SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 15
Descargar para leer sin conexión
An Analysis of Wind Energy and Danish Power Clusters




                                          ANDERS LARSEN E03647
                                      ALESSANDRO PAPELLO 627411
                                      CHRISTIAN JØRGENSEN E03629
                                        JONAS PETTERSSON E03685
                                 MARIA D SANCHEZ HERRERO (LOLA) E03697
                                           SIYUN SHEN 636471




                                                            1/1/2011




                 INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS CLASS:                     PROFESSOR J OHN A. MA THEWS




L U I S S G U I D O C A R L I U N I V E R S I T Y V I A L E R O MA N I A 3 2 0 0 1 9 7 R O MA I T A L Y T E L + 3 9 0 6 8 5 2 2 5 5 0 4
                                                         FAX +3906 8522 5985
CONTENTS
                                        1.         I N TR O D U C T I O N          2



2.         HI S TO R Y & D Y N A M I C C O M P E TI T I V E F O R C E S - D I A M O N D A N A L Y S I S O F T H E D A N I S H
                                       W I N D TU R B I N E I N D U S TR Y         3



                                        2 . 1 . T HE F A C TO R C O N D I T I O N 3



                         2 . 2 . F I R M S TR A TE G Y , S TR U C TU R E A N D R I V A L R Y       3



                                        2.3. DEMAND CONDITION                      4



                              2 . 4 . R E L A TE D A N D S U P P O R T I N G I N D U S TR Y    4



                                              2.5. GOVERNMENT                 4



                                                   2 . 6 . C HA N C E   4



          3.       T HE R E A L E X A M P L E O F T HE F R A M E W O R K : A A R HU S . T HE C L U S T E R . 5



                   4.         V E S TA S : W O R L D ’ S # 1 TU R B I N E M A N U F A C TU R E R        6



     5.        HO W D I D T HE A C T O R S I N C L U S T E R C O N TR I B U TE T O T HE I N D U S TR Y ?                7



     6.        DIFFERENCE IN WIND TURBINE PATH BETWEEN DENMARK AND USA                                                  8



                        7.        T HE N E W E U R O P E A N P O L I C Y : E N E R G Y 2 0 2 0 1 0



                        8.        C O N C L U S I O N S A N D R E C O M M E N D A TI O N S         11



                                       9.         BIBLIOGRAPHY                    12




                                                                                                                                1
1. INTRODUCTION
   The document’s main purpose is to clarify and complement the presentation of Professor
Mathews 2010-2011, Master Course in International Business, about Denmark’s Wind Clusters.

Therefore, some introductory parts about the Danish land or the global wind industry will be
overlooked, in favor of a deeper analysis on the framework applied to the case, the real
application of it – the Aarhus cluster- as well as an intensive explanation of the theories and
industry analyzing techniques used in this example.

Keeping in mind, that no explanation can come without an informational context, we have
introduced the history of the cluster in the explanation of the Dynamic Competitive Forces
Framework applied to the Danish Wind Industry cluster.

Following, we will also take a look at United States’ evolution in this industry and how does it
compare to Denmark’s, using the “Bricolage vs. Breakthrough” approach from Garud, Raghu,
and Peter Karnøe.

We have also dedicated one of the closing points, to the new European policies and how this
may affect the cluster evolution in Denmark. We have considered this of special importance, due
to the effect of institutions and related official entities to the industry and to its competition.
This part is related to a more dynamic analysis of the competitive forces. Overlooked by Porter
in his static analysis, it was developed by Mathews as a revision of Porter’s framework, allowing
it to acquire a dynamic status, allowing us to comprehend better the evolution of competition.

For graphics, and more introductive data, please refer to the slides attached at the end.

We are not going to analyze why it happens, but also how it happened, where did it start, what
conditions took part, how do the theories apply and who are the main actors of this amazing
play:

THAT HAS TODAY CREATED, THE BIGGEST WIND INTERLINKED INDUSTRY OF THE WORLD,
DESPITE ALL PREDICTIONS.




                                                                                                 2
2. HISTORY & DYNAMIC
       COMPETITIVE FORCES-DIAMOND
       ANALYSIS OF THE DANISH WIND
       TURBINE INDUSTRY
THE DIAMOND FRAMEWORK AND DYNAMIC COMPETITIVE FORCES FRAMEWORK CAN
EFFECTIVELY EXPLAIN THE SUCCESS OF DANISH WIND TURBINE INDUSTRY. THE FOUR MAIN
FACTORS, FACTOR CONDITIONS, STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND RIVALRY, DEMAND AND RELATED
INDUSTRIES, ARE ALL INTERDEPENDENT AND TOGETHER FORM A PICTURE OF THE
ATTRACTIVENESS OF DANISH WIND TURBINE INDUSTRY. IN ADDITION TO THIS GOVERNMENT
AND CHANCE ALSO HAVE AN IMPACT ON ALL FACTORS IN THE DIAMOND AND THE
COMPETITIVENESS OF THE INDUSTRY.


                               2.1. THE FACTOR CONDITION

This part comprises nature resources, human resources and traditional culture. Natural
resource in Denmark is wind --- an abundant “raw material” in Denmark due to the nation’s long
shore and thus a requirement for the expansion.

Concerning the human resources, one of the most important factor conditions in Denmark was
the old blacksmith industry and tradition of building wind turbines, which started in the late
19th century. It all began as private/individual experiments, some of which were more
successful than others. These persons were mostly handicrafts workers and engineers with
previous experience from the machine industry. Together researchers and manufacturers
consequently utilized their existing capabilities and skills in the building of the wind turbines
and the competencies they did not have in-house were accessible from sub-contractors who
were on the lookout for new business areas to carry their businesses through the ups and
downs of the business cycle.

With reference to the traditional culture, in the old Danish industry, workers were keen on
sharing knowledge and skill, hence the culture that persists in today’s wind turbine clusters.1


                  2.2. FIRM STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND RIVALRY

Danish wind power industry during the 1970s did not start from scratch, but was built on a
solid base of theories and practical know-hows in machinery sector. It leverages the machinery
practices to develop the three-blade turbine which works as a standard even today.

The industry adopted a “Learning by doing” approach, without scientific knowledge they used a
learning process which continually try and fail and try again to improve the quality of wind
turbine. The efficiency of one component supplier grew with the number of units which already
produced.

Danish wind turbine industry faced rivalry of alternative energy as fossil fuel, nuclear power so
that the R&D never stopped in 20th century.

1Jens Vestergaard (2004) Industry Formation and State Intervention: The Case of the Wind Turbine
Industry in Denmark and the United States. Aarhus School of Business.

                                                                                                   3
2.3. DEMAND CONDITION

Local demand came from the Danish educated consumers. The 1970s oil embargo, price
increases and the political measures had a huge impact on the public’s attitude towards energy
and energy consumption, which until then had not been a matter at all. People suddenly became
more aware of the environment problem, energy and eco-friendly policies became important
subjects and were intensely discussed in the mass media, in the offices as well as in private
households in Denmark. Progressively more people were supportive of renewable and non-
polluting energy sources and started to unite themselves in organizations and support groups.


                     2.4. RELATED AND SUPPORTING INDUSTRY

At the end of the 1970s and the beginning of the 1980s a well-functioning network of
subcontractors supplying wings (blades), control systems and gears was established. The
Danish wind turbine cluster includes not only the manufactures, components suppliers but also
research institutions, such as national laboratory and universities. Test center and users also
become a part of the cluster in which they provide input.


                                    2.5. GOVERNMENT

Government played an important role in the development of Danish wind turbine industry.
First, it set up the Risø National Laboratory in 1978, which improved the research and testing
works. Second, it enacted the policy of energy package and energy plan, which permitted the
linking of wind power to the grid and set a base price for the wind power. The plan established a
market for wind turbine electricity and focused the market’s attention on the cost efficiency of
the turbines. Lacking these subsidies wind turbines as suppliers of energy would not have been
competitive compared to the traditional power plants and other energy sources. Finally, its
environment policy also supported the development of wind power industry.


                                        2.6. CHANCE

The triumph of Danish wind turbine industry was due to some chances outside. First, two oil
embargoes of 1973 and 1979 and the awakening green movement in the Western societies gave
a real boost to the Danish wind turbine industry and set the stage for the present era of wind
power. Second, California wind rushes during 1980-1986 stimulated the international wind
energy industry to develop. In 1982 when an examination of the American market confirmed
that a basis for “something big” existed, all of the large wind turbine manufacturers immediately
rushed to the other continent and came home with orders in sizes that were not even possible
in the small domestic market but which made it possible for the manufacturers to start batch
production of wind turbines.




