SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 20
1 Page
MANAGING VIRTUAL TEAMS – A GLOBAL
MARKETING PROGRAM MANAGER’S
PERSPECTIVE


 Rashmi K - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd

 Sowmya Moni - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd

 Yamuna Padmanabhan - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd

 Abhishek RVRK Sharma - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd
Contents
1. Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ 4
2. Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 4
3. Research Methodology ................................................................................................................. 5
4. Research Findings ......................................................................................................................... 6
   4.1 Marketing challenges for virtual teams ................................................................................. 6
   4.2 Advantages of virtual teams ................................................................................................... 7
   4.3 Important Work Dimensions in virtual teams ....................................................................... 7
5. Go-to- Market Program — New Product Launch Case Study ................................................ 7
6. Solution Framework ....................................................................................................................... 8
   6.1 Global Virtual Governance Structure .................................................................................... 9
   6.2 Role Task Methodology ........................................................................................................ 10
   6.3 Consensus Building Process ............................................................................................... 11
   6.4 Cross Cultural Communication Model ................................................................................ 12
7. Conclusion..................................................................................................................................... 14
8. Bibliography .................................................................................................................................. 14
9. Appendix 1 .................................................................................................................................... 15
10. Appendix 2a ................................................................................................................................ 16
11. Appendix 2b ................................................................................................................................ 17
12. Appendix 2c ................................................................................................................................ 18
13. Appendix 3 .................................................................................................................................. 19
14. Author’s Profile ........................................................................................................................... 20




3 Page
1. Abstract
"...you cannot build network organizations on electronic networks alone...If so,... we will probably
need an entirely new sociology of organizations." Nohria & Eccles, 1992, pp. 304-305.

The purpose of this paper is to present the challenges faced by marketing program managers and
make recommendations for effectively managing virtual teams working on global marketing
programs.

Global marketing programs refer to marketing activities co-ordinated and integrated across multiple
country markets to achieve a specific marketing outcome for an organization. Today, many global
fortune companies design marketing programs to drive key marketing outcomes such as improving
time to market for launching new products globally, creating agility in product development life cycle
to compete effectively in an environment, responding to competitor, industry changes and customer
needs etc. In such a program, core concepts such as value proposition building, product roadmap
definition, marketing plan development, and communication strategy are developed at a global level
and implemented in countries. These programs are driven by virtual teams that usually comprise
hybrid mix of location specific and diverse competencies.

The advent of low cost, real-time collaboration communication technology has made it possible for
teams divided by time and space to interact and contribute effectively. Not only does the marketing
program manager needs to manage the triple constraints (time, scope and cost) but also needs to
manage challenges related to cross-cultural communication while ensuring consistency of one
voice in marketing planning and execution. There is also often a need to diagnose and handle
differences, challenge assumptions, and defuse the potential for conflict. The paper will detail the
challenges faced by marketing managers through few business cases.

In order to successfully achieve the marketing outcome and overcome the challenges, marketing
program managers need to manage a whole spectrum of communication strategies and project
management techniques as well as human and social processes in ways that support the team.
The authors will discuss their experiences and share best practices of effectively managing virtual
teams — some of which include establishing a global virtual governance structure, building a
culture for collaboration and formal consensus building process, and creating a role task
prioritization matrix and a cross-cultural relevant communication model for the virtual team
and its stakeholders.



2. Introduction
                                                                     1
All projects have two core features – activities and decisions.  Most challenges stem from
managing these two features. All activities and decisions need to be effectively managed for




1
 New Product Development Decision-Making Effectiveness: Comparing Individuals, Face-To-Face Teams,
and Virtual Teams, Schmidt et al., Decision Sciences, Volume 32 No. 4, Fall 2001

4 Page
achieving project or program outcomes successfully. Managing marketing projects and programs
are no different. The context of activities and decisions in marketing can be related to managing the
customer journey (customer relationship management), developing the marketing strategy and
plan, defining and launching products, and or management of the marketing mix. Authors, who are
experienced marketing managers, have managed several global marketing programs and have
collectively 25 years of managing and working in large globally distributed teams. This paper
discusses aspects of virtual team management in marketing context.

The authors conducted field study with the objective of determining the challenges and benefits of
managing and working in virtual marketing teams. The study was a mixed-methods approach to
gather quantitative and qualitative data using a Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire, one-
on-one interviews and a Go-to-Market marketing program case study. The authors conducted
few one-on-one interviews with several marketing leaders and project practitioners managing
diverse marketing projects across domains such as research/analytics and product marketing
launches to learn perspectives on managing virtual teams. The insights gained from the interviews
and the authors’ collective experiendces were used in designing the questionnaire. Refer to the
Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire in Appendix 1 and Qualitative Interview Transcripts in
Appendix 4. A correlation analysis was conducted on quantitative data, while qualitative data was
themed and counted. The findings of the study have been discussed in detail in the paper. Authors
have also discussed the challenges of managing virtual team through a Go-to-Market case study of
a New Product Launch.

Authors have provided a proven, actionable and suggestive solution framework to reduce the
risks associated with challenges when working with culturally diverse virtual teams..

3. Research Methodology
A short questionnaire was designed and administered online to 30 mid-senior level marketing
managers working or managing large global programs across the organization. Questions in the
survey focused on gaining insights from marketing managers on challenges and benefits when
working in a virtual team.

Respondents provided their responses on the perceived challenges pertaining to role/responsibility
of team members, cultural sensitivity, customer and market data acquisition, task prioritization,
governance processes, communication, speed of decision making, cost effectiveness, efficacy of
output/deliverables and quality of work, in the survey. Questions on perceived benefits of working in
a virtual teams were also included in the questionnaire and centered around improved time to
completion for marketing planning and execution, clear and effective communication, time saved
through faster decision making and real time collaboration facilitated in accelerating speed to
market.

 Refer to the Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire in Appendix 1.




5 Page
4. Research Findings
It was important to establish the role of the respondent as the survey responses to the perceived
challenges and benefits in the questionnaire and interviews were role specific. The respondent
chose the role most applicable — program/ project manager or a team contributor while responding
to the questions on the survey. The results of the survey brought out some interesting insights.
Project managers and team contributors viewed challenges and benefits of working in virtual teams
differently. The research results are presented below, with interpretive statements with regard to
their results.

4.1 Marketing challenges for virtual teams
(Refer Appendix 2, Figure 1)


It was surprising to find out that most of the respondents seem to corroborate authors’ views on
challenges and benefits in virtual teaming. Most marketing managers cited communication and
governance related challenges more over other types of challenges. In a large globally
distributed organization, communication is presented as a significant challenge, unsurprisingly and
perhaps compounded by high levels of cultural diversity within project teams that are spread across
multiple time zones. Additionally, there is stress on governance difficulties, indicating difficulties
with decision making and tracking of project progress. With multiple teams working together,
the lack of clear definition of responsibility and task priority definition becomes a major
challenge for virtual teams. The distances inherent to virtual teams make face to face collaboration
difficult, which helps resolve such issues in traditional teams

One of the respondents quoted: ―Decision making structures are often not very clearly defined, as
the nature of virtual teaming means such structures would need to change often. With virtual teams
being created and dismantled frequently, it becomes difficult to maintain good governance in terms
of decision making and communication. Another parameter that was of concern was task
prioritization. With virtual teams so geographically divided, regional biases sometimes emerging
within the team with respect to task prioritization‖

The use of Global Virtual Governance Structure has been seen to improve the incidence of
definition of realistic ideas and implementable solutions in culturally diverse virtual teams. It has
been noted that cultural diversity has both positive and negative implications for virtual team, the
positives stemming from improved decision making and idea generation, and the negatives from
                                                            2
the challenges associated with intercultural communication . This has been discussed in detail in
the solution framework section of the paper.




