQJWZRUDN DKDIWHUDEOXWLRQ $EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLGWR%LODO2%LODOWHOO PHZKDWJRRGGHHGRXKDYHGRQHLQ,VODPWKDW,KHDUWKHVRXQGRIRXUIRRWVWHSVLQ3DUDGLVH%LODO
VDLG7KDWDIWHU,SXULIPVHOIGXULQJWKHGDRUQLJKW,SUDZLWKWKDWSXULILFDWLRQDVPXFKDV$OODK KDV GHVWLQHG IRU PH 5HODWHG E DO%XNKDUL DQG 0XVOLP
186.
8TEDK LEQ $DPU
UHODWHG WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG,IRQHSHUIRUPVDQGSHUIHFWVKLVDEOXWLRQDQGSUDV WZR UDN DK ZLWK KLV KHDUW DQG IDFH FRPSOHWHO RQ KLV SUDHU
187.
3DUDGLVH EHFRPHV KLV
5HODWHG E 0XVOLP$EX'DZXG,EQ0DMDKDQG,EQ.KX]DLPDKLQKLV6DKLK
188.
.KXPUDQWKHFOLHQWRI 8WKPDQ DGGHG,VDZ 8WKPDQFDOOIRUZDWHUIRUDEOXWLRQSRXULWIURPWKHSRWRQWRKLVULJKWKDQGDQGZDVKLW WKUHH
WLPHV+H WKHQ SXW KLV ULJKW KDQG LQWR WKH FRQWDLQHUULQVHGKLVPRXWKDQGQRVHDQGEOHZWKH ZDWHU RXW 7KHQ KHZDVKHG KLV IDFH WKUHH WLPHV IROORZHG E KLV DUPV XS WR WKH HOERZV 7KHQ KH ZDVKHG KLV IHHW WKUHH WLPHV DQG VDLG , VDZ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH PDNH DEOXWLRQ OLNH WKLV $QG WKHQ KHZRXOG VD :KRHYHU PDNHV DEOXWLRQ OLNH WKLV DQG WKHQ SUDV WZR UDN DKZLWKRXWKDYLQJDQRWKHUFRQFHUQRQKLVPLQGDOOKLVSDVWVLQVZLOOEHIRUJLYHQ5HODWHGE DO%XNKDUL0XVOLPDQGRWKHUV
189.
2WKHU SUDFWLFHV SURWHFWLQJ
WKHHHVDQGZULQNOHVUHPRYLQJDQULQJVZLSLQJWKHQHFNDQGVRRQ
190.
KDYHQRWEHHQPHQWLRQHGKHUHDVWKHLUQDUUDWLRQVDUHVWLOOTXHVWLRQDEOH%XWRQHPDIROORZWKHPDV SDUWRIJHQHUDOFOHDQOLQHVV )LTK1XOOLILFDWLRQRIDEOXWLRQ
,WLVQRWGHVLUDEOHWKDWRQHZKRLVPDNLQJDEOXWLRQVKRXOGOHDYHDQRIWKHVXQDQWKDWKDYHMXVWEHHQ PHQWLRQHG7KHSHUVRQZRXOGWKHQORVHWKHJUHDWUHZDUGRIWKHVHVLPSOH
191.
DFWV$QWLPHRQHDEDQGRQV WKHVXQQDKKHKDVGRQHDGLVOLNHGGHHG )LTKD$QH[FUHWLRQRIWKHSHQLVYDJLQDRUDQXV
7KLVZRXOG LQFOXGH XULQH IHFHV $OODK VDV RU RQH RI RX FRPHV IURP UHOLHYLQJ KLPVHOI WKXV SURYLQJWKDWVXFKDQDFWREOLJDWHVDQHZSXULILFDWLRQ
192.
DQGUHOHDVLQJJDVIURPWKHDQXV$EX+XUDLUDK LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
193.
UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH0HVVHQJHU
RI$OODK VDLG $OODK GRHV QRW DFFHSW WKH SUDHU RI D SHUVRQZKR KDV UHOHDVHGJDVXQWLOKHPDNHVDQHZDEOXWLRQ$SHUVRQIURP+D]KUDPDXWDVNHG$EX+XUDLUDK:KDW GRHVUHOHDVLQJJDVPHDQ+HDQVZHUHG:LQGZLWKRUZLWKRXWVRXQG5HODWHGEDO%XNKDULDQG 0XVOLP
194.
+HDOVRQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG,IRQHRIRXILQGVDGLVWXUEDQFHLQKLVDEGRPHQDQG LVQRWFHUWDLQLIKHKDVUHOHDVHGDQJDVRUQRWKHVKRXOGQRWOHDYHWKHPRVTXHXQOHVVKHKHDUVLWV VRXQGRUVPHOOVLWVVFHQW5HODWHGE0XVOLP
195.
+HDULQJWKHHVFDSLQJJDVRUVPHOOLQJLWLVQRWDFRQGLWLRQIRUQXOOLILQJDEOXWLRQEXWKHVWUHVVHGWKDW RQH VKRXOG
EH FHUWDLQ RI WKH DFWLRQ $V IRU DO0D]KL SURVWDWLF IOXLG
196.
WKH 3URSKHW VDLG
0DNH DEOXWLRQRQFHUQLQJVSHUPRUDOPDQLVDLG,EQ $EEDV,WUHTXLUHVJKXVODQGIRUDOPD]KLDQGDO ZDGLZDVKRXUVH[RUJDQVDQGPDNHDEOXWLRQ7KLVZDVUHODWHGEDO%DLKDTLLQKLV6XQDQ )LTKE'HHSVOHHSWKDWPDNHVDSHUVRQFRPSOHWHOXQDZDUHRIKLVVXUURXQGLQJV ,IWKHSHUVRQGLGQRWNHHSKLVERWWRFNVILUPOVHDWHGRQWKHIORRUZKLOHVOHHSLQJKHPXVWPDNHDQHZ DEOXWLRQ6DIZDQLEQ $VDOVDLG7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHXVHGWRRUGHUXVZKLOHZHZHUH WUDYHOOLQJ QRW WR WDNH RXU VRFNV RII XQOHVV ZH ZHUH LQ SRVWVH[ LPSXULW LH QRW IRU GHIHFDWLRQ XULQDWLRQ RU VOHHS
197.
5HODWHG E $KPDG
DQ1DVD L DQG DW7LUPL]KLZKR JUDGHG LW VDKLK
198.
,I RQH V EXWWRFNV
KDV UHPDLQHG ILUPO RQ WKH IORRU GXULQJ KLV VOHHS QR QHZ DEOXWLRQ LV QHFHVVDU 7KLV LV LPSOLHGEWKHKDGLWKRI$QDVZKRVDLG7KHFRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHWZHUHZDLWLQJIRUWKHGHODHG QLJKWSUDHUXQWLOWKHLUKHDGVEHJDQQRGGLQJXSDQGGRZQIURPGURZVLQHVVDQGVOHHS
199.
7KHZRXOG WKHQ SUD
ZLWKRXW SHUIRUPLQJ DEOXWLRQ 5HODWHG E DVK6KDLIL 0XVOLP $EX 'DZXG DQG DW 7LUPL]KL
200.
7KH ZRUGLQJ WKDW
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
201.
PXVWSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ5HODWHGE$KPDG ,EQ+LEEDQDQGDO+DNLPZKRFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLKDVGLG,EQ $EGXO%DUU
202.
6DLG,EQDV6DNLQ7KDWKDGLWKLVIURPWKHEHVWRIZKDWKDVEHHQUHODWHGRQWKLVWRSLF$VK6KDI L UHODWHG$QPDQZKRWRXFKHVKLVSHQLVPXVWSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ$QZRPHQZKRWRXFKHVKHUYDJLQD PXVWSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQRPPHQWLQJRQLWVDXWKHQWLFLW,EQDO4DLPTXRWHVDO+D]LPLZKRVDV
7KDWFKDLQLVVDKLK7KH+DQLILDKDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQEDVHG RQWKHIROORZLQJKDGLWKWKDWWRXFKLQJ WKHVH[XDORUJDQGRHVQRWQXOOLIWKHDEOXWLRQ$PDQDVNHGWKH3URSKHWLIDPDQZKRWRXFKHVKLV SHQLVKDVWRSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ6DLGWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH1RLWLVMXVWDSDUWRIRX 5HODWHGEWKHILYH,EQ+LEEDQFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLKDQG,EQDO0DGLQLVDLG,WLVEHWWHUWKDQWKH KDGLWKRI%XVUDK
203.