                                                                                               4
FIGURE 1 DYNAMIC FORCES FRAMEWORK ADAPTED TO CASE. ADAPTED FROM THEORY IN: MATHEWS,
STRATEGIZING, DISEQUILIBRIUM AND PROFITS (STANFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, 2006).




   3. THE REAL EXAMPLE OF THE
      FRAMEWORK: AARHUS. THE
      CLUSTER.
“A CLOSER LOOK AT DENMARK’S WIND INDUSTRY REVEALS A LARGE CONCENTRATION OF
COMPANIES LOCATED IN THE CENTRAL DENMARK BELT FROM AARHUS IN THE EAST TO
RINGKØBING AND SKJERN IN THE WEST. “

More than a third of the 175 companies which, according to Denmark’s Central Business
Register are directly involved with the production of wind turbines are located in this region.
The largest and most globally significant companies reside in the area around Denmark’s
second largest city, Aarhus. The Greater Aarhus area and its surrounding municipalities are also
home to half of all Danish wind energy companies with five employees or more. Many global
companies have located their headquarters or development centers in the Aarhus area. This
includes the world’s largest wind turbine manufacturer, Vestas, which will be discussed in the
following point (see point 7 of the project).

Aarhus is the leading global knowledge center of wind energy. One of the keys to its success is
cross-sector cooperation. Aarhus has benefited enormously from the strong professional and
industrial environment in the region within energy and environmental technology. Many of the
wind industry suppliers are also suppliers to other energy sectors and major environmental and
energy-tech companies in the area. This turns competition to coopetition, allowing the dynamic


                                                                                              5
forces of supply and factor conditions to act on the industry and the firms, creating synergies
and maximizing the results.




       FIGURE 2 AARHUS MAP WITH DESCRIPTION OF THE DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES. SOURCE:
          HTTP://WWW.AARHUSKOMMUNE.DK (USE BIBLIOGRAPHY TO SEE IN HIGH RES.)




   4.      VESTAS: WORLD’S # 1 TURBINE
           MANUFACTURER
AS VESTAS IS THE GLOBAL LEADER ON THE WORLD MARKET FOR WIND ENERGY AND BETWEEN
THE KEY DRIVERS OF THE DANISH WIND ENERGY CLUSTER.

Vestas was founded in 1898 by H.S. Hansen, a blacksmith, in Denmark. Father and son
manufactured steel windows for industrial buildings. In 1945, his son established the company
VEstjysk-STålteknik A/S, whose name was shortened to Vestas. In 1979, Vestas delivered the
first wind turbines.

Vestas has installed over 39,000 wind turbines in 63 countries on 5 continents. In 2008, Vestas
installed a new turbine every three hours worldwide, generating more than 60 million Mwah a
year. Being a pioneer in the industry, Vestas now counts with a staff of more than 20,000 people.
Vestas reached revenues of EUR 6,035 million with operational margin of 11.1% in 2008 and
they got global market share of 19% (5,581 MW). Vestas’ core business comprises the
development, manufacture, sale and maintenance of wind turbines.

Their expertise in modern energy covers more than just wind turbines, specializing in planning,
installation, operation and maintenance. Their competencies cover everything from site studies
to service and maintenance. So we can detect a high degree of vertical integration. At the same

                                                                                               6
time, production and sourcing are carried out as close to the market as possible. In 2008, Vestas
opened the world’s largest research and development center for wind energy in Aarhus.



   5.       HOW DID THE ACTORS IN
           CLUSTER CONTRIBUTE TO THE
           INDUSTRY?
SHAPING THE DANISH WIND TURBINE DESIGN WAS AN ACT OF COLLABORATIVE NETWORK
CONSISTING OF MANY ACTORS INVOLVED IN WIND TURBINES LIKE DESIGNERS,
MANUFACTURERS, SUPPLIERS, INSTITUTIONS, TEST ORGANIZATIONS AND POLICY MAKERS. THE
ACTORS IN DENMARK PURSUED A PROCESS THAT DEPLOYED MODEST RESOURCES TO
PROGRESSIVELY BUILD UP A VIABLE WIND TURBINE PATH.




                         FIGURE 3 EXPLICATIVE GRAPHIC OF THE SYSTEM.

In the cluster a sectorial system of innovation played an important role. The firms do not
innovate in isolation rather innovations are product of various complementary processes. These
complementary processes involve both firms as well as non-firm organizations (such as
universities, research centers, government agencies, financial institutions and others). Thus the
sectorial system of innovation approach emphasizes actors, networks, knowledge and
institutions and the interactions between these elements. For instance, designers and producers
become involved based on their beliefs and experiences on the design and production of
technological artifacts. Users become involved based on the meanings that they attach to
products with respect to their forms, functions and values in use. Evaluators become involved
based on their understanding of the tests and standards required to compare and contrast
different products. Policy makers enact laws based on their beliefs on the efficacy of specific
policy instruments to shape the rate and direction of a technology’s development.

The momentum a technology generates as it accumulates inputs from actors shapes the
activities of distributed actors. These inputs are generated through learning and knowledge

                                                                                               7
accumulation processes that are activated as actors become involved with an emerging path.
From the supply side, producers learn by doing and by experimenting. Through these processes,
these actors generate capabilities that are critical for the systematic design, production and
distribution of goods and services. Users generate feedback when they use products and
services that emerge from the technology. Such learning by using generates knowledge of
customers’ emerging preferences. Institutional players generate other kinds of learning. For
instance, those in regulatory bodies develop institutional mechanisms and policies to “steer” the
technology development process. More proximally, test centers generate inputs by a process of
learning by testing. The testing criteria that they codify and the results of comparative tests
become valuable community level knowledge.2




    6.      DIFFERENCE IN WIND TURBINE
            PATH BETWEEN DENMARK AND
            USA
We use overall contrasting labels “Bricolage” and “breakthrough” to highlight the differences in
the processes associated with actor involvement in the two paths. Bricolage, named used to
label the processes of the Danish industry, was characterized by up-and-coming co-shaping. For
example, designers and producers progressively scaled up designs all the while incorporating
the inputs of the many companies involved. Users offered continual feedback while those in test
centers developed evaluation routines that co-evolved with experiences in the field. All the
while, policy makers “modulated” the rise of the market to keep the technological path alive.

A diverse logic of disseminated agency appeared in the development of the US wind turbine
route. Designers and producers tried to “leap-frog” Denmark with high-tech designs.
Researchers at the test center followed a “linear” engineering science based technology-push
model as their source for exchanges with industry participants. Regulators passed policies to
jump-start the technology, outgrowth the development of a vast market, and then brusquely
removed subsidies.

In terms of design and production, there were key differences in the traditions. Companies in
the US started with a advanced design, took large steps in design scale-up, and did not engage in
much product development in-between stages. In contrast, actors in Denmark started with a
low-tech design, took smaller steps in design scale-up, and engaged in product development in-
between stages. (Therefore from the figure below we can see there are more scale-ups in Danish
wind power.)




2Garud, R. and P. Karnøe (2003). "Bricolage versus breakthrough: distributed and embedded agency in
technology entrepreneurship." Research Policy 32(2): 277-300.


                                                                                                      8
FIGURE 4 P., R. GARUD, ET AL. (1997). PATH CREATION AND DEPENDENCE IN
 THE DANISH WIND TURBINE FIELD.


The firms in Denmark possessed a core group of skilled workers, technicians and a few practical
engineers. Such a mix was representative of the “mechanical skill” base that had emerged as a
result of a “practical engineer” education typical of the Danish machine industry. These firms
began developing wind turbines without an appreciation of the complexities involved. The
people involved saw the wind turbine as presenting a set of problems similar to those they had
confronted in the construction of agricultural machinery. (The table below shows five typical
component firms in Denmark.)

On the other side, experts in the US approached design from an engineering science knowledge
base, conceptualizing problems in terms of the formal, academic language of aerodynamics and
structural dynamics. The goal of many engineers was to create a design that had drastically
changed features compared to existing technology.




                                                                                             9
FIGURE 5 FIVE TYPICAL COMPONENT FIRMS IN DENMARK




     7. THE NEW EUROPEAN POLICY:
        ENERGY 2020
IN 2007 THE EUROPEAN COUNCIL ADOPTED AMBITIOUS ENERGY AND CLIMATE CHANGE
OBJECTIVES FOR 2020; THESE WERE REFERRED TO AS THE "20-20-20" TARGETS.