2
  Shachaf, P. (2008). Cultural diversity and information and communication technology impacts on global virtual teams: An
exploratory study. Information and Management, 45(2), 131‐142.
6 Page
4.2 Advantages of virtual teams
(Refer Appendix 2, Figure 2)

The two most significant advantages presented included the ease of exchange of information
due to virtual communication capabilities and ease of access to Subject Matter Experts
(SMEs) and data resources. The core advantages provided in the survey seem to gain
reasonable amount of acceptance from the respondents, indicating that the perceived advantages
of virtual teams are common across most marketing programs. Faster decision making, improved
completion times for marketing planning and messaging are all represented advantages of virtual
teaming.


4.3 Important Work Dimensions in virtual teams
(Refer Appendix 2, Figure 3)

With respect to factors that are influenced by virtual teams, the most significant factor in moving
towards virtual teaming was that of cost savings. The use of virtual teams for a geographically
dispersed organization represents significant savings in terms of costs incurred for travel and
exchange of information. Additionally, the efficiency and improved quality of work were seen as
other advantages of virtual teaming, with the ease of information exchange and access to
Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) across geographies.

Qualitative interviews corroborated with the findings of the survey. Marketing managers
mentioned that due to vast time differences across teams, it is challenging to coordinate tasks and
ensure goal alignment while keeping the availability of resources in different regions under
consideration necessitating some team members to work at odd hours. One of the biggest
advantages that virtual teams present for marketing is the work continuance to follow the sun,
thus making sure that work progresses continually as it moves from team members from one time
zone to another across the globe. The work allocation becomes easier as there is accessibility to
global talent. The clear definition of marketing objectives and role task prioritization initially
goes a long way in mitigating the risk in time and communication management.



5. Go-to- Market Program — New Product Launch Case
Study
The authors manage global technology product launches. Global launches are usually done
simultaneously across geographies and require co-ordination with multiple teams across functions.
A diverse globally distributed team such as product engineering, planning, operations, delivery and
deployment works to plan and execute various aspects of a launch. The case study below focuses
on marketing team’s involvement in launching an enterprise software product.

Creating and managing the launch schedule is the single most critical responsibility of a
marketing launch program manager.




7 Page
An enterprise software product upgrade was to be launched with 1000 global customers across 140
countries. This product aimed at upgrading the Enterprise customers’ IT environment to the next
level. The objectives of the launch were to:

   Encourage at least 80% of the customers to migrate to the new product in the first wave of
   migration over 12 months
   Increase customer satisfaction levels by 30 % post migration

It was imperative that sales, IT delivery managers and customers had access to marketing
literature to the new product earliest and latest finish of 8 and 6 weeks respectively before the
product launch date. A virtual go-to-market team was put together to work on the marketing
activities pertaining to the launch and a launch program manager was assigned to the launch. The
launch schedule was planned for 10 weeks with 5 critical milestones that included approval
of project charter, release of value proposition and positioning statements, roll out of an
integrated communication plan and release of customer and sales facing marketing
collaterals. The program manager had to manage multiple teams with different functional
specializations (marketing, product development, regional sales and delivery) from different
geographies (Asia Pacific (APJ), Europe, the Middle East and Africa (EMEA), Americas).

Being a global launch, all marketing content has to be translation ready. The prioritization of
languages translations for marketing content, created several hurdles in meeting the critical
milestones of the launch schedule. With a finite budget, and decision to translate all marketing
collateral in only 10 languages meant meeting with all concerned stakeholders and seeking
consensus. Consensus building requires trust and building relationships and trust in a
virtual team is a significant challenge. The launch manager had to schedule many meetings for
these discussions. The deliberations did create conflict like situations within the core marketing
team. As a program manager, one had to be sensitive to time zones and work hours and therefore
do resource and task allocation in such a manner that the work is uninterrupted – famously referred
to as the Follow the Sun approach! While the overall launch schedule was met on time which was
(Latest Finish) 6 weeks before launch, 2 critical milestones were on critical path throughout the
project. Lessons learned from addressing ways to dealing with the challenges outlined above, have
helped in building some kind of defense mechanisms to counter risks of delays in managing
launches.

The solution framework provided below has been seen to improve the incidence of managing some
of the known risks and success in managing culturally diverse virtual teams.

6. Solution Framework
We have seen that challenges for managing a marketing team which is connected virtually are
many. However, from the authors’ perspective, the benefits of a virtually managed marketing team
far outweigh the challenges. It has been observed that organizations which cater to the demands of
cross cultural markets, have an inherent opportunity to consolidate and connect the skills and
expertise of resources spread in strategic locations under a common umbrella for the achievement
of marketing objectives. In such a scenario, the successful achievement of the marketing outcomes


8 Page
is the result of management of a whole spectrum of communication strategies and project
management techniques as well as human and social processes in ways that support the team.

Having observed the dynamics of successful virtually operational marketing organization, the
authors talk detail a solution framework from their collective experience of launching
products globally. This solution framework can be applied in principle to all marketing programs.
The framework consists of the following components:

1.   Global Virtual Governance Structure
2.   Role Task Prioritization Matrix
3.   Consensus Building Process
4.   Cross Cultural Communication Model

6.1 Global Virtual Governance Structure
Most global marketing teams have a strong matrix organization structure. The challenge of
managing interpersonal relationships, communicating and monitoring the progress of a marketing
program is managed by defining its Governance structure. A governance structure establishes
the strategic, operational, and technical decision-making process required to ensure marketing
teams enable the organization to excel in its mission. Governance structures are mostly defined at
leadership level such Marketing Council or Business Steering Committee with representation from
several functional teams working virtually across the globe. The leadership team consists of
representatives from the top management of the company. Marketing budgets are owned by this
team and they are the final approval and escalation point for all marketing programs. The top
management is assisted in governance and decision making by the Strategy and Executive teams
who align with the marketing objectives outlined by the Leadership team. Cross-team collaboration
and prioritization decisions are formulated at this level. The Executive teams are also responsible
for setting standards and driving governance guidance, which is necessary in order to sustain an
environment of cohesion within virtual program teams working towards the achievement of the
marketing objectives. Governance structure is also influenced by industry groups and other
business functions (such as finance, legal etc) in the organization.

Decisions making is facilitated by sharing information through multiple mediums of communication
such as team share sites, collaboration websites, virtual rooms, audio conferencing tools etc.
These communication tools enable marketing teams working towards a complex marketing
program such as product launch to collaborate and share information, negotiate and assess
progress of the program. In fact, many organizations in recent times have used these
communication platforms to launch products. The illustration below shows a formal Governance
structure for a launching a product globally across regions. The Launch Program manager interacts
with several teams (product, regional marketing, country marketing, and engineering, global
support functions) which are geographically dispersed to launch a product. Whether it is customer
requirements gathering, product development, messaging, creating marketing outbound
communication or co-coordinating the launch roll out, all of these activities are carried out
seamlessly through virtual teaming.




9 Page
1.0 Governance Structure




6.2 Role Task Methodology
The importance of role task prioritization can best be summarized through a sound bite from a
marketing leader, the authors interviewed recently, “I have found that spending more time up front
ensuring everyone is on the same page and knows who is doing what, is a very prudent investment
as the team can then execute against clearly defined goals with everyone pulling in the same
direction.”

How does a marketing program manager keep tabs on who in the virtual team are responsible for
what aspect of the launch program? The answer to the question lies in Role Task Prioritization.
This involves defining and providing members of the marketing program clarity on the role and
responsibilities. Marketing program managers map the responsibilities of different virtual teams by
creating a program RACI. RACI — Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed. In a virtual
team, where face to face interaction among the members is very low, a RACI provides a reference
point for decision making and task assignments. Having a detailed program RACI reduces risks on
conflicts and progression of the marketing program as per predefined schedules. The sample below
is a program RACI for global marketing product launch across countries. All the teams are virtually
work together to launch the product.