)LTK7RXFKLQJDZRPDQ $LVKDKUHODWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHNLVVHGKHUZKLOHKHZDVIDVWLQJDQG VDLG
.LVVLQJ GRHV QRW QXOOLI WKH DEOXWLRQ QRU GRHV LW EUHDN WKH IDVW 5HODWHG E ,VKDT LEQ 5DKDZDLKDQGDO%D]]DUZLWKDJRRGFKDLQ
204.
LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
205.
(YDOXDWLQJLWVDXWKHQWLFLW $EGXO+DTTVDV,GRQRWNQRZRIDQGHIHFWLQWKHKDGLWKWKDWFRXOG FDXVHLWVUHMHFWLRQ $LVKDKDOVRVDLG2QHQLJKW,PLVVHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKLQPEHGDQGVRZHQWWRORRNIRU
KLP,SXWPKDQGRQWKHERWWRPRIKLVIHHWZKLOHKHZDVSUDLQJDQGVDLQJ 2$OODK,VHHNUHIXJH LQRXUSOHDVXUHIURPRXUDQJHULQRXUIRUJLYHQHVVIURPRXUSXQLVKPHQWLQRXIURPRX, FDQQRWSUDLVHRXDVRXKDYHSUDLVHGRXUVHOIUHODWHGE0XVOLPDQGDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHGLW DVVDKLK
206.
DQGVKHDOVRUHSRUWHG 7KH3URSKHWNLVVHGVRPHRIKLVZLYHVDQGZHQWWRSUDHUZLWKRXW SHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ5HODWHGE$KPDGDQGWKHIRXU DQGLWVQDUUDWRUVDUHWUXVWZRUWK
207.
6KHDOVR VDLG,ZRXOGVOHHSLQIURQWRIWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZLWKPIHHWLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKH TLEODK
WR KLP
208.
:KHQ KH PDGH
SURVWUDWLRQV KHZRXOG WRXFK PH DQG ,ZRXOGPRYHP IHHW ,Q DQRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLWVDV:KHQKHZDQWHGWRSURVWUDWHKHZRXOGWRXFKPOHJV )LTK%OHHGLQJIURPDQXQXVXDOSODFH 7KLVLQYROYHVEOHHGLQJGXHWRDZRXQGFXSSLQJRUDQRVHEOHHGDQGUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKHDPRXQW RIEORRGLVVPDOORUODUJH 6DLG DO+DVVDQ 7KH0XVOLPV VWLOO SUDHG HYHQZKLOHZRXQGHG 5HODWHG E DO%XNKDUL
209.
+H DOVR UHSRUWHG,EQ 8PDUVTXHH]HGDSLPSOHXQWLOLWEOHGEXWKHGLGQRWUHQHZKLVDEOXWLRQ,EQ$EL 8TL
VSDWEORRGDQGFRQWLQXHGKLVSUDHU 8PDU LEQDO.KDWWDESUDHGZKLOHEORRGZDVIORZLQJIURPKLP ,EEDG LEQ%LVKUZDV KLW ZLWK DQ DUURZZKLOH SUDLQJ EXW FRQWLQXHG KLV SUDHUV 5HODWHG E$EX 'DZXG,EQ.KX]DLPDKDQGDO%XNKDULLQPX DOODTIRUP
210.
)LTKD9RPLW 5HJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKH DPRXQWRIYRPLWZDVJUHDWRUVPDOOWKHUHLVQRVRXQGKDGLWKWKDWLWQXOOLILHV
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
211.