They can be summarized in three main points, first being to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
by 20% compared to 1990 levels (or by 30% if the conditions are right); second being achieving
20% of total energy consumption to be from renewable energy and increasing energy efficiency
by 20%; and third: that the 3% of the EU's GDP was to be invested in research and development.

EU2020 seems to have forgotten to attach a feasible strategy to the policy. Of course, due to the
momentum’s excitement, nobody seemed to realize the vacant. Recently, studies have shown
that the existing strategy is currently unlikely to achieve all the 2020 targets, for general
disappointment and global shame.

The main issue, concerning our research, is that –as said by the Dynamic Competitive Forces
Framework- what happens in the Institutions, affects the industry. This is proved by the fact
that if governments do not get behind the proposal for a European grid (i.e. a new strategy for
the current objectives), we will “face an absurd situation in which renewable energy capacity is
being built, but no adequate grid exists to deliver the 34% of renewable electricity needed by 2020
to reach the EU’s binding renewable energy targets3”. Consequently, blocking Denmark’s wind
cluster growing capacity, since there will be no point in continuing to build stock and turbines, if
they cannot be used.


3Christian Kjaer, EWEA chief executive officer. (2010) http://www.euractiv.com/en/energy/eu-says-
200bn-needed-energy-grids-2020-news-499806

                                                                                                    10
The consequences are far more than serious, since the whole industry interconnection is deeply
linked to the demand pull and supply pull innovation and evolution. Thus, we cannot limit our
concerns to environmental issues and energy costs, furthermore we need to take into account
the impact of such a mistake on the global energy industry, keeping in mind that its value
depends on its interconnections and no part of it has value itself. Comprising in union, a mega-
web of synergies and linkages, basic to develop leverage, learning and in sum: Growth.

Hence, the European Council has lately come up with a solution, which is still being revised due
to its controversial measures. One of which is to make, over the next ten years, energy
investments in the order of 1 € trillion. Indeed, 200€ billion are needed to upgrade Europe's gas
and electricity grids over the coming decade.

The new Europe 2020 strategy 4will drive major efforts in: Energy market regulation, grid
management and the security of energy systems; Technical innovation and investments;
Education and incentives for domestic and business consumers to save energy, reduce Wastage
and switch to low-carbon technologies and fuels.




    8. CONCLUSIONS AND
       RECOMMENDATIONS
    Denmark is now the leading center within the field of wind power. However during the
recent years a significant change in technology and markets has taken place. Denmark is faced
with the challenge to maintain its leading position in spite of growing competition from firms
operating in lower cost countries, especially China and India. The wind energy cluster and the
political system must assume a proactive position towards this change to ensure that Denmark
will strengthen its position as unique value creator.

The industrial environment is built on a foundation which consists of a significant effort in
research and education as well as innovative development focused on environmentally
sustainability. This field of wind power is influenced by cooperation and knowledge-sharing to
find technological development tracks.

The Danish research-environment has a leading position within a number of areas, but great
challenges in step with the rapid development of international markets put a lot of pressure of
the Danish knowledge center to hold on the talented researchers and students. In order to
maintain the unique Danish position, an extraordinary effort must be put in.

The strategic issues are focusing on both, development of the wind power industry by
improving wind turbines and effectiveness of wind power, and the improvement of the
knowledge center regarding research and education.

Creating one strategy for the whole value chain with sub-strategies for each of the dimensions
of the industry would strengthen the integration and the competitiveness of the wind power
industry. This could be provided through common guidelines for the frames of cooperation.
Following these recommendations, Denmark will be prepared to face the current challenges.

4ENERGY 2020: A strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy. Citizens’ Summary.
http://ec.europa.eu/energy/strategies/2010/doc/2010_11_10_energy_2020_citizens_summary.pdf

                                                                                              11
9. BIBLIOGRAPHY
" ProvenModels - dynamic competitive forces - John A. Mathews ." ProvenModels - Management Models |
         Management Theory | Business Models | Michael Porter | Henry Mintzberg | Management Model |
         Business School . N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Jan. 2011. <http://www.provenmodels.com/599>.
A toolbox for cluster inspired regional development:           innovative regions facing the challenges of
         globalisation.. Aalborg: North Denmark EU-office, 2008. Print.
"Blowing in the wind: the Danes have shown that wind energy thrives when there is consistent
         government support and community ownership." Alternatives Journal 1 Jan. 2004: 1. Print.
Boon, M.C.. Why did Danish entrepreneurs take the lead in the wind turbine industry and not the Dutch?: a
         study on the interaction between evolution and strategy of two communities in an emerging
         industry. Rotterdam: Erasmus Universiteit, 2008. Print.
Brandt, Urs Steiner, and Gert Svendsen. Switch point and first-mover advantage: the case of the wind
         turbine industry.. Aarhus: Department of Economics, Faculty of Business Administration, Aarhus
         School of Business, 2004. Print.
Bæk, Jeppe. New ways in the transport of wind turbines: on transportational challenges to be faced by the
         wind turbine industry. S.l.: Nordisk Transportpolitisk Netværk, 2004. Print.
Chiesa, Vittorio, and Davide Chiaroni. Industrial Clusters In Biotechnology: Driving Forces, Development
         Processes And Management Practices.. Singapore: World Scientific, 2004. Print.
"Denmark - Wind Power Hub." Visiolink - defining Digital Media. N.p., n.d. Web. 26 Nov. 2010.
         <http://www.e-pages.dk/windpower/21/>.
Drejer, Ina, Frank Kristensen, and Keld Laursen. Cluster studies as a basis for industrial policy: the case of
         Denmark.. Denmark: N.A., 1999. Print.
Energy statistics of OECD countries = [electronic resource] : Statistiques de l'e̕nergie des pays de l'OCDE.
         2008 ed. Paris: OECD/IEA, 2008. Print.
Future offshore: a strategic framework for the offshore wind industry.. London?: Department of Trade and
         Industry, 2002. Print.
Garud, Raghu, and Peter       Karnøe,Path dependence and creation . Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum
         Associates, 2001. Print.
Identification and analysis of industry cycles . na: Elsevier, 2009. Print.
Karnøe,¸e, Peter. Comments on "Wind energy in America - a history" (a book by Robert W. Righter .
         Copenhagen Business School: Copenhagen, 1998. Print.
Karnøe,¸e, Peter, and Raghu Garud. Path creation and dependence in the Danish wind turbine field .
         Copenhagen: Institute of Organization and Industrial Sociology, Copenhagen Business School,
         1998. Print.
Karnøe,¸e, Peter, Peer Hull Kristensen, and Poul Houman Andersen. Mobilizing resources and generating
         competencies: the remarkable success of small and medium-sized enterprises in the Danish
         business system. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Business School Press :, 1999. Print.
Mathews, John A.. Strategizing, disequilibrium, and profit . Stanford, Calif.: Stanford Business Books, 2006.

                                                                                                           12
Print.
Porter, Michael E.. Clusters and the new economics of competition . Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review ,
         1998. Print.
Potter, Jonathan, and Gabriela Miranda. Clusters, innovation and entrepreneurship . Paris: Oecd, 2009.
         Print.
The U.S. small wind turbine industry roadmap: a 20-year industry plan for small wind turbine technology.
         Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2002. Print.
Wijbrands, H.G.. Innovation networks for a better environment: how successful innovation networks van
         stimulate the wind turbine industry. Rotterdam: Erasmus Universiteit, 2006. Print.
Winds of change a manufacturing blueprint for the wind industry.. Washington, DC: American Wind
         Energy Association, 2010. Print.