10 Page
2.0      Program RACI

6.3 Consensus Building Process
One of the challenges in managing a virtual team is the varying degree of prioritizations and
involvements existent within a program team. While managing marketing programs such as
launches, launch Program Manager and his/her core team may have a high degree of involvement
on all stages of launch, other teams such as country marketing teams participating in the launch
may have a relatively low degree of involvement in the launch process. Therefore, a formal
consensus building process needs to be initiated in order to manage the triple constraints of
time, cost and scope.

In a virtual team, marketing program managers require consensus in order to:

      Develop clear understanding of the roles and responsibilities
      Arrive at an agreement on the turnaround time on the marketing deliverables

11 Page
Agree at convenient time to schedule update and clarification meetings among members of
    different time zones
    Develop an agreement on the content review process and toll gates
    Define success factors for marketing effectiveness

Consensus building can be achieved by respecting different points of view, understanding working
styles and gaining insights through focus group discussions, brainstorming sessions, meetings etc.
The authors have observed certain working styles to work most effectively in a in a consensus
seeking discussion and that can be categorized broadly as Initiator, Facilitator and Devil’s
advocate and Observer.

Members with Initiator style will be proactive to reach out to the relevant members in the team and
would have the ability to identify conflicts and risks requiring consensus building exercise.

Facilitators are active participants to discussions and provide suggestions and alternate options to
the arrive at consensus. They will diffuse emotional, aggressive conflicting situations through their
unbiased, mature conversation style, humor sense or power position in the team.

Devil’s advocates are active participants questioning the status quo in the team.

Observers are passive participants who do not typically voice their views pro-actively but are the
doers in the group.

It is important for program manager to identify the working style of the team members and use this
to his/her advantage while managing the program. For instance, one would like to have more
facilitators present in a conflict resolution meeting and perhaps a devil’s advocate while negotiating
a contract with an external agency. A program manager has to adopt all these styles depending on
the situation while leading a program.

6.4 Cross Cultural Communication Model
One of the characteristics which differentiate a virtual team from a location specific team is the wide
diversity of cultures. Cultures define our approach towards working with different members which
can be perspectives and values towards deliverables and outcomes. A commonly reference theory
on Culture is that of Greet Hofstede’s., who analyzed cultural values on dimensions such as
individualism, uncertainty avoidance, power distance, masculinity-femininity and self-restraint etc.

For a marketing program manager working with cross cultural virtual teams, developing an
understanding of the cross cultural differences and adapting his communication and program
approach to sensitivities of other members is of utmost importance. Because of the relevance of
cultural sensitivities in understanding market trends and successful achievement of program
outcomes, organizations today conduct a number of Cultural Sensitivity Training programs for
members of its marketing organizations. The Transnational Management Association’s Country
Navigator portal for example, helps a program manager profile his cultural values and styles on a
nine point scale and compare it with the various countries where its virtual team members are
stationed.




12 Page
Authors have highlighted dimensions of a cross cultural communication model which are
relevant when managing global programs. Given below are a few case scenarios of cultural
sensitivity which needs to be taken into account while handling marketing programs in a virtual
environment:

 Cultural Dimensions
 Scheduling        Virtual teams work across different time zones and scheduling meetings across
 Meetings          time zones is a challenge. In a few cultures (like India , China and many Asian
                   Countries), scheduling meeting post working hours may be considered
                   acceptable , but in a few others (Germany) stick to deadlines and is particular
                   of timekeeping

 Explicit vs.      Americans/German teams have a very explicit communication styles – direct,
 Implicit          assertive and message which is spelt out clear and concise. It is imperative to
 Communication     learn to read the signals, and to read between the lines.

 Team work         Some cultures like and prefer to work in a group than on an individual basis.
                   Therefore a marketing initiative which requires delegation, negotiation and
                   decision making will make such cultures more comfortable.

 Initiation of     Initiation of marketing meetings in a virtual environment with resources from
 Conversation      cross cultures requires careful consideration of various aspects. Few cultures
                   encourage relationship building such as an ice breaking session, before moving
                   on to business scenarios.

 Conflict          Different cultures may have different ways of handling conflicts. Launch
 Management        marketing program described in the paper heading for its due date will be an
                   apt example for this. Under such scenarios, where there is a possibility of tense
                   conversations with varying degree of assertions, different members of a launch
                   team may react differently. If we have a background of members who belong to
                   cultures which do not encourage such open conversations, there is a possibility
                   of such members taking the situation personally.

 Risk              The way a member of a virtual team perceives risk is an important aspect of
 Perceptions       cross cultural sensitiveness. The degree of acceptance and appreciation of risk
                   associated with a proposed project varies – For example, US as a culture is
                   more appreciative of handling risk and uncertainties. Many cultures such as the
                   French have been generally found to be more protective and act more
                   proactively to safeguard the program and self.




13 Page
7. Conclusion
Through the use of survey, personal experiences, one-on-one interviews with leaders and a real
time product launch case study, authors have attempted to describe challenges managing virtual
teams in the marketing world. We understand many of these challenges may not be unique to
marketing only.

The suggested solution framework aims at providing guidance to marketing program managers and
project management practitioners who are looking to increasingly use virtual teaming to enable
effective marketing without spiraling costs. With the pro-active use of some of the concepts and
frameworks mentioned in the paper, it is possible to combat most of the challenges managing
virtual teams while also noting that particular situations may emerge which may require modification
of the methods suggested.




8. Bibliography
al., K. e. (2007). Conflict and Performance in Global Virtual Teams. Journal of Management
Information Systems.

al., S. e. (Volume 32 No. 4, Fall 2001). New Product Development Decision-Making Effectiveness:
Comparing Individuals, Face-To-Face Teams, and Virtual Teams. Decision Sciences.

Association, T. M. (n.d.). www.countrynavigator.com. Retrieved from The Transnational
Management Association’s Country Navigator Portal.

Hofstede, G. (2010). Theory of Cultural Dimensions (Updated). Cultures and Organizations:
Software of the Mind.

Shachaf, P. (2008). Cultural diversity and information and communication technology impacts on
global virtual teams: An exploratory study. Information and Management, 45(2), 131‐142.




14 Page
9. Appendix 1
Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire



Question 1 – What is your job role in your team?
   A.   Project Manager
   B.   Project Team Contributor


Question 2 – What are the typical challenges you have had in your engagement/projects while
working in virtual teams? (Rank from most prevalent (1) to least prevalent or nonexistent (9) )
  A.    Cultural Issues – Dealing with different cultures as part of my engagement with various
        stakeholders and teams
  B. Governance Issues – Decision making and tracking progress are issues
  C. Communication Issues – Clear and consistent communication of messaging and other
        marketing assets is difficult across geographies
  D. Role and Responsibility Identification
  E.    Prioritization of tasks that need to be done by the team – Everyone thinks their own tasks are
        the most important
  F.    Identification of the right messaging for products/services
  G. Process Issues – Launch/Go-To- Market/Product Development/Market and Customer
        Intelligence processes are not well defined
  H. Capacity Issues – Not having right or enough resources
  I.    Data Acquisition – Marketing Data (customer, competitor and industry intelligence, product
        sales reports , customer information) and document acquisition from other teams is delayed
  J.    Other Issues (Please specify)


Question 3– Rate the importance of work parameter while working in a virtual team (Scale of 1 to 5
from much worse to much better)
    A. Time for decision making
    B. Cost
    C. Responsiveness
    D. Efficiency
    E. Quality of work(Output/ Deliverables)