,EQ.KX]DLPDKVDLG,NQRZRIQRGLVSXWHRYHU WKHDXWKHQWLFLWRIWKLVUHSRUW,QVXPPDWLRQDQ1DZDZLFDQEHTXRWHGDVVDLQJ7KLVRSLQLRQKDV WKHVWURQJHVWSURRIDOWKRXJKWKHPDMRULWRIWKHVFKRODUVGLIIHUIURPLW
)LTK2IGRXEWVZKHWKHURUQRWRQHKDVUHOHDVHGJDV 7KLVLVWKHFDVHZKHUHWKHSHUVRQFDQQRWTXLWHUHFDOOLIKHLVLQDVWDWHRISXULWRUQRW6XFKDVWDWHRI PLQGGRHVQRWQXOOLIDEOXWLRQUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKHSHUVRQLVLQSUDHURUQRWXQWLOKHLVFHUWDLQ WKDWKHKDVQXOOLILHGKLVDEOXWLRQ $EEDGLEQ7DPHHPUHODWHGWKDWKLVXQFOHTXHULHGWKH3URSKHWDERXW DSHUVRQZKRIHHOVVRPHWKLQJLQKLVDEGRPHQZKLOHSUDLQJ6DLGWKH3URSKHW+HVKRXOGQRWOHDYH WKHSUDHU
212.
XQWLOKHKHDUVLWRUVPHOOVLW5HODWHGE0XVOLP$EX'DZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL
213.
,WGRHV QRWPHDQWKDWLWVVRXQGRUEDGVPHOOQXOOLILHVDEOXWLRQEXWWKDWWKHSHUVRQPXVWEHFHUWDLQDERXWWKH IDFWWKDWKHKDVQXOOLILHGKLVDEOXWLRQ6DV,EQDO0XEDUDN,IRQHLVXQFHUWDLQDERXWKLVFRQGLWLRQRI
SXULWKHGRHVQRWQHHGWRSHUIRUPDQHZDEOXWLRQ,IRQHLVFHUWDLQWKDWKHKDVQXOOLILHGKLVDEOXWLRQ DQGGRXEWVZKHWKHUKHKDVSXULILHGKLPVHOIRUQRWKHPXVWSHUIRUPDQHZDEOXWLRQ )LTKD/DXJKLQJGXULQJSUDHU 7KLVGRHVQRWQXOOLIDEOXWLRQIRUWKHUHDUHQRFRQILUPHGUHSRUWVWKDWVWDWHVXFKDWKLQJ )LTKE:DVKLQJDGHDGSHUVRQ 7KLVDOVRGRHVQRWUHTXLUHDQHZDEOXWLRQIRUWKHUHSRUWVWKDWVDLWQXOOLILHVDEOXWLRQDUHZHDN )LTKF$QWSHRIULWXDOSUDHU 7KLVLQYROYHVRQOREOLJDWRUYROXQWDURUIXQHUDOSUDHUVQRWWKHVXSSOLFDWLRQVGX D
214.
7KLVLVEDVHG RQ$OODK VVWDWHPHQW2RXZKREHOLHYH:KHQRXJHWXSWRSHUIRUPDSUDHUVDODK
215.
ZDVKRXU IDFHDQGRXUDUPVXSWRWKHHOERZVDQGZLSHRXUKHDGDQGIHHWWRWKHDQNOHV$OVRWKH0HVVHQJHU LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
216.
RI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG$OODKGRHVQRWDFFHSWDSUDHUWKDWZDVSHUIRUPHGZKLOHWKH SHUVRQ
217.
ZDVQRWLQDVWDWHRISXULW1RUGRHVKHDFFHSWFKDULWIURPPLVDSSURSULDWHGERRW5HODWHG EWKHJURXSH[FHSWIRUDO%XNKDUL
218.
)LTKLUFXPDPEXODWLQJWKH.D EDK ,EQ $EEDV
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
219.
$SSDUHQWOWKLV KDGLWKKDVDSUREOHP7KHZRUGSXULIPXVWKDYHRQHSDUWLFXODUPHDQLQJKHUH7KHUHIRUHWRVDWKDW RQH
ZKR KDV D PLQRU GHILOHPHQW PD QRW WRXFK WKH 4XU DQ PDNHV QR VHQVH RQFHUQLQJ $OODK V VWDWHPHQWZKLFKQRQHWRXFKHVVDYHWKHSXULILHGDO:DTL DK
220.