Cluster Observatory: Country Report: Denmark (2007)
         http://www.clusterobservatory.eu/upload/Policy_Report_Denmark_20080116.pdf
Danish Energy Authority (2002) Wind Energy in Denmark Status 2001
http://193.88.185.141/Graphics/Publikationer/Forsyning_UK/Wind_Energy_in_Denmark170402.pdf

Danish Exporters: http://www.danishexporters.dk/scripts/danishexporters/export.asp (11.01.10)

DWIA (2008) Denmark – Wind Power Hub, Danish Industry Association
http://www.windpower.org/download/378/profilbrochure_2008.pdf

DWIA (2009) Facts on production, number and capacity, Danish Wind Industry Association

DWIA (2009) Past and present - successful developments followed by stalemate, Danish Wind Industry
Association

Energy Policy Statement (2008) The report of the minister of climate and energy pursuant to the Danish Act
on Energy Policy Measures

Energy Statistics 2007, Danish Energy Agency

EREC: Renewable Energy Policy Review Denmark

Gamesa: http://www.gamesacorp.com/en/where-are-we/contacts-by-countries/wind-turbines-
manufacture

 Krohn, S. (2002) Danish Wind Turbines: An Industrial Success Story, Danish Wind Industry Association
http://guidedtour.windpower.org/media(483,1033)/Danish_Wind_Turbine_Industry,_an_industrial_succes_s
tory.pdf

Krohn1, S. (2002) The Wind Turbine Market in Denmark, Danish Wind Industry Association

Krohn2, S. (2002) Wind Energy Policy in Denmark: 25 Years of Success – What Now? Danish Wind Industry
Association

Krohn3, S. (2002) Wind Energy Policy in Denmark Status 2002, Danish Wind Industry Association

Meyer, N.I. (2007) Learning from Wind Energy Policy in the EU: Lessons from Denmark, Sweden and Spain,
European Environment, 17, 5, pp. 347-362




                                                                                                       13
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark: Factsheet Denmark
http://www.denmark.dk/NR/rdonlyres/916BAEE6-AFB8-4720-B118-
03366AB1154A/0/DenmarkOverview.pdf

Vestas: http://www.vestas.com/en/about-vestas/history.aspx

Vestergaard, J., et al. (2004) A Brief History of The Wind Turbine Industry of Denmark and the United States,
Academy of International Business (Southeast USA Chapter) Conference Proceedings, November 2004, pp.
322-327

World Economic Forum: Global Competitiveness Report 2009

World Economic Outlook Database

World Fact Book: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2078rank.html

Yettin, et al. (2003) Are Diamonds a Country’s Best Friend? Australian Journal of Management, 17, 1, June
1992




                                                                                                            14

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Marketing Strategy of LEGO Company
Marketing Strategy of LEGO CompanyMarketing Strategy of LEGO Company
Marketing Strategy of LEGO CompanyUmurMutlu
 
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case study
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case studyGlobal protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case study
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case studyHarleen Arneja
 
Ben & Jerry Organizational Design
Ben & Jerry Organizational DesignBen & Jerry Organizational Design
Ben & Jerry Organizational DesignMubashir Ahmed
 
Lego fall and rise
Lego fall and riseLego fall and rise
Lego fall and riseShafique002
 
mondelez international ANSHUL BALI
mondelez international ANSHUL BALImondelez international ANSHUL BALI
mondelez international ANSHUL BALIAnshul Bali
 
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdf
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdfIKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdf
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdfP&CO
 
Brand Analysis on North Face
Brand Analysis on North Face Brand Analysis on North Face
Brand Analysis on North Face Jenna Chamblee
 
Dollarama's (1).pptx
Dollarama's (1).pptxDollarama's (1).pptx
Dollarama's (1).pptxPatelGreeshma
 
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade Theory
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade TheoryIBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade Theory
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade TheoryPreston Teeter, PhD
 
Grolsch growing globally beer case study
Grolsch growing globally beer case studyGrolsch growing globally beer case study
Grolsch growing globally beer case studyMustahid Ali
 
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of Adidas
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of AdidasPorter's 5 Forces Analysis of Adidas
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of AdidasAkshay Narkar
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Marketing Strategy of LEGO Company
Marketing Strategy of LEGO CompanyMarketing Strategy of LEGO Company
Marketing Strategy of LEGO Company
 
Starbucks—Going Global Fast
Starbucks—Going Global FastStarbucks—Going Global Fast
Starbucks—Going Global Fast
 
Nike supply chain
Nike supply chain Nike supply chain
Nike supply chain
 
Ben and jerry case study
Ben and jerry case study Ben and jerry case study
Ben and jerry case study
 
Hindalco’s acquisition of novelis
Hindalco’s acquisition of novelisHindalco’s acquisition of novelis
Hindalco’s acquisition of novelis
 
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case study
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case studyGlobal protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case study
Global protection of intellectual property : Pfizer case study
 
Ben & Jerry Organizational Design
Ben & Jerry Organizational DesignBen & Jerry Organizational Design
Ben & Jerry Organizational Design
 
Lego fall and rise
Lego fall and riseLego fall and rise
Lego fall and rise
 
Ferrero
FerreroFerrero
Ferrero
 
mondelez international ANSHUL BALI
mondelez international ANSHUL BALImondelez international ANSHUL BALI
mondelez international ANSHUL BALI
 
Plan de marketing - Primark
Plan de marketing - PrimarkPlan de marketing - Primark
Plan de marketing - Primark
 
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdf
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdfIKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdf
IKEA- A Better Everyday Life.pdf
 
Grolsch case study
Grolsch case studyGrolsch case study
Grolsch case study
 
Brand Analysis on North Face
Brand Analysis on North Face Brand Analysis on North Face
Brand Analysis on North Face
 
Dollarama's (1).pptx
Dollarama's (1).pptxDollarama's (1).pptx
Dollarama's (1).pptx
 
Heineken case study
Heineken case studyHeineken case study
Heineken case study
 
Nike Is Bad
Nike Is BadNike Is Bad
Nike Is Bad
 
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade Theory
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade TheoryIBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade Theory
IBUS2301 - Tutorial #2 - Chapter 6 - International Trade Theory
 
Grolsch growing globally beer case study
Grolsch growing globally beer case studyGrolsch growing globally beer case study
Grolsch growing globally beer case study
 
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of Adidas
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of AdidasPorter's 5 Forces Analysis of Adidas
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis of Adidas
 

Destacado

Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analyses
Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analysesWind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analyses
Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analysesSustainableEnergyAut
 
International Competitiveness Automobile Cluster In Germany
International Competitiveness   Automobile Cluster In GermanyInternational Competitiveness   Automobile Cluster In Germany
International Competitiveness Automobile Cluster In GermanyNikunj Gupta
 
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping Framework
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping FrameworkSqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping Framework
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping FrameworkESUG
 
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmas
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmasLidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmas
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmasNatalia Aguilar
 
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)IOZ AG
 
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog Sada
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog SadaRoundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog Sada
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog SadaTanja Kalezic
 
Feelgood-tutkimusraportti
Feelgood-tutkimusraporttiFeelgood-tutkimusraportti
Feelgood-tutkimusraporttiTaltioni
 
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47sifexol
 
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamenteMonicacpe2015
 
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbino
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de UrbinoLa Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbino
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbinomanutebolo
 

Destacado (20)

Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analyses
Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analysesWind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analyses
Wind Energy trends in Denmark - Aisma vitina, ea energy analyses
 
SoG_WhitePaper_WindPower_210x297_V13_SINGLE
SoG_WhitePaper_WindPower_210x297_V13_SINGLESoG_WhitePaper_WindPower_210x297_V13_SINGLE
SoG_WhitePaper_WindPower_210x297_V13_SINGLE
 
Pure Power - Wind Energy Targets from 2020 and 2030
Pure Power - Wind Energy Targets from 2020 and 2030Pure Power - Wind Energy Targets from 2020 and 2030
Pure Power - Wind Energy Targets from 2020 and 2030
 
International Competitiveness Automobile Cluster In Germany
International Competitiveness   Automobile Cluster In GermanyInternational Competitiveness   Automobile Cluster In Germany
International Competitiveness Automobile Cluster In Germany
 
Ciudad - Nación - Mundo
Ciudad - Nación - MundoCiudad - Nación - Mundo
Ciudad - Nación - Mundo
 
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping Framework
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping FrameworkSqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping Framework
SqueakSave An Automatic Object-Relational Mapping Framework
 
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmas
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmasLidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmas
Lidiando con gandallas, monstros y fantasmas
 
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)
Workflow Management mit Nintex Workflow (Grundlagen)
 
Guia epjct 2012 13
Guia epjct 2012 13Guia epjct 2012 13
Guia epjct 2012 13
 
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog Sada
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog SadaRoundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog Sada
Roundhouse, Ranžirna stanica - Nova kulturno-muzejska celina grada Novog Sada
 
UP | 10 Comunicación interna
UP | 10 Comunicación internaUP | 10 Comunicación interna
UP | 10 Comunicación interna
 
Feelgood-tutkimusraportti
Feelgood-tutkimusraporttiFeelgood-tutkimusraportti
Feelgood-tutkimusraportti
 
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47
BIBLIA CATOLICA, ANTIGUO TESTAMENTO, REYES, PARTE 12 DE 47
 
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente
7. Proyecto - Valoro y convivo sanamente
 