Question 4– What, according to you, are the major benefits of working in a virtual team? (Rank these
in order from Most Useful (1) to Least Useful (7))
     A. Improved time to completion for collateral/messaging or marketing projects
     B. More clear and effective communication (two way, translated)
     C. Time saved through reduction of decision making delays
     D. Real time collaboration facilitated discussion time savings
     E. Faster GTM (Go To Market) and generic marketing planning
     F. Better sharing of information across the team (reports/analytics)
     G. Others (Please specify)



15 Page
10. Appendix 2a
Research Results

(n=30)

Figure 1




16 Page
11. Appendix 2b
Research Results

(n=30)

Figure 2




17 Page
12. Appendix 2c
Research Results

(n=30)

Figure 3



   Virtual Teams
   Effect on work parameters

           Time for decision making                         -0.03

  Response Times for team members                                       0.10

                     Quality of work                                       0.33

                   Efficiency of work                                          0.43

                                Cost                                              0.60

                                        -2   -1.5   -1   -0.5       0      0.5           1   1.5   2




18 Page
13. Appendix 3
Excerpts from an interview with a marketing leader, who is currently managing a large virtual
marketing team in Hewlett Packard

(One example) Interview transcript with Director, Technology Services Marketing, Hewlett
Packard

1. What are the major challenges you face while working with your global teams?
Given we span all regions of the world and multiple time zones, Alignment & Communication are
the key challenges we face. While we communicate effectively and frequently via e-mail, often
times the best or only way to effectively communicate is live voice-to-voice, which means phone
calls at very inconvenient times for some of our team members.

2. In your opinion, what has been the impact of virtual team engagements on marketing
KPAs – Time/Resource Availability, Marketing Spends, Return on Marketing Investment etc.
There are both positives and negatives associated with the global virtual team model. The negative
is what I stated above, i.e. inconvenient times for meetings/calls and challenges associated with
aligning a global team. However, the global virtual team model also provides advantages in that
―work can follow the sun‖, meaning we can pass and hand-off work from one region and time zone
to the next so that the project continues to progress 24x7.

3. What could be done to improve the current operating model for virtual teams in
marketing?
Adequate funding for both people and program money is always a challenge that every global
marketing team faces, so increases in marketing funding drives a corresponding increase in ROI.

4. Which marketing activities work best with virtual teams?
Activities that are VERY clearly defined and scoped out at the beginning of the project. I have
found that spending more time up front ensuring everyone is on the same page and knows who is
doing what, is a very prudent investment as the team can then execute against clearly defined
goals with everyone pulling in the same direction.

5. As a marketing leader, what has been the single most important challenge while working
with your extended team across countries?

Balancing the seemingly infinite and ever-increasing demands for more out of marketing with the
very finite resources (people, time, money) we have. Requires being very tough on setting
priorities and then being very transparent and communicative to stakeholders on what marketing
will do, and equally important, what marketing will not do, with our precious/finite resources.




19 Page
14. Author’s Profile


                Sowmya Moni has 12+ years of proven experience in technology
                marketing. She is a senior marketing manager with Hewlett Packard’s
                Global Analytics team. She holds an MBA in Marketing from MDI,
                Gurgaon and is a certified PMP. She has co-authored the paper with
                her team Rashmi K, Yamuna Padmanaban and Abhishek RVRK
                Sharma.




20 Page

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a EMDT_1

Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-GuidelinesWeb-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
Vu Nam Hung
 
Vardarajan sethuraman
Vardarajan sethuramanVardarajan sethuraman
Vardarajan sethuraman
PMI2011
 
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
PMI_IREP_TP
 
117091485 product-and-brand-management
117091485 product-and-brand-management117091485 product-and-brand-management
117091485 product-and-brand-management
k1236541212
 

Similar a EMDT_1 (20)

Viral marketing of digital products using social media - MBA Dissertation
Viral marketing of digital products using social media - MBA DissertationViral marketing of digital products using social media - MBA Dissertation
Viral marketing of digital products using social media - MBA Dissertation
 
City brands
City brandsCity brands
City brands
 
How to Improve Time to Market w Existing Resources
How to Improve Time to Market w Existing ResourcesHow to Improve Time to Market w Existing Resources
How to Improve Time to Market w Existing Resources
 
Content: The New Marketing Equation - Altimeter Group Research
Content: The New Marketing Equation - Altimeter Group ResearchContent: The New Marketing Equation - Altimeter Group Research
Content: The New Marketing Equation - Altimeter Group Research
 
[Report] Content: The New Marketing Equation, by Rebecca Lieb
[Report] Content: The New Marketing Equation, by Rebecca Lieb[Report] Content: The New Marketing Equation, by Rebecca Lieb
[Report] Content: The New Marketing Equation, by Rebecca Lieb
 
Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-GuidelinesWeb-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
Web-Project-Management-Best-Practice-Guidelines
 
Team Development Process
Team Development ProcessTeam Development Process
Team Development Process
 
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
 
The Evolution of Personal Branding
The Evolution of Personal BrandingThe Evolution of Personal Branding
The Evolution of Personal Branding
 
Planning and execution of marketing strategy for pleximus
Planning and execution of marketing strategy for pleximusPlanning and execution of marketing strategy for pleximus
Planning and execution of marketing strategy for pleximus
 
Coaching material and tools for altruistic entrepreneurs -mentors - Module 3.pdf
Coaching material and tools for altruistic entrepreneurs -mentors - Module 3.pdfCoaching material and tools for altruistic entrepreneurs -mentors - Module 3.pdf
Coaching material and tools for altruistic entrepreneurs -mentors - Module 3.pdf
 
How does big data disrupt marketing : the modification of a marketer’s job
 How does big data disrupt marketing : the modification of a marketer’s job  How does big data disrupt marketing : the modification of a marketer’s job
How does big data disrupt marketing : the modification of a marketer’s job
 
Vardarajan sethuraman
Vardarajan sethuramanVardarajan sethuraman
Vardarajan sethuraman
 
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
Vardarajan 20sethuraman-131008015800-phpapp02
 
Term Report: Barriers to Communication and it effects on New Product Launches
Term Report: Barriers to Communication and it effects on New Product LaunchesTerm Report: Barriers to Communication and it effects on New Product Launches
Term Report: Barriers to Communication and it effects on New Product Launches
 
0809 garciac
0809 garciac0809 garciac
0809 garciac
 
Business Model Framework using Knowledge Management
Business Model Framework using Knowledge ManagementBusiness Model Framework using Knowledge Management
Business Model Framework using Knowledge Management
 
submited
submitedsubmited
submited
 
MBA-Branding-Jon Tan-BRANDJONTAN
MBA-Branding-Jon Tan-BRANDJONTANMBA-Branding-Jon Tan-BRANDJONTAN
MBA-Branding-Jon Tan-BRANDJONTAN
 
117091485 product-and-brand-management
117091485 product-and-brand-management117091485 product-and-brand-management
117091485 product-and-brand-management
 

Más de PMI2011

Bhavesh pmi final
Bhavesh  pmi finalBhavesh  pmi final
Bhavesh pmi final
PMI2011
 
Day 1 1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
Day 1   1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay saneDay 1   1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
Day 1 1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
PMI2011
 
Day 1 1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
Day 1   1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyyaDay 1   1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
Day 1 1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
PMI2011
 
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data un...
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data   un...Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data   un...
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data un...
PMI2011
 
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthyWilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
PMI2011
 
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakrabortiVs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
PMI2011
 