DSSDUHQWOWKHSURQRXQUHIHUVWR WKH %RRN
NHSW KLGGHQ IURP WKH SUHFHGLQJ YHUVH
221.
DQG WKDW LV
WKH ZHOOSUHVHUYHG WDEOHW DQG WKH SXULILHGUHIHUVWRWKHDQJHOVZKLFKLVVLPLODUWRWKHYHUVHV2QKRQRUHGVFUROOVH[DOWHGSXULILHG VHWGRZQ
222.
EVFULEHVQREOHDQGULJKWHRXV$EDVDK
223.
,EQ $EEDVDVK6KD ELD]K=KDKDN=DLG LEQ $OLDO0X DLDG%LOODK'DZXG,EQ+D]PDQG+DPPDGLEQ$EX6XODLPDQDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQWKDW RQHZKRKDVDPLQRUGHILOHPHQWPDWRXFKWKH4XU DQ0RVWRIWKHVFKRODUVKRZHYHUDJUHHWKDWVXFK
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
224.
5DHSRUWHG$EX-XKDLPLEQDO+DULWK7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHPHWDSHUVRQDWWKHZHOORI -DPOZKR JUHHWHG
KLP EXW KH GLG QRW UHWXUQ KLV JUHHWLQJ XQWLO KH KDG ZLSHG KLV IDFH DQG KDQGV 5HODWHG E $KPDG DO%XNKDUL 0XVOLP $EX 'DZXG DQG DQ1DVD L
225.
7KLV DFWLRQ ZDV
RQH RI SUHIHUHQFHQRWRIREOLJDWLRQ0HQWLRQLQJWKHQDPHRI$OODKLVSHUPLVVLEOHIRUWKHRQHZKRLVLQDVWDWH RISXULWRQHZKRKDVDPLQRULPSXULWDSHUVRQLQSRVWVH[LPSXULWRURQHZKRLVVWDQGLQJVLWWLQJ DQGVRRQ6DLG $LVKDK7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXVHGWR UHPHPEHU$OODKDWDOOWLPHV5HODWHGE WKH ILYH H[FHSW IRU DQ1DVD L
226.
$O%XNKDUL UHFRUGHG LW
LQ PX DOOLT IRUP
227.
5HSRUWHG $OL 7KH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZRXOGFRPHIURPUHOLHYLQJKLPVHOIUHFLWHWRXVDQGHDWPHDWZLWKXV1RWKLQJ ZRXOGVWRSKLPIURP WKH4XU DQH[FHSWSRVWVH[LPSXULW5HODWHGEWKHILYH$W7LUPL]KLDQG ,EQDV6DNLQFDWHJRUL]HGLWDVVDKLK
228.
)LTK*RLQJWRVOHHS $O%DUUD LEQ $D]LEUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KHQRXJR WRRXUEHGSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQOLHRQRXUULJKWVLGHDQGWKHQVD 2$OODK,VXEPLWPVRXOWRRX
DQG,WXUQPIDFHWRRX,HQWUXVWPDIIDLUVWRRX,UHWUHDWXQWRRXIRUSURWHFWLRQZLWKKRSHDQG IHDULQRX7KHUHLVQRUHVRUWDQGQRVDYLRUEXWRX,DIILUP PIDLWKLQRXUERRNVZKLFKRX UHYHDOHGDQGLQRXUSURSKHWVRXVHQW ,IRXGLHGXULQJWKDWQLJKWRXZLOOEHDORQJWKHQDWXUDO SDWK0DNHLWRXUILQDOVWDWHPHQWRIWKHQLJKW
229.
+HUHSRUWHGWKDWKHUHSHDWHGWKLVVXSSOLFDWLRQWRWKH 3URSKHW XSRQ
ZKRP EH SHDFH DQG KH VDLG DQG RXU PHVVHQJHUV 7KH 3URSKHW LQWHUMHFWHG 1R DQGWKHSURSKHWVRXVHQW5HODWHGE$KPDGDO%XNKDULDQGDW7LUPL]KL
230.