YOGA Y AYURVEDA PARA LA PAZ
YOGA Y AYURVEDA PARA LA PAZYOGA Y AYURVEDA PARA LA PAZ
YOGA Y AYURVEDA PARA LA PAZ
 
Tomo 1 derecho comparado latinoamericano
Tomo 1 derecho comparado latinoamericanoTomo 1 derecho comparado latinoamericano
Tomo 1 derecho comparado latinoamericano
 
077989
077989077989
077989
 
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbino
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de UrbinoLa Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbino
La Visitación - Rafael Sanzio de Urbino
 
Presentacion linux ubuntu 11.10
Presentacion linux ubuntu 11.10 Presentacion linux ubuntu 11.10
Presentacion linux ubuntu 11.10
 
Crystal Fund Presentation
Crystal Fund PresentationCrystal Fund Presentation
Crystal Fund Presentation
 

Similar a How denmark powers its Future

CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014
CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014
CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014Gisli Gudmundsson
 
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...Marcellus Drilling News
 
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex Lightman
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex LightmanFood, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex Lightman
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex LightmanNetwork Society Research
 
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas Development
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas DevelopmentFact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas Development
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas DevelopmentMarcellus Drilling News
 
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdf
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdfAdhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdf
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdfYasser Al-Wasifi
 
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016Diego Fernandez Sevilla, Ph.D.
 
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia Policy
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia PolicyClimate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia Policy
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia PolicyRichard Hodge
 
Telesford DBA 2014 Strategic
Telesford DBA 2014 StrategicTelesford DBA 2014 Strategic
Telesford DBA 2014 StrategicJohn Telesford
 
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDEN
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDENDOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDEN
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDENJohn Hutchison
 
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdf
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdfBHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdf
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdfGustavoAgudelo11
 
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing Remote Sensing GEOIMAGE
 
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...Conor Moran
 
Bdew 8.6.16 f
Bdew 8.6.16 fBdew 8.6.16 f
Bdew 8.6.16 fHELMJV
 
Composite Resin Restoration.pdf
Composite Resin Restoration.pdfComposite Resin Restoration.pdf
Composite Resin Restoration.pdfYasser Al-Wasifi
 

Similar a How denmark powers its Future (20)

CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014
CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014
CV_Gudmundsson_Certificates_2014
 
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...
EARTHWORKS Study: Gas Patch Routlette - How Shale Gas Development Risks Publi...
 
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex Lightman
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex LightmanFood, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex Lightman
Food, Water And Energy In The Network Society - Alex Lightman
 
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas Development
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas DevelopmentFact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas Development
Fact-Based Regulation for Environmental Protection in Shale Gas Development
 
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdf
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdfAdhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdf
Adhesion & Adhesives 2022.pdf
 
Aegc 2019 perth
Aegc 2019 perthAegc 2019 perth
Aegc 2019 perth
 
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016
Diego Fdez-Sevilla PhD Blog Filling In Finding Out FRAMEWORK June 2016
 
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia Policy
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia PolicyClimate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia Policy
Climate Change - An Approach to a One-Australia Policy
 
Telesford DBA 2014 Strategic
Telesford DBA 2014 StrategicTelesford DBA 2014 Strategic
Telesford DBA 2014 Strategic
 
NG-85
NG-85NG-85
NG-85
 
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDEN
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDENDOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDEN
DOD PRESENTATION TOM BEARDEN
 
INDIGENOUSPOWER
INDIGENOUSPOWERINDIGENOUSPOWER
INDIGENOUSPOWER
 
CAR Emails 6.28.02
CAR Emails 6.28.02CAR Emails 6.28.02
CAR Emails 6.28.02
 
Avoiding Sunstroke
Avoiding  Sunstroke Avoiding  Sunstroke
Avoiding Sunstroke
 
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdf
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdfBHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdf
BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY - INDIA.pdf
 
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing
Grsg abstract book v5 Advances in Geological Remote Sensing
 
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...
ANALYSIS OF PHARMACEUTICAL EXCIPIENTS BY BROADBAND ACOUSTIC RESONANCE DISSOLU...
 
RCEC Email 2.25.03
RCEC Email 2.25.03RCEC Email 2.25.03
RCEC Email 2.25.03
 
Bdew 8.6.16 f
Bdew 8.6.16 fBdew 8.6.16 f
Bdew 8.6.16 f
 
Composite Resin Restoration.pdf
Composite Resin Restoration.pdfComposite Resin Restoration.pdf
Composite Resin Restoration.pdf
 

Más de Lola Sanchez

ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETING
ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETINGROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETING
ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETINGLola Sanchez
 
Mision colinna commerce pdf
Mision colinna commerce pdf Mision colinna commerce pdf
Mision colinna commerce pdf Lola Sanchez
 
Intraining.es Plan de Fidelización
Intraining.es  Plan de FidelizaciónIntraining.es  Plan de Fidelización
Intraining.es Plan de FidelizaciónLola Sanchez
 
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van Rompuy
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van RompuyEconomía de la Unión Europea EU - Van Rompuy
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van RompuyLola Sanchez
 
La integración económica en América
La integración económica en AméricaLa integración económica en América
La integración económica en AméricaLola Sanchez
 
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herd
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herdThaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herd
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herdLola Sanchez
 
Choice Architecture in Behavioral Economics
Choice Architecture in Behavioral EconomicsChoice Architecture in Behavioral Economics
Choice Architecture in Behavioral EconomicsLola Sanchez
 
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketing
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketingel ipad análisis de estrategia de marketing
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketingLola Sanchez
 

Más de Lola Sanchez (12)

Colinna 12
Colinna 12Colinna 12
Colinna 12
 
ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETING
ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETINGROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETING
ROCHAS MAN DIRECCION COMERCIAL PLAN ESTRATEGICO DE MARKETING
 
Yupi marzo
Yupi marzoYupi marzo
Yupi marzo
 
Mision colinna commerce pdf
Mision colinna commerce pdf Mision colinna commerce pdf
Mision colinna commerce pdf
 
Rochas Man
Rochas ManRochas Man
Rochas Man
 
Intraining.es Plan de Fidelización
Intraining.es  Plan de FidelizaciónIntraining.es  Plan de Fidelización
Intraining.es Plan de Fidelización
 
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van Rompuy
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van RompuyEconomía de la Unión Europea EU - Van Rompuy
Economía de la Unión Europea EU - Van Rompuy
 
La integración económica en América
La integración económica en AméricaLa integración económica en América
La integración económica en América
 
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herd
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herdThaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herd
Thaler and Sunstein Nudge - Following the herd
 
Choice Architecture in Behavioral Economics
Choice Architecture in Behavioral EconomicsChoice Architecture in Behavioral Economics
Choice Architecture in Behavioral Economics
 
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketing
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketingel ipad análisis de estrategia de marketing
el ipad análisis de estrategia de marketing
 
marketing
marketingmarketing
marketing
 

Último

Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communicationskarancommunications
 
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...noida100girls
 
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMANA DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMANIlamathiKannappan
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayNZSG
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurSuhani Kapoor
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyEthan lee
 
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfUnlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfOnline Income Engine
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael Hawkins
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael HawkinsHONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael Hawkins
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael HawkinsMichael W. Hawkins
 
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in India
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in IndiaBest Basmati Rice Manufacturers in India
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in IndiaShree Krishna Exports
 
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...anilsa9823
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMRavindra Nath Shukla
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfPaul Menig
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...Paul Menig
 
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Tina Ji
 
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine ServiceCall Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Serviceritikaroy0888
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒anilsa9823
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...Any kyc Account
 

Último (20)

Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
 
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
 
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMANA DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
 
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfUnlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael Hawkins
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael HawkinsHONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael Hawkins
HONOR Veterans Event Keynote by Michael Hawkins
 
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in India
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in IndiaBest Basmati Rice Manufacturers in India
Best Basmati Rice Manufacturers in India
 
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
 
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
 
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine ServiceCall Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
 