Vineet jain
Vineet jainVineet jain
Vineet jain
PMI2011
 
Yamuna padmanaban
Yamuna padmanabanYamuna padmanaban
Yamuna padmanaban
PMI2011
 
Vimal kumarkhanna
Vimal kumarkhannaVimal kumarkhanna
Vimal kumarkhanna
PMI2011
 
Venkatraman l
Venkatraman lVenkatraman l
Venkatraman l
PMI2011
 
Soumen de
Soumen deSoumen de
Soumen de
PMI2011
 
Sujit sopan barhate
Sujit sopan barhateSujit sopan barhate
Sujit sopan barhate
PMI2011
 
Srinivasa desikanraghavan
Srinivasa desikanraghavanSrinivasa desikanraghavan
Srinivasa desikanraghavan
PMI2011
 
Sharad pandey abhisek goswami
Sharad pandey abhisek goswamiSharad pandey abhisek goswami
Sharad pandey abhisek goswami
PMI2011
 
Soma roy sarkar
Soma roy sarkarSoma roy sarkar
Soma roy sarkar
PMI2011
 
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuramanShallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
PMI2011
 
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoycebRegeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
PMI2011
 
Ramesh ganiga
Ramesh ganigaRamesh ganiga
Ramesh ganiga
PMI2011
 
Pranabendu
PranabenduPranabendu
Pranabendu
PMI2011
 
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandey
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandeyRt sundari ashutosh_pandey
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandey
PMI2011
 

Más de PMI2011 (20)

Bhavesh pmi final
Bhavesh  pmi finalBhavesh  pmi final
Bhavesh pmi final
 
Day 1 1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
Day 1   1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay saneDay 1   1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
Day 1 1410 - 1455 - pearl 2 - vijay sane
 
Day 1 1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
Day 1   1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyyaDay 1   1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
Day 1 1620 - 1705 - maple - pranabendu bhattacharyya
 
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data un...
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data   un...Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data   un...
Final chakradhar purohith proposal milieu analysis (without account data un...
 
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthyWilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
Wilso anandaraj balasubramaniankrishnamurthy
 
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakrabortiVs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
Vs velan dchakravarty_ppchakraborti
 
Vineet jain
Vineet jainVineet jain
Vineet jain
 
Yamuna padmanaban
Yamuna padmanabanYamuna padmanaban
Yamuna padmanaban
 
Vimal kumarkhanna
Vimal kumarkhannaVimal kumarkhanna
Vimal kumarkhanna
 
Venkatraman l
Venkatraman lVenkatraman l
Venkatraman l
 
Soumen de
Soumen deSoumen de
Soumen de
 
Sujit sopan barhate
Sujit sopan barhateSujit sopan barhate
Sujit sopan barhate
 
Srinivasa desikanraghavan
Srinivasa desikanraghavanSrinivasa desikanraghavan
Srinivasa desikanraghavan
 
Sharad pandey abhisek goswami
Sharad pandey abhisek goswamiSharad pandey abhisek goswami
Sharad pandey abhisek goswami
 
Soma roy sarkar
Soma roy sarkarSoma roy sarkar
Soma roy sarkar
 
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuramanShallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
Shallu soni mymoonshabana_lavanya raghuraman
 
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoycebRegeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
Regeena pererira sujithn_rai_suchitrajoyceb
 
Ramesh ganiga
Ramesh ganigaRamesh ganiga
Ramesh ganiga
 
Pranabendu
PranabenduPranabendu
Pranabendu
 
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandey
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandeyRt sundari ashutosh_pandey
Rt sundari ashutosh_pandey
 

Último

Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Nauman Safdar
 
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al MizharAl Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
allensay1
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
daisycvs
 

Último (20)

Durg CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN durg ESCORTS
Durg CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN durg ESCORTSDurg CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN durg ESCORTS
Durg CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN durg ESCORTS
 
Unveiling Falcon Invoice Discounting: Leading the Way as India's Premier Bill...
Unveiling Falcon Invoice Discounting: Leading the Way as India's Premier Bill...Unveiling Falcon Invoice Discounting: Leading the Way as India's Premier Bill...
Unveiling Falcon Invoice Discounting: Leading the Way as India's Premier Bill...
 
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond InsightsWheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
WheelTug Short Pitch Deck 2024 | Byond Insights
 
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
 
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
 
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTSJAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR  ESCORTS
JAJPUR CALL GIRL ❤ 82729*64427❤ CALL GIRLS IN JAJPUR ESCORTS
 
Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
Chennai Call Gril 80022//12248 Only For Sex And High Profile Best Gril Sex Av...
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
Escorts in Nungambakkam Phone 8250092165 Enjoy 24/7 Escort Service Enjoy Your...
 
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptxPutting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
 
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al MizharAl Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
Al Mizhar Dubai Escorts +971561403006 Escorts Service In Al Mizhar
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investorsFalcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
 
Cannabis Legalization World Map: 2024 Updated
Cannabis Legalization World Map: 2024 UpdatedCannabis Legalization World Map: 2024 Updated
Cannabis Legalization World Map: 2024 Updated
 
PHX May 2024 Corporate Presentation Final
PHX May 2024 Corporate Presentation FinalPHX May 2024 Corporate Presentation Final
PHX May 2024 Corporate Presentation Final
 
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 MonthsSEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60%  in 6 Months
SEO Case Study: How I Increased SEO Traffic & Ranking by 50-60% in 6 Months
 
Nashik Call Girl Just Call 7091819311 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Nashik Call Girl Just Call 7091819311 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableNashik Call Girl Just Call 7091819311 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Nashik Call Girl Just Call 7091819311 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All TimeCall 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
 
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...
joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...joint cost.pptx  COST ACCOUNTING  Sixteenth Edition                          ...
joint cost.pptx COST ACCOUNTING Sixteenth Edition ...
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
 