7KLVDOVRDSSOLHV WRRQHZKRLVLQSRVWVH[LPSXULW,EQ 8PDUDVNHGWKH3URSKHW20HVVHQJHURI$OODKFDQRQHRI XV
VOHHS ZKLOH KH LV LQ SRVWVH[ LPSXULW 7KH 3URSKHW DQVZHUHG HV LI KH PDNHV DEOXWLRQ LVODPPHVVDJHFRP
231.
5HSRUWHG $LVKDK:KHQWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZDQWHGWRVOHHSLQDVWDWHRISRVWVH[ LPSXULWKHZRXOGZDVKKLVSULYDWHSDUWV
DQGSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ5HODWHGEWKHJURXS
232.
)LTKD7RUHPRYHDVH[XDOLPSXULW ,I D
SHUVRQ LQ D VWDWH RI SRVWVH[ LPSXULWZDQWV WR HDW GULQN RU KDYH LQWHUFRXUVH DJDLQ KH VKRXOG SHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ 6DLG $LVKDK :KHQ WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH ZDV LQ D VWDWH RI LPSXULW EHFDXVH RI LQWHUFRXUVHDQGZDQWHGWRHDWRUVOHHSKHZRXOGSHUIRUPDEOXWLRQ $PPDULEQDVDUUHSRUWHGWKDW WKH 3URSKHW SHUPLWWHG D SHUVRQ LQ SRVWVH[LPSXULW WR HDW GULQN RU VOHHS LI KH SHUIRUPHG DEOXWLRQ ILUVW5HODWHGE$KPDGDQGDW7LUPL]KLZKRFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK
233.
$EX6D HHGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG,IRQHKDVLQWHUFRXUVHZLWKKLVZLIH DQG ZDQWV
WR UHSHDW WKH DFW KH VKRXOG SHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ 5HODWHG E WKH JURXS H[FHSW IRU DO %XNKDUL,EQ.KX]DLPDK,EQ+LEEDQDQGDO+DNLPUHFRUGHGLWZLWKWKHDGGLWLRQ,WPDNHVWKHUHWXUQ PRUHYLYDFLRXV
234.
)LTK%HIRUHSHUIRUPLQJJKXVO ,W LV
SUHIHUUHG WR SHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ EHIRUH JKXVO UHJDUGOHVV RIZKHWKHU WKDW SDUWLFXODU JKXVO ZDV DQ REOLJDWRU RU D SUHIHUUHG DFW 6DLG $LVKDK:KHQ WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK XSRQZKRP EH SHDFH SHUIRUPHGSRVWVH[JKXVOKHZRXOGEHJLQEZDVKLQJKLVKDQGVDQGWKHQSRXUZDWHUIURPKLVULJKW KDQG WR KLV OHIW DQG ZDVK KLV SULYDWH SDUWV +H ZRXOG WKHQ SHUIRUP DEOXWLRQ 5HODWHG E WKH JURXS
235.
)LTKD%HIRUHHDWLQJIRRGWRXFKHGEILUH 6DLG,EUDKLPLEQ $EGXOODKLEQ4DUL]K,SDVVHGE$EX+XUDLUDKZKLOHKHZDVSHUIRUPLQJDEOXWLRQ DQGKHVDLG 'RRXNQRZZK,DPPDNLQJDEOXWLRQ,WLVEHFDXVH,DWHVRPHRJKXUWGULHGRYHUD
ILUH IRU , KHDUG WKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKVD 3HUIRUPDEOXWLRQEHIRUHHDWLQJIRRGWRXFKHGEILUH 5HODWHGE$KPDG0XVOLPDQGWKHIRXU
236.
$LVKDKUHODWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG3HUIRUPDEOXWLRQIURPZKDWHYHUWRXFKHV ILUH5HODWHGE$KPDG0XVOLPDQ1DVD LDQG,EQ0DMDK
Descargar ahora