How denmark powers its Future

  • 1. An Analysis of Wind Energy and Danish Power Clusters ANDERS LARSEN E03647 ALESSANDRO PAPELLO 627411 CHRISTIAN JØRGENSEN E03629 JONAS PETTERSSON E03685 MARIA D SANCHEZ HERRERO (LOLA) E03697 SIYUN SHEN 636471 1/1/2011 INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS CLASS: PROFESSOR J OHN A. MA THEWS L U I S S G U I D O C A R L I U N I V E R S I T Y V I A L E R O MA N I A 3 2 0 0 1 9 7 R O MA I T A L Y T E L + 3 9 0 6 8 5 2 2 5 5 0 4 FAX +3906 8522 5985
  • 2. CONTENTS 1. I N TR O D U C T I O N 2 2. HI S TO R Y & D Y N A M I C C O M P E TI T I V E F O R C E S - D I A M O N D A N A L Y S I S O F T H E D A N I S H W I N D TU R B I N E I N D U S TR Y 3 2 . 1 . T HE F A C TO R C O N D I T I O N 3 2 . 2 . F I R M S TR A TE G Y , S TR U C TU R E A N D R I V A L R Y 3 2.3. DEMAND CONDITION 4 2 . 4 . R E L A TE D A N D S U P P O R T I N G I N D U S TR Y 4 2.5. GOVERNMENT 4 2 . 6 . C HA N C E 4 3. T HE R E A L E X A M P L E O F T HE F R A M E W O R K : A A R HU S . T HE C L U S T E R . 5 4. V E S TA S : W O R L D ’ S # 1 TU R B I N E M A N U F A C TU R E R 6 5. HO W D I D T HE A C T O R S I N C L U S T E R C O N TR I B U TE T O T HE I N D U S TR Y ? 7 6. DIFFERENCE IN WIND TURBINE PATH BETWEEN DENMARK AND USA 8 7. T HE N E W E U R O P E A N P O L I C Y : E N E R G Y 2 0 2 0 1 0 8. C O N C L U S I O N S A N D R E C O M M E N D A TI O N S 11 9. BIBLIOGRAPHY 12 1
  • 3. 1. INTRODUCTION The document’s main purpose is to clarify and complement the presentation of Professor Mathews 2010-2011, Master Course in International Business, about Denmark’s Wind Clusters. Therefore, some introductory parts about the Danish land or the global wind industry will be overlooked, in favor of a deeper analysis on the framework applied to the case, the real application of it – the Aarhus cluster- as well as an intensive explanation of the theories and industry analyzing techniques used in this example. Keeping in mind, that no explanation can come without an informational context, we have introduced the history of the cluster in the explanation of the Dynamic Competitive Forces Framework applied to the Danish Wind Industry cluster. Following, we will also take a look at United States’ evolution in this industry and how does it compare to Denmark’s, using the “Bricolage vs. Breakthrough” approach from Garud, Raghu, and Peter Karnøe. We have also dedicated one of the closing points, to the new European policies and how this may affect the cluster evolution in Denmark. We have considered this of special importance, due to the effect of institutions and related official entities to the industry and to its competition. This part is related to a more dynamic analysis of the competitive forces. Overlooked by Porter in his static analysis, it was developed by Mathews as a revision of Porter’s framework, allowing it to acquire a dynamic status, allowing us to comprehend better the evolution of competition. For graphics, and more introductive data, please refer to the slides attached at the end. We are not going to analyze why it happens, but also how it happened, where did it start, what conditions took part, how do the theories apply and who are the main actors of this amazing play: THAT HAS TODAY CREATED, THE BIGGEST WIND INTERLINKED INDUSTRY OF THE WORLD, DESPITE ALL PREDICTIONS. 2
  • 4. 2. HISTORY & DYNAMIC COMPETITIVE FORCES-DIAMOND ANALYSIS OF THE DANISH WIND TURBINE INDUSTRY THE DIAMOND FRAMEWORK AND DYNAMIC COMPETITIVE FORCES FRAMEWORK CAN EFFECTIVELY EXPLAIN THE SUCCESS OF DANISH WIND TURBINE INDUSTRY. THE FOUR MAIN FACTORS, FACTOR CONDITIONS, STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND RIVALRY, DEMAND AND RELATED INDUSTRIES, ARE ALL INTERDEPENDENT AND TOGETHER FORM A PICTURE OF THE ATTRACTIVENESS OF DANISH WIND TURBINE INDUSTRY. IN ADDITION TO THIS GOVERNMENT AND CHANCE ALSO HAVE AN IMPACT ON ALL FACTORS IN THE DIAMOND AND THE COMPETITIVENESS OF THE INDUSTRY. 2.1. THE FACTOR CONDITION This part comprises nature resources, human resources and traditional culture. Natural resource in Denmark is wind --- an abundant “raw material” in Denmark due to the nation’s long shore and thus a requirement for the expansion. Concerning the human resources, one of the most important factor conditions in Denmark was the old blacksmith industry and tradition of building wind turbines, which started in the late 19th century. It all began as private/individual experiments, some of which were more successful than others. These persons were mostly handicrafts workers and engineers with previous experience from the machine industry. Together researchers and manufacturers consequently utilized their existing capabilities and skills in the building of the wind turbines and the competencies they did not have in-house were accessible from sub-contractors who were on the lookout for new business areas to carry their businesses through the ups and downs of the business cycle. With reference to the traditional culture, in the old Danish industry, workers were keen on sharing knowledge and skill, hence the culture that persists in today’s wind turbine clusters.1 2.2. FIRM STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND RIVALRY Danish wind power industry during the 1970s did not start from scratch, but was built on a solid base of theories and practical know-hows in machinery sector. It leverages the machinery practices to develop the three-blade turbine which works as a standard even today. The industry adopted a “Learning by doing” approach, without scientific knowledge they used a learning process which continually try and fail and try again to improve the quality of wind turbine. The efficiency of one component supplier grew with the number of units which already produced. Danish wind turbine industry faced rivalry of alternative energy as fossil fuel, nuclear power so that the R&D never stopped in 20th century. 1Jens Vestergaard (2004) Industry Formation and State Intervention: The Case of the Wind Turbine Industry in Denmark and the United States. Aarhus School of Business. 3
  • 5. 2.3. DEMAND CONDITION Local demand came from the Danish educated consumers. The 1970s oil embargo, price increases and the political measures had a huge impact on the public’s attitude towards energy and energy consumption, which until then had not been a matter at all. People suddenly became more aware of the environment problem, energy and eco-friendly policies became important subjects and were intensely discussed in the mass media, in the offices as well as in private households in Denmark. Progressively more people were supportive of renewable and non- polluting energy sources and started to unite themselves in organizations and support groups. 2.4. RELATED AND SUPPORTING INDUSTRY At the end of the 1970s and the beginning of the 1980s a well-functioning network of subcontractors supplying wings (blades), control systems and gears was established. The Danish wind turbine cluster includes not only the manufactures, components suppliers but also research institutions, such as national laboratory and universities. Test center and users also become a part of the cluster in which they provide input. 2.5. GOVERNMENT Government played an important role in the development of Danish wind turbine industry. First, it set up the Risø National Laboratory in 1978, which improved the research and testing works. Second, it enacted the policy of energy package and energy plan, which permitted the linking of wind power to the grid and set a base price for the wind power. The plan established a market for wind turbine electricity and focused the market’s attention on the cost efficiency of the turbines. Lacking these subsidies wind turbines as suppliers of energy would not have been competitive compared to the traditional power plants and other energy sources. Finally, its environment policy also supported the development of wind power industry. 2.6. CHANCE The triumph of Danish wind turbine industry was due to some chances outside. First, two oil embargoes of 1973 and 1979 and the awakening green movement in the Western societies gave a real boost to the Danish wind turbine industry and set the stage for the present era of wind power. Second, California wind rushes during 1980-1986 stimulated the international wind energy industry to develop. In 1982 when an examination of the American market confirmed that a basis for “something big” existed, all of the large wind turbine manufacturers immediately rushed to the other continent and came home with orders in sizes that were not even possible in the small domestic market but which made it possible for the manufacturers to start batch production of wind turbines. 4
  • 6. FIGURE 1 DYNAMIC FORCES FRAMEWORK ADAPTED TO CASE. ADAPTED FROM THEORY IN: MATHEWS, STRATEGIZING, DISEQUILIBRIUM AND PROFITS (STANFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, 2006). 3. THE REAL EXAMPLE OF THE FRAMEWORK: AARHUS. THE CLUSTER. “A CLOSER LOOK AT DENMARK’S WIND INDUSTRY REVEALS A LARGE CONCENTRATION OF COMPANIES LOCATED IN THE CENTRAL DENMARK BELT FROM AARHUS IN THE EAST TO RINGKØBING AND SKJERN IN THE WEST. “ More than a third of the 175 companies which, according to Denmark’s Central Business Register are directly involved with the production of wind turbines are located in this region. The largest and most globally significant companies reside in the area around Denmark’s second largest city, Aarhus. The Greater Aarhus area and its surrounding municipalities are also home to half of all Danish wind energy companies with five employees or more. Many global companies have located their headquarters or development centers in the Aarhus area. This includes the world’s largest wind turbine manufacturer, Vestas, which will be discussed in the following point (see point 7 of the project). Aarhus is the leading global knowledge center of wind energy. One of the keys to its success is cross-sector cooperation. Aarhus has benefited enormously from the strong professional and industrial environment in the region within energy and environmental technology. Many of the wind industry suppliers are also suppliers to other energy sectors and major environmental and energy-tech companies in the area. This turns competition to coopetition, allowing the dynamic 5