EMDT_1

  • 2. MANAGING VIRTUAL TEAMS – A GLOBAL MARKETING PROGRAM MANAGER’S PERSPECTIVE Rashmi K - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd Sowmya Moni - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd Yamuna Padmanabhan - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd Abhishek RVRK Sharma - Marketing Manager, Hewlett Packard Ltd
  • 3. Contents 1. Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ 4 2. Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 4 3. Research Methodology ................................................................................................................. 5 4. Research Findings ......................................................................................................................... 6 4.1 Marketing challenges for virtual teams ................................................................................. 6 4.2 Advantages of virtual teams ................................................................................................... 7 4.3 Important Work Dimensions in virtual teams ....................................................................... 7 5. Go-to- Market Program — New Product Launch Case Study ................................................ 7 6. Solution Framework ....................................................................................................................... 8 6.1 Global Virtual Governance Structure .................................................................................... 9 6.2 Role Task Methodology ........................................................................................................ 10 6.3 Consensus Building Process ............................................................................................... 11 6.4 Cross Cultural Communication Model ................................................................................ 12 7. Conclusion..................................................................................................................................... 14 8. Bibliography .................................................................................................................................. 14 9. Appendix 1 .................................................................................................................................... 15 10. Appendix 2a ................................................................................................................................ 16 11. Appendix 2b ................................................................................................................................ 17 12. Appendix 2c ................................................................................................................................ 18 13. Appendix 3 .................................................................................................................................. 19 14. Author’s Profile ........................................................................................................................... 20 3 Page
  • 4. 1. Abstract "...you cannot build network organizations on electronic networks alone...If so,... we will probably need an entirely new sociology of organizations." Nohria & Eccles, 1992, pp. 304-305. The purpose of this paper is to present the challenges faced by marketing program managers and make recommendations for effectively managing virtual teams working on global marketing programs. Global marketing programs refer to marketing activities co-ordinated and integrated across multiple country markets to achieve a specific marketing outcome for an organization. Today, many global fortune companies design marketing programs to drive key marketing outcomes such as improving time to market for launching new products globally, creating agility in product development life cycle to compete effectively in an environment, responding to competitor, industry changes and customer needs etc. In such a program, core concepts such as value proposition building, product roadmap definition, marketing plan development, and communication strategy are developed at a global level and implemented in countries. These programs are driven by virtual teams that usually comprise hybrid mix of location specific and diverse competencies. The advent of low cost, real-time collaboration communication technology has made it possible for teams divided by time and space to interact and contribute effectively. Not only does the marketing program manager needs to manage the triple constraints (time, scope and cost) but also needs to manage challenges related to cross-cultural communication while ensuring consistency of one voice in marketing planning and execution. There is also often a need to diagnose and handle differences, challenge assumptions, and defuse the potential for conflict. The paper will detail the challenges faced by marketing managers through few business cases. In order to successfully achieve the marketing outcome and overcome the challenges, marketing program managers need to manage a whole spectrum of communication strategies and project management techniques as well as human and social processes in ways that support the team. The authors will discuss their experiences and share best practices of effectively managing virtual teams — some of which include establishing a global virtual governance structure, building a culture for collaboration and formal consensus building process, and creating a role task prioritization matrix and a cross-cultural relevant communication model for the virtual team and its stakeholders. 2. Introduction 1 All projects have two core features – activities and decisions. Most challenges stem from managing these two features. All activities and decisions need to be effectively managed for 1 New Product Development Decision-Making Effectiveness: Comparing Individuals, Face-To-Face Teams, and Virtual Teams, Schmidt et al., Decision Sciences, Volume 32 No. 4, Fall 2001 4 Page
  • 5. achieving project or program outcomes successfully. Managing marketing projects and programs are no different. The context of activities and decisions in marketing can be related to managing the customer journey (customer relationship management), developing the marketing strategy and plan, defining and launching products, and or management of the marketing mix. Authors, who are experienced marketing managers, have managed several global marketing programs and have collectively 25 years of managing and working in large globally distributed teams. This paper discusses aspects of virtual team management in marketing context. The authors conducted field study with the objective of determining the challenges and benefits of managing and working in virtual marketing teams. The study was a mixed-methods approach to gather quantitative and qualitative data using a Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire, one- on-one interviews and a Go-to-Market marketing program case study. The authors conducted few one-on-one interviews with several marketing leaders and project practitioners managing diverse marketing projects across domains such as research/analytics and product marketing launches to learn perspectives on managing virtual teams. The insights gained from the interviews and the authors’ collective experiendces were used in designing the questionnaire. Refer to the Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire in Appendix 1 and Qualitative Interview Transcripts in Appendix 4. A correlation analysis was conducted on quantitative data, while qualitative data was themed and counted. The findings of the study have been discussed in detail in the paper. Authors have also discussed the challenges of managing virtual team through a Go-to-Market case study of a New Product Launch. Authors have provided a proven, actionable and suggestive solution framework to reduce the risks associated with challenges when working with culturally diverse virtual teams.. 3. Research Methodology A short questionnaire was designed and administered online to 30 mid-senior level marketing managers working or managing large global programs across the organization. Questions in the survey focused on gaining insights from marketing managers on challenges and benefits when working in a virtual team. Respondents provided their responses on the perceived challenges pertaining to role/responsibility of team members, cultural sensitivity, customer and market data acquisition, task prioritization, governance processes, communication, speed of decision making, cost effectiveness, efficacy of output/deliverables and quality of work, in the survey. Questions on perceived benefits of working in a virtual teams were also included in the questionnaire and centered around improved time to completion for marketing planning and execution, clear and effective communication, time saved through faster decision making and real time collaboration facilitated in accelerating speed to market. Refer to the Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire in Appendix 1. 5 Page
  • 6. 4. Research Findings It was important to establish the role of the respondent as the survey responses to the perceived challenges and benefits in the questionnaire and interviews were role specific. The respondent chose the role most applicable — program/ project manager or a team contributor while responding to the questions on the survey. The results of the survey brought out some interesting insights. Project managers and team contributors viewed challenges and benefits of working in virtual teams differently. The research results are presented below, with interpretive statements with regard to their results. 4.1 Marketing challenges for virtual teams (Refer Appendix 2, Figure 1) It was surprising to find out that most of the respondents seem to corroborate authors’ views on challenges and benefits in virtual teaming. Most marketing managers cited communication and governance related challenges more over other types of challenges. In a large globally distributed organization, communication is presented as a significant challenge, unsurprisingly and perhaps compounded by high levels of cultural diversity within project teams that are spread across multiple time zones. Additionally, there is stress on governance difficulties, indicating difficulties with decision making and tracking of project progress. With multiple teams working together, the lack of clear definition of responsibility and task priority definition becomes a major challenge for virtual teams. The distances inherent to virtual teams make face to face collaboration difficult, which helps resolve such issues in traditional teams One of the respondents quoted: ―Decision making structures are often not very clearly defined, as the nature of virtual teaming means such structures would need to change often. With virtual teams being created and dismantled frequently, it becomes difficult to maintain good governance in terms of decision making and communication. Another parameter that was of concern was task prioritization. With virtual teams so geographically divided, regional biases sometimes emerging within the team with respect to task prioritization‖ The use of Global Virtual Governance Structure has been seen to improve the incidence of definition of realistic ideas and implementable solutions in culturally diverse virtual teams. It has been noted that cultural diversity has both positive and negative implications for virtual team, the positives stemming from improved decision making and idea generation, and the negatives from 2 the challenges associated with intercultural communication . This has been discussed in detail in the solution framework section of the paper. 2 Shachaf, P. (2008). Cultural diversity and information and communication technology impacts on global virtual teams: An exploratory study. Information and Management, 45(2), 131‐142. 6 Page