  • 7. forces of supply and factor conditions to act on the industry and the firms, creating synergies and maximizing the results. FIGURE 2 AARHUS MAP WITH DESCRIPTION OF THE DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES. SOURCE: HTTP://WWW.AARHUSKOMMUNE.DK (USE BIBLIOGRAPHY TO SEE IN HIGH RES.) 4. VESTAS: WORLD’S # 1 TURBINE MANUFACTURER AS VESTAS IS THE GLOBAL LEADER ON THE WORLD MARKET FOR WIND ENERGY AND BETWEEN THE KEY DRIVERS OF THE DANISH WIND ENERGY CLUSTER. Vestas was founded in 1898 by H.S. Hansen, a blacksmith, in Denmark. Father and son manufactured steel windows for industrial buildings. In 1945, his son established the company VEstjysk-STålteknik A/S, whose name was shortened to Vestas. In 1979, Vestas delivered the first wind turbines. Vestas has installed over 39,000 wind turbines in 63 countries on 5 continents. In 2008, Vestas installed a new turbine every three hours worldwide, generating more than 60 million Mwah a year. Being a pioneer in the industry, Vestas now counts with a staff of more than 20,000 people. Vestas reached revenues of EUR 6,035 million with operational margin of 11.1% in 2008 and they got global market share of 19% (5,581 MW). Vestas’ core business comprises the development, manufacture, sale and maintenance of wind turbines. Their expertise in modern energy covers more than just wind turbines, specializing in planning, installation, operation and maintenance. Their competencies cover everything from site studies to service and maintenance. So we can detect a high degree of vertical integration. At the same 6
  • 8. time, production and sourcing are carried out as close to the market as possible. In 2008, Vestas opened the world’s largest research and development center for wind energy in Aarhus. 5. HOW DID THE ACTORS IN CLUSTER CONTRIBUTE TO THE INDUSTRY? SHAPING THE DANISH WIND TURBINE DESIGN WAS AN ACT OF COLLABORATIVE NETWORK CONSISTING OF MANY ACTORS INVOLVED IN WIND TURBINES LIKE DESIGNERS, MANUFACTURERS, SUPPLIERS, INSTITUTIONS, TEST ORGANIZATIONS AND POLICY MAKERS. THE ACTORS IN DENMARK PURSUED A PROCESS THAT DEPLOYED MODEST RESOURCES TO PROGRESSIVELY BUILD UP A VIABLE WIND TURBINE PATH. FIGURE 3 EXPLICATIVE GRAPHIC OF THE SYSTEM. In the cluster a sectorial system of innovation played an important role. The firms do not innovate in isolation rather innovations are product of various complementary processes. These complementary processes involve both firms as well as non-firm organizations (such as universities, research centers, government agencies, financial institutions and others). Thus the sectorial system of innovation approach emphasizes actors, networks, knowledge and institutions and the interactions between these elements. For instance, designers and producers become involved based on their beliefs and experiences on the design and production of technological artifacts. Users become involved based on the meanings that they attach to products with respect to their forms, functions and values in use. Evaluators become involved based on their understanding of the tests and standards required to compare and contrast different products. Policy makers enact laws based on their beliefs on the efficacy of specific policy instruments to shape the rate and direction of a technology’s development. The momentum a technology generates as it accumulates inputs from actors shapes the activities of distributed actors. These inputs are generated through learning and knowledge 7
  • 9. accumulation processes that are activated as actors become involved with an emerging path. From the supply side, producers learn by doing and by experimenting. Through these processes, these actors generate capabilities that are critical for the systematic design, production and distribution of goods and services. Users generate feedback when they use products and services that emerge from the technology. Such learning by using generates knowledge of customers’ emerging preferences. Institutional players generate other kinds of learning. For instance, those in regulatory bodies develop institutional mechanisms and policies to “steer” the technology development process. More proximally, test centers generate inputs by a process of learning by testing. The testing criteria that they codify and the results of comparative tests become valuable community level knowledge.2 6. DIFFERENCE IN WIND TURBINE PATH BETWEEN DENMARK AND USA We use overall contrasting labels “Bricolage” and “breakthrough” to highlight the differences in the processes associated with actor involvement in the two paths. Bricolage, named used to label the processes of the Danish industry, was characterized by up-and-coming co-shaping. For example, designers and producers progressively scaled up designs all the while incorporating the inputs of the many companies involved. Users offered continual feedback while those in test centers developed evaluation routines that co-evolved with experiences in the field. All the while, policy makers “modulated” the rise of the market to keep the technological path alive. A diverse logic of disseminated agency appeared in the development of the US wind turbine route. Designers and producers tried to “leap-frog” Denmark with high-tech designs. Researchers at the test center followed a “linear” engineering science based technology-push model as their source for exchanges with industry participants. Regulators passed policies to jump-start the technology, outgrowth the development of a vast market, and then brusquely removed subsidies. In terms of design and production, there were key differences in the traditions. Companies in the US started with a advanced design, took large steps in design scale-up, and did not engage in much product development in-between stages. In contrast, actors in Denmark started with a low-tech design, took smaller steps in design scale-up, and engaged in product development in- between stages. (Therefore from the figure below we can see there are more scale-ups in Danish wind power.) 2Garud, R. and P. Karnøe (2003). "Bricolage versus breakthrough: distributed and embedded agency in technology entrepreneurship." Research Policy 32(2): 277-300. 8
  • 10. FIGURE 4 P., R. GARUD, ET AL. (1997). PATH CREATION AND DEPENDENCE IN THE DANISH WIND TURBINE FIELD. The firms in Denmark possessed a core group of skilled workers, technicians and a few practical engineers. Such a mix was representative of the “mechanical skill” base that had emerged as a result of a “practical engineer” education typical of the Danish machine industry. These firms began developing wind turbines without an appreciation of the complexities involved. The people involved saw the wind turbine as presenting a set of problems similar to those they had confronted in the construction of agricultural machinery. (The table below shows five typical component firms in Denmark.) On the other side, experts in the US approached design from an engineering science knowledge base, conceptualizing problems in terms of the formal, academic language of aerodynamics and structural dynamics. The goal of many engineers was to create a design that had drastically changed features compared to existing technology. 9
  • 11. FIGURE 5 FIVE TYPICAL COMPONENT FIRMS IN DENMARK 7. THE NEW EUROPEAN POLICY: ENERGY 2020 IN 2007 THE EUROPEAN COUNCIL ADOPTED AMBITIOUS ENERGY AND CLIMATE CHANGE OBJECTIVES FOR 2020; THESE WERE REFERRED TO AS THE "20-20-20" TARGETS. They can be summarized in three main points, first being to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 20% compared to 1990 levels (or by 30% if the conditions are right); second being achieving 20% of total energy consumption to be from renewable energy and increasing energy efficiency by 20%; and third: that the 3% of the EU's GDP was to be invested in research and development. EU2020 seems to have forgotten to attach a feasible strategy to the policy. Of course, due to the momentum’s excitement, nobody seemed to realize the vacant. Recently, studies have shown that the existing strategy is currently unlikely to achieve all the 2020 targets, for general disappointment and global shame. The main issue, concerning our research, is that –as said by the Dynamic Competitive Forces Framework- what happens in the Institutions, affects the industry. This is proved by the fact that if governments do not get behind the proposal for a European grid (i.e. a new strategy for the current objectives), we will “face an absurd situation in which renewable energy capacity is being built, but no adequate grid exists to deliver the 34% of renewable electricity needed by 2020 to reach the EU’s binding renewable energy targets3”. Consequently, blocking Denmark’s wind cluster growing capacity, since there will be no point in continuing to build stock and turbines, if they cannot be used. 3Christian Kjaer, EWEA chief executive officer. (2010) http://www.euractiv.com/en/energy/eu-says- 200bn-needed-energy-grids-2020-news-499806 10
  • 12. The consequences are far more than serious, since the whole industry interconnection is deeply linked to the demand pull and supply pull innovation and evolution. Thus, we cannot limit our concerns to environmental issues and energy costs, furthermore we need to take into account the impact of such a mistake on the global energy industry, keeping in mind that its value depends on its interconnections and no part of it has value itself. Comprising in union, a mega- web of synergies and linkages, basic to develop leverage, learning and in sum: Growth. Hence, the European Council has lately come up with a solution, which is still being revised due to its controversial measures. One of which is to make, over the next ten years, energy investments in the order of 1 € trillion. Indeed, 200€ billion are needed to upgrade Europe's gas and electricity grids over the coming decade. The new Europe 2020 strategy 4will drive major efforts in: Energy market regulation, grid management and the security of energy systems; Technical innovation and investments; Education and incentives for domestic and business consumers to save energy, reduce Wastage and switch to low-carbon technologies and fuels. 8. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Denmark is now the leading center within the field of wind power. However during the recent years a significant change in technology and markets has taken place. Denmark is faced with the challenge to maintain its leading position in spite of growing competition from firms operating in lower cost countries, especially China and India. The wind energy cluster and the political system must assume a proactive position towards this change to ensure that Denmark will strengthen its position as unique value creator. The industrial environment is built on a foundation which consists of a significant effort in research and education as well as innovative development focused on environmentally sustainability. This field of wind power is influenced by cooperation and knowledge-sharing to find technological development tracks. The Danish research-environment has a leading position within a number of areas, but great challenges in step with the rapid development of international markets put a lot of pressure of the Danish knowledge center to hold on the talented researchers and students. In order to maintain the unique Danish position, an extraordinary effort must be put in. The strategic issues are focusing on both, development of the wind power industry by improving wind turbines and effectiveness of wind power, and the improvement of the knowledge center regarding research and education. Creating one strategy for the whole value chain with sub-strategies for each of the dimensions of the industry would strengthen the integration and the competitiveness of the wind power industry. This could be provided through common guidelines for the frames of cooperation. Following these recommendations, Denmark will be prepared to face the current challenges. 4ENERGY 2020: A strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy. Citizens’ Summary. http://ec.europa.eu/energy/strategies/2010/doc/2010_11_10_energy_2020_citizens_summary.pdf 11
  • 13. 9. BIBLIOGRAPHY " ProvenModels - dynamic competitive forces - John A. Mathews ." ProvenModels - Management Models | Management Theory | Business Models | Michael Porter | Henry Mintzberg | Management Model | Business School . N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Jan. 2011. <http://www.provenmodels.com/599>. A toolbox for cluster inspired regional development: innovative regions facing the challenges of globalisation.. Aalborg: North Denmark EU-office, 2008. Print. "Blowing in the wind: the Danes have shown that wind energy thrives when there is consistent government support and community ownership." Alternatives Journal 1 Jan. 2004: 1. Print. Boon, M.C.. Why did Danish entrepreneurs take the lead in the wind turbine industry and not the Dutch?: a study on the interaction between evolution and strategy of two communities in an emerging industry. Rotterdam: Erasmus Universiteit, 2008. Print. Brandt, Urs Steiner, and Gert Svendsen. Switch point and first-mover advantage: the case of the wind turbine industry.. Aarhus: Department of Economics, Faculty of Business Administration, Aarhus School of Business, 2004. Print. Bæk, Jeppe. New ways in the transport of wind turbines: on transportational challenges to be faced by the wind turbine industry. S.l.: Nordisk Transportpolitisk Netværk, 2004. Print. Chiesa, Vittorio, and Davide Chiaroni. Industrial Clusters In Biotechnology: Driving Forces, Development Processes And Management Practices.. Singapore: World Scientific, 2004. Print. "Denmark - Wind Power Hub." Visiolink - defining Digital Media. N.p., n.d. Web. 26 Nov. 2010. <http://www.e-pages.dk/windpower/21/>. Drejer, Ina, Frank Kristensen, and Keld Laursen. Cluster studies as a basis for industrial policy: the case of Denmark.. Denmark: N.A., 1999. Print. Energy statistics of OECD countries = [electronic resource] : Statistiques de l'eÌ•nergie des pays de l'OCDE. 2008 ed. Paris: OECD/IEA, 2008. Print. Future offshore: a strategic framework for the offshore wind industry.. London?: Department of Trade and Industry, 2002. Print. Garud, Raghu, and Peter Karnøe,Path dependence and creation . Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2001. Print. Identification and analysis of industry cycles . na: Elsevier, 2009. Print. Karnøe,¸e, Peter. Comments on "Wind energy in America - a history" (a book by Robert W. Righter . Copenhagen Business School: Copenhagen, 1998. Print. Karnøe,¸e, Peter, and Raghu Garud. Path creation and dependence in the Danish wind turbine field . Copenhagen: Institute of Organization and Industrial Sociology, Copenhagen Business School, 1998. Print. Karnøe,¸e, Peter, Peer Hull Kristensen, and Poul Houman Andersen. Mobilizing resources and generating competencies: the remarkable success of small and medium-sized enterprises in the Danish business system. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Business School Press :, 1999. Print. Mathews, John A.. Strategizing, disequilibrium, and profit . Stanford, Calif.: Stanford Business Books, 2006. 12
  • 14. Print. Porter, Michael E.. Clusters and the new economics of competition . Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review , 1998. Print. Potter, Jonathan, and Gabriela Miranda. Clusters, innovation and entrepreneurship . Paris: Oecd, 2009. Print. The U.S. small wind turbine industry roadmap: a 20-year industry plan for small wind turbine technology. Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2002. Print. Wijbrands, H.G.. Innovation networks for a better environment: how successful innovation networks van stimulate the wind turbine industry. Rotterdam: Erasmus Universiteit, 2006. Print. Winds of change a manufacturing blueprint for the wind industry.. Washington, DC: American Wind Energy Association, 2010. Print. Cluster Observatory: Country Report: Denmark (2007) http://www.clusterobservatory.eu/upload/Policy_Report_Denmark_20080116.pdf Danish Energy Authority (2002) Wind Energy in Denmark Status 2001 http://193.88.185.141/Graphics/Publikationer/Forsyning_UK/Wind_Energy_in_Denmark170402.pdf Danish Exporters: http://www.danishexporters.dk/scripts/danishexporters/export.asp (11.01.10) DWIA (2008) Denmark – Wind Power Hub, Danish Industry Association http://www.windpower.org/download/378/profilbrochure_2008.pdf DWIA (2009) Facts on production, number and capacity, Danish Wind Industry Association DWIA (2009) Past and present - successful developments followed by stalemate, Danish Wind Industry Association Energy Policy Statement (2008) The report of the minister of climate and energy pursuant to the Danish Act on Energy Policy Measures Energy Statistics 2007, Danish Energy Agency EREC: Renewable Energy Policy Review Denmark Gamesa: http://www.gamesacorp.com/en/where-are-we/contacts-by-countries/wind-turbines- manufacture Krohn, S. (2002) Danish Wind Turbines: An Industrial Success Story, Danish Wind Industry Association http://guidedtour.windpower.org/media(483,1033)/Danish_Wind_Turbine_Industry,_an_industrial_succes_s tory.pdf Krohn1, S. (2002) The Wind Turbine Market in Denmark, Danish Wind Industry Association Krohn2, S. (2002) Wind Energy Policy in Denmark: 25 Years of Success – What Now? Danish Wind Industry Association Krohn3, S. (2002) Wind Energy Policy in Denmark Status 2002, Danish Wind Industry Association Meyer, N.I. (2007) Learning from Wind Energy Policy in the EU: Lessons from Denmark, Sweden and Spain, European Environment, 17, 5, pp. 347-362 13
  • 15. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark: Factsheet Denmark http://www.denmark.dk/NR/rdonlyres/916BAEE6-AFB8-4720-B118- 03366AB1154A/0/DenmarkOverview.pdf Vestas: http://www.vestas.com/en/about-vestas/history.aspx Vestergaard, J., et al. (2004) A Brief History of The Wind Turbine Industry of Denmark and the United States, Academy of International Business (Southeast USA Chapter) Conference Proceedings, November 2004, pp. 322-327 World Economic Forum: Global Competitiveness Report 2009 World Economic Outlook Database World Fact Book: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2078rank.html Yettin, et al. (2003) Are Diamonds a Country’s Best Friend? Australian Journal of Management, 17, 1, June 1992 14