  • 7. 4.2 Advantages of virtual teams (Refer Appendix 2, Figure 2) The two most significant advantages presented included the ease of exchange of information due to virtual communication capabilities and ease of access to Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) and data resources. The core advantages provided in the survey seem to gain reasonable amount of acceptance from the respondents, indicating that the perceived advantages of virtual teams are common across most marketing programs. Faster decision making, improved completion times for marketing planning and messaging are all represented advantages of virtual teaming. 4.3 Important Work Dimensions in virtual teams (Refer Appendix 2, Figure 3) With respect to factors that are influenced by virtual teams, the most significant factor in moving towards virtual teaming was that of cost savings. The use of virtual teams for a geographically dispersed organization represents significant savings in terms of costs incurred for travel and exchange of information. Additionally, the efficiency and improved quality of work were seen as other advantages of virtual teaming, with the ease of information exchange and access to Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) across geographies. Qualitative interviews corroborated with the findings of the survey. Marketing managers mentioned that due to vast time differences across teams, it is challenging to coordinate tasks and ensure goal alignment while keeping the availability of resources in different regions under consideration necessitating some team members to work at odd hours. One of the biggest advantages that virtual teams present for marketing is the work continuance to follow the sun, thus making sure that work progresses continually as it moves from team members from one time zone to another across the globe. The work allocation becomes easier as there is accessibility to global talent. The clear definition of marketing objectives and role task prioritization initially goes a long way in mitigating the risk in time and communication management. 5. Go-to- Market Program — New Product Launch Case Study The authors manage global technology product launches. Global launches are usually done simultaneously across geographies and require co-ordination with multiple teams across functions. A diverse globally distributed team such as product engineering, planning, operations, delivery and deployment works to plan and execute various aspects of a launch. The case study below focuses on marketing team’s involvement in launching an enterprise software product. Creating and managing the launch schedule is the single most critical responsibility of a marketing launch program manager. 7 Page
  • 8. An enterprise software product upgrade was to be launched with 1000 global customers across 140 countries. This product aimed at upgrading the Enterprise customers’ IT environment to the next level. The objectives of the launch were to: Encourage at least 80% of the customers to migrate to the new product in the first wave of migration over 12 months Increase customer satisfaction levels by 30 % post migration It was imperative that sales, IT delivery managers and customers had access to marketing literature to the new product earliest and latest finish of 8 and 6 weeks respectively before the product launch date. A virtual go-to-market team was put together to work on the marketing activities pertaining to the launch and a launch program manager was assigned to the launch. The launch schedule was planned for 10 weeks with 5 critical milestones that included approval of project charter, release of value proposition and positioning statements, roll out of an integrated communication plan and release of customer and sales facing marketing collaterals. The program manager had to manage multiple teams with different functional specializations (marketing, product development, regional sales and delivery) from different geographies (Asia Pacific (APJ), Europe, the Middle East and Africa (EMEA), Americas). Being a global launch, all marketing content has to be translation ready. The prioritization of languages translations for marketing content, created several hurdles in meeting the critical milestones of the launch schedule. With a finite budget, and decision to translate all marketing collateral in only 10 languages meant meeting with all concerned stakeholders and seeking consensus. Consensus building requires trust and building relationships and trust in a virtual team is a significant challenge. The launch manager had to schedule many meetings for these discussions. The deliberations did create conflict like situations within the core marketing team. As a program manager, one had to be sensitive to time zones and work hours and therefore do resource and task allocation in such a manner that the work is uninterrupted – famously referred to as the Follow the Sun approach! While the overall launch schedule was met on time which was (Latest Finish) 6 weeks before launch, 2 critical milestones were on critical path throughout the project. Lessons learned from addressing ways to dealing with the challenges outlined above, have helped in building some kind of defense mechanisms to counter risks of delays in managing launches. The solution framework provided below has been seen to improve the incidence of managing some of the known risks and success in managing culturally diverse virtual teams. 6. Solution Framework We have seen that challenges for managing a marketing team which is connected virtually are many. However, from the authors’ perspective, the benefits of a virtually managed marketing team far outweigh the challenges. It has been observed that organizations which cater to the demands of cross cultural markets, have an inherent opportunity to consolidate and connect the skills and expertise of resources spread in strategic locations under a common umbrella for the achievement of marketing objectives. In such a scenario, the successful achievement of the marketing outcomes 8 Page
  • 9. is the result of management of a whole spectrum of communication strategies and project management techniques as well as human and social processes in ways that support the team. Having observed the dynamics of successful virtually operational marketing organization, the authors talk detail a solution framework from their collective experience of launching products globally. This solution framework can be applied in principle to all marketing programs. The framework consists of the following components: 1. Global Virtual Governance Structure 2. Role Task Prioritization Matrix 3. Consensus Building Process 4. Cross Cultural Communication Model 6.1 Global Virtual Governance Structure Most global marketing teams have a strong matrix organization structure. The challenge of managing interpersonal relationships, communicating and monitoring the progress of a marketing program is managed by defining its Governance structure. A governance structure establishes the strategic, operational, and technical decision-making process required to ensure marketing teams enable the organization to excel in its mission. Governance structures are mostly defined at leadership level such Marketing Council or Business Steering Committee with representation from several functional teams working virtually across the globe. The leadership team consists of representatives from the top management of the company. Marketing budgets are owned by this team and they are the final approval and escalation point for all marketing programs. The top management is assisted in governance and decision making by the Strategy and Executive teams who align with the marketing objectives outlined by the Leadership team. Cross-team collaboration and prioritization decisions are formulated at this level. The Executive teams are also responsible for setting standards and driving governance guidance, which is necessary in order to sustain an environment of cohesion within virtual program teams working towards the achievement of the marketing objectives. Governance structure is also influenced by industry groups and other business functions (such as finance, legal etc) in the organization. Decisions making is facilitated by sharing information through multiple mediums of communication such as team share sites, collaboration websites, virtual rooms, audio conferencing tools etc. These communication tools enable marketing teams working towards a complex marketing program such as product launch to collaborate and share information, negotiate and assess progress of the program. In fact, many organizations in recent times have used these communication platforms to launch products. The illustration below shows a formal Governance structure for a launching a product globally across regions. The Launch Program manager interacts with several teams (product, regional marketing, country marketing, and engineering, global support functions) which are geographically dispersed to launch a product. Whether it is customer requirements gathering, product development, messaging, creating marketing outbound communication or co-coordinating the launch roll out, all of these activities are carried out seamlessly through virtual teaming. 9 Page
  • 10. 1.0 Governance Structure 6.2 Role Task Methodology The importance of role task prioritization can best be summarized through a sound bite from a marketing leader, the authors interviewed recently, “I have found that spending more time up front ensuring everyone is on the same page and knows who is doing what, is a very prudent investment as the team can then execute against clearly defined goals with everyone pulling in the same direction.” How does a marketing program manager keep tabs on who in the virtual team are responsible for what aspect of the launch program? The answer to the question lies in Role Task Prioritization. This involves defining and providing members of the marketing program clarity on the role and responsibilities. Marketing program managers map the responsibilities of different virtual teams by creating a program RACI. RACI — Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed. In a virtual team, where face to face interaction among the members is very low, a RACI provides a reference point for decision making and task assignments. Having a detailed program RACI reduces risks on conflicts and progression of the marketing program as per predefined schedules. The sample below is a program RACI for global marketing product launch across countries. All the teams are virtually work together to launch the product. 10 Page
  • 11. 2.0 Program RACI 6.3 Consensus Building Process One of the challenges in managing a virtual team is the varying degree of prioritizations and involvements existent within a program team. While managing marketing programs such as launches, launch Program Manager and his/her core team may have a high degree of involvement on all stages of launch, other teams such as country marketing teams participating in the launch may have a relatively low degree of involvement in the launch process. Therefore, a formal consensus building process needs to be initiated in order to manage the triple constraints of time, cost and scope. In a virtual team, marketing program managers require consensus in order to: Develop clear understanding of the roles and responsibilities Arrive at an agreement on the turnaround time on the marketing deliverables 11 Page
  • 12. Agree at convenient time to schedule update and clarification meetings among members of different time zones Develop an agreement on the content review process and toll gates Define success factors for marketing effectiveness Consensus building can be achieved by respecting different points of view, understanding working styles and gaining insights through focus group discussions, brainstorming sessions, meetings etc. The authors have observed certain working styles to work most effectively in a in a consensus seeking discussion and that can be categorized broadly as Initiator, Facilitator and Devil’s advocate and Observer. Members with Initiator style will be proactive to reach out to the relevant members in the team and would have the ability to identify conflicts and risks requiring consensus building exercise. Facilitators are active participants to discussions and provide suggestions and alternate options to the arrive at consensus. They will diffuse emotional, aggressive conflicting situations through their unbiased, mature conversation style, humor sense or power position in the team. Devil’s advocates are active participants questioning the status quo in the team. Observers are passive participants who do not typically voice their views pro-actively but are the doers in the group. It is important for program manager to identify the working style of the team members and use this to his/her advantage while managing the program. For instance, one would like to have more facilitators present in a conflict resolution meeting and perhaps a devil’s advocate while negotiating a contract with an external agency. A program manager has to adopt all these styles depending on the situation while leading a program. 6.4 Cross Cultural Communication Model One of the characteristics which differentiate a virtual team from a location specific team is the wide diversity of cultures. Cultures define our approach towards working with different members which can be perspectives and values towards deliverables and outcomes. A commonly reference theory on Culture is that of Greet Hofstede’s., who analyzed cultural values on dimensions such as individualism, uncertainty avoidance, power distance, masculinity-femininity and self-restraint etc. For a marketing program manager working with cross cultural virtual teams, developing an understanding of the cross cultural differences and adapting his communication and program approach to sensitivities of other members is of utmost importance. Because of the relevance of cultural sensitivities in understanding market trends and successful achievement of program outcomes, organizations today conduct a number of Cultural Sensitivity Training programs for members of its marketing organizations. The Transnational Management Association’s Country Navigator portal for example, helps a program manager profile his cultural values and styles on a nine point scale and compare it with the various countries where its virtual team members are stationed. 12 Page
  • 13. Authors have highlighted dimensions of a cross cultural communication model which are relevant when managing global programs. Given below are a few case scenarios of cultural sensitivity which needs to be taken into account while handling marketing programs in a virtual environment: Cultural Dimensions Scheduling Virtual teams work across different time zones and scheduling meetings across Meetings time zones is a challenge. In a few cultures (like India , China and many Asian Countries), scheduling meeting post working hours may be considered acceptable , but in a few others (Germany) stick to deadlines and is particular of timekeeping Explicit vs. Americans/German teams have a very explicit communication styles – direct, Implicit assertive and message which is spelt out clear and concise. It is imperative to Communication learn to read the signals, and to read between the lines. Team work Some cultures like and prefer to work in a group than on an individual basis. Therefore a marketing initiative which requires delegation, negotiation and decision making will make such cultures more comfortable. Initiation of Initiation of marketing meetings in a virtual environment with resources from Conversation cross cultures requires careful consideration of various aspects. Few cultures encourage relationship building such as an ice breaking session, before moving on to business scenarios. Conflict Different cultures may have different ways of handling conflicts. Launch Management marketing program described in the paper heading for its due date will be an apt example for this. Under such scenarios, where there is a possibility of tense conversations with varying degree of assertions, different members of a launch team may react differently. If we have a background of members who belong to cultures which do not encourage such open conversations, there is a possibility of such members taking the situation personally. Risk The way a member of a virtual team perceives risk is an important aspect of Perceptions cross cultural sensitiveness. The degree of acceptance and appreciation of risk associated with a proposed project varies – For example, US as a culture is more appreciative of handling risk and uncertainties. Many cultures such as the French have been generally found to be more protective and act more proactively to safeguard the program and self. 13 Page
  • 14. 7. Conclusion Through the use of survey, personal experiences, one-on-one interviews with leaders and a real time product launch case study, authors have attempted to describe challenges managing virtual teams in the marketing world. We understand many of these challenges may not be unique to marketing only. The suggested solution framework aims at providing guidance to marketing program managers and project management practitioners who are looking to increasingly use virtual teaming to enable effective marketing without spiraling costs. With the pro-active use of some of the concepts and frameworks mentioned in the paper, it is possible to combat most of the challenges managing virtual teams while also noting that particular situations may emerge which may require modification of the methods suggested. 8. Bibliography al., K. e. (2007). Conflict and Performance in Global Virtual Teams. Journal of Management Information Systems. al., S. e. (Volume 32 No. 4, Fall 2001). New Product Development Decision-Making Effectiveness: Comparing Individuals, Face-To-Face Teams, and Virtual Teams. Decision Sciences. Association, T. M. (n.d.). www.countrynavigator.com. Retrieved from The Transnational Management Association’s Country Navigator Portal. Hofstede, G. (2010). Theory of Cultural Dimensions (Updated). Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind. Shachaf, P. (2008). Cultural diversity and information and communication technology impacts on global virtual teams: An exploratory study. Information and Management, 45(2), 131‐142. 14 Page
  • 15. 9. Appendix 1 Virtual Team Effectiveness Questionnaire Question 1 – What is your job role in your team? A. Project Manager B. Project Team Contributor Question 2 – What are the typical challenges you have had in your engagement/projects while working in virtual teams? (Rank from most prevalent (1) to least prevalent or nonexistent (9) ) A. Cultural Issues – Dealing with different cultures as part of my engagement with various stakeholders and teams B. Governance Issues – Decision making and tracking progress are issues C. Communication Issues – Clear and consistent communication of messaging and other marketing assets is difficult across geographies D. Role and Responsibility Identification E. Prioritization of tasks that need to be done by the team – Everyone thinks their own tasks are the most important F. Identification of the right messaging for products/services G. Process Issues – Launch/Go-To- Market/Product Development/Market and Customer Intelligence processes are not well defined H. Capacity Issues – Not having right or enough resources I. Data Acquisition – Marketing Data (customer, competitor and industry intelligence, product sales reports , customer information) and document acquisition from other teams is delayed J. Other Issues (Please specify) Question 3– Rate the importance of work parameter while working in a virtual team (Scale of 1 to 5 from much worse to much better) A. Time for decision making B. Cost C. Responsiveness D. Efficiency E. Quality of work(Output/ Deliverables) Question 4– What, according to you, are the major benefits of working in a virtual team? (Rank these in order from Most Useful (1) to Least Useful (7)) A. Improved time to completion for collateral/messaging or marketing projects B. More clear and effective communication (two way, translated) C. Time saved through reduction of decision making delays D. Real time collaboration facilitated discussion time savings E. Faster GTM (Go To Market) and generic marketing planning F. Better sharing of information across the team (reports/analytics) G. Others (Please specify) 15 Page
  • 16. 10. Appendix 2a Research Results (n=30) Figure 1 16 Page
  • 17. 11. Appendix 2b Research Results (n=30) Figure 2 17 Page
  • 18. 12. Appendix 2c Research Results (n=30) Figure 3 Virtual Teams Effect on work parameters Time for decision making -0.03 Response Times for team members 0.10 Quality of work 0.33 Efficiency of work 0.43 Cost 0.60 -2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 18 Page
  • 19. 13. Appendix 3 Excerpts from an interview with a marketing leader, who is currently managing a large virtual marketing team in Hewlett Packard (One example) Interview transcript with Director, Technology Services Marketing, Hewlett Packard 1. What are the major challenges you face while working with your global teams? Given we span all regions of the world and multiple time zones, Alignment & Communication are the key challenges we face. While we communicate effectively and frequently via e-mail, often times the best or only way to effectively communicate is live voice-to-voice, which means phone calls at very inconvenient times for some of our team members. 2. In your opinion, what has been the impact of virtual team engagements on marketing KPAs – Time/Resource Availability, Marketing Spends, Return on Marketing Investment etc. There are both positives and negatives associated with the global virtual team model. The negative is what I stated above, i.e. inconvenient times for meetings/calls and challenges associated with aligning a global team. However, the global virtual team model also provides advantages in that ―work can follow the sun‖, meaning we can pass and hand-off work from one region and time zone to the next so that the project continues to progress 24x7. 3. What could be done to improve the current operating model for virtual teams in marketing? Adequate funding for both people and program money is always a challenge that every global marketing team faces, so increases in marketing funding drives a corresponding increase in ROI. 4. Which marketing activities work best with virtual teams? Activities that are VERY clearly defined and scoped out at the beginning of the project. I have found that spending more time up front ensuring everyone is on the same page and knows who is doing what, is a very prudent investment as the team can then execute against clearly defined goals with everyone pulling in the same direction. 5. As a marketing leader, what has been the single most important challenge while working with your extended team across countries? Balancing the seemingly infinite and ever-increasing demands for more out of marketing with the very finite resources (people, time, money) we have. Requires being very tough on setting priorities and then being very transparent and communicative to stakeholders on what marketing will do, and equally important, what marketing will not do, with our precious/finite resources. 19 Page
  • 20. 14. Author’s Profile Sowmya Moni has 12+ years of proven experience in technology marketing. She is a senior marketing manager with Hewlett Packard’s Global Analytics team. She holds an MBA in Marketing from MDI, Gurgaon and is a certified PMP. She has co-authored the paper with her team Rashmi K, Yamuna Padmanaban and Abhishek RVRK Sharma. 20 